Great grocery store. I appears to have about anything you would want from a large selection of wine and liquor to food. Product section and pastries look inviting. Good selection of sundry item. This is the only place I shop for grocery when I visit the island. Restaurant is great also for breakfast, lunch or dinner. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Key Lime Pie. Out of this world - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

I enjoy going to Jerry's on sanibel. I especially like the bakery. The chocolate chip cookies are fantastic as well as the doughnuts. Everything is baked on premises. I enjoy seeing all of the exotic birds before entering the store. My only complaint that it's prices are a bit high. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Caesar is his name. I enjoy seeing him at Jerry's - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

Came for breakfast. Shared an omelette with my wife. Service was very good and the prices were surprisingly low. Too bad the omelette wasn't better; it could have been light and fluffy, instead it was overdone and chewy. I'll come back just not for an omelette. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Large windows enable you to enjoy the scenery while you enjoy your breakfast. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

If your looking for a low key, inexpensive diner meal Jerry's is the place. It has a diner atmosphere , however if there are large parties , it can be unbearably noisy. It was so noisy that we had to move from where we were sitting. The server was very nice and apologetic about the noise. We ordered the blackened mahi-mahi and the Parmesan chicken. All entrees come with awesome soup and salad bar at the salad bar in the supermarket. The fish was a little extra fishy and the chicken was to be expected, but it was worth the salad bar. 25 per person, good price for the quality. read more

A little pricey for a meal.. but that's expected on Sanibel. It is very good food, made fresh to order. So yummy. Full salad bar and different soup choices. All subs are made with Boars Head meat which is the best! So a balance is... the food is great but a little expensive. read more

The waitress was super rude to us...but the food was alright, just regular dinner food as one would expect. Cake portions are hugeeee!

Restaurant has gone WAY downhill. Food used to be pretty good, wine inexpensive, and the service good. Used to be one of the best deals on the island. Now everything positive about the place has changed. Don't waste your money. And by all means don't order anything blackened unless you like eating a handful of salt for dinner! read more

The food in the restaurant was good, fresh, and quick. Service was friendly. The grocery store is well-stocked and not as pricey as I had feared, though certainly higher than a mainland grocery. The pickup option was very nice. read more

Very cool concept but I saw a mouse outside near the bird cages and had to flee the scene immediately. I understand that it is outdoors and certainly not Jerry's fault but I'm deathly afraid of rodents. read more

I confirm Maddie's review. Also good place for inexpensive dinners and wine, especially the daily specials. Interesting setting, nicely landscaped. Several interesting shops in the same complex. Before going to specialty shops, check Jerry's for a good selection of all sorts of beach required gear and goodies. read more

We love this grocery store. Been shopping there for 30 years and when our kids were young, they loved the way you can put your grocery bags in a bin and send them down the ramp for a car pick up service. The food selection is great as well as pool toys and suntan lotion. Our favorite are the parrots- used to be "Jerry" and now "Jerry Jr." read more

Decent selection for a local grocery store, but the prices are crazy. Some products I saw were 2-3 times more expensive than off the island. I guess they can do this because of the convenience they offer as opposed to leaving the island, but still pretty wild. Wouldn't want to do a full shopping trip here but convenient if you forget one or two things. read more

You have been warned! CHECK EXPIRATION DATE BEFORE YOU BUY, More than half of the items I purchased were expired. To solve this problem simply choose the item in the back each time and it is easily avoided Also they have exotic bird exhibits that are CAGED UP in small metal bars. SHAME ON YOU! Release them or place them on a larger containment. These birds are stressed and ridiculed by children passing by each time by the hundreds daily. Only in the South does this happen. read more

Great produce section. Excellent wine and beer selection. Great easy access and nice parking garage.

Was very impressed by Jerry's high quality products and store layout. Beer and wine especially. Wish every community had one

Jerry's Food is where you go when you are staying on the Island and don't want to pay the toll to go back to the mainland to get groceries. It has a decent selection but it is pricier, since it is on an island. So keep that in mind. The baked goods are really stellar though. I highly recommend the cinnamon chunk bread. We even bought a couple loaves to bring home with us, because we enjoy it so much. The little plaza Jerry's is in is really nicely laid out as well. read more

Jerry's carries a lot of vegan / vegetarian options. Not so much organic, but they seem to be improving on that front year over year. The prices are pretty reasonable. The only drawback is that getting your cart from the store to your car is a bit of a journey. read more

Jerry's is one of our first stops when we come to Sanibel. We usually eat out while on the island, but stop at Jerry's to stock up on cold drinks, snacks, sun screen, etc. It is more touristy than Bailey's but has a great selection of all kinds of food, including gluten-free, plus beach/pool essentials, postcards, souvenirs, etc. Jerry's makes excellent key lime pies. It is so much more economical to buy whole pies at Jerry's than to pay by the slice at the restaurants. Everyone at Jerry's is friendly and helpful. I don't recommend the restaurant just because there are so many great places to eat on Sanibel, but the food is good and priced right. The rest of the shopping center also has some great shops, especially the one at the end, furthest from Jerry's -- best place for pool and beach stuff and t-shirts. read more

Super fresh food, but very skimpy. I ordered a corned beef deli sandwich which was advertised to be thick. Now, where I come from, a deli sandwich is very substantial with mounds of thinly sliced, warm meat. This, however, was the skimpiest portion of cold meat I had ever seen, even for a typical cafeteria sandwich. read more

The staff here is kind of curt. They must know that many who come to Jerry's are not from the island and are unfamilar with how Jerry's works. As such, maybe they should explain how you have to pick up your groceries in the parking garage. The parrots at the entrance are nice. But the store itself was 'eh.' It was cheaper than Bailey's on some stuff, but more expensive than Bailey's for other stuff. $15 for a tiny little bottle of sunscreen? Ouch, that hurt worse than the sunburn. The selection wasn't all that great either. But overall I did like it better than Bailey's. read more

We got the fish tacos. Everything was cold. The sauce on the tacos tasted awful. None of us liked it. Iced was fresh and delicious. Service was very good. Supermarket was ridiculously overpriced. read more

Worst service ever. Rude hostess, rude waitress and isn't even able to respond to our continual requests for our first order of coffee and water. The food could have been good, but the bad taste in our mouths for terrible customer service ruined it for us. Never again. read more

Jerry's Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

The second part of the Jerry's Food is a restaurant. There is a great place for breakfast with a nice menu of comfort foods, eggs, bacon, omelets, hash browns, grits, etc. However, the service was SLOOOWWWW. I mean, slow! Breakfast should not take 2 hours! This is the way it broke down -- *There were two of us and we were seated after only waiting for a few minutes at the podium. Off to a good start. *Then we waited for menus, but this person could not take our coffee order. - Wait 10 minutes. *Then we waited to order our coffee, but she did not want to take our breakfast order yet, give us time to look at the menu. - Wait 10 minutes. *Then we got our coffee, but she said just a minute to take our order. - Wait 15 minutes. *Waitress takes our order. We both ordered omelets. - Wait about 20 minutes. (this time wait is acceptable, it does take time to actually MAKE the food) *Food arrives. The omelets were full of the yummies and very fluffy and light. Very happy with the food. *Had to flag down the waitress and wait for Tabasco, she forgot the catchup so had to wait for that too. (At this point I lost track of time) - Wait for bill, give credit card before even seeing the bill. - Wait long time, sign and FINALLY leave. Was it as painful to read as it was to sit through? I like to leisurely eat but I want attentive service. I don't want to be told to wait, wait, wait. I understand she was busy. They were probably understaffed and I still gave her a nice tip but it appeared that she was just not waitress material. She could not do two things at once and was easily distracted. The food was good. The management should make sure to hire staff that does not take away from the food and the "Island" laid-back feel. read more

This is the world's best restaurant that's in a grocery store. I'm not sure what it's competition is.... but still.... On Sanibel, you're you going to order the same basic stuff: grouper, maybe a sandwich, a slice of key lime pie. And at Jerry's it will be at least as good is it will be elsewhere....and it will be cheaper....and you can do your grocery shopping while you wait (though it won't be a long wait). We'd be driving around Sanibel at night, looking for a place to eat, and everywhere else has a line. And we'd eat and Jerry's and it was always better than wherever else we would have eaten. And the service is always good. So we just kept going there. And they have a great salad bar. And great deserts. And the people are nice. And the Tilapia Oscar is off the hook, literally, because if it were on the hook, we might have a law suit on our hands (HAHAHAHAHA). read more

I love this grocery store. It's pretty much the only one on the island of sanibel so I'm glad it's good. You will find everything you expect grocery store and all the added little goodies you would expect from a local island grocery. Staff is always friendly and my favorite part is that they offer to have your groceries sent down where you can pick them up downstairs. The bag boys will place groceries in your car and you can then ATTEMPT to tip them (they discourage tipping). They never take my money which is frustrating because they work hard. read more

The food was perfect diner-style food, which we wanted, since it was breakfast. BUT... There was a problem with the kitchen, as they kept messing up the order. (There were only two of us, in an empty house.) Our server was very friendly, and we watched her put the orders in correctly (we sat at the counter) but the kitchen obviously had something else in mind. My friend's order was served with grits, after he had chosen hash browns for his side. Easy fix, he had his hash browns after a quick request. Mine was served with a choice of toasted bread, and I had chosen sourdough. (One of my all time favourites, and I was thrilled they offered it.) Surprise! My order came out with toasted white bread, Wonder-bread, really. So I told our server, and she apologized and asked the cook - he said "nope that is sourdough." I tasted it, it was NOT. Inexplicably, perhaps thinking it was just over-toasted and unrecognizable (it was perfectly toasted) she had him make another order "less toasted." It was, of course, still Wonder-bread. Even the hostess, who wandered over to ask how everything was, said "oh honey, you're right - that is NOT sourdough." You would think that someone would have confronted the cook about it, but no, once he said it was sourdough, nothing more was done. I finally gave up trying and enjoyed my meal, sans toast-of-choice. This is my second dining experience on Sanibel, and I am not impressed. read more

I was pleasantly surprised to find a decent grocery store on the island with the bonus of not being outrageously overpriced. Some items were higher than back home, Chicagoland, but not bad. We also liked sending the groceries down the rollers at checkout to be placed in our car with no fuss. Nice touch. read more

This review is for the restaurant within Jerry's grocery. Best pancakes on the island and reasonably priced. We've been here often and the kids love the chocolate chip pancakes and I get the traditional. read more

I agree with Phil R here! They do have a great selection and I find, when we are here, that everything is fresh and good quality.

Favorite grocery store. Plus they have s great little onsite restaurant if your hungry and stuck for time. We needed a quick place to eat after getting settled in at our rental. Food was great, esp. The Reuben. read more

Has everything you need...prices are a little higher, but hey, you're on an island! Donuts are delicious...bacon and maple...YUMMY!! I liked their method of picking up the groceries...they load them in your car!! Only a 10 mile drive from Captiva. read more

Nice supermarket! Higher priced items but that's expected for the convenience of on island shopping. Only a mile from Sanibel Beach Club resort. read more

Grocery store IS CRAZY OVER PRICED. but you need to go for the famous key lime pie and all of the birds outside that talk to you! Fun place to stop for a few things but not your whole grocery list. Go off the island for the whole list. read more

Great grocery store in a nice outdoor mall (I love the parrots!) They have a good selection of deli foods and breads from the bakery. Good selection of everyday items as well. The diner near the deli, same name I believe, is a great place for breakfast. read more

This review is for the restaurant only... horrible service. The waitress was slow. Knew nothing about the menu. I almost got up to get my own refill. I ordered the salad bar and my fiancee got a sandwich... the waitress added 18% gratuity. I don't get it. Adding gratuity to 2 people? What's the point of a tip anymore. read more

The absolute best service and amazing food! The omelettes are delicious! And the chocolate cake is a slice of heaven!

Food is always excellent, usually we have breakfast or lunch so I can't testify about dinner but would guess it will be excellent. Granddaughters say best Apple fritters in town I agree (: lots of unusual items to look at. Neat shops with high end merchandise in same plaza. Do yourself a favor and stop . read more

No trip to Sanibel is complete without a trip to Jerry's! It is one of only 2 grocery stores on the island and is definitely the nicest one. Jerry's is located in a tropical shopping center oasis and is home to at least a half dozen tropical birds. Jerry Jr. is the star and my boys love to talk to him and his friends before heading into the store. As far as grocery stores go, it is perfect for the island. The prices are ok, but the selection is rather large given the size of the store. (It is a small grocery store on an island, not the Flagship Whole Foods in Austin, TX.) The service is great and Jerry's is a great place to grab sunscreen and noodles and other beach accessories as well. Recently, they have added one of those Redbox machines that sell movies for $1/movie/day. This is a nice feature for the island, although it can get rather slammed in the evenings. The restaraunt at Jerry's is very tasty and well priced. It has the least expensive children's menu on the island and a terrific salad bar, where you can also get items to go. Although the little cafe is in the grocery store, the atmosphere is still pretty cool, since you are surrounded by tropical plants. read more

Don't be fooled by the restaurant tucked into the grocery store. This is a great breakfast place that is reasonably priced for Sanibel. The chunky cinnamon French toast is amazing. It's made with bread baked fresh in the store. The coffee is a step up from typical diner coffee and the service is friendly. read more

Great grocery! I chose Jerry's from Yelp reviews and the Yelpers were right! Great selection. Clean store. Friendly service. A bit expensive but not unexpected for Santibel. read more