First time going to Jersey Mikes. Ordered the roast beef and a chicken sub. Both were delicious. Especially liked the bread. Plenty of meat in each. They were very good and the service excellent. I'll be back !! read more

I heard such amazing things about jersey mikes so I got it for the first time today. Can someone explain to me how your BLT is the number one sub but I get no bacon? I get BLT's from Wawa all the time and the amount of bacon they put on their sub is insane. If you go to Jersey mikes they will give you two pieces of bacon and call that a BLT. They put 3 pieces of cheese on my BLT but TWO pieces of bacon TWO. I've never seen a sub place put such little bacon on a BLT. How is there more cheese and toppings than meat! Absolutely ridiculous, go to Wawa for BLT's it is way more worth it. The only reason I am rating a 2 star instead of the one it deserves is because my fiance got a cheesesteak and it was amazing. read more

Clean location and usually not busy so they are quick to help. I like this spot for a quick sandwich while doing work at Starbucks , I tried a few of their sandwiches and my favorite is the classic Italian but nothing special. The Philly cheesesteak is so bland and not worth it unless you add some banana peppers / hot sauce in it. Their bread tastes ok but doesn't taste very fresh read more

Ate lunch in this establishment today. Unfortunately there was trash all over the floors, including chips and lettuce. The tables were dirty so I had to clean my own table off when I sat down. Most disappointing goal was that the bread on the sub that I had Was not soft and actually hard when I bit into it. read more

The sandwiches have gotten smaller. Anyone else notice this? This used to be my favorite sub shop!

We cannot get enough of this combo: rosemary parm bread, Turkey, cheese, lettuce, onion, Mayo, banana peppers, oregano and oil/vinegar. Delish. Love that the meat is cut to order. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I loved my last experience here! Called ahead and it was ready quick and I was able to walk right in and pay at a separate register which had no line! Also loved the cheese steak! Best one I have ever had from a fast food chain. Great with the roll toasted and onions. It was packed with meat and cheese. I will order this again! Hoping that their meatball sub comes back so I can try that on their Rosemary Parmesan roll. read more

See all

I've been told by a number of people that this place is the place to visit for a good sub. I don't like Subway, Firehouse was an utter disappointment and so I stick to local joints. Went over lunch time, line moves fairly quickly and there are a lot of choices. Two minis, one regular and one giant - $34. A bit shocked at the price, I understand it's higher quality, but not sure the quality is quite there. I enjoyed the red wine oil, but I would suggest a bread that can handle the amount. By the time I got home the bread was soggy on one side which made the sub start to fall apart. Overall, not bad. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Parking lot was busy but they had parking on the side. The staff was friendly. We got our food In little to no wait. Subs were delicious as always. read more

So, you want a great sub sandwich? Go to the place where it's all fresh. Fresh sliced meats, fresh baked bread sliced normally so it's easier to eat, and fresh ingredients. Once you try Jersey Mike's, you'll not be tempted to go to Subway where they pre-slice meat and stack it up so it gets slimy. Jersey Mike's is just so fresh, it's delicious. Love the classic Italian. Try it, you'll like it! read more

I like the food and service! Not somewhere I'll eat at often because it's pricey but still good.

Let me start off by saying this has nothing to do with the location of Jersey Mike's however it has everything to do with the franchise. If you are looking for a review on this specific location, continue scrolling. Now upon becoming hungry one day I noticed a Jersey Mike's was nearby so I went to their menu. I am a fan of deli subs and have had good subs in the past from Jersey Mike's so I thought I would at least peruse the menu. Upon making a selection and going to checkout (online) I noticed the price seemed a little high. I then decided to do a little more research and comparison with another similar nearby option (Wawa). I personally enjoy Wawa subs more but the Jersey Mike's was located nearby. Nonetheless a regular sub from Jersey Mike's will cost you $10.75 for 7 inches of sub (about $1.50 per inch of sub). If you're feeling advantageous you can upgrade to a giant but that will cost a whopping $18.65 for 15 inches of sub ($1.24 per inch of sub). Now comparing this to Wawa if you chose to get the classic sub (10 inches) for $7.49. This plays out to $1.33 per inch of sub. If you're looking at this and thinking that the giant from Jersey Mike's is the best option then you're wrong. $11 dollars for an extra 5 inches of sub is not practical when you could get two 10 inch subs from Wawa and STILL be cheaper than the giant from Jersey Mike's. Could even get a drink and you might still be under the whopping $18.65 price tag. You could talk about this and that and share preferences but this review is entirely based on price and I could never see myself paying $18.65 for "fresh sliced and fresh baked". It simply doesn't seem worth it. If it is worth it to you and you enjoy it, good on you I hope you continue to enjoy every single sub you order from JM. Nevertheless, I rest my case and will be taking my sandwich needs to Wawa. I hope this helps, or at least provided some enjoyment to your day. read more

Located in the bustling Belmont Shopping Center one can find Jersey Mike's nestled between a Starbucks and Core Life Eatery. Jersey Mike's offers a variety of cold and hot subs. Today, I tried the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak. It normally comes with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños and extra cheese. I had my sandwich built with all of these ingredients but also asked to add their Chipotle Mayo. If you sign up with your email address on their website you receive a coupon for a free regular sized sub and fountain drink. I used this coupon for this meal. At the fountain I found an Agave Vanilla Cream Soda. It sounded very interesting so I chose this for my beverage. The sandwich was good. The roll held up well to the gooey meat and veggies. I appreciated that the cheese was incorporated into the mix so that it was all melted and evenly distributed in each bite. It was definitely an enjoyable birthday sandwich. I am not a huge soda drinker but this flavor was good. Artisinal. Jersey Mike's also offers a variety of chips for purchase but I opted out today. Again, I enjoyed my sandwich and will have to try another option another day. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Big Kahuna Cheesesteak, Agave Banilla Cream Soda - Fast Food Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Love Jersey Mikes! We usually get the sub tubs. They are delicious. A little pricey but worth it!

Here's the question, should I know, or even care, what Mike's way is? Here's the answer, HELL NO!!!! I am NOT Mike, I want what I want, let Mike have what Mike wants and let ME have what I want. For that to happen, this place needs to employ people who listen and can work OFF of the Mike's way script. The last two times I have been here, i was asked do I want it Mike's way? I just told the employee WHAT I WANTED. Was I listened to and did I get what I ordered? No I didn't, but It seems to me that making the sandwich as I am telling the employee what I want instead of waiting until I am done should help. Or is this about the difficulty of working off the Mike's way script for these people? Without asking, I was told what Mike's way is at the first of these two visits by the employee, after they made the sandwich incorrectly. But I guess that was my fault for not ordering Mike's way and then not paying attention to what the employee was doing. These employees seem to think if I want something close to Mike's way, but not exactly like it, I should just tell them yes I want it Mike's way. Did I not make myself clear that I want what I want? What is important to this place, educating the customer about something they don't care about or listening to and giving them want they want? It will probably be a LONG time before I am spending my money here again. Yeah, thanks mr business owner? I guess that's how I should respond to your reply. I hope I'm wrong, but you're lack of an answer to my question regarding what is important to this place leads me to believe you don't agree with me. Who cares I'm only one customer. read more

Not my go to sub shop, locally, but they consistently make Tasty subs, with several different options for size and fixings. Delivery has also been fast and convenient. First time ordering from Lancaster shop and the story was the same. Good to know... read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - 8" club sub all fixings per menu - Fast Food Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I'm down. Fresh chain. What's more to ask for? Clean and friendly. What's more to ask for? read more

See all

I'm a fan of Subway and love Firehouse so when Jersey Mike's came to town and I heard the hype I thought they'd fall somewhere in the middle. But because of the insane traffic surrounding Belmont I have to plan my trips there strategically. Last night traffic was light so it was the perfect opportunity to check them out. Unlike some of the other retailers in Belmont this one is a fairly easy in/out which I am thankful for as the traffic patterns in this shopping center are funky. Inside the line was about 6 deep. There were several inside empty tables and some nice bistro seating outside. The menu was very basic and small but I'd rather patronize a business that does a few things very well than someplace that offers a lot of choices they can't execute. Hubby wanted a basic ham and cheese sub and I was jonezing for a toasted Italian. I was disappointed to learn that none of their cold subs can be served toasted as I can't stomach a cold sub. Firehouse they are not! Nothing else was screaming out at me but I wanted something warm so I settled on a chicken bacon ranch cheesesteak. I ordered both subs large size so we'd have lunch for work the next day. Imagine my horror when 2 large subs cost me the equivalent of 1/3 of my weekly grocery budget at a total of $30!!!! They must be pretty good subs I thought and prayed...... I was mortified as I saw the employee pull a big block of ham from the cooler and slice it. The ham they use is the kind that they sell at the grocery store, you know the kind, a step below generic, square, slimy and marbled. I was grossed out just watching her make hubby's sub. Another Yelper also mentioned their cheap meat, so I know it's not just me. The fixings also were just the very basic offerings; lettuce, tom, onion, pickles. Subway they are not! They did offer a few bread choices but of course the parmesan rosemary was sold out. The line moved rather slow as one girl took orders and sliced meat, another made the sandwich and another person cashed you out. Flow and procedure has room for improvement as you pay and get your cold sub and have to wait around for your hot while they continue to check people out. They should give you all of your order all at once otherwise it creates confusion and interruption to others in the line when your hot order is up. The cashier must work on commission because he was pretty aggressive about selling brownies and promoting their loyalty program more so than someone just making minimum wage. Annoying..... My cheesesteak was nothing special and rather bland. I didn't see any bacon and the ranch was runny and had no flavor. Because the contents were hot yet served on soft, untoasted bread it got wet and sloppy pretty fast. I longed for some crunch or textural element and hated the soft, cold bread even more with each bite. I bought my other half for lunch today but the thought of eating it is a turn off so it'll probably just get tossed. Overall a waste of time and money. I just don't get the hype, just because something is new doesn't make it good. If this is what they consider a good sub in Jersey I feel bad for the residents. We won't be back. read more

Chain, obviously. Clean because its new. Limited choices of sandwiches and toppings. Seating layout is odd as their line to order has to stand right up against the tables you sit at. Otherwise its your standard chain. Subway is healthier if that's a deciding factor for you. It doesn't make me think, "ok, I could go for a jersey mikes!" Its super standard including that their bread is shipped in and kept cold until use. Expensive to. Average price is $8.00 for 6 inch sandwich. read more

I love Jersey Mike's. My favorite part is the freshness of the meat. Unlike the majority of sub shops, the meat is sliced when you order and immediately put on your sub. And, they don't skimp on the meat. I really enjoy their subs! The only drawback to them is the location. It's right by a Chick-fil-a and traffic is awful! I could eat Jersey Mike's every day (if I could afford to do so). read more

I had Jersey Mikes thru work a few years back. Those subs were filled and absolutely delicious. Not the one I got a few days ago! Soft bun. Harding any meat. Not worth raving about. read more

You know, I see some reviews that say that it takes too long, the food is too high priced, its not as cheap as subway or a "Gas station". It is apparent that none of these folks that posted reviews like that have ever been to a great old school deli. Thats what Jersey Mikes is and thats what you get, great quality, made fresh and the taste, well that speaks for itself. If you like cheap, Subway is just up the road. I travel the country and for sure, whenever I come across a Jersey Mikes, thats my choice for lunch,. I even find them at the airports which is great. read more

The staff was ridiculously rude won't be spending my money here anymore . Avoid coming here if you like good customer service

Let me keep it short and simple: WAY too expensive for what you get. Been here twice, including on my wedding day to grab three subs for the groomsmen on my way to the venue. It was $44. We'll just end the review there. read more

Returned to give this another try. Lettuce issue seems to be resolved but Still not impressed, sorry but this chain has a lot of improving to do if it wants to compete with the other sub shops around town. Their meats are pretty low quality (ham is in a square block), not fresh deli meats like primo or Bruno's, and the bread is nothing to write home about. The "Mikies way" in my opinion is a big mess. Sure it's nice to have oil and vinegar but why cover it so much that it's a disaster to eat. The ingredients are "subway" quality but twice the price. If I want a low-end sub, I will go to subway, and spend a lot less. I will stick to another chain. read more

If you haven't tried them, you must. We love the tuna & the roast beef. We haven't tried the others yet but the extras for the sub taste fresh & are tasty. We are hooked on the tuna & get the giant size to share. The white bread is our favorite. Try this place today. Subway cannot come close to the quality of food or the value. Jersey Mike's is outstanding. read more

My favorite sub shop. Very tasty product and prompt service. Highly recommend. I especially appreciate the online app.

Jersey Mike's has never disappointed. They're fast, friendly and fresh. I've always had great service from standing in line to order to grabbing my online order. I like that they slice the meat right in front of you as opposed to having to guess where the meat came from and how long it's been sitting out and how it's been handled getting to the front line. My favorite sub? Number 13, Mike's way! read more

I don't understand the negative things some other folks have written about this place. It reminds me of food back home. The store is brand new and I understand what staffing a New place can be like especially having to teach greenhorns how to multitask customer service, quality product, and keep the line moving! I've been in there often and don't expect anything less than a great sandwich and a staff that always appears to be in good moods, friendly, fast, and quick (even though they slice every sub to order!) Thank you! read more

When this first opened, I went there and I liked it! It has gone down hill since that first time. I ordered 2 regular sandwiches - #13 Original Italian and #8 Club Sub. It Original Italian did not taste spicy. I examined it further and realized it contained no pepperoni. None. I ordered it Mike's Way and there didn't appear to be any vinegar on it either. My husband's sub was the club and he was disappointed as well. I paid over $20 for 2 regular subs and I threw mine out. Leftover Chinese was my meal instead. I won't be going back. read more

Stick to the local pizza/sub shops. Decided to try them due to having a BOGO coupon. The ordering process is annoying; you have to talk to someone over a high deli case, and they only take the custom orders for hot subs at that point. They do custom make your sub with the toppings. Prices are ridiculously high for a place like this: almost $50 for four 7.5" subs, three bags of chips and three fountain drinks. They didn't ask if we were eating in our taking out, they just pushed our subs at us, no bag, no tray. And they didn't seem to think there was anything wrong about the air conditioner dripping on us. Never going back. read more

The Lancaster store is THE BEST. We love Jersey Mike's and always look for the JM's wherever we travel. The subs are consistently good, and the ingredients fresh, but the LANCASTER store is a STEP ABOVE. We are always greeted, and everyone is friendly. Christina and several of her staff recognize us, and she always remembers how I like my #3. It may not always be the most convenient location, but we go out of our way to go to the Lancaster store. The service is quick, the staff is engaging, and the subs are delicious! Great job, Lancaster. read more

Keep in mind this is only my opinion. The highlights: convenient location, extensive menu, nice people, quick service. What I was not impressed with was the prices, OMG were they a little high ($13-14 for a large sub), I didn't think the meats were of high quality which made for just an ok sandwich. With so many really good sandwich shops around, I'll pass on returning. read more

I want to say I love Jersey mike I've been coming here this location since they open. Three times a week. Last two times I had a bad experience I'd rather go to Subway for the price I paid today. We bought three large subs came to $51. I got the same lady the last two times It e was barely any meat I even showed the guy when he wrapped it. I ask why have the last 2 times the meats are barely nothing on them. All he said to me was would you like to have them here or take out. I just laughed it off and we left since I already paid for the order. I noticed like I said the few times it was same girl that made them. I feel it depends on who makes them because this girl deafly does not know what she's doing. Subway from now on I thought when I went up to the counter the manager would have came over but instead like I said the guy just asked if I wanted to eat or take it home. Poor Customer service read more

I see that Jersey Mike took down my previous review and paid one person to write something nice lol Save your $10 folks go to Subway. More varieties of toppings and subs at Subway ; Jersey Mike's subs are not worth the price and the long wait in line folks. read more

First time I went was right after it opened- it was super busy but service was quick. I had an Italian- it was good- nothing off the charts. Tonight I returned, I ordered online which was easy and convenient. When I arrived I went to the counter that says online orders pick up- I stood there without a single acknowledgment for several minutes which is incredibly rude and a complete turn off. Making eye contact with someone and a simple acknowledgement is basic customer service- so not sure how that's not a standard? I ordered the chicken Caesar wrap and added bacon- they forgot to add the bacon but realized it before giving it to me. The person unwrapped and rewrapped the wrap to put the bacon on- when I opened it at home it was a complete mess! Holes all in the wrap and just fell apart- totally inedible. Extremely dissatisfied with my visit tonight. read more

I absolutely love this place. Came here 3 times so far and never been disappointed! The hoagies are so stuffed and delicious! Price may be high but you get hoagies that are stuff just like the picture you see! If not better read more