4.5 Pizza 4, service a 5+. Easy late night pizza by the slice, warm and good. Great vibes and service- best welcome and example of good people making work fun. Pizza by the slice- huge, and whole pies. We had cheese and pepperoni- both good and just what we needed for an easy and quick dinner. Thanks again for the music and laughs- will be back. read more

See all

Went on a Sunday afternoon and it was just the two of us and the homeless guy inside. Not a great first impression but I learned quickly that Savannah has a homeless problem. The girl behind the counter was ok and I asked for 2 pepperoni slices. There was 1 pepperoni slice visible and a cheese pizza next to it. I thought she could throw a few pepperoni on the cheese slice and heat it up but no dice so 1 cheese and 1 pepperoni. The pizza had obviously been sitting for quite some time and tasted like it. I also read the reviews about giant slices and these were very average size. Inside had an unclean feeling to it and was very bland and old. The $4 slices were worth more like $1.50 We'll find somewhere else next time. read more

The pizza is amazing here taste like New York pizza!! But the men in there are very creepy and unhygienic, talking about fighting someone and getting to close to me.The place was dirty and had an interesting smell. Also noticed they drastically change their prices through out the day. For lunch I paid $2 for a slice of pizza, in the evening it was brought up to $7. read more

Ordered through Grubhub and Yelp. Pizza never came. Restaurant phone number disconnected. Either Yelp, grubhub or Kay's is a scam at worst. Poor business practices at best for not verifying restaurant information. . I did get a refund but that did not solve the hunger issue. read more

Pizza was ok and slices where Huge!! I would say it was worth the price and I would recommend to give it a shot! read more

Kay's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Last minute slice of pizza before our walk back to the Airbnb. Not greasy, very thin crust but oh so soft and doughy! It's the best slice of pizza I've ever had from a walk up late night snack. I'd buy a whole pie! Fast service! read more

Kay's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Terrible service good pizza but getting shoved out of the bathroom by someone who claims to be a co-owner is some loser shit. if your reading this your a fucking loser and you lost more than a few customers. read more

Kay's Pizza was one of the only restaurants open when we ended a ghost tour around 10:30 on a Saturday night and needed a snack/late dinner. There was a line to get in, and the process was quick and easy - order at the counter, receive a slice and pay and the end of the line. The slices were enormous -- so long that they don't fit on a paper plate and need to be folder over, which is how it was served. I think it was over $6 for a slice, which seemed on the high side for such a thin crust, but the pizza was decent, especially since we were hungry. I'd return in a pinch, but there's so much good food in the area that I wouldn't necessarily seek out the pizza. read more

Kay's Pizza - Slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Open super late! In Savannah it is a MUST to find food late. I just don't understand the low ratings here. We came close to 1am. Their pizzas are some of the biggest I've ever seen. HUGE! They'd be awesome for a party. But one slice as a walk up was perfect! I got their pepperoni pizza, it was really good! They have a small drink case, and a station by the exit door to get your peppers, Parmesan and napkins. There is no inside dining, so you'll have to eat it on the go or sit in a nearby square. read more

Kay's Pizza - a man in a kitchen with a large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Can't beat the pizza who cares if the workers are rude. They can be as rude as they want to me if the pizza tastes like that

Great late night pizza stop to fill your belly with goodness. The slices are so long they have to fold it over to fit on the plate. The garlic Parmesan wings were great! The staff were friendly. Typical late night small pizza joint atmosphere! You're probably buzzed so it won't matter! read more

Bouncer was extremely disrespectful and racist towards us tonight. My husband came to meet me to pay for our pizza and the bouncer "security" made racial slurs to him and would not allow him in. Once I was able to walk out he continued being completely rude to both of us. Will never be back to this establishment again. Completely disrespectful and do not recommend. read more

Pizza was good but the staff was mean. They were yelling and being rude to customers. It was hard to tell if they are being serious at first but then we were all uncomfortable when we realized they were. read more

I love any form of pizza: real pizza, frozen pizza, fast food pizza, New York slices, grandma pies, lunchables, homemade pizza, cafeteria pizza, mall pizza, whatever. I'm down for any form of pizza. Kay's was formerly Sweet Mellisa's, which I'm not going to lie...was some pretty bad pizza. It tasted like greasy nothing. I reviewed it on Yelp ten years ago and gave it a 2 and compared it to Chucky Cheese Pizza. Kay's is not as offensive as Sweet Melissa's, but it's not good. It's very okay. That is it. It won't knock your socks off, but it's still pizza and it tastes just okay for $3 a slice. Where do I put it? It's like a step better than Little Caesars. Domino's, Pizza Hut, or Papa Johns could definitely beat Kay's. It's really cheap pizza with cheap ingredients so keep your expectations low. I bet a kid would love this pizza. * if you give this place a 5 please go to Vinnie's or Screaming Mimi's in Savannah. They are light years better and do slices. read more

Kay's Pizza - A regular cheese slice appears. - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Kays then. There's lots of fun to be had late night in Savannah but there's not a lot of great food and for that reason I can put this fairly average sold-by-the-slice pizza up from a 3 if it were in good pizza towns, to a 4. Part of my affinity for it is probably because am I sentimentally attached to them since this is where I played my concert many years ago when I performed in Savannah for the first and only time. I'll always love this place and this town. read more

Kay's Pizza - Pizza on earth - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

I visited here at 2 a.m. on a Thursday night (Friday morning) after playing in a poker tournament and very hungry. The first thing I noticed was a drunk and potentially promiscuous crowd along with security guards. Therefore, if you visit here at around the same time, I recommend buying a crazy oversized condom that will fit over your entire body (whether you're male or female). You'll look like a d***head, but safety first. The pizza is large and the people who work here seem cool, but the taste is average and the pizza is insanely overpriced. Only recommended in an emergency, such as at 2 a.m. on a weeknight, but only if you're wearing a raincoat. read more

See all

First of all they are open late which automatically grants this pizza establishment 4 stars but then..... wait for it..... the pizza is actually really good. The crust is perfectly sweet and the sauce delicious. Considering how many drunk people they serve each weekend they don't need to be that good but yet they are. I'd go there during the day! And btw, I'm from Jersey so we know good pizza and this place deserves the rating. read more

Kay's Pizza - Ta go za - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Being from NY, this is not NY pizza. It is GA style NY pizza. However, the staff is very friendly. Great people watching spot as counters with stools along windows. Recommend if you are looking for a quick bite. read more

Kay's Pizza - Thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

I was torn on the star level; I give it a 3.5 and rounded up to four. The standout for this place is the herb infused crust. It really is tasty. Unfortunately the rest of the pizza is pretty floppy and greasy. We ordered to go at the store since it was pretty packed with the late night crowd. The team moved people through quickly since they have a limited late night menu of cheese or pepperoni which is very smart considering the volume of customers. I'd like to give it another shot in the daytime with a more customized pizza, but I'm not sure it would matter much since I saw the pizza we ordered was fresh out of the oven. As good as the crust is, I just didn't like the greasiness of the slices, but I'd still hit this location again for late night convenience. read more

Kay's Pizza - Large slices! - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Only good if you're super drunk and everything else is closed. Line can get long, 4 slices .+ tip was $29. Easy to feel unsafe here from a ton of teenage loiterers. I've never come here and not had people beg me to buy them a slice. Pizza itself is very greasy. This is a - I'm really drunk but need something in my stomach so I don't have the world's worst hangover, so I think I'll risk getting mugged and wait in a 20 minute line for an unsatisfying greasy slice of pizza - kind of place. read more

Good drunk pizza. Fast service, nice people, and they give you a to go box which is nice especially when you're only ordering one slice. My beef with this place is that they only serve cheese or pepperoni pizza...I have honestly never been to a pizza joint that is so limited. They had a huge line so it's clearly a popular place, why not offer a few different choices? I'm assuming they have a bigger variety during the day but even at night they should offer more. read more

This is no frills pizza. Looking for a greasy slice late night? This is your place. I went with a pretty big group and we ordered the extra large. It took 4 of us to carry the huge box out of the restaurant! There's not much more to say. The slices are huge! It's greasy, filling and hot. Just go. You're welcome. read more

Kay's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

No restrooms, pizza not out in oven when ordered, no seats, and crappy service. Took two bites and left on window sill. Trash read more

If you're drunk enough this might be good . Long greasy , thin and salty pizza . Lay out is not ideal and makes me feel like I can get pizza and robbed all in one stop. read more

This is a shabby pizza place but the NYC style pizza slices are the best in SAV. The salads aren't bad for the price but never forget to splurge for the brownie. Like never pass on the homemade plastic wrapped brownie. read more

Always a reliable place for a late night pizza bite. When all food establishments are closed... Kay's is open. Their pizza is delicious and affordable. We have been here many over the years as we visit Savannah at least once a year. Last night they only had cheese and pepperoni available and was delicious. You cannot eat inside but there are parks all around you can walk to and eat. read more

We were hungry after a late night of bar hopping and this place was the only spot open. Pepperoni pizza was really good. Slices are a good size and line moved fast. Great place to grab some late night grub after all of the partying! read more

Pizza had good flavor and the seasoning on the crust was top notch. Service was really fast as we walked right in and were seated with our slices within a few minutes. Pretty good place if you're in the area and want pizza by the slice. My Yelp ratings explained: *- "Awful". If this was the last place to eat on Earth I would rather eat sticks & dirt. **- "Ok". It's not terrible but if you have a better choice take it. If not then you can safely eat here. ***- "Good". This is my middle of the road. Decent place to eat, worth going to. ****- "Very good". You should add this to your list of places you want to visit one day. *****- "Outstanding". Get a babysitter, leave the kids with the dog. Whatever you have to do, go to this place now! read more

Said they were open until midnight. Walked all the way there at 10:00pm and they were closed. Don't recommend unless you call and confirm they're open. read more

We came here super late while walking around... pizza was too soft & mushy... no type of crispy ness to the crust... I was extremely hungry so I ate it. Next time I will wait. read more

Kay's Pizza - Cheese slice to go - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Came by for a late night snack meal. Pizza is just okay. Not much flavor. Pepperoni or cheese were the only options. A combo would have been a good option. It's open late and has a night club vibe - given the time of night it was better than nothing. We hadn't had dinner. read more

OMG was the best pizza and service. When we walked in the guy at the counter greeted us with a very happy attitude. Was friendly and joking with us. The pizza was amazing. Huge slices of pizza. read more

The pizza here is delicious.... The herb infused crust and crispy pieces (I have no idea how do they it but it's a thing) were so yummy. We almost passed this one up thinking it was a regular pizza spot, that would have been a mistake. read more

Kay's Pizza - Single slice- Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED [ LIKED The pizza was delicious! Yummy, hot, fresh and authentic taste. DISLIKED ] DISLIKED ] DISLIKED ] DISLIKED ] DISLIKED ] DISLIKED No seating, like at all.. I get it cause the place is small. But we'd been walking for a min, we wanted to pop a squat, enjoy a slice and move on. It wasn't ideal but hey, it was delicious and I guess their style. read more

I am a faithful customer and I am so sad that the light skinned girl named Kay doesn't work here anymore her pizzas were very delightful to me the other girl that short isn't really clean and it's disgusting every time I eat there plus her attitude sucks love the pizza but not the customer service ... read more

If you are fans of Seinfeld you may be familiar with the "Soup Nazi"-- Well Kay's is the Pizza equivalent ! The service provided by this short, brunette was unreal ... before we stepped back into time of this small throwback greasy pizza joint this girl was slamming pizza pans yelling to herself profanities and we at first opted to not order...but after one of our party sought to seek out info regarding the lunch special ... she was able to summon a more pleasant attitude so we took the bait. The special 2 slices and a soda for $8.00. Great deal ... we asked for 3 specials with cheese slices... at the time we ordered we were the only customers there . She threw up on top of the counter nothing but Pepperoni .. when we corrected her- immediately she went into a tirade and started yelling that she didn't appreciate out f'n attitude ! We asked about the soda as she pointed to the machine and yelled there it is dumb " ass" ... which we could see but there were no cups ... as the line started to grow the situation escalated and I was ready to dive for cover. At that point we left w/o pizza or soda never to return . We should have heeded our first instinct - if you see a girl slamming pans, shouting profanities and yelling to staff that's not there ... run!!! As to the pizza ... who knows. Buyer beware. read more

Hannah took the time to make out pizza just the way we wanted it. Hannah even took the time have a little conversation which made us feel our business was appreciated. read more

Prepare to wait 45 minutes for your 10-inch personal pizza while being subjected to death metal music on max volume in a tiny shop.

The pizza is cardboard with ragu sauce and Walmart mozzarella cheese. Pepperoni might be from the dollar store. But the service is great, people are nice and friendly. Still Wouldn't feed this pizza to my worst enemy. read more

Once known as Sweet Melissa's, Kay's Pizza was the highlight of my weekend in Savannah. After a serious recommendation from a waitress the previous night, I made sure to stumble in...literally...before a drunken ghost tour I planned around the Riverfront. I figured a nice cheesy slice was a good base for some heavy drinking. Boy was I right! Slices are wide and thin. Definitely a classic NY Foldable crust, just with a special surprise underneath. I say special surprise because when you first fold that baby, you're greeted by flakes of fresh oregano, parsley and rosemary. Had me moaning "Yass Honey!" Forget the traditional corn meal, here at Kay's, they literally infuse the crust with fresh herbs. Very nice touch! One slice is a huge portion but you'll be tempted for a second once you inhale the first because yes, you will literally inhale it. My drinking partner described it perfectly by screaming "I want it ALL UP in my face!" If you arrive before 9 p.m. they serve a wider variety of slices like veggie or meat lovers. They switch to classic pepperoni and cheese slices once the drunk crowd rolls in after 11 p.m. I would know first hand, since I stumbled in TWICE in one night. Definitely worth stopping by if you have plans to bar hop in Savannah! read more

Kay's Pizza - Meat Lovers Slice - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all