Loved this place. Hidden gem. Food was very good and waitress was friendly. Will definitely go back for dinner.

First time at Johnny's, the food service and the atmosphere was outstanding definitely will be back.!!

However my steak was done a little to much for my liking. The family all loved their choices

What's not to like? The noise, maybe, but food and service are quite good. Situated off the beaten path of the dining crowd, Johnny's offers up a large variety of Italian entrees. The restaurant was filled to capacity on Friday yet the food and service was without complaint. read more

Old school Italian and has stood the test of time! Delicious food. Good Beverages. A varied and unique Menu. A different band every weekend is my understanding. Hustle bustle. Leftovers to be sure. Our server was extremely busy and did the best she could. Street parking only but we parked close by. Veal saltin Boca was delish. Chicken Ala Johnnys tasty and a huge portion with hot and sweet peppers. Veal and shrimp was delish. Salmon always tasty. Sides were very big of our choice of penne w red sauce. Apps of oysters Rockefeller, calamari, zucchini planks, wedding soup were all excellent. Will go back soon. Definitely make resers. Bar is big but was full at 6 pm read more

See all

Excellent table service provided by Isabella from start to finish. Everyone at our table enjoyed their entrees and sides. I must say that this was one of the better dining experiences I've had in quite a while. A tip of the hat to all of the folks at Johnny's Fine Italian Dining. read more

We've been dinning at Johnny's for years! Never had a bad meal! Just had dinner last evening! Rgere were 10 of us, and everything was delicious, hot, and Luke provided great service! I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Johnny's! Ron is an excellent chef!! read more

I love this place so much the food is delicious I love the Italian music and the theme the wedding soup is delicious and delightful I love it so much the food comes fast too I love Jonny's read more

See all

We went on a Saturday night and it was very busy. Food took about an hour to get to the table. We were hangry and already wrote this place off. However, when the food arrived everything changed. DELICIOUS! Chicken ala Johnny's was one of the best meals that I have ever had. Will 100% be returning, just not on a Saturday night. read more

The best Italian restaurant around here. Great chicken parm fantastic chicken Romano. My favorite is barbaqued shrimp. Everything is just superb. Ambiance is the 70's Italian Restaurant. Have to experience. read more

Excellent food, very good service, and throwback atmosphere to 1970. Love the place and look forward to going back. My veal saltimbocca was one of the best I ever had. Meal comes with two sides for $30! How can you beat that! read more

Excellent as always!!!! Great food, great service...staff is amazing and very friendly. Ron's food is always excellent!

After so many years Johnny's is still my absolute favorite place ! The food absolutely NEVER misses. 98% as good to go as in person. Staff is great. Has improved immensely over the past few years. read more

See all

We flew into Pittsburgh this day and called my Mom to take her out to eat! She recommended Johnny's Italian restaurant which is why we went there!! We started by splitting a Caesar salad very good and delicious. The dressing tasted like homemade! And also started with a bottle of Reporta Sangiovese at 40% off, a nice treat for being here on Wednesdays. Mom had their Spaghetti and Meatballs which was very good, Mike had started with Arancini balls and then had the Veal Saltimbocca a La Romano and I got the Veal Marsala. Both were excellent and delicious! After that we were done and ended up taking a lot of it back to our hotel and eating it during the week. Our waitress was excellent in taking our order, making suggestions and getting Mike and myself Manhattans with extra cherry juice and my Mom got a beer to start. I loved the ambiance here, the restaurant was very busy yet they found us a booth fairly quickly and we got up to it and sat in it. The restaurant was decorated with Christmas ornaments and it put me in the Christmas mood. read more

I love the food here. I would include a photo but we literally ate it all. Had Johnnys chicken and ricotta stuffed eggplant. I would give a five but service was pretty slow tonight. This is the first time we had slow service and it is Valentine's Day. Staff were very pleasant. read more

I was at Johnny's the other night with my girlfriend the food there is excellent and the bartender Luke made the evening enjoyable at the bar. Highly recommend you visit and order the filet mignon you will get a better steak here then Morton's steakhouse. read more

The service is excellent ! The staff is extremely friendly and helpful! The food was excellent there were 7 of us for dinner they got all of our orders correct of course 6 of us got the barbecued shrimp dinner I was the only different one I had the chicken ala Johnny's with hot and sweet peppers it was delicious! We will definitely be going back there read more

Johnnys has forever been a family resturant for as long as I can remember. While they have been around for awhile their recipes are the same and amazing as they always have been. I highly recommend the chicken arrabbiata dish if you enjoy spicy cuisine. Their wedding soup was also full of flavor and very filling in portion. I always have food to take home. The staff are well trained and kind. I only give four stars due to how hard it can be to make actually getreservation,but that goes to show how popular they are! read more

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining - Lemon drop - Italian Near Me - Wilmerding, Pennsylvania

Everything we tasted was delicious and fresh. My friend originally made a reservation for a party of 10 at 7PM. She'd heard about Johnny's so many times, and now a friend is playing live music tonight. I'll get to the issues after. The atmosphere is fun like the others describe, an Italian place like my parents used to take us when we were little. We had the cheese sticks- I thought to die for. Friends had shrimp, strip steak, fillet, garlic bread (with their really good bread they put out in baskets) eggplant parm, pasta with sauce, and a shrimp past dish, I had a taste of chicken marsala - very good- didn't realize I had to pick pasta as a side. (Ordering was yelling over music and playing telephone down the table.) He ordered gnocchi and meatball- will taste tomorrow as it was so late we had to take it to go. He works at 6am. So for the delays, I show up at 7, and everyone trickled in. The BDAY girl let us know she HAD called to update it to a party of 7, still at 7. There were still 3 extra places set, and it seemed as though the staff was awaiting their arrival as we hadn't gotten drinks ordered. There wasn't open seat, it seems in the house, so it's unfortunate they didn't rearrange, if possible, for another table. Also. Somehow they had us down for 6pm. If you met us, you'd know better. After every other table ordered, we got our shouts in. Eventually we hear a big loud crash - yup that was all our food. If you've worked in a restaurant, you know the back has to be livid at this point. So, we are waiting again and decide we are going to have to take ours to go. It was still fun to go with friends enjoy the live music, we could have done without the passive aggression and the strange literal running around by some of the staff that ended, as we predicted, in an accident. If he didn't have to be up so early, it would've been fine. We just didn't expect to get home at 11 from a 7pm reservation. Felt bad for the kitchen staff. Sorry no food pics read more

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining - Table reservation definitely suggested!!! Maybe call twice to confirm? As it should have been for 7 at 7 - Italian Near Me - Wilmerding, Pennsylvania

Food Presentation was beautiful and the Taste & Seasoning was Mmmmm Good. Service was excellent and felt comfortable , I was at home. Try Johnny's You'll Like it read more

Excellent food in an old world styled restaurant. I've been here a bunch of times and it is really excellent. Red pepper soup, beans and greens, stuffed mushrooms, Johnny's chicken. All were delicious and simply the best. Must try. Service too is excellent. I can't say enough. read more

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining - Johnnys chicken - Italian Near Me - Wilmerding, Pennsylvania

See all

Very 1980's decor but really enjoyed the food. Thought i was in a Soprano's episode! Lol Amazing portions and the staff was extremely friendly. Will definitely go back!! read more

Johnny's is located in the borough of Wilmerding, which is adjacent to the borough of Turtle Creek. With this being said, expect to find a unique blend of small town, western Pa characteristics and personalities when opting to dine at Johnny's. One will first sense that either time has stood still a few decades, or that the supper clubs of Sinatra days are making a comeback. I will endorse the "fine dining" aspect of its name for several valid reasons. "Fine" can be described in many ways. In comparison to all else in the immediate area, it is fine dining, complete with cloth napkins and table coverings, low lighting, mirrored walls,a fancy bar, and full menu with higher price points on entrees and appetizers. Atmosphere is warm, inviting and lively. No subdued conversations going on in here. In fact, I was told it gets so busy most Saturday evenings, that tables are hard to come by. Service is pleasant, and professional, yet with a twist of being served at home. So relaxing. A majority of the patrons were dressed up for their Saturday night on the town, so it helped set the tone for being somewhere special. Definitely a place that attracts a regular crowd. Overall, this 1st experience was an enjoyable one. Not only did it turn a cold, snowy evening into a warm and cozy one filled with tasteful food, live music, new conversations and laughs, but it offered me an opportunity to revisit an era of the past, and reminded me of the importance of connecting with one's roots and community. read more

See all

The food was great. Our server and assistant did an amazing job! It was a perfect date night.

Great food and service, but too loud for taste. The live music hurts the ears and makes it hard to carry a conversation with people right next to you. Even at the other side of the restaurant as the band. Some people like loud music, but if it's not your taste I'd recommend going somewhere else. read more

Great lil Old school Italian place that probably needs updating but that's part of the charm. Food takes me back to The Godfather movie days when I was young and my parents would take me out for spaghetti. Everything I've ever had there is great. Never been on a Friday nite but they have music. Johnnys chicken is my favorite so far, and don't forget to get a side of spinach. We're going back tomorrow to try all of the apps. And celebrate a family member's success. I'm tired of trying different Italian places and being disappointed. This one is for me. read more

First visit. Food prepared to perfection. Flavor was great. Jessica our Waitress was on top of everything. Host was so pleasant. Warm, inviting, and welcoming atmosphere especially for a Friday night! Can't wait to go back. They have bands Saturday evenings! read more

See all

Amazing food! I will definitely come back I was my first time. Food was very fresh. Great Red sauce read more

The service was terrible. Waited two hours for our food and 45 minutes for the waitress to come over. no one said that they were sorry for our wait. The waitress never came over the entire time we were waiting no one apologized, or offered us anything. we ordered a shrimp cocktail for $15 and there were three shrimp only and every other place we have gone and had a shrimp cocktail had at least five jumbo shrimp. food is good but service terrible and customer service is horrible. read more

This is like going to CHEERS! The food is fabulous! It's old school Italian but serves a great steak or lobster or even vegetarian and it is all delicious made from scratch by the owner/chef. It has live Saturday night entertainment and you DEFINITELY need RESERVATIONS on any night! It's always PACKED! Which speaks for the great food, a lot of regulars. Don't believe the bad reviews! No place that serves food has business like this if it isn't great! And it is great! But plan on waiting an hour or so for your meal, but it's worth the wait. Great place to go with family or friends, very fun, friendly atmosphere. And try the Chicken Parmesan or a steak! Just fabulous! read more

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining - Italian Near Me - Wilmerding, Pennsylvania

My great aunt and I went to Johnny's on a Friday night for dinner and were not disappointed. If you are looking for a traditional Italian dinner this is your place! We did not make reservations but the hostess was able to accommodate us as a walk-in. The server and support staff were on top of it and did a great job! We ordered the arancini and fried zucchini. My great aunt asked for extra lemons for the zucchini and used them to squeeze over top instead of using the sauce...if you have not tried it you should....although the sauce was great! I got the salad with dinner and she got the wedding soup. The wedding soup was amazing....rich and hearty. I ordered the gnocchi and meatball and she had the veal with a side of spaghetti. She told me that the dish reminded her of her mothers...love this!! The whole thing from start to finish was great! If you are looking for a great meal without fighting with traffic or parking, definitely check it out! read more

We've been dining at Johnny 's for over two decades. When Ron bought the restaurant, we were a little worried that the food wouldn't be as good. Boy were we wrong!! The food and service are as good or better than ever! We love every menu item with no exceptions. What ever you're in the mood for, rest assured it will be excellent! Oysters Rockefeller, BBQ Shrimp and Veal Saltimbocca a La Romano are some of our favorites. Restaurant could use a little updating but then again it would probably change the overall great ambiance of Johnny's!! read more

To celebrate my mother's 85th birthday, we chose Johnny's as the place for our family to gather. Our disappointment in the experience is profound. We were immediately presented with "family-style" food options that we didn't ask for to make it easier for them to serve a large party. It took 40 minutes to get our appetizers, another hour for soup and salad and after being there for over 2.5 hours, our entrees were no where to be seen. When we requested to talk to the manager, we were denied. It was an all around horrible experience and ruined my mother's birthday celebration. A one star rating is generous. read more

Been here many times. This time got the pork chops. They're delicious. House salad with Johnny's dressing and meatballs. It's a scratch kitchen so leave time. Reservations are necessary. read more

Very disappointing, made reservations 3 weeks in advance and when we arrived to be notified that our table was right next to a band that was playing, we were atleast given the option of moving to another table which we chose but the table was clearly out of the area of our waitress so she was very much overwhelmed so our service was definitely affected by that, it took forever to get our food because of that. It was a very disappointing birthday dinner which I was so looking forward to. I really wish it would have gone better. When we were given a complimentary greens and beans it was actually insulting. I don't know if I will ever go back. read more

Poor service long wait for food. Bartender rude and ignores you or seems annoyed by your questions or needs. We didn't feel welcome and it was clear the bartender needs assistance behind that bar. This wasn't the first time this happened last time the wait was hours, food was very wrong and people were charged for other peoples tabs and tips and it wasn't made right for everyone and the ones it did was because we had to call out their mistake. Sorry 3 strikes your out! read more

Celebrated my husband and sisters birthday tonight. Food was excellent. We had a waitress named Michelle. She was amazing. She had so many tables and so many people to serve. I don't know if they were short staffed but she hustled the whole time. We never wanted for anything for a busy a she was. Thank you Michelle for a great first time experience. read more

Four of us decided it was time for some small town Italian cuisine. Small town... BIG taste! First the only CON we came up with: The place is big and it was very crowded. The kitchen couldn't keep up with the orders. We didn't mind, as we were still in full holiday mode, but could be an issue for some. We tried for the Oysters Rockefeller to start, but they were out. There were plenty of others to choose from, but not what were set on, so no replacement. Salads were fresh, crisp and the house dressing had a pleasant zip. Bread fresh, real butter... yay! I had the scallops - they were worth the wait. Very large and on a bed of spinach sautéed with bacon. Each scallop seated on a perfectly ripened tomato slice. Oh my yum. Hubs had the pasta special. Ho hum yum... Friend had the Eggplant Stuffed Parm and it was beautiful and a large portion. She pronounced it as tasty as it was lovely. Two of us ordered the risotto as a side - it was in cream sauce and very soupy, not unpleasant - but not what we expected. Service was excellent and ambiance was casual, warm and inviting. We all voted thumbs up and cannot wait to continue to explore the menu! read more

See all

Fine Italian food, priced right, great service. Good entertainment the Saturday we were there. Long drive for us, but worth it.

Here's the good (and I'm not being ironic or facetious): the overall quality of the food. And the bad: EVERYTHING ELSE. Reservations at 7PM (party of 10, with 5 being regulars). Ordered at 7:30, apps came at 8:15, main course (drum roll please)... came at 10 fricking PM. No lie. And place was half full on a Friday night. Moreover, there was no apology by the server or the manager/owner. Moreover; no comps but the offer of a free drink. The decor is straight outta a bad Staten Island joint from 1955, with the average customer age well over Social Security. My advice: get takeout, skip the AWFUL service. read more

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining - Straight outta Goodfellas. - Italian Near Me - Wilmerding, Pennsylvania