Soooo good. 5/5 and we are definitely going back. We ordered takeout, and the thick pizza had the…read moreperfect crisp. Highly recommend. We also tried the cookies, and they reminded me a lot of Lion's Cub cookies - thick, soft, and loaded with chocolate chips (especially the chocolate chip one). Takeout was fast, everything stayed hot, and the person working was really nice. Adding a photo of the inside because the place is fun and has a great vibe.

Crumb uncooked. They claimed they would replace it, but when I called for my replacement pizza…read morethey blocked my number and never made good in their promise to replace it. Not worth the price and the worst customer service I have ever experienced.

I was very impressed by their pizza, I went in with lower expectations and was surprisingly pleased…read morewill definitely be a return customer

Waited too long to try this local Gahanna pizza shop! Tasty pies (always) & the staff is a really…read moregreat group of people that are friendly & provide awesome service. Cant wait for another pizza night soon

While I wasa recuperating from surgery my girls brought in Sunday lunch from Bellacinos. It was…read moreour first time having their food. I had the stromboli which was very delicious. Meat was well seasoned crust was crisp and tasty. I liked it so much that I ordered it again on the following Sunday. One of these days we will try dine in.

In strip mall Laid back with two tv monitors…read more Excellent toasted grinder bread is crunchy and soft Good flavor Order and they bring to table Quick friendly service

Absolutely housed. My only gripe is that the grease kept getting on my new pants, which made me…read morelook homeless.

First time visiting this pizza shop. The order process was easy and friendly. There is indoor…read moreseating, but it's kind of small. Plenty of parking outside and its in a decent location. The Pizza options was kind of limited to me, but you can add extra toppings. There's two size options, traditional pie or square. The pzzaa looked really great. The flavor of it was good. But my crust was a little burnt, which made it hard to eat.

I want to thank to god and this pure nation for this Amazing pizza joint. SPECTACULAR!!! I think…read moreis not gonna get old any time soon, They don't skimp on the ingredients as you can see on the pic and the flavor is amazing. My only complain is that they told 30 min to pick it up and I had to wait 10 minutes more at the location, totally worthy at the end but be more precise with the waiting time, that's all peace

This place has great pizza! I love the olde world pepperoni flavor…read more I was adventurous and ordered from them, great customer service and reasonable prices.

Let Jess Tell It ‼ Brenz Pizza Co. - New Albany, OH…read more 1/2 -- Great basil. Mid chicken. Manage your expectations. Visited: Aug 2025 Heritage Honey pizza sounded like a win -- hot honey, basil, ricotta -- but only the basil came to play. Hot honey was too syrupy, crust was super doughy, and I couldn't taste the red sauce or garlic butter base I asked for. (I saw it. My taste buds didn't.) Loaded Pep & Cheese had more flavor, but still not craveable. We debated the wings... then got the Hot Buffalo BBQ. Ordered them extra saucy after seeing those dry pics online. And yeah -- still a letdown. Even cook, no crisp, no seasoning soaked in. Just chicken being chicken with sauce sitting on top. The vibe? Clean, modern, great staff. The flavor? Flat. Good if you're already nearby. Not worth a trip. That basil, though? Still thinking about it.

Got many recommendations about Brenz being the pizza place to try and it definitely lived up to the…read morehype. Many options to choose from a traditional pie to something more unique. We got the 14" Rustic Pizza, Personal Spinach Artichoke and Garlic Parm Jumbo Wings The 14" pizza looked huge and more than enough for 3 people. Lots of toppings and a great sauce. I do wish the dough was cooked a little bit more but everyone else said it was great. The artichoke pizza did not disappoint since there was an abundance of it. The wings were good because they weren't the traditional breaded then fried. I do wish there was more garlic parm flavor but the ranch sauce helped make up for it. Tip: Sign up for their loyalty program. I already of $5 off my next purchase!

When I was being discharged from a skilled nursing facility, I wanted to thank the staff. I found…read morethis family run pizza place with great reviews on Yelp. In ordered 3 pies, 1 handtossed crust plain, 1 regular crust veggie, and one regular crust pepperoni. The staff said they were so delicious that they would order from here again. The delivery was quick,correct and included plates and napkins. I will order from here again. I didn't get pix since it was a surprise dinner for them.

Have gotten this several times a family, we do delivery and the staff always gets the order right,…read morethe Stromboli is easily the best part! Pizza is good too. Unsure about cleanliness since we always deliver. If you're craving Stromboli I highly recommend!

Oil for the old world sub not good at all and ruined our sub... no one in my party liked it. I…read moresuggest putting it on the side. Pizza (chicken bacon ranch) was ok but there was literally no crust at all. We love a thin crust pizza but this was way too thin crustless pizza.

We went in through the Pub to order carry out but later realized there's an exterior entrance to…read moreStadz if you are just going there and not otherwise planning to be at The Pub. Pizza was excellent, we ordered Floyd's Flying Pig, a meat lovers pizza. Toppings were very plentiful, the crust was thin but not crunchy with just enough texture to hold up to handling pizza without dropping your toppings. Employees were very nice.