I'm in town for the holidays and saved this place after spotting it while getting gas. So glad I did!!! Price was initially the biggest shock. I'm from Indiana (so, nowhere fancy) and you cannot find a NY slice of pizza anywhere for less than $6-9. If you want toppings, drinks, a side. Forget it. Even a lunch deal is going to cost a pretty penny. I got two slices of pizza. One a basic cheese. The other with two toppings- pepperoni and Italian sausage. Slices start off at $2.99. I couldn't believe it! The low cost is NOT a reflection of the taste or quality. This blew every overpriced Indiana slice out of the water. Even the crust was fantastic, fresh ingredients, just the right amount of cheese, and marinara. I ordered online for an "ASAP Pick up" it estimated 35 minutes. I went early since I was close and it was ready to go for me (and still warm). Mondays they have a deal on large pizzas (16in) for $12. The restaurant had about 3 groups inside dining when I showed up. It was clean and the workers were very friendly. I plan to go back before the end of my trip + every time I'm here in the future. read more

See all

Campbell, the crust mister! Guys this young man makes the best crusted pizza ever! Give him a shot you want be disappointed

Everything was fire!!!! Fried pickles, garlic knots, pizza, club sub. The wings were decent. I would order again. I forgot to add the blonde server with the pretty smile was amazing. She suggested every single thing we ate. read more

See all

On vacation looking for a quick meal. This place was amazing. Walking in was greeted by a great server. Comfortable seating. The garlic knots were amazing super fresh and enough to share with a party of 5. Fried pickles were great also. Subs was great everything 10 out of 10!!! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Gallic knots with cheese - Italian Near Me - Hickory Flat, Georgia

See all

Delicious pizza, they heap on the topping and you don't need extra cheese, they put enough on the pie. Love their food!!

We haven't been in a while and after last night wondered why!? Our pizza was wonderful. The service was great too. Then we get the bill, oh my gosh, fantastic prices too! If in Hickory Flat area, stop by. I don't see how you'll be disappointed! read more

Terrible service. My food was brought 15 minutes before my wife got hers. Then my calzone had no ricotta cheese at all. They forgot our garlic bread, and made us wait an hour for the crap food we did get. At least they charged us absolutely full price for everything, though! read more

The food was good as always, but the service always stands out. They treat you like you're just the neighborhood pizza joint and that they know where everyone I love coming to Johnny's. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Half ham and half cheese - Italian Near Me - Hickory Flat, Georgia

See all

I absolutely love this pizza and garlic knots. I love that they offer it by the slice as well as the whole pizza. They have daily specials and eat in or take out options. I can't get over the size of the slice as it is so large! read more

Alway find the food great! Even at busy times, the staff acknowledge your there, they work hard to serve everyone asap! Typical pizza place ....fun to be at! read more

Waited 20min for 3 slices of pizza and a salad. The place had 4 sit down customers. It was the beginning of dinner time. We were charged .85 for extra dressing which seemed a little ridiculous. Pizza isn't much, very flat and basic. We thought one slice would be fairly filling but ended up super disappointed. Wouldn't eat here again. read more

This used to be my favorite spot to grab a slice. It's been a few months since I've been in and something has changed.... not for the better either. The slice was soggy and greasy and the cheese had no pull to it. I am no pizza expert, but am a pizza lover. And it really seems as though the cheese is different now, and I personally don't like it. Unfortunately I will need to find another pizza place. read more

Great family run pizza joint. Pizza and service are excellent with reasonable beer prices. In the winter you can also get home made soups.

Food was pretty good, service was excellent, unfortunately we will not be back because those dang arcade games in the back. Our kids could not stay away and half are broken and eat your money and there are no refunds which resulted in a lot of upset kids. Food not good enough to overlook the headache of the terrible arcade games. If you don't have little kids who are drawn to cheap arcade games this place is worth a visit! read more

Solid neighborhood pizza. We can never finish the large pizza between two of us, so opt for the medium. They don't skimp on ingredients so those slices are heaped with goodness. Kids love the Quattro Formaggio. read more

Foods great ! But felt like I was annoying the girl that brought out my to go order . And she didn't even give me a minute to sign the check before she shoved me the food. Do better Johnnys !!!!!!!!!!! read more

Love this spot. Wayne and Tammy are the best. This is THE spot in the flat. Subs and Pizza are great!

Great food, great service, and decent prices.. The wing specials on Sunday is what brings me in a family coming back for more. The food here is consistently good, the service a standing, what's a good clean and list.. Can't ask for much more !! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hickory Flat, Georgia

Very nice people who work here. Food was ready when I arrived for delivery. Chicken Park sandwich was good, wife had no Complaints. Pizza.. we'll it reminded me of Papa John's.. sauce was better. It was very "bready" and not crispy. This is more of a big chain pizza style, not NY style. Wasn't horrible and wasn't great. I'm not Surprised this pace has great reviews, there's a lack of pizza around here and maybe people don't know any better? read more

Johnnys is usually pretty good. Have had issues in the past but tonight made me have to review. Tonight that one star is due to several things. 1). Sat there for 30 minutes before anyone even acknowledged us at the table and we had to flag down a server that wasn't even ours. FYI our server went to the table next to us continuously but never came over. 2) Ordered an antipasto salad at $8 ish and it was missing over half the toppings (olives, peppers) and the creamy Italian dressing was mostly Mayo. 3) Never have I recalled being charged full price for a soda refill at almost $3. We like your food most of the time but you all need to get your front of the house trained and in order. read more

Pizza is really good at this spot. It is better pizza than all the other places in the area except they don't offer a "delivery service" which is unheard of for a pizza place. Nonetheless, the pizza quality makes it worth it to pick up your own order. The ambience appears to be somewhat of a "diner feel" and is always full with patrons anytime I visit to pick up my pizza. I recommend it for anyone looking for some good pizza read more

Nice staff and good pizza. Prices are great. Also The owner is a first class act. Always in the trenches slinging dough and working his butt off. read more

Feels like a local hangout spot. It's very casual but we have always enjoyed coming here. There are TVs where you can watch sporting events. They even have a small arcade in the back. We've always enjoyed the pizza even though it's not the best I've ever had. Last time we ordered the cauliflower crust pizza for a healthier option and definitely enjoyed it, it is pretty small though. Also enjoy getting the Sunday wing special. read more

I come into Johnny's almost every day on my lunch break, and they have been nothing but kind to me. The atmosphere is friendly and the staff really take the time to get to know their customers. Its cheap enough i can pay with the tips I earn and tip them back. Will continue to come here :) read more

The pizza was solid. They didn't skimp on the toppings, and I really liked their sauce. The crust was chewy but you can ask them to make it crisper if you want. The price was on point for what you get. I plan on working them into my pizza rotation. The customer service was fine. read more

See all

Family friendly, great staff and wonderful menu with way more than pizza! Go see Wayne and the team!!

5th return visit and the service is outstanding along with the food. Everyone is happy and very welcome as if your part of the family.

Usually, Johnny's is pretty good. Tonight is a one star. When the menu says Spaghetti and meatballs (plural), the item description says the same thing, and the online picture shows at least TWO meatballs (maybe 3) you expect at least 2 meatballs. Plus they were about half the size as shown. I know restaurants have struggled and I've given them business many times through the pandemic. And they have raised prices. I fully expect to receive what I believe I ordered based on their photo, description and title. Not up to par Johnny's. read more

Pizza was better than expected but online ordering did not work. If calling in to order make sure to have at least an hour to wait for your food they seem very popular, which is not a bad thing. read more

Great pizza! the crust is really good! We had the meat lovers pizza and it's packed full - so yummy! Friendly staff too!

An hour to get a slice of pizza and very inattentive service has become the norm here. Not sure what happened read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hickory Flat, Georgia

This place is a joke. Worst customer service ever. I called to place a to go order and was placed on eternal hold twice! Wish I could rate the food but I never got a chance to get any. read more

Always great pizza and wings!! The staff Is nice and atmosphere is great. Calzones are also amazing!

Great food! We ordered the garlic knots with cheese which were amazing. Drenched in garlic butter, and topped with baked cheese. We also ordered a specialty pizza which I don't remember the name of, but it was topped with feta cheese and banana peppers. We added pepperoni. It was delicious. They had a great selection of craft and domestic beer. Service was good. This will definitely become a regular pizza spot for us. read more

Johnny's special sub is the way to go and of course you just can't beat their pizza. All around great family spot. Drinking high and hazy by terrapin read more

Haven't been here in a few years because the pizza is never cooked. Folks told me to try it again they have gotten better. Well, same old thing. I ordered a large cheese and it basically looks like it was in the oven for 5 mins. Gross read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Under cooked pizza Johnnys specialty apparently - Italian Near Me - Hickory Flat, Georgia

30 minutes after being seated without a waiter/waitress we finally gave up. Tried to get their attention but it is easier to not make eye contact. Don't waste your time here if you're hungry or thirsty. It's quicker to drive across town and find someplace else. read more

Pizza is still good but staff has really fallen off and the last few times we came in either lunch on weekdays or dinner on weekends there was no place to sit because every single table that was empty was dirty. I hope this location can get the staff back up to par again soon. read more

This location is one of the best johnnys around. Service isn't always great, but my most recent experience was and we had a very large group. The calzones are huge and absolutely amazing and they have the best marinara sauce of any pizza restaurant. The garlic cheese breadsticks are also delicious. read more

I have a soft spot for Johnny's, close to home (literally) and it is my go to pizza place if I don't want to or can't drive out to Downtown Canton or Woodstock. Newly expanded and really clean, me and my better half went in during game seven of the Stanley Cup finals when a storm came in and had the lights out for a good 20-30 minutes. The employees kept it cool and went about their duties, lighting candles on each table to ensure our visibility. Unlike most pizza places, I have tried almost everything on the menu. I enjoy the sub sandwiches and the eggplant parm. The garlic knots are good if they're the bigger doughy kind and not the little things. If you're not into pizza, try the sandwiches or maybe switch up the usual and get a calzone, fills you up and makes for some leftovers. read more