Flavor is there but the quality is poor. All the sandwiches only had 1 egg and 1 piece of meat. I think I speak for most consumers when I say we want a sandwich that is filling. When compared to other bagel shops, this one does not perform close enough to make me want to come back. Charge an extra dollar and put more meat on them things! Such a beautifully renovated building with such potential if only the food was more appealing and filling. Staff was great, very pleasant! read more

Jessie's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

See all

Service with a smile, any semblance of greeting or eye contact are obviously not part of the job requirements according to the girl who took my order. Being anything but that sour face would be an improvement Is she the same chick garnering the 1 star reviews? I would fire her and anyone there who behaves like that No, 2 sugars does not mean heap spoons full or half cup of sugar. Please learn measurements. Don't be so sloppy. Don't make customers remind you a coffee was ordered. More scowl face putting my order on the counter. The bagel was alright. More like crispy bread in a bagel shape. The seating area was fine. I did not appreciate how some of the staff glared at some of the customers and replied in impatient near eye rolling tones Work ethic at a counter job reflects what your work ethic is. Don't expect doors to open for you if you can't honor the basics of SERVICE. read more

The person who took the order could care less. Ordered to eat in bagel with jelly and butter and a bagel w cream cheese and coffee. And a roast beef to go. The bagel with jelly was brought to table about ten minutes later the bagel w cream cheese no coffee. Asked about the coffee and told working on it. Was told had no roast beef. How do you run out of roast beef. Ordered tuna. Finally coffee came. The cream cheese was not what would expect from a bagel place. The bagels not up to ny standard and any of the other area places had better bagels and cream cheese. Recommend you go elsewhere. Perhaps the burgers and other stuff better read more

this used to be my favorite bagel place i have been coming for years im not sure if she sold out to someone else but the bagels are now super dry & I ordered a roll with egg and cheese and they gave me a singular egg and one slice of cheese on my roll for over 5$.. the customer service is disappointing to say the least I had to repeat my 2 bagel order three times, mind you I was the only person in the place. read more

I was on my way to work on Friday 21 of Feb, I tried calling ahead to place a dozen bagel order, it was about 4:45 am, no answer, I waited until 4:50 and tried again, no answer, So as I drove up I saw the lights on a women at the counter, she saw me pull up as my headlights were Illuminating my arrival, I got out of the car walked up and the door was locked it was 4:58 the sign say open 5:00 she did not even look up at me, and really 2 minutes early and she would not open the door, so I left as I approached the thruway I called back about 5:10 and on the first ring she picked up, this is just wrong I was there and ready to get a order and for her to not even address me because of 2 minutes, this is not the kind of employee I would want working for me, Have a nice day Steve read more

The guy who took my order its a really sweet person and i saw him when it was my first time and he give me advice in what to order and he was really good i recommend it love this place and coming back soon read more

10/10 bagels. picky with my bagel especially the butter but it's fire here. perfectly sized bagels, perf amount of butter. takes a little bit to order and get ur food so expect 10 min wait read more

Great bagel, solid sausage, egg and cheese! Friendly staff too! Will definitely be stopping by again when in the area.

This gets 2 stars only bec the young white guy who took my order, he was polite engaging and professional and seemed to be having a decent day. The other women who made my smoothie seemed to have just awakened. Got up this morning graving a NY bagel with nova lox and cream cheese. We are in Sloatsburgh visiting our daughter so I googled bagels near me this one popped up right down the road. I go. Pulled up the curb appeal or what curb appeal there is none, but that's ok. Hopefully the bagels are ambrosial since the place looks so shabby. Ordered an everything and raisin bagel they were as equally disappointing as the curl appeal. I ordered a mango protein shake, dear god you would have been better off ordering gasoline with a straw. It was horrible! I'd never return and never recommend this please . read more

Never disappointed. My friend and I had breakfast burritos made by the lovely woman behind the counter. Amazing! Super fresh ingredients and felt like it was made with love read more

Great place to stop in for a breakfast pickup. It's located on a busy strip but an easy access in and out.

I have been coming here for a little while. Someone who is new there - seems to not give hoot at all. She seems bothered to even be there.. She never puts any of the items in a bag. I saw a police officer getting food - He asked for a bag and the same new lady put the bag on the counter for him to fill it. Then someone orders a bread stick and a part of it falls off. The lady goes to get a replacement and the owner says - its only a small piece you don't care right? The guy said he didn't care... I highly doubt that he didn't care - I am sure he was just saying ok to be polite. Maybe he should get a 2% discount.. Its a small amount - Your don't care right?? Just give him the 2% off. Since 2% of the bagel is on the floor. That was just a crazy scenario on top of 2 more scenarios. No more stopping there. read more

Great little hole in the wall to stop at after backpacking in Harriman. Personally, I always get the French fries ( SOO GOOD) so can't speak for the other menu items but anytime I bring someone else with me, I force them to get the fries and they are shocked at how good they are read more

The Asiago cheese bagel warmed up with cream Cheese was soo delish! Hubby has the salted Carmel pastry and he enjoyed it. The lemon pot was just ok. The food overall was pretty good and definitely fresh and homemade. Service was good as well. We just happened to pass by it on way to visit family. Would I come back? Yeah, just so I can try the other pastries. read more

My review is only based on ordering plain and pumpernickel bagels. They were light and fluffy. 3 quality bagels for 75 cents each. The individual behind the counter was an older friendly lady. read more

Jessie's Bagels - two pieces of bread on a plate - Bagels Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

Friendly staff - bagels are always fresh but if you are particular about the amount of butter and/or cream cheese, be specific when ordering Prices are very reasonable, rarely a wait and nice to have an area to eat in if you wish. Apple turnovers were good but I think the baked goods could be left in the oven slightly longer so they brown more. read more

Looks like a run down old convenience store with a cafe. Surprisingly the food is pretty decent, as well as the prices. They serve a wide variety of sandwiches and bagel sandwiches. We were a larger group and our food came out all at once decently quick! It also seems to be a local favorite for some reason. The thing that got to me was the lack of friendliness of staff and cleanliness and sanitation practices. When we walked in, we weren't greeted and the girl behind the counter gave us a look almost as if we were a major inconvenience to her for being there. Very off-putting and made us feel very awkward and not want to be there. At the end of our visit we said the food was good and she just gave us a half smile and said nothing. She was very rude. The MAJOR issue I had with this place is NONE of the staff wash their hands. They put a glove on one hand to make your food yet still handle money transactions and take orders and touch the pens, etc. with the gloves on. Not clean at all and very unsettling. I saw one staff member handle the deli meats with her bare hand which she had used to handle a previous money transaction. While leaving we also witnessed one of the workers eating where the food was prepped. This place is just gross. Skip it. I wish I could give 1.5 stars just because the food didn't taste bad. read more

Jessie's Bagels - Onion rings very few for what you pay for them but the dipping sauce was good. - Bagels Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

See all

Quality quality bagels and service. The have a rage of selections and it's always a pleasure to be ordering from a family business. Lovely business. read more

I absolutely love this place. I've been in weekly for the last few weeks. Bagel sandwiches, iced coffee, and cookies are all super solid and well priced. Bagels are fresh and made perfectly and the cookies are to die for. It can be hard to find good iced coffee and they nail that too. Planning to try other sandwiches in the future! read more

Ocassionally, I come here when I'm on my way somewhere and it's a solid choice. I like the bagels.

Very helpful and friendly staff; best bagel I have had in a long time; fresh and made in house by the owner. Definitely worth a 25-30 min drive. read more

Popular roadside bagels, don't think they are winning any awards. My youngest loves stopping here , she loves the egg cheese and bacon with extra ketchup read more

Jessie's Bagels - a view of the dining room - Bagels Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

Its really busy in the morning , there really short staffed only like three people . The food is really good and its for a really good reasonable price as well . The breakfast platters are a good size and its a really good . The coffee is alright its too sweet , just skip having the coffee . The staff is really nice . It just gets really hectic in there . Try it out there at a bigger location now . read more

I noticed some complaints here about the gorgeous young ladies that work here. Heck, they are the only reason i go to this place! They always give me fast and very friendly service. read more

I've been coming here for years. I'm not sure if what they're doing today is new or if I never paid enough attention in the past. During my recent and most likely last visit, I experienced a horror I hope never happens again. I'll set the tone with a simple expectation I have when ordering food. Call me crazy, but I expect the establishment and people handling my food to keep it clean and wash their hands. I walk in and the only lady working is cleaning the floor with an old dirty broom. She walks behind the counter without washing her hands BUT she puts gloves on. OK. She takes my order and starts making 3 egg sandwiches. Another patron enters and pays for his order in cash. Tons of change and some bills. Mind you, she handles the transaction wearing the same gloves she was wearing to make my breakfast Sammy's. So I watch her walk back to the grill and she never changes her gloves. She finishes making the sandwiches and I politely notify her of the situation. She asks if I want new sandwiches. Of course I do. This is the kicker!!!! She then says she ALWAYS wears the same gloves she handles money with and only changes them at the request of the customer. Are you kidding me???? This is food service 101. I was beyond disgusted. Someday an undercover food sanitation worker is going to walk in and this place is going to be shut down. read more

This little restaurant has fantastic food! Quick service and huge burgers make it appealing bit their first are even better. Worth the side trip to get here if you're in the area. We had bacon cheeseburgers and a fries and a chicken salad. All delicious and fresh made. read more

Jessie's Bagels - What's left of three orders - Bagels Near Me - Sloatsburg, New York

i don't know where to start....we started coming there when places in Tuxedo closed....thought it was just bagels but were soon pleasantly surprised. Now we go practically every day and have tried many of the menu items. All of the following have been wonderful----chef salad, burgers, fries, gyro platter, meatball hero, chicken parm and of course the bagels and pastries...Friendly staff, good service , fair prices...you can't go wrong.... read more

My fiancé and I moved to the area around August. Since then, on our way to work we'd frequently stop there for a quick to go breakfast like a bagel or bacon egg and cheese. Needless to say it's always good. However today was our day off so we decided to go pick up breakfast to go back home. We ordered 2 omelettes that we're exceptional. I ordered an egg white omelette with peppers, onions and American cheese, my fiancé ordered a Taylor ham , egg and cheese omelette. Their home fries were some of the crispiest tastiest I've ever had. Their portions are generous, prices are reasonable and they're an overall great breakfast spot. Highly recommended. read more

I get there very early in the morning so, bagels were fresh out the oven, delicious! That has been the case for last couple of months, however when I went there around 9:30/10:00 am felt that bread was old and hard. I say it's a 5 star if your there early and a 2 or 3 star after. read more

They handled our breakfast sandwiches with the same gloves used to count Cash. Again...

Ate lunch here today. So gross. It took 20 min to make a greasy panini. Which was on the wrong bread. My frien had a turkey cheese lett tomato on a bagel and the bagels were stale at 11:30. It was so gross I probably should have stopped them when making it be the older woman was counting money an placing it on the cutting board where my friends bagel was cut. They had no business what so ever for lunch. That should have tipped me off. The just upgraded and move into a better building but it was gross I didn't even eat it. I'm not one to complain, when I tried to call to speak with the owner he wasnt there and the rude girl who works there told me you might be able to catch him tomorrow. So how can I tell the owner how his business is being run. Hope the health department gets to them quick, maybe someone should tip them off:) read more

Disgusting! Ordered a toasted poppy seed bagel with cream cheese and the server gave me a non toasted poppy with butter. The server took the bagel back - wiped the butter off and tossed it on te grill where she was making eggs and bacon for another customer right in front of me. I just walked out and told her to shove up her arse read more

Another Sloatsburg joint that has been around for years. Nothing special, pretty good bagels but I'm sure if you looked harder around here there's a better option. That being said, they are cheap and have a ton of options, so there's also no reason not to stop for a quick meal! read more

Food is amazing all of the staff is great. Except for one lady who is constantly rude and disrespectful to the customers and other staff. Very nasty. If I see her in the front I leave and drive 15 minutes to a different place just so I can avoid her. I think her name is Keri. Jessy make your place great and get rid of her. She is mean read more

This is a great place for bagels, coffee, deli. I also have worked here and the owner &manager are crazy about cleanliness, good food, low prices and keeping the customers happy. They are very hard workers and expect their employees to follow suit. They don't tolerate slacking off, and they should not have to. The place is always busy and sometimes you have to wait because everything is prepared to order, fresh, unless you are coming in for coffee and bagels and then the staff have you in and out in a flash. Do yourself a favor and see for yourself. I try to stop in every weekend for their great sandwiches. read more

Painfully slow abd unfriendly service. The bagels were not very good and coffee was very week. I would keep going. Guess they are in business due to lack of any competition in the area. read more

Slow service. Bagel tasted like a heavy, wet sponge. Wife's bagel had something hard in it. Recommend driving a couple more miles to Bagel Train in Suffern. read more

Stopped in to give this place a try. With only only one other customer who was wrapping up his order the woman cooking kept going back and forth not acknowledging me patiently waiting the other woman took a lengthy phone order never once saying I will be with you or anything. I left and went to Dunkin Donuts. I will never go back there!!! read more

Good bagels especially when I see those bubbles on the plains :) , great bacon egg and cheeses .. reasonable prices. Owner is a good person, proven when I forgot cash when they only accepted cash and said it was fine and let me take what I ordered. Jessie was surprised when I returned w payment. read more

Incredible bagels, sandwiches, and hot food. Seriously, it's all delicious. They also started doing cold brew coffee, which I would definitely recommend. Their lox and cream cheese bagel is one of the best deals in the area. The staff is super friendly and this will always be one of my favorite go to spots in the area! read more