When you are from NJ, you can quickly get bored of Italian takeout joints. However, even though Joe and Anthony's has the same menu I've seen from every other place, they do it exceptionally well. We ordered the Joe and Anthony Salad, the Drunken Chicken, a Stromboli, and a cannolo. The salad was excellent. They didn't skimp on the salad's chicken and veggies. The salad's chicken was tender and seasoned very well. The drunken chicken was slightly bland but the cutlet was fried perfectly and there was plenty of sauce. The Stromboli was loaded with meat and veggies. We ordered a small but it was HUGE! The cannolo was also awesome. It was still crispy, so you can stuff them on demand. I will definitely return for the salad and cannoli. The inside of the restaurant is no-frills but that's what I would want for the authentic NJ Italian feel. The service was also helpful and kind. read more

See all

Always welcomed when you walk in. Food is served hot and fast. Tried the Philadelphia cheese steak pizza for something different. Boy did not disappoint. Was just as good as a sandwich with less bread. Also got the plain cheese pizza again really good. Had the garlic bread not bad, would like a bit more garlic, I did have an end piece so maybe it was just that the end had less. They are definitely my favorite pizza place in the area. read more

See all

Great service with delicious food to match. Got an array of slices and a side of garlic knots. Not a crumb was left behind in my household! Will be back. read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Mixed bag - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

Came here a few days ago Great pizza, everything tasted good. Staff were awesome, Would definitely come back I highly suggest

I'm sure you all noticed when you got up this morningthat it was National PizzaWith Everything (Except Anchovies)Day. Well...@BigDudesBigFoods did and as we do every year, we found a different pizzeria to celebrate. BDBF loves supporting #SmallBusiness so we like to find a Mom & Pop shop, or in Joe & Anthony's case a Pop & Pop shop to enjoy our annual fishless "Pizza With The Works" . So whether you call it #PizzaWithEverything , #PizzaWithTheWorks or #GarbagePie like Joe & I do, @JoeAndAnthonysPizzeria in #FlandersNJ makes a great one. With their all-natural ingredients and unbleached flour, it's guilt free. There were plenty of other options on the menu but today was not the day for that, although, I swear I heard some riceballs and a cannoli call my name as I was leaving. It has a comfortable storefront pizza shop feel and Anthony was a great host. You will not be disappointed if you stop in for a slice. #JoeAndAnthonysPizzeria #BigDudesBigFoods #SupportSmallBusiness #BDBFCertified #BDBF read more

See all

Place has amazing pizza he just started making bar pies they taste so damm good make sure you ask for the bar pie it's top 3 in Morris county. read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

Excellent pizza. Everything fresh, except the pineapple, it was still good. Plenty of toppings on each pie.

Ordered takeout and was very disappointed. The calamari and pizza crust on the deep dish grandma were extremely hard. See videos. Worst calamari I've ever had and leaves you with a fishy and old aftertaste in your mouth. Will not be ordering again. read more

First time here. Came in with my family, we sat down to have a quick bite after going to Lowe's which is right near by. The ambiance is casual (very typical) takeout pizza spot, but they did have a few tables/chairs and a few stools by the window. We ordered a grandma Margherita pie and it was great. Made fresh on the spot, perfect proportions and super friendly service :) will definitely be back again. Price/value was also good. read more

So I came to this place originally for the Pizza because I saw review and it was amazing while I was there. I saw a guy get a meatball sub and the bread looked amazing so I had to try it today . I went and had a vodka, chicken sub and the Bread was 100% one of the best breads I've had on a sub and the sub was amazing . definitely recommend this place to anybody who is looking for some amazing Italian food. !!!!! read more

Always on the lookout for new pizzerias to try, my wife and I were in the area, so we stopped in at Joe and Anthony's last night. The pizzeria is located next to Walmart at the Trade Zone shopping area in Mt. Olive. It's a small place with only a few tables up front, but what a great find! The pizza was delicious! We each ordered a slice of the chicken bacon ranch and split a few garlic knots. The slice was huge with ingredients piled high. The garlic knots were excellent as well. Very friendly staff, reasonable prices, easy parking. A nice pizza parlor! read more

See all

Doordash service. The food is pot on, smells amazing and tastes sublime. Despite the garlic knots getting cold from the journey, I highly recommend! The pasta looks creamy and delicious ! Highly recommend for more than just a good meal! read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Garlic Knots Fettuccine Alfredo Lunch Garden Salad - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

Good lil pizza spot, alot of different varieties if your looking for something different.

Just stopped for a pizza. Got a fresh pizza with mushrooms and it was delicious! The inside is small, not many tables (like only 1 table for 4, all others small). They do a good take out biz and it was only 5pm. My favorite part though? 3 men were working in behind the counter, no one on their phones, actually working (making boxes, replenishing pizza toppings, etc). Will definitely be back to try other food. read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

I ordered from the catering menu and the food was fantastic! The food powered my son's baptism celebration and was well received. Everyone raves about the food. read more

Hidden gem, I think the best pizza around! Staff is super nice, and the food is excellent. What more can you ask for?

Found Joe and Anthony's while searching for local pizza places to support. The pizza was sooo good (sauce was the highlight). Tried the eggplant Parmesan and was incredibly savory and more than enough for one meal. Wings were a little on the dry side but decent. We were so impressed with the food that we decided to cater them for our daughter's @home Prom that we threw her last Sat. I spoke with Anthony personally several different times for advice on which dishes would be good, the amounts, pick up day/time, even briefly cancelled the order due to forecasted rain. Fortunately the weather changed and Anthony accommodated us virtually last minute. He was always patient, friendly and so helpful. It was such a pleasure to talk with him!! Food Catered: 1/2 tray penne vodka 1/2 tray chicken francese Full tray of garlic knots 1/2 tray salad PERFECTION. We are going back to try other items on their extensive menu! Thank you so much Anthony for having been such a pleasure to chat with and for all of the amazing food! See you again soon! Like Friday!! Lol read more

Joe & Anthony's makes some of the tastiest Pizza around and believe Me when I tell You, they don't skimp on the Toppings either. This place has been open for about a Year now and they've gone unnoticed for far too long. Located Right next door to Walmart they share the same wind swept Mountain and most folks usually just head straight into the store in order to avoid that horrendous cross wind. Which brings Me back to My point of that's why this Excellent Pizzeria unfortunately gets overlooked. While not the biggest place that You'll ever find Yourself in, what they lack in size they more than make up for in quality and quantity of ingredients. As I was taking pictures, the Friendly Chef was preparing a Shrimp Scampi Pizza, He offered to show Me the sizzling pan of fresh Shrimp that gets piled onto a typical Pie. Since that wasn't going to be ready for 15 minutes, I went with a Sausage & Pepperoni slice plus I also wanted to try Their Buffalo Chicken Slice. I found them both to be Stellar Slices of Unique Pizza. And again in both cases the Toppings were unequaled to most of the local competitors. Huge Chunks of Flavorful Sausage had me asking right away, "Where do you get Your Meat from?" So the Chef tells Me He gets all his Meats locally from an Italian Market where the Gentleman not only makes his own Sausage, but He can tell You the name of the Pig that it came from as well. Now You'd be excused if You overlooked Joe & Anthony's before, but after reading this or seeing these pics, You better not let it happen again ;D Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

See all

Just happened upon this place while in the area. Wide variety of slices here at reasonable prices. Fresh ingredients with an excellent crust. Grandma square A++. Highly recommended. read more

the first time I went there it was very good the second time I went there it was a one star. terrible the pizza was under cooked and the calzone was not good either, to small and expensive. they won't be seeing me anymore read more

The food is amazing! Thank goodness because the delivery was not. I am not sure who delivered the food, but it was sloppy. No one sent me a message to let me know it arrived, so when I realized it was 10 minutes past delivery, I went to my door to check and everything was cold. Despite the eggplant rollatini being a sloppy mess, since it was carelessly left at the door, and the sauce was seeping through the brown bag; it was divine. Great taste. I only gave a 3 for delivery. Food is a 5, delivery a 0. read more

Got to try the grandmas pizza here!! The tomatoes are so delicious along with the cheese and fresh basil!!

This place is a mom and pop restaurant. Saw what I believe to be son and Dad working. Amazing pizza! The service was great! My favorite was the pepperoni pizza. So much cheese and was fresh out the oven. Great flavor! read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

Our go to pizza in the area. Really good Sicilian pie and just all around good pies. Worth the 15 minute drive

As a picky pizza person convinced the area has very few very good options im pleased to say their grandma square pie is better than anything within miles and miles. Crispy with sweet tangy sauce. It's hands down the best pizza in the areas and top 20 in the state and I've tried 95% of the notable hyped up pies. I can't wait to order it again. read more

I have been going to Joe & Anthony's since they opened. It's the best pizza around...and we have a lot of pizza in our area. I literally pass several places on my way to pick up our weekly Friday night pizza. Pizza is hot, ingredients are fresh and they do not skimp on toppings at all. Special requests are handled perfectly. It's not just the pizza that's excellent...sandwiches, dinners, and sides are equally good. Classic desserts like Cannoli and Zeppole are fantastic. Stop in for lunch and you might be treated to one of Antonio's specialty pies that are not on the menu. If you need an event catered, look no further. I highly recommend you give Joe & Anthony's a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

Best pizza in town! What sets Joe and Anthony's Pizza apart from others is not just the fact that the owners are straight from the birthplace of pizza, Naples, Italy; but more importantly, it's the quality and freshness of the ingredients. The mozzarella is homemade by the owner and the pepperoni is made from real meat, not from processed meats and whatever else gets added. His tomato sauce is made from the much-loved San Marzano tomatoes and he uses real olive oil pressed from Sicilian olives. Located next to Walmart on International Drive, my family and I have found the quality and freshness to be superior. The owner is also very friendly and he gets involved in community events with schools and teaching kids how to make their own pizza. I was born in Italy and have traveled there almost every year since I moved from there at the age of one, I have tried the best pizzas from Naples to Sicily and many other places that are highly rated, not just abroad, but also locally (including NYC), and I can easily say that Joe and Anthony's Pizza delivers in every way. Very highly recommended! read more

Their meat lovers pizza is the best I have ever had! They do not hold back on toppings. One slice is like a meal. In my opinion, best pizza in the area! read more

The passion and love put into pairing flavors with the best ingredients make this my favorite place around. Awesome! read more

Joe and Anthony's Pizzeria - Sausage and magic - Pizza Near Me - Flanders, New Jersey

Very disappointed. With all the great reviews I had high hopes but even just a plain pizza wasn't good. The crust was paper thin and the bottom was dark and unpleasant to taste. read more

I popped in for a slice of pizza. This restaurant had a wonderful selection to choose from...I ended up with 2 slices because I could not make up my mind, lol! Both slices were delicious and the server was supper nice! I highly recommend either stopping in or ordering out! read more

Real pizza cooked by a real Italian. Unheard of anymore in the pizza industry. Nice selection of pies all day long. It's always delicious and it's nice to see the pizzero makes everything as if it was going to be HIS last meal. Well done Antonio read more

Excellent food, chicken parmigiana to die for. Pizza is always good with friendly service.

Soooo delicious. They catered an affair at my home. My son & brother in law are chefs (no pressure) the food was so amazing. Everyone raved about it. Their portions are so generous that my children were happy to take food home. Not so much when mom cooks. The party was a great success. The chicken Francese pizza was a big hit. The meatballs are second to none. Highly recommend. The pasta dishes homemade bread & salad are just the best. Thank you Joseph & Anthony can't wait to do it again. read more

I absolutely love this pizzeria. Best pizza I've ever had in my life. So many places now make their pizza thin and cheap but not here! When I've also tried their sandwiches and other meals they also never disappoint. Great amount of food for the price and tastes great. Hope they never go out of business! read more

Great pizza. I ordered the grandma's pizza last week. The best pizza I've had. A must. Also, super nice people

Always fantastic pizza. I like to bring my young daughter and they always offer to cut it in small slices for her and always offer a small cup for her. Very friendly and decently priced as well! read more

We have ordered two different times and have been impressed both times. The quality, freshness, and value is hands down the best in the area. The four cheese, honey mustard chicken, chicken w/ vodka sauce are some of the best pizzas I have ever had. read more

Best cheese pizza in town, the crust and tomato sauce are the highlight. Highly recommend the grandma thin crust pizza as well, Packed with flavor. read more

My girlfriend and I have come here now on multiple occasions and the pizza has always been phenomenal! Best spot I've been to around here. The owner is super friendly and is a fun environment wether you're ordering to go or sitting down inside. Will continue to keep coming back!! read more