Update: (Order from here you will love it!) Two weeks ago we discovered this place. I left a favorable review. I am not joking or exaggerating.... I have been craving this pizza ever since. Tonight almost 14 days later we got the founders choice (pep, sausage, mushroom) on their regular crust. It was even better than before. You know how you try something and love it, rush back have it again and find it meh... that is not the case here. It was delicious. To me, I dont think there is a better pizza anywhere near New Albany (sorry, sextons, this is way better) We ordered it from the center of downtown town New Albany and it was almost ready for pick up by the time we got there. Oh, tip: and ask for it to be cut pie shaped. The crust here is excellent for pie shaped slices. Yum read more

Antolino's Pizza - Founders favorite - we asked for it to be cut pie shaped. - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Stopped in as we make our way thru the CBus Pizza trail and discovered a great CBus style pizza. We ordered the Founded Favorite and enjoyed the combination of sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, and fresh mushrooms. It was delicious. Service was very good. Staff and owner were very personable. We enjoyed our dinner time conversation as we ate at the counter. There are also a few tables and other areas where you can relax. Stop in and give them a try. You may find a new pizza spot you add to your rotation. read more

See all

Pizza was exactly what i asked for will return. I am from Columbus, in town for graduation from Baltimore. Ill order from here again read more

Antolino's Pizza - 2 pep sausage well done - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

As good as it's ever been. They have been around for a bunch of years for great reasons. This joint been in my top 5 for 25 yrs.

Phenomenal pizza! My husband and I got the Bueller Pizza size Medium, it was so good I only wish it had more Alfredo. I'm sold though and I need to try more from the menu! read more

Antolino's Pizza - Bueller Pizza Medium - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Visiting from out of state and really wanted this pizza. Tried to order pizza to go and called and male worker on phone this evening was extremely rude! We hung up in shocks and took our business elsewhere to another pizza place nearby and didn't even care how much it costs b/c we knew we weren't giving this Antolinos our business! Treat your customers right! read more

Amazing service, food came out quick and is very reasonable priced. They were quick to move tables around to fit our group of 5. Will be back read more

We had the Columbus spicy Italian double subs. They were really amazing, exactly what pizza house subs should taste like. My new favorite sub in town. read more

Very good Columbus style pizza. We each had ordered small versions of the specialty pizzas. We could have easily shared one of the generously topped pies and been quite satisfied for lunch.Service was friendly and quick, considering there was a steady pick up of carryout orders. This is a nice little place, serving good quality food at a very reasonable price. read more

This is my go to place for pizza. Been in business for years, just moved to Gahanna around 4 years ago. One of the best's is Mike's Delight, and the Stromboli is really good too. I miss Ashley but everyone there has been very friendly and you can tell they like their customers. read more

Love the pizza and customer service. Laid back family friendly pizza place. One of my favorites!

Omg the STOMBOLI! The food is soooo good! Can't wait to come back! Service is impressive! Not sure about Ambiance; I've only ordered to go because my job is so hectic! Can't wait to re-visit! I'm so hungry at 8am on a Monday. read more

3 stroms, a sub, two cannolis and a great time. Fantastic food, truly great experience. We'll be back for sure! read more

Antolino's Pizza - Cannolis - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Had their pant based special pizza. Fantastic! Pizza has amazing flavors and is vegan! Other pizzas were great also. read more

We love pizza and we found this place at an event that hosted 10 pizza places. And this was one of the ones we sampled. And we had no idea it was so close to home. I personally love the crust and toppings I can say I'm a pizza snob. So if you like pizza give Antolino's a try!! You will thank me later. At least I thought it was amazing!! read more

This was my third time there. I guess I am working my way through the menu The spaghetti and meatballs was made with handmade pasta; it was wonderful. The first time we had the Founder's pizza And second time their Italian sub. Wonderful people serving great food. read more

Found a great pizza place today. Antolino's is a great pizza place to order your pizza and eat in. The employees, Brian and Jen, are super nice and personable. We had pizza and an Italian sub and both were great. For me, might be my favorite pizza sauce. Highly recommend sitting at the bar and talking about the different beers with Brian. Very enjoyable dinner. Thank you. We will definitely be back. read more

Great service, amazing Pizza, fresh ingredients, I give it 5 out of 5 stars. I like that they have Small, Medium, Large and extra large. Prices are very reasonable. read more

I hate to be that guy, but today I have to be that guy, sigh. So this was my second time here. I enjoyed the first pizza I got, which was a pepperoni and sausage pizza. So I decided to come back for a second time. My next visit wasn't as good as the first; as a matter of fact, it was a nightmare. On my second visit to the establishment, I tried to place a call over the phone. I called four times, but there was no answer, so I figure they must've been busy with calls. I pulled up into the parking lot in front of the shop and tried to call them. I noticed the person who was supposed to take the calls wasn't answering the phone; instead, she talked to the other two workers, but that's not where the nightmare began. I get out of my car and go inside, and placed the order. Upon receiving my order, I go home for family pizza night. We are eating and watching movies when all of a sudden, I feel something in my throat. I thought maybe I didn't chew one of the toppings thoroughly. When I further investigated what the unknown morsel was, I was grossed out. It was an acrylic nail. The rest of the family stopped eating their pizza after this occurred. I called the place at 9:36 pm to share the horror story with them. I was instructed to come in the following day and see the owner. When I got there, before I could introduce myself and get through the door, the owner asked, "You had two medium pizzas?" I said yes. He asked me how much I paid. I said I'm not sure; I didn't have my receipt on hand. He then tells me, based on the toppings I got, that it'll be about $25, but it's a little less than that, but I'll just give you $25. I said okay, and waited for some type of sincere apology. I got my $25 but no apology nor explanation of how the nail could have got into my pizza, literally in and out in one minute. What I'm most upset about, aside from no apology, is that I have a three-year-old son that loves pizza. I kept imagining if he had that square. read more

Antolino's Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

It's delicious & the service is great! So happy to have this awesome pizza place in Gahanna! Thank you.

Big shot out to Antolino's Pizza! Our family orders pizza from them monthly. It doesn't matter the time or day it's always on point. I really like their sub sandwich's too. I have not tried the Stromboli yet. I did see a few come out of the oven and my mouth was drooling. read more

Antolino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

It pains me to do this, considering I have ordered before and had no issues but buyer beware do not door dash from Antolino's. Waited over two hours for the pizza and it was not only never delivered but the order was messed up by the restaurant and delayed another 20 plus minutes. We were watching the door dash and what was supposed to be a 20-40 minute delivery was screwed up beyond belief. Will never order from here again. read more

Awesome pizza and subs! I just hope that they are thriving in their newer, tucked away location

I was really really happy with this pizza! I love that you can order online, and that process is on point. I also love the prices! A medium pizza- which fed 2 people with a couple of leftover slices was only 12.50, and that's with a total of 4 different toppings. That's awesome! I thought about getting extra sauce or maybe extra cheese, but I didn't. Good thing, because there was a good amount of red sauce and melty cheese. Toppings were great, especially the sausage. My friend and I raved about it the whole time we were eating : ) read more

Antolino's Pizza - Medium half pep/mush and half sausage/banana pepper. Loved it! - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

This is our go to pizza! It is the most delicious pizza and they never fail to deliver a piping hot pizza. We always order the medium Special Deluxe pizza with the Quart salad. We always ordered from the big local pizza chain in New Albany and it was always hit or miss. Cold or skimpy deluxe pizza and their salad was consistently bad as the lettuce was always brown and old and so bad I had to remove a good portion of lettuce and use my own. Not so with Antolinos salad, it's always fresh and perfect for two people with plenty of cheese, pepperoni, tomatoes, banana peppers. We order at least every week or every other week. Do yourself a favor and get your pizza here. I want to try their subs but their pizza is soooo good, I order it every time. Thanks for serving up such a great pizza and salad everytime. Love the drive thru pick up window. Happy to support our local pizza restaurant.. read more

Antolinos is now one of my new favorite pizza places! On my recent visit, I wanted to go with a large pizza, 5 toppings, thin crust. The woman behind the counter advised me that thin wasn't a good option, because all toppings are fresh and the crust would get soggy. So instead I went with the regular. The crust was nice and crispy, and the cheese was slightly browned, which added to the deliciousness of the pizza. The sauce had a nice tang to it as well. The real test for the pizza came the next day when I had it for lunch. It was still delicious, even cold. Whenever I'm on this side of town Antolinos will be my new go to for pizza. The prices are very reasonable, the service is super friendly and the pizzas are top notch! read more

I'm a bit obsessed with this place right now. I've probably ordered it four out of seven days a week for the past month. This pizza is "the bomb". It's a thinner style crust with a good amount of sauce and the toppings are a decent amount. They have speciality pizzas that are wonderful as well. read more

Restaurant reached out and explained what happened. Fully refunded me and I'm satisfied with the outcome.

Our pizza was over cooked, super dry & lacked flavor. Tasted like reheated pizza, burnt in the oven. In my opinion they should not have let this pizza go out the door. Worst pizza I've had. There are several other pizza places in the area. Do yourself a favor & skip this one. Angies down the street is 10x better! read more

Antolino's Pizza - Burnt pizza- over cooked, dry & flavorless - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

It's Friday pizza night so we decided to go with Antolino's. We placed our order online through the Yelp interface with Grubhub and although it returned the Yelp disconnected dinosaur after processing payment I received an email confirming the order so all's good there. With it being 7:15pm on a Friday night I expected a delayed delivery but the email indicated our takeout order would be ready in 45-65 minutes. Wow! Really? So we drove over and parked in their lot to wait as we enjoyed the cooler evening temp. It looked like there were four people working inside but we only saw very few customers come and go while we waited. At 8:00pm I walked in as it'd been 45 minutes since I placed our order. Yeah, my pizza was sitting all boxed up and on top of the over to stay warm. Why give such a huge, inaccurate wait time like that? The pizza tasted alright but you could tell it'd been sitting for a little while. There was almost too much sauce on it as it was a bit messy to eat and there was a good collection of grease under the crust. Would I order it again? Maybe but definitely not through Yelp to avoid the inaccurate wait time provided. read more

Antolino's Pizza - Lots of grease soaked into the pizza box under the crust - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

I was hesitant to give this place a try - reviews not the best and I really wanted pizza - but decided to go for it. Glad I did! Pizza is solid for sure. Honestly wasn't blown away but I thought it was pretty good pizza. I'm sort of a pizza snob and will not eat it, if "I've been wronged by a slice". Pizza Hut, little cesar (whatever), donatos read more

I just didn't like the flavor of the sauce or sausage. Service was fine but no atmosphere for dine in. The crust was ordinary.

While I find it totally crazy how many pizza places are in one square mile in this area, I figured it was worth a trip to try out the new guy in town and I'm glad I did. Both the sausage stromboli and chicken bacon ranch pizza were baked to perfection and had generous toppings. I would absolutely order again as they have one of the tastier cheeses in the area and I love that they have a drive thru window for easy pick up. I do wish that they had wings or other fried apps but I appreciate that they do a few things really well. Can't wait to visit again! read more

Antolino's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

Pizza is always hot a delicious. I order here about once a week/every other week. This is my go-to pizza place. I ordered for a party once and everyone loved the pizza. I would highly recommend giving them a try. You will not be disappointed. read more

I absolutely love their pizza!! They offer specials during the week, either $2 off extra large or two larges single topping for $7 each. One of my favorite pizza places in the city. Only to go orders. They also offer pasta dinners. Excellent to re heat in the oven or the microwave for days following the initial order! read more

Antolino's Pizza - X large half cheese half pep. $13 with coupon on Wednesday - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had. Staff tells me that the difference is bbq sauce for the sauce

One of the best pizzas I've had in years, two types of pepperoni makes it. Bought through DoorDash and was still very hot. No need for extra cheese it's loaded on. read more

Fantastic pizza with a can't beat Monday deal for a large 1 topping 7$ bucks......you get more than what you pay for here/great service/ friendly staff, subs are good a Definitely will be here again Does not disappoint....as good as some of the top spots in this area read more

Antolino's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Superb. Not sure if you remember me but I was your last customer on Saturday 2/27/21. The pizza was amazing. This was my first time trying your pizza while at the new location and I had it only one time at the Morse location. Will definitely be back ! read more

Antolino's Pizza - Pep and extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Ok so 1st off, I'm not to sure what's going on with the flee market decor inside? I'm past it, most of you wont be. It is kinda of filthy for being a establishment that serves food and want to give it a 3 star rating but the pizza is really good for $7.00 so I'll bump it up to 4 stars. Straight up the area is low-key hood and the owner isn't the exactly the best at customer relations. Now that we got that out of the way... It's a $7.00 pizza, Monday's only but more importantly if you don't order it well done it is not a good pizza at all! I ordered once and didn't ask for well done. It tasted like frozen pizza that wasn't cooked & I almost never went back again! It's not my number one pizza spot but for a "well done" pizza on a Monday, it's not bad. read more

See all