Had Joe's several years ago and it was very good. Came back visiting my son and decided to order for the family. $70.00 for a small Joe's combo, a medium sausage and a large pepperoni and an order or garlic bread that was supposed to have cheese on it. 1st off the garlic bread had no cheese and was not toasted. It was a 5 inch by 3 inch bread for $10.00. Will not order again. Don't waste your money. When I called to complain about the garlic bread The woman was rude. I don't eat soggy bread. Yuck. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - Garlic Bread. Smaller than a woman's hand. - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, Illinois

Last week we had Italian Beef sandwich & spaghetti with meatballs. The sandwich was the best!!!! I would get it again. Joe & his staff is kind & grateful for my business. Thanks Joe! See ya again soon. read more

Good pizza. Old time place. Reminds me of early 1970s Chicago pizza joints. Has that great pizza aroma.

Best pizza in Lincoln !!! Always order from Joe's!! Quality ingredients and perfect every time .

Doesn't look like much when you walk past, but the smell of Italian cooking just draws you in. Joe's Pizzeria definitely has some of the best tasting pizza and spaghetti & meatballs. If you're ever in Lincoln Illinois be sure to stop by Joe's! Their authentic Italian cuisine will leave you full and happy. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - All meat pizza 14" recommended! - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, Illinois

Ordered 2 family sized pizzas and order of garlic bread, over $60. Seemed really high. Crust was very thin, crispy and dry and toppings were sparse. The sauce was also barely there. Considering the hype I had heard about the place, I was not impressed. Especially at that price. read more

Stopped on our way through town. Service is good. Employees are friendly. The pizza is gross. The cheese is so tough and hard to chew--very low quality cheese. Crust is so-so. Do not recommend! Be ye warned. read more

Cash only - seating inside - but not a huge space - but pizza was good! Wish they had a patio space and/or a bigger menu - but love supporting local and this felt local :) read more

Pizza at Joe's is good. When you walk through the door the place has a rich aroma of tomato sauce and spices. You'll see Joe behind the counter or back in the kitchen. Carry-out averages about 25 minutes to prepare. read more

See all

CASH OR CHECK ONLY!!! When I walked in I smelled fresh pizza being made with fresh sausage, with Joe in the back. But the inside was old and in poor condition, it need a serious renovation to eat inside. There is a bar next door with a atm and drinks. I only went here because I was hungry, and I would not go again. read more

Joe's Pizzeria - menu - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, Illinois

See all

Although there are a lot of pizza places to get a pizza this place has become one of top picks. Love the crust, cheese, sauce and all. I will be coming back for more in the future. The dine in area is very run down, but this is no reflection of the food they serve. I will be doing carry out because I know they can do that! Give this place a try if you are feeling like a thin crust pizza. I've never been a big fan of thin crust, but this one I like. read more

Staying in Lincoln at hotel. Had pizza delivered. Service was quick and pizza was delicious. Can not speak to being at the restaurant - but hope to check it out on next visit! read more

Had this the other night. Fabulous pizza. Great service. Leftovers went into the oven the next day.. Came out perfect. Would like to see fresh mushrooms added instead of canned and perhaps spinach. ;) read more

Joe's Pizzeria - Joes special!! Absolutely tasty!! - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, Illinois

See all

An easy contender for the best pizza in Lincoln. It's my go to every time I want pizza. The owner still works and makes some of the best pizza around read more

Best pizza in town. Hands down. Joe knows what he's doing. Love him. Eating his pizza is like high-fiving Jesus or fist bumping Martin Luther King. read more

Me and my uncle and dad were trying to find a restaurant so we decided that let's find some pizza and we sat a bench trying to figure out we're we would go I thought about Joe's pizza so we walked down to Joe's pizza and ate and watched TV and made jokes and had a good time best place of my life read more

We came in here during our first visit to Lincoln. We introduced ourselves to Joe, the owner, and talked with him a while, telling him we had just arrived in town, etc. He was friendly and easy to talk with. Our pizza was pretty good - nothing amazing, but no complaints either. It was pretty tasty overall. Unfortunately, like many places in the area (we later learned), Joe's does not accept credit cards. When we went to pay, our visit turned sour over this issue. Much to my surprise, Joe's entire demeanor changed when I told him that I did not have cash on hand. I offered to go to a nearby ATM or resolve the issue as he saw fit. He acted as if I were trying to scam him - but I had no way of knowing that he didn't accept cards. There's no sign on the door or the register and he didn't tell us before we ordered, despite knowing we'd never been there before. We ended up writing a personal check (yes, apparently there are places in 2016 that accept personal checks, but not cards) but he made us feel VERY uncomfortable about it. Ultimately, it was just a misunderstanding, but the owner handled it pretty poorly. read more

My wife and I recently moved back to the area. We had heard of Joe's before but never tried it until now. I'm sorry I didn't before! It's amazing. Everything from the crust to cheese to the fresh sausage. So good! We're big fans of Sorrento's and Guzzardo's in town, but I'd put Joe's right up there with 'em. Couple reasons why I can't give this a 5-star review. 1) The interior of restaurant is a bit grim. I wouldn't recommend eating there. Take it home or deliver. 2) He only accepts cash or checks. NO CREDIT OR DEBIT CARDS! Don't let that deter you though. Joe is a great guy and makes a fantastic pie. read more

Best pizza around! NOT cheap, but extremely good. He had some issues getting drivers as regular guy had long term illness but that stuff happens. You want cheap? Call a chain. You want good pizza? Call Joe's!!! I don't get cheese very often but I'll say it's as close to NY pizza I've had in the Midwest read more

We stopped in since it is only a few miles off the expressway. Parked right in front. Crispy crust. Great pizza. Would go there again in a second. Too bad I live so far away. read more

Tried to call and place an order 15 times within 5 minutes and never got an answer. Any time it was answered it asked for an access code? I should not need an access code to order a pizza for pickup. read more