Soooo good. 5/5 and we are definitely going back. We ordered takeout, and the thick pizza had the perfect crisp. Highly recommend. We also tried the cookies, and they reminded me a lot of Lion's Cub cookies - thick, soft, and loaded with chocolate chips (especially the chocolate chip one). Takeout was fast, everything stayed hot, and the person working was really nice. Adding a photo of the inside because the place is fun and has a great vibe. read more

Pizza Nerds - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Crumb uncooked. They claimed they would replace it, but when I called for my replacement pizza they blocked my number and never made good in their promise to replace it. Not worth the price and the worst customer service I have ever experienced. read more

Great service! Ordered based off TikTok reviews for the buffalo pizza - they don't have it anymore so we went for the Thick Crust Mario (hot honey, pepperoni, banana pepper). Good quality toppings and they have a really delicious ranch you can get on the side which was our favorite part. Generous sizes for the side sauces. Not too much hot honey flavor, but they provided red pepper flakes and parm. I asked for light sauce and extra cheese, because I don't really love tomato sauce and they have a pesto but not as a base option. I was surprised after paying for extra cheese that the sauce was still visible - it seemed like a regular pizza amount of cheese, so maybe not a great place for modifications but overall good pizza. Got the medium cook on the dough and was very satisfied with the crisp and light browning. Not burnt, not doughy, just as described. They had a great deal for a free cheesy bread when you spend $30 - and we liked it even more than the pizza! It was so seasoned - garlicky, buttery, generous herby oregano, and a nice crisp crust on the bottom. Came with 2 big sides of red sauce. If I were to order cheesy bread for a party in Cbus I'd order this one. read more

Pizza Nerds - Large 9 Cut THICK Crust Mario - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

Amazing pizza, so tasty! Staff has once messed up our order but was so quick to make the fix. Staff is super friendly! We always order in so I'm not sure what the cleanliness is like but gahanna community loves this pizza! read more

Treated to pizza nerds at work. Detroit style perfectly baked to my liking! The cheese was excellent with the perfect amount of sauce. The pep pizza was lacking sauce unlike the cheese one. Definitely would recommend if you're in the area. read more

See all

When a friend called me to say hey, let's try this pizza place way out on the east side east of Easton, I was wondering why in the world we would travel so far out of our bubble, living on the other side of the Columbus Metropolitan area. Boy, let me tell you I am sure glad that we did this! This pizza is truly FANTASTIC! Well worth the time it took to drive here. I am envious of the local residents who get to live nearby this place! It has a kitschy decor, focused on classic cult movies and nostalgic items. There are only a few tables to dine in, and it appears most people take their pizzas to go. We ate ours on site. Look at my photos you'll see all the boxes stacked up and ready to be filled with their amazing creations. I am not kidding. You need to go try this place. Take a look at the photos. Just the right crunch, just the right amount of sauce and cheese, and they don't skimp on ingredients. I cannot imagine someone getting a pizza here and not being a fan of it after they've eaten it. And I say that being a self described pizza aficionado. Get some!!! read more

See all

We've been wanting to try Pizza Nerds for a few months now, and finally ordered on a cold, rainy Sunday -- the perfect pizza day! Ordering online was super easy and fast. One quick note: Apple Maps currently says they don't open until 3 PM, but that's not true -- they open at noon. I actually requested an edit after realizing that because it gave me a little scare since I had already ordered and paid for pickup! We tried their thick-style weekly special -- spicy vodka sauce, meatballs, basil, and tomatoes -- and it was so good. The crust was buttery and crispy, perfectly balanced. We also ordered a thin crust Hawaiian to try something different, and it was equally delicious -- different texture, same amazing flavor. Both styles were fantastic and will definitely be added into our regular rotation. The ranch deserves a shoutout too -- clearly homemade, creamy with a nice tang. The space itself has a fun '80s theme, and the vibe is super friendly and inviting. They even have homemade cookies that looked tempting... definitely grabbing one next time! read more

Pizza Nerds - Thin Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

Best specialty pizza in all of Columbus. I absolutely love their Detroit style crust! So for this this week only I ordered. "The Texas Tony" (I like mine well done) Swiss American, Mozzarella, Beef, Bacon, Crispy Onions, and thier house-made Nerds Tangy Burger Sauce, straight up ridiculous! Brent was kind enough to let me try their new Garlic Knots that are Comings soon! Stuffed Triple Choco Cookie (A must have!) read more

See all

The entire experience was notably enhanced by the attentive service offered. Harlen demonstrated a strong commitment to ensuring customer satisfaction throughout the interaction. His professionalism and efficiency contributed significantly to the positive atmosphere. Moreover, his knowledge of the menu was impressive, and he was able to offer helpful suggestions. Ultimately, the exceptional service was a key factor in the overall success. Pizza Nerds read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch on a Sunday - we thought they had tables for dine in but as of February 2026, it is carry out only! The pizza is Detroit style and pretty tasty - a little greasy but to be expected. The fresh ricotta on top was a major highlight ! While on the expensive side it was still delicious. Our group also got several cookies - they were ok but not out of this world, really nothing special except a slightly under baked center. For the price, there are better "gourmet" cookies around. Overall go for a pizza but don't expect to eat there! read more

Pizza Nerds - Medium 6 Cut Cheese and Chong - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

This city does know know how to make pizza. Very bad. Putting that much dill in ranch, and to have the audacity to put I on a buffalo chicken pizza (with clearly frozen chicken), should be a criminal offense. Good luck Ohio. read more

Another review for Pizza Nerds! This time we tried the monthly special called Eugene. It was a crab rangoon inspired pizza drizzled with sweet chili sauce. It definitely had a kick! This pizza was yummy & glad I got to try it but wish it was cheesier. I'm assuming it had cream cheese but it wasn't obvious (at least not in the one we ordered). This was the first time dinning in & unfortunately it was so loud in there. Mostly small kids slamming on the video games. The drink options are a huge bummer though. You can't even get a glass of water because they don't even have a soda fountain. You have to purchase a bottled drink from their cooler. They said they might be getting a liquor license at some point, which I hope so because a beer is what I want when eating pizza. I am a bit bummed that they got rid of salads on their menu, so it's hard to make a meal there of anything but pizza unfortunately. I still rated them high because I like the food & the people but hoping for some of these things to sort themselves out soon. read more

See all

We were so excited to try Pizza Nerds for the first time. Nothing better than a pizza Friday night! It was packed which is amazing for them. The space is a full-on 80s/90s fever dream and I am so here for it! We live about 20 minutes away and forgot the pizza bag, so it had cooled off quite a bit by the time we got home, but that's our fault. Best part? It still tasted like outstanding! We went with a simple pepperoni plus a cookie, since we base most first-try pizzas this way. Everyone raved about the cookies, so that was a no-brainer. Ok seriously? This pizza was SO freaking good. Nostalgia old school pizza Book It days good. The thick crust is pillowy, like a focaccia. Perfect amount of cheese and cup & char pepperoni. The sauce is a perfect blend of sweet and flavorful (and not over-sauced, either.) I haven't been this impressed by a pizza in awhile, but this might be a new favorite... and Columbus has a strong pizza game. I can't wait to get it again. This is the special Friday Night pizza of my dreams. read more

Pizza Nerds - Huge cookie! Toffe and choc chip - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

I absolutely LOVED the pizza here! We opted to do a deep dish and split the larger size. When you do that, it goes from 9 slices to 8. My husband enjoyed his Donkey Kong, and I kept it simple with pepperoni and cheese. It almost reminded me of what Pizza Hut USED to be like when we were little kids redeeming our Book Club vouchers. Buttery crust with a crisp bite to the bottom, a sweeter sauce, pepperoni slightly singed, nice and cheesy. Speaking of nostalgia, this place is heavy on it. Lots of movie posters from the 90s, Monica and Rachel's door from "Friends", 90s pop music playing on the background. Dude working the front counter was really friendly too. Looking forward to them doing a real sit down situation with fountain drinks. We will happily return, I'm thinking the Cheese and Chong. Wishing Pizza Nerds all the success! read more

Pizza Nerds - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

We saw a review on instagram and figured we'd give it a try. We ordered 2 pies and garlic knots. The food was fine but I've had better. I wish they would have given more toppings, for the price point they are at. The sauce is pretty basic and kinda watery, it needed to be cooked down more and needed Italian seasoning. I'm pretty sure it's just tomatoes, onion, garlic and a little salt. The crust was the best part of the pie. The staff was nice and helped us pick which pizza's we ordered. The garlic knots were good but they needed salt in the garlic butter and more parm and Italian seasoning. They just needed to put more seasoning and toppings on everything. We'll give them another shot but I won't be in a hurry to do it. It wasn't bad, it just wasn't great and I was disappointed by the lack of flavor and toppings. I'd give it 2.5 out of 5. Not terrible but nothing amazing. It's fine. read more

Pizza Nerds - On the left, honey I shrunk the chicken, garlic knots and a half pep and half sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

The pizza from this spot is top notch. This is not hype-it's really that good. The crust is that perfect balance for those that like a crispy crust and those that like something a little more doughy. I tried their homemade ranch for the first time from the new location and it was 10/10. And the cookies! They're literally so delicious-always stuffed with some delicious something special inside like a birthday cake sprinkle cookie with a cream cheese birthday cake icing sort of filling. This new spot is great with some indoor seating and arcade games. The staff is super nice and helpful. The owners seem really passionate about their shop which I really value in a small business. read more

See all

I can't say enough about my pizza. I'll never forget it! I have been dying to get here but I saw that the crab Rangoon pizza was back and I got my date and headed there on Friday night. We ordered the thick crust (half Eugene--crab rangoon and half Mario-more traditional pep/banana peppers and hot honey). I loved both but was back by Tuesday to get the Eugene again! This time the owners were there and so personal and soooooo FRIENDLY!!! Super impressed with that! Customer service is out the door, so when it happens, it needs recognized. They also have these amazing cookies--I had an almond one Friday night and got a peanut butter one today. Big, (REALLY BIG), soft and filled and topped with all the things. The almond one was a stand out to me...LOVED IT! Will definitely return when it is featured. They do not have eat in, but we drove up to a local park a few mins away (it's about a 35 min drive from home and I've been twice in 5 days if that tells you anything--plus no way I could wait to dig in!). I want to try the buffalo chicken dip pizza when it returns and alllllll the others. I also want to try the thin crust. Definitely a fan! read more

See all

What a fun themed pizza shop that serves a delicious pizza. So happy they have arrived in the CBus market. They were a long standing shop in Newark and recently opened in Gahanna. So happy to have a good pizza option that isn't like eating a cracker with sauce and toppings. They have a small dining area to eat in and also offer takeout. We called in our order to a very pleasant person and then upon agreeing received text message updates on our order. Our pizza was prepared quickly and was ready upon my arrival. I loved the pizzas flavor and ratio of toppings. They will definitely be a regular option to consider for my future pizza nights. I am looking forward to try some of their specialty pizzas. read more

See all

I wasn't a huge fan. The decorations are cute. The pizza lacked flavor and the garlic knots tasted frozen. Visually everything looked stunning including the cookies. I just didn't find much flavor in the items I had. I will say the prices aren't bad. read more

See all

So hot today so I decided that I would go to Pizza Nerds for a pizza. Ordered a small pepperoni, mushroom and Hot Honey. Brent and Ellie were working today. I love coming here just for the simple fact that they are the most down to earth people. Love to discuss what is going on in the pizza world. Pizza came out and got in the car, OMG the aroma. Got home and got half the pizza out for today. The crust was nice n crispy on the bottom and sides. They use a phenomenal sauce with chunky tomatoes. Gives it a really fresh taste. The pepperoni crisps up nicely. I believe the mushrooms are sautéed in oil, super tasty. Then you add the Hot Honey. Puts it off the chart. I love coming here just for the people. Today it was Brent (The Owner) and Ellie (Kitchen Manager). You get to feel like one of the family and that's the way it should be. Love you guys!!!! read more

See all

Picked up "Pizza Needs" for the first time for the family. I had heard good things about their pizza and we opted to give them a try when we found out our other pizza place went out of business. When you enter the shop, it's very quirky with pictures, and large old school arcade games. Very nostalgic and reminds me of how I grew up. Their customer service was good, very chill, and friendly, which I loved. I mentioned it was our first time having their pizza, and the guy at the desk immediately perked up and mentioned that we would like it because they make their own sausage in house, he also told me to have a good day! Which many places don't always do because they're so rushed. Got home and tried it out with the fam. We all thought it was pretty decent. Not too salty like most pizza tends to be, however the sausage almost tasted like ham or bacon. I think the only down side is that it's pan, square, and deep dish so we only got 3 pieces each. But it was more than enough for me. Unfortunately They aren't close to where we live, so I'm not sure of our chances of going back any time soon. However, the customer service was really good. Thanks Pizza Nerds! read more

See all

Both pizzas were delicious but the Cosmo Kramer is incredible! The crust is perfectly crunchy and airy. But the jalapeños, bacon and pineapple are what really make this pizza a 10/10! read more

Pizza Nerds - Medium 6 Cut Cosmo Kramer - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

Wonderful experience at the Nerds! I've always been a thin crust lover, but this pizza is so crunchy and still soft inside. I don't know how they do it! Also, the guy up front was really wonderful! Very kind and helpful. Will be back!! read more

I'm so in love with this pizza -- I've tried both the thick and thin and can't decide which I love more. The ranch is the best ranch I've ever had in my life. I have to say though... as a place that seems to be all about its unique specialty pies, the offerings for vegetarians are a bit disappointing and limited. I would absolutely order from here more often if the vegetarian specialty pies offered more than just the typical vegetable toppings and pesto. I don't necessarily expect them to go to the level that Ohio Pie Co goes... but it really feels like they could do a little more to attract vegetarians, and I'd love to see them get more creative here. read more

I love this pizza. Something about the sauce is different than other places. Highly recommend!

It was a quick delivery of a delicious pizza with a side of golden cheese sticks. The pizza was a true work of art which was as colorful as it was flavorful. Clearly a lot of time went into getting everything just right. read more

One of my favorite pizza spots, and so glad it is close to us. Beyond the deliciousness, I appreciate that they have a text system which alerts you that your pizza will be ready in about 15 mins, they have a reward system, and the cookies are also great. And they are starting to do specials. Only negatives are that the online ordering is still missing some toppings/ items, and the phone line can get super busy, which also leads to backed up lines to pick up. But this has quickly become our go-to spot! read more

A fun shop with great pizza and giant cookies. Love the video game/movie theme decor in the shop and names of the dishes. Service was quick and friendly. The crust is chewy, buttery and focaccia-like. Excellent quality cheese and delicious fresh sauce. The pepperoni is cup style but not too greasy and has great spice. Loved the drizzle of hot honey. Cookies are giant, fresh and tasty. This is a fun new pizza addition in Gahanna/Columbus and I highly recommend it. read more

See all

Ordered three of the thin crust. Arrived fast enough (door dash) and the prices were not bad, but the pizza was atrocious. Definitely not thin and the crust had so much grease absorbed into it that it made it inedible and so chewy it was impossible to eat. Also, the sausage was barely there and the sauce had no flavor. If thick pizza is your thing, Jets, as bad as it is, would be better. Wouldn't recommend. In fact, worst pizza I have ever had in Columbus. read more

Mae tried Pizza Nerds last night to see what the hype was all about! We got the 1/2 Donkey Kong and 1/2 Captain Planet. You can order online, but there seemed to be limited options online (ie. cannot order cookies or 1/2 &1/2 pizzas) so we ended up calling in! They were super helpful and the pretty quick to get our order done. They text you when the pizza is heading into the oven to help you time your drive so you can pick up fresh! Out of the two pizzas, our favorite was the Donkey Kong. The Donkey Kong was DELICIOUS and I say that as someone who is not a typical pickle fiend. The Captain Planet was also good, but didn't seem super special. The cookies though were honestly our favorite parts of the meals. They were huge and soft. The flavors change daily, but we got the M&M and snickerdoodle w/ vanilla filling. They were quite possibly the best cookies we've ever had (and we've had our fair share of them!) I had forgotten my phone when I went to pick up the order so unfortunately I don't have pictures of the inside, but it was decked out in old toys (so many FURBIES!) and had a few arcade style games to help kill some time. read more

Pizza Nerds - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

One of my fav Detroit style pizzas in Columbus. Awesome flavor, bake, and holds up perfect even after a 30+ mins drive. Looking forward to trying their many specialties. You need to try this place! read more

Pizza Nerds - Large pepperoni and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

This could possibly be my new favorite pizza. I found out about them on Youtube. I ordered two pies for Wildcard Weekend. I ordered the limited time Kano pizza and the Donkey Kong pizza. This place is about 40 minutes from me, but it was well worth it. The Kano pizza comes with breaded chicken, french fries, and a tangy drizzle sauce. The Donkey Kong pizza comes with hamburger, red onions, pickles, and smash sauce. I asked them to remove the pickles on my pizza. The inside of this place is really cool. They have a lot of retro items and decor. I will have to snap some pics the next time I visit. The Kano pizza was my favorite, sucks it is a limited run. The tangy sauce was an amazing compliment to the breaded chicken and fries. The crust is deep dish style, and it was cooked to perfection! The Donkey Kong pizza was really nice as well. The smash sauce should be bottled and sold! Kano Pizza 1-5=5! Donkey Kong Pizza 1-5=4.5. Customer Service 1-5=4.5. read more

See all

First time customer, i was really impressed with the pizza we ordered... The Cheese and Chong was the best... GREAT JOB....

Wonderful mom & pop shop! I felt like I was walking back into my childhood when I went inside. Then, top it off the pizza and cookies are next level good! So happy I found this place read more

Online ordering from their website was very concise and specific. Picked up my Tommy Pickles and Mario along with a couple cookies. Wasn't a fan of the Tommy Pickles but had to forcibly stop myself from eating the entire Mario pizza myself. The Mike's hot honey is the perfect final touch to this delicious masterpiece. Also, absolutely do not skip the cookies, they are just as good as the pizza. read more

Pizza Nerds - Tommy Pickles - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

See all

I tried Pizza Nerds this weekend and it was sooo good! I got the 12x12 since I wasn't sure how filling it would be and I wanted left overs. Two slices was plenty for one meal and I had lots of leftovers. I've never had hot honey before but I got the Mario and it went really well with the other toppings. Definitely a must try!! I'll definitely be back to try some other combos! read more

Pizza Nerds - The Mario - Pizza Near Me - Gahanna, Ohio

Wow, talk about great pizza! We ordered the Doug and the Kramer and I can say with certainty we will be back!!

We ordered pizza nerds for the first time and are big time converts! Has the kind of crunchy thick crust that Jet's aspires to but so much better. The toppings were plentiful and the pizza reheated beautifully. We will definitely order again. read more

Our first experience here. I hate to be the one person who doesn't rave about this place but we only eat out once a month now so given the plethora of rave reviews, we thought this would be a safe bet. I need to preface this as we're an 'extra sauce' household. We got a plain pep and cheese but no extra sauce because we wanted to know how it tasted on it's own for our first time as well as a chocolate chip cookie to split. First off, where are all of the pepperoni's like the bazillion other people have on their pizzas in the pics here? We had maybe 15 split over 6 pieces. The sauce is drizzled on top; no sauce as a base so it's basically cheese bread with sauce drizzle and definitely not enough for us. 50% of every bite we took was sauceless. Sigh. Now if I paid the extra $1.50 for the extra 'sauce on top' I suppose it would be fine- the flavor was decent but I'm not a sauce on top kinda girl. So I felt like the dinner I felt a little cheated out of a good monthly meal out. We intended to split a cookie, but I took one bite and handed it over. It didn't taste like chocolate chip at all. I couldn't even tell you what it tasted like other than it smelled a little like Play Doh to me. He ate it out of principle for what we paid. It's clearly other people's cup of tea and that's great. I love the concept, staff was friendly but the food just isn't for us. More for everyone else! read more

I'll preface this by saying/admitting I am a New Yorker and a pizza snob. I'm not a fan of Pizza Nerds. Here's why. 1. Doughy; more than the cheese, sauce, toppings, the dough/bread to me is a bit overpowering, or the balance is underwhelming. I felt it could have been baked long to take some of that doughy feel out 2. I didn't think there was much cheese. As mentioned, a lot of dough, weak on toppings 3. Sauce, and perhaps this is just a midwest thing, but it has a bit of spice/heat to it. Not a lot, but it's there. I don't get it, but again, maybe a midwest thing? 4. Cheesy Garlic Bread: where is the garlic. I literally didn't taste a hint of garlic. They use garlic butter, but not garlic. Ironically, if they used this much cheese on the pizza, that would help the pizza While I know managing one box size helps simplify things, getting the 10x10 in such a big box, I couldn't help but think using a smaller box that better fits the pizza is more environmentally friendly, although I will recycle the box. I've lived here over 8 years now, and outside of one or two places, I'm still NOT impressed with the pizza here. I had hopes, while this wasn't going to be NY pizza, that it would have great flavor, but I was really disappointed. I didn't find it better than Jets Pizza really, in fact I'd recommend Jets before Pizza Nerds, which I'm not happy about as I respect the family run business, but the product just isn't doing it for me. read more