Arrived right on time, which I really appreciated. The rosemary Parmesan bread was excellent--crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They're definitely not skimpy with the ingredients; there was a great balance of meat, cheese, veggies, and condiments. I was genuinely surprised by how large the giant sub was. It was cut into four sections, which made it easy to share and gave everyone a chance to try different flavors. It was more than enough for two or even multiple meals, which made it feel like a great value. Online ordering was easy and smooth. Overall, a really good experience, and I'd definitely go again. read more

The bread was at least 5 days old - I will not be back! Why does mgnt put up with such poor food quality being sold for top dollar!

Ordered an online order at 5:20 PM. Order was supposed to be ready at 6:07 PM. It's currently 6:50 PM and I'm still waiting. Process for managing online orders is atrocious. Absolutely no system in place. Walk in customers are given priority to online orders, with no system to disposition orders as they come into the system. Communication was horrible. DO NOT PLACE AN ONLINE ORDER AT THIS LOCATION! EVER! read more

amazing service workers really know what they're doing and how to create the best atmosphere for their customers. Ryan knows how to make a sandwich and how treat his customer. read more

We decided to give this place another chance after we ordered DoorDash almost 2 years ago and they messed up our order by adding an allergen I couldn't eat, and then refusing to fix it when my husband drove back and told us to take it up with DoorDash. It was very hot in the store. It was very unsanitary, they were putting sandwiches on the bare dirty counter, and using the same knife dripping with mayo to cut everyone's sandwiches. We will never eat here again. read more

I reached out to them when it happened & they never responded back to me. You can write whatever you want on this app, but it's really important to follow through with your customers. read more

They cut the meat right in front of you, as you order! The difference in freshness is amazing. I like how simplified everything is - they don't have dozens of toppings, but those they do have don't appear to have been just dumped from a bag. The parking situation here is awful. But the sandwiches are really good. I usually have my husband drop me at the door and get our food to go. The service is great. Always friendly and helpful. Definitely better than other national chains in Greeley. read more

I went in today early at 11:30 am. There were 4 or 5 employees behind the counter and no other customers in the store. The nice girl behind the counter asked what I would like. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak. She told me there would be about a 15 minute wait because of the online orders in front of me. They were cooking several cheesesteaks on the grill. I said I didn't want to wait and left disappointed. I went in early so I wouldn't have to wait. I remember when customers who went in to an establishment got service. read more

Very disappointed in the service we received today. None of the employees were friendly at all, sandwiches weren't good either. I love Jersey Mike's sandwiches, but won't be back to this store. read more

The staff was so friendly, and the Big Kahuna is always delicious. It's so nice to have real food get cooked immediately not sitting under a heat lamp in the same amount of time. Thank you! read more

I don't have many places I can eat here in the Greeley area. I found out I could order a gluten free sub I was so happy. This is one of my husbands favorite sub places. I don't go that often but when I do everyone is very kind. Dakota remembers I need a gluten free subs every time. I walk in and I'm greeted right away. Dakota always cleans the machine/area and prepares my food on a separate tray. I'm so happy she's away of cross contamination with gluten free eating. For me this is just a step above and warms my heart. I know it shouldn't be a big deal but to those that have celiac or gluten allergy, it's a huge big deal. I appreciate how much care Dakota takes. Thank you so much!! read more

I try to come here and support this Greeley store but every time there seems to always be something not right' Everything from rude workers to No masks being worn by the food preparers. This time I called ahead to pick up and it wasn't even started yet! Last time I ordered ahead and they only had one thing made from my order of two things. I was very clear with my order. . I never hardly see anyone here. Don't know how long this place is going to stay open. I'm just tired and wanted my food to be ready when i got here to take home!! Ugh! read more

I was just in there with a co worker and we received the best service ever imaginable by an Employee by the name of Ormando (hope the spelling is correct). I will be coming back here without a doubt and I highly recommend this location to anybody looking for great service. read more

Won't be back to greeley location. Girls who work there are not very polite. No use in getting upset at the incompetence of rude high school kids. I like jersey mikes..not going to put up with rude employees read more

This location has by far the nicest employees around. The place is always super clean, employees are super friendly, and the sandwiches are always made fresh and in front of you. Make sure to go "Mike's Way" you won't regret it. read more

Excellent handling of gluten free bun and preparation. They go out of the way to prevent cross contamination which is important for celiacs. I almost never get asked if gluten free is a preference or and allergy. read more

I absolutely love this place! Food is always good. I would give it 5 stars except that on a few different occasions when I called to order 5hey said they were out of bread....how you gonna be a sandwich shop and not order enough bread??? Also closed early a few times when their site said "open" but the sandwiches are always awesome so 8 will keep going back read more

Excellent. Fresh ingredients sliced as they make the sandwich. Chipotle cheese steak is a favorite but everything we have tried has been delicious. Friendly service and fair prices. read more

Really good sandwich - waaaay too expensive. $9-10 for a "regular" (prob about 8") and $14-16 for a "large" (double the reg). It's cold cuts and veggies on bread. It tasted good and service was friendly though. read more