Got lunch special, 2 slices and huge soda for $8.99. Fast service. Military discount. read more

We used to go there weekly, but it got where it was so dirty, from the floors to the condiment tray, we just stopped. What a great place it has returned to. Everything was so clean and the food was great! Looks like we may be back to our weekly visits! AAA+++ read more

I have gave two bad reviews for this place this year and quit eating there but today I tried again. It was great. Service with a friendly waitress and the cook was on it. I think I have my pizza place back. Bad news for my waistline. lol read more

Good service from Dixie, Was a great pizza, crust was very good ! Would go again, if ever in Jasper! read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Only one piece got to go home with us! - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

Last month I had bad service. Thought I would give it another try. We waited 35 minutes and no food or response. We did get a drink order. Three other people walked out while we waited. I went to pay for my drink and they did not charge me. Before last month we never had an issue with Johnny's Pizza. This sucks. read more

We've been here before and really enjoy it. There is decent parking in the strip mall with some spots in the shade. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. We chose outdoor today because it was beautiful weather-wise, they have screens (so no bugs!) and ceiling fans. The server paced our toasted ravioli (unpictured), wings, and slices perfectly. She was patient when we couldn't decide what to order. I love the new cup and char pepperoni! The wings are a little on the small side so I'd head over to nearby Buffalo Luke's for those. The pizza was authentic and delish. We'll be back! read more

See all

Tried this place a few times and always something, one time it's the service, another time the food takes forever to come out. But this time I requested if they could adjust the ceiling fan above use to at least a low setting, they said no. If I had a step ladder with me I'd probably would have done it myself. So instead I get to watch my wife and son shivering while still waiting for our dinner to arrive. And yes there is an outside patio but even those fans are set a Mach 5 and the seating outside is hard seating, so we prefer indoor. There was no offer to move us anyways. Sad because the food is pretty good. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Goosebumps maker 5000 - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

Stopped in here on the way to Ellijay for a quick lunch. Was really surprised to find a cauliflower crust on the menu and it was the same price as any other pizza. It was absolutely fabulous, cooked up very crisp and the buffalo chicken recipe was fantastic. Order a side of blue cheese to drizzle over the top and it was heaven! My husband and daughter each had different slices, they said the crust was very crispy and all in all a very good meal. On Saturday they have bud light pints for $2.50, so very budget friendly location as well. Service was good and we were in and out in 30 minutes read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

Delicious fast friendly and good atmosphere Highly recommend their food. Delicious pizza salads. Fried mushrooms are yummy. Easy to get to and you won't be disappointed. I am a regular and so are my friends and family. read more

my husband & father in law really seem to love the place, but when my husband went to order his food one of the cooks seemed to have a problem with what he ordered & made a nasty comment about the order. read more

Terrible. I ordered baked ziti (or penne) to go. When I got home, before I ate any, I looked beneath the cheese and there was NOT ONE pasta shell. All the pasta were just slivers and scraps of pieces you get when you are rough when stirring the pot during cooking and pieces get sliced up. Any other cook would be ashamed to serve that. Must have been the last of the pot and just gathered up the scraps and threw it together. It was limp and overcooked as well. Dog food. Just shows the cook really doesn't care. Had the pizza too...eh. Just terrible. Never going back. read more

I really enjoy Johnny's. Quite often when my husband feels like pizza, and I don't, I can get a salad (several great choices) and garlic knots, a hot sub sandwich, pasta. There's so many options. There's also some great lunch deals with a sub, fries, and a drink, or a slice and a drink, etc for really reasonable prices. The staff is always super friendly and it's generally a nice place to hang out. The only tiny little thing I'm not crazy about is the sausage on the pizza. It's kind of like a crumble type of sausage that I have not seen before. But aside from that great pizza! read more

High quality and fresh ingredients every time, with prompt and friendly service! Andy runs a great restaurant!

Can't believe I didn't even know this place was here! Lol Not usually a fan of a chain restaurant like this but we were pleasantly surprised! Excellent service! Especially since we arrived 30mins before closing, they didn't rush us at all! We couldn't agree on a pizza so we were able to get half and half:) Both very happy with our choice and tons of toppings! Also had a small Caesar salad that was just OK. Ambience was ok, basic family style strip mall place with lots of tv's. Not my favorite but it wasn't bad. Leftovers were even better the next day read more

Not giving this one star as the food was partially edible. But just don't go here. It's a terrible representation of Johnny's. Not enough staff, at least half the tables in the restaurant not cleaned off, and overall just a bust. read more

Everything from the food to the service was great. It was served hot with large portions. I look forward to returning.

Wasnt super in the mood for pizza when my husband suggested it but he was on the ball!! Best food ive had in a while. we waited in the car for 20 minutes before deciding to go pick up our to go order and they immediately handed it to us, and it was hot! I'd pick here over Dominos or Pizza Hut any day read more

I don't know what has happened but tonight will be the last time we go back. This is a stark contrast of my previous review. We ordered 2 pizzas tonight and went to pick them up, paid 48.00 and was told one was ready but the other one left, by mistake, on a delivery. How do you not check your delivery to be sure its correct before you leave? I was told we would have to wait for the other pizza to be made again. Its snowing, I have my pregnant stressed dog that had just been to the Vet in the car and now I have to wait on a pizza. We get the pizzas home and they were the worst we have ever had from there. Clearly rushed. Not cooked well. Doughy. No sauce hardly. No flavor. Not worth 48.00 for sure. Unfortunate for them losing a customer. read more

Went here tonight, the food is terrible, the pizza was like shoe leather and the Stromboli was super small and not edible, I will not go back, ironically plenty of people in there but because it is in jasper the people don't have many choices read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

We have eaten at Johnny's numerous times. While having our house built in Big Canoe, we came over from Alabama about once a month for over a year. We ate here at least once each time. Pizzas are great, calzones too. Good side salads, & beer/wine okay. It is noisy, & true that the tables aren't cleaned off immediately, but they are working as hard as they can, & that makes a difference to us. Seems everyone is short handed, & hiring. I think they do very well, & the pizzas are delicious! read more

Slow service today while staff stood around talking among themselves. Got my order wrong -x2 and 45 minutes later and still waiting for our meal. Not understaffed, just incompetent read more

First game having Johnnys pizza. I had delivery. We're from up north. This pizza actually reminded me of home. We lived 30 miles from NY. Crust was perfect. Pizza was a 9 out of 10. My girlfriend ordered the gluten free pizza. She said it's the best she has had since we have been in Georgia. (8 months) Highly recommend Johnnys. Cheese bread was on point. And there salads were packed with goodness. Definitely a fan and a repeat customer for sure. read more

Pizza done right. So happy this is close by. Friendly staff... excellent Veggie Pizza. Delish.

Excellent food, excellent service! Very family friendly!! Try the Bronx Bomber, it's awesome!!

So this is my opinion one of the better chain Pizza places. The Jasper location is up to par with others I tried. We live close so we usually get delivery. Pizza always gets here hot and fresh. Pizza is decent. Salad is a good side choice. Kids always gotta have garlic knots. There a little greasy for me. So we think in general the best choice for pizza in Jasper since we lack a small hometown place. read more

Great service, everyone made us feel at home after a long day on the road. Great food too. Clean Bathrooms as well. Good area with good people. read more

They serve NY style pizza as they advertise but it is not NY tasting pizza. It is good though and the service was good the two times I've had lunch there. For the area, it is good pizza. If you like your pizza more crispy, you should ask them to cook it a little longer. read more

This is a tiny place-but big on flavor!! Had a calzone-was fresh, cheesy, and delicious crust. My husband had the Bbq chicken pizza-and said it was great. Our server was friendly, very helpful. We plan on coming here again!! read more

Bad service, average food. We sat for 10-15 minutes before anyone acknowledged us. Many of the beers advertised on the beer list were not available. We had to remind the waitress that we ordered an appetizer and it arrived after the meal. No salad dressing brought with the salads. Dirty silverware. We have never had a problem with other Johnny's locations and usually enjoy their food, so I think this location is just a bust, unfortunately. read more

Not sure what has happened but we used to get very good pizzas with a lot of cheese without asking for a lot of cheese but the last two times we went the pizza was barely done. It was very white and doughy. The first time I figured it was a bad day but we got the same again this week. Disappointing. Not a lot of cheese or sauce either. Probably won't go again for awhile unless someone responds to this with an explanation. Something has changed and it's not for the good. read more

Broke down and decided to try this place again, this time for lunch. Ordered two of the lunch specials. Pizza was undercooked, soggy in the middle. Salad was much better this time. Service simply sucked. Employees behind the counter talking and playing on their phones. I'm done with this location. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Who is this Johnny's pizza cop? He loves to comment then doesn't follow up. Very poor corporate follow up. - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

This place is gross. There are no clean tables in the entire place. People keep coming in and looking for a place to sit. There isn't and all the servers are playing on there phones. Damn good pizza. read more

Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jasper, Georgia

Ordered a salad for takeout. Found a piece of plastic in salad about 1.25 inches in diameter. Management was not apologetic nor did they offer any concessions! Was it because of my Trump hat? read more

Godly service boys, honestly not gonna lie, pizza is great here and they are not light on toppings! BBM PIN NOW!!!!

We just left there. Sat for 10 minutes before the waitress came by to only drop off the menus, didn't take our drink order. Took another 8 minutes, the little blonde with glasses and a tie dyed shirt, to get out drinks. Sat for and additional 10 minutes and she was too busy eating behind the line. What kind of establishment are you running when you have unenthusiastic staff that is more concerned about stuffing their faces than service?? We will never be back. read more

Update: went back again, another greek salad and a slice - which appeared to be 1/4 of a very large pizza, and loaded with toppings. Delicious! read more

The pizza is decent, but it takes forever and the price is outrageous. I'm used to waiting 45 minutes for thick, Chicago style pizza, but not for paper-thin New York style. After two eat-ins and one carry-out with the same results, I'm done. Too expensive and takes too long. read more

This is literally our favorite pizza place in jasper! Also the only place we can find amazing gluten free for our son who has celiacs! I would definitely recommend this place to anyone and we have! read more

I'm leaving an updated review now- We order at least once a week if not twice a week since first trying Johnny's when we became new to the area. (We order delivery and take out.) It always takes an hour to an hour to an hour and half when we do delivery even though we are 6 minutes down the road and this is fine. We had an issue getting the food cold one time however there was no point in complaining so we just re-heated it and ate our dinner. The last time we ordered and will ever order there again was tonight when we had ordered 10 wings, 2 subs, a calzone and a gallon of tea. I was told it would be an hour and the driver arrived an hour and 20 minutes later. Ok just 20 mins later than told..not a problem. Then we're given our order and there is no tea. My fiancé stops the driver and asks him if he forgot the tea. The driver said he would find out and left. Fiance calls the store and they answer and put us on hold right away and we're on hold for 10 minutes while we can hear them laughing and talking amongst themselves the whole time. Then a girl says "did you leave them on hold?". A lady answers and I let her know we've been holding 10 minutes and the driver has forgotten our gallon of tea. Instead of apologizing she gets defensive and keeps saying "people make mistakes". My fiancé asks for a refund because at this point our food has been sitting on the table 20 mins and we're still waiting on our tea to be brought back to us. She says we can get a refund if we bring our food back up there. She says the driver is bringing the tea to us. It's now been 45 minutes since our food was delivered and it's safe to say no tea is coming. This whole thing has been handled very unprofessionally. No apology or any sort of compensation. --- We actually had to go up there to pick up the tea and they offered us 50% off our next order. We have ordered maybe twice since then and the food hasn't been up to par. Pretty disappointing and wouldn't order again if it wasn't for their wings. read more

Just had a meatball sub hear the meatball tasted funny so I asked the waitress to look at it she said I may have gotten some old meatballs and cook 10% off of my sub wow. I think this will be the last time I eat here for sure! read more