Giving a solid 4 stars. Honestly its much easier to list what could be improved. And considering…read morethis environment, I can only think of a couple. 1. Hot Tin Roof Restaurant. The breakfasts for the price taste dismal and lower quantity. 2 eggs bacon, toast, and chopped potatoes a bit over $20 as most other dishes plus smaller sizes if you just want a donut or similar. The vibe I get is for breakfast this place is for guests who have a hotel package that includes free breakfasts. They also charge a 18% mandatory "service charge" and of course another line for the tip. We didn't do dinner here. I hope its better than the breakfast. 2. We booked under The Edge Chase Sapphire Reserve so its $100 property credit and free breakfasts for 2. When you consider "service charges" tips, taxes, and determine what the credit can be used for, it becomes a bit confusing. I know for a fact that laundry is not included, neither is the $50/day valet parking. Sort of an resort advantage to keep the guest guessing. Drinks food, spa i know are included with the $100. The valet guy was cool and informative. Considering the small island size and the cost of everything, this was a great stay. The room and balcony overlooking Malery Square plus the ocean and Sunset Island were fantastic. I have stayed at many locations over the years and this was by far the best. Pegasus on Duval is a dump. Both Hyatts are nice but on east side of the island so transportation becomes an issue. Do you really want to drive close to Duvall....if you can find a space, then pay for parking? This place is 2 blocks from Sloppy Joe's, Hogsbreath, next to Malerly Square and sunset pier. Walking distance to the hot spots at night.

Terrible hotel building with terrible customer service…read more Building is old and consist of few buildings combined. Need to change elevator 2 times to go to your room. Rooms are nicely decorated but not what you expect for $1000 a night. They are way over priced for the quality. Front desk staff is terrible. Don't know how to handle issues which you will have plenty. We didn't have AC 2 out of 3 nights and they didn't even feel bad about it. They said basically it is what it is and we have to deal with it. One night they moved us to another room and they were acting like they were doing us a favor. It was major problem for us. second night they moved us to our room which has broken AC And gave us boxed fan to cool off. Front desk manager is clueless and don't know how to handle issues and he has kids working for him who do not know how to handle anything. They are like teenagers. I would never ever stay there again and warn anyone not to there. Oh you will wake up 5am because of dumpster trucks getting the trash and it takes like 20 min. Another thing is their damn roosters , they start 4am and won't let you sleep. Jesus, it was 3 days of hell!

Hyatt accommodated us wonderfully with a beautiful third-floor room overlooking the beach. The beds…read morewere incredibly comfortable, and the unit had everything we needed--including soap, dishwashing detergent, a washer and dryer, and laundry detergent. The outdoor patio was huge and offered a gorgeous view, making it the perfect place to relax. We had a very comfortable and enjoyable stay!

Beautiful but small resort in Key West. Got the double balcony ocean front room and it's totally…read moreworth the money to see the water view and the spectacular sunset. Great central location that we technically didn't need a car. The beach was tiny but the water was crystal clear. We booked the jet ski at the resort toi and that was super convenient. We'll definitely come back the next time we're in Key West. One of my most favorite beach front rooms for sure.

We haven't stayed here although the place looks awesome. Rooms open to the pool…read more We just stop at the bar, which is really cool looking. Stylish! But then they showed us their rooftop bar (live music!) that overlooks Duvall St. so now that's our go to spot to drink and people watch. See you there!

Beautiful property with fantastic tropical garden landscaping. We enjoyed stopping here on our…read moremeandering walks around town and admiring the classic style and elegance of the property.

Another fantastic stay at Opal Key! This was another return visit for us, and once again, we…read moreabsolutely loved it. Check-in was busy when we arrived, but the staff remained friendly, patient, and accommodating. We've stayed here several times over the years, including during the renovations, so we've seen the resort through all its phases. It's wonderful to see everything almost completed, and the property looks great. Throughout every visit, the staff has always gone above and beyond to make our stay enjoyable. One thing we've learned is that if you have a special request, just ask , they're happy to help whenever they can. Our two-bedroom suite was perfect for our family. We love the layout and found it incredibly comfortable. While many guests prefer the ocean-view rooms, we actually enjoy them, even with the occasional cruise ship in the harbor. Besides, you're in Key West! Take a walk and explore, you'll find gorgeous ocean views all around the island. The location truly couldn't be better. You're within walking distance of Duval Street, Mallory Square, great restaurants, shopping, and so many Key West attractions. We also had dinner at the newly decorated Lolita's Coastal Cocina, and it was absolutely delicious. A special thank you to Damir K., who has been wonderful throughout our stay. His hospitality, along with the rest of the staff, is one of the many reasons we keep coming back. Keep up the great work, Opal Key...we're already looking forward to our next visit!

Save your money on the ocean view. the entire complex is obscured by 8+ story cruise ships that…read morearrive EVERY DAY at 7am, play the Star Spangled Banner (loudly) at 8am, and don't leave until 7pm. Also watch out for the valet guy. I rolled down my car window to find out where I should leave me car while checking in and despite being less than 10 feet away from me, he ignored me and walked away. After I checked in and tried to get my kiddos situated in the lobby with our luggage so I could go self-park the car I finally got his attention by him calling out "hey, can you move your car?" To which I replied "As soon as I'm done doing what I'm doing. And for the record, I tried to ask you where to park and you ignored me and walked away so... sorry, not sorry?"

Second time at the Eden House and the staff was amazing as they were the first time we stayed…read more Rooms were clean. After we check out we could use the pool and changing area. They provided a welcome drink and the Tiki bar staff were incredible. We already booking our next stay in Dec.

***Buyer Beware*** This hotel is a scam. They advertise…read morerooms with queen size beds that are clearly full size at best. I actually measured the bed and it was far smaller. On top of that the room is almost closet sized with an exposed shower and sink which makes it feel very humid in the room. Theres barely enough space between the bed and wall to walking into the room. The shower also hadn't been cleaned with a piece of old soap stuck to the floor and bug crawling under the pillow when i moved it.. I brought it to the attention of the man working the front desk who first told me it was a queen. The GM came on later that evening and admitted that it wasn't a queen and offered us a slightly larger rom but same size bed. Again the sink was in the room and it was stuffy and humid which made it hard to sleep more than four hours. I canceled the room after one night and tried to get my money back, but they've refused. Do not stay at this hotel. The "queen room" is basically just a hostel at hotel prices. $260 a night in my case.

The hotel is in a beautiful, picture-perfect setting…read more The check-in process was unpleasant with the clerk seeming to be very annoyed with us. Our room was down a hallway off from the main building and reminded me more of a Days Inn than a resort. The bed was comfortable and the room spacious, but not on the level of a resort.

We stayed at Casa Marina Key West in August, which is considered the slower season. The hotel is in…read morea great location--about a 20-minute walk to Duval Street--and they offer bike and golf-cart rentals as well. Check-in was easy, and the lobby was very clean and inviting. The property has a bar, café, concierge, and a small restaurant serving breakfast. Our room was spacious, the bed was very comfortable, and the shower had excellent water pressure. We also enjoyed having pool access. The pool was definitely the highlight. It is saltwater and has separate adults-only and children's sections, which was a huge plus. The pool attendants were wonderful, and the pool manager did an exceptional job. Their service is the main reason I would give this hotel three stars instead of fewer. Unfortunately, housekeeping was very slow. Our room was not serviced until around 4 p.m. most days and was not serviced at all on Sunday. This was especially odd because housekeeping staff could be heard speaking loudly in the hallway very early in the morning. We also had one very uncomfortable experience at the hotel bar. A heavily intoxicated gentleman was yelling racial slurs while another woman played country music loudly from her phone. The bartender was alone, and there did not appear to be any security support nearby. We left immediately. Ironically, we had planned to attempt a little ghost-conjuring of our own one evening, given Key West's spooky reputation, but our plans were quickly interrupted by the very drunk man in the lobby yelling racial slurs. It was certainly not the supernatural encounter we had in mind. The hotel does have beach access, although we avoided the beach because of the significant seaweed issue, which was not the hotel's fault. Overall, Casa Marina has a beautiful pool, comfortable rooms, and a convenient location, but the housekeeping delays and bar incident made the experience feel inconsistent.

Beautiful property just two blocks from Duval Street. Staff was attentive and friendly. Our room…read morewas in great condition and well cared for with daily housekeeping and turn down service. Despite being close to the action, the location was a relaxing and quiet atmosphere. Unfortunately didn't take any pictures of the hotel during our stay, but we had a great time and would definitely stay here again!

Marquesa Hotel is a small boutique hotel in Key West. Our brief stay was lovely, and I'd want to…read morestay here again if returning! What I enjoyed: *Great location *Delightful, helpful employees *Neighboring restaurant Cafe Marquesa is fantastic dining! *Complimentary sangria at afternoon check in and coffee in the morning. *Beautiful pools, water fall garden and tropical landscaping *In room dining available. *See attached Hotel information photos.

The one thing this place has going is the location! For the things we did, it was in a great spot!…read moreHowever, for the ammount of money you spend I would probably not come back! We were so excited to find out there was live music every day at the pool, only to be disappointed when most of the time it was not that good! They also allow locals/ non guests to come in which we heard several times while we were out from people and it was proven true! The bar/restaurant hours were so odd and it closed pretty early for being the only food in the place! Do not expect early check in or late check out- they do not accommodate this even though they text you to ask when you will be arriving! We only had someone clean our room once during the 6 days we were there! We ended up bringing our own trash out everyday, finding someone for toilet paper/towels, etc! This trip was for our honeymoon and it was just disappointing to spend so much money to get the bare minimum!

Got a deal on this spot. A bit pricey otherwise. Spent 5 nights here. Great location to all of…read morethe things-very walkable. Resort fee is a bit much given you don't really get anything for it. Rooms were clean, bed was a little too firm for me and the pillows were flat. Different activities throughout the week. Only downside is housekeeping slamming doors in the morning when cleaning rooms-if you were trying to sleep you wont be.

From the moment we arrived, I knew this trip would be special. The hotel grounds were absolutely…read moregorgeous, peaceful, and beautifully maintained. Even though it's just off Duval, it felt totally secluded and relaxing, like our own little oasis in Key West. The staff made the experience unforgettable. Trudy, Cindy, Alex, Randy, and Rose went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. And of course, the little bar quickly became our favorite daily tradition...our first stop every day at 5pm. Everything about this trip exceeded my expectations. I've traveled quite a bit, but this was truly one of my favorite vacations. We can't wait to come back!

Best place to stay in Key West. Everyone one the staff is super nice. Everything is within walking…read moredistance and it's not noisy.

My husband booked Sunset Key Cottages for my birthday weekend, at first I didn't know how I felt…read moreabout having to take a water shuttle back and forth to the main KW island, but it was great! The shuttle was very comfortable, always on time and the captains were professional. As long as you plan for it, it was never an issue. The property is beautiful, lush and beautifully decorated, with orchids and flowers. We had a 2 bedroom/3 bathroom cottage, it was huge and very comfortable. We also loved Latitudes restaurant, we enjoyed a few breakfasts and dinners there, fantastic food and service. We can't wait to go back!

3/16/24-Well, all I can say is, thank goodness for Sunset Cottages. It was gray and rainy in DC…read more(that's the norm this time of year) so Key West was a wonderful way to avoid the DC winter! I can't say enough about the staff. I've never met so many people with smiles on their faces. Food was fabulous. Pool satisfied my grandchild. Two br cottage perfect. Glitch in AC, which was fixed in a nanosecond. I can't say enough wonderful things about this resort! Thank you Sunset Keys!