After enjoying dinners at Kindred Fare numerous times since their opening years ago, last night's performance fell flat. As usual, the appetizers were always a hit. The cauliflower and the friendship fries are always very welcome, and filling. A caution to those of you who order these to share that too much of a good thing can impact your stomach later on! But the main courses disappointed. Two in our group had their fried chicken. As an aside, whatever happened to the option to have 2 pieces, not four? They were sauced with a sweet honey hot sauce that was just overwhelming and all diners felt was not appropriate. And my wife has always ordered and loved the fried chicken. This time three pieces came home that I'll end up eating at lunch today and probably tomorrow. One of our other dining partners and I both ordered the fennel sausage pasta (with a side of the foccacia bread). I can't comment for my dining partner as he expressed that he enjoyed it but a LOT was left uneaten. As for me, it was bland. Very bland. I expected so much more and was left with hardly any taste at all. The house made sorbets and ice creams were also wonderful as always but served wrong. I ordered two completely incompatable scoops - one a sweet sorbet and the other a creamy ice cream. The sorbet was served on top of the ice cream. My wife liked the ice cream, she did not like the sorbet. But the melting sorbet ruined the ice cream for her. Think differently about presentation. The cute glasses it is served in are perfect for one, not for two scoops. Serve them separately. Last evening was also the end of their Negroni week and I tried one of the Liv gin drinks with tomato. Wonderful, a great creation on the part of the bartending staff. It was refreshing, not overpowering, and definitely left you wanting more! Service as always was spot on and the atmosphere humming. read more

This is our second visit to this place to eat. We were last here in 2018 when it was our first visit to the area. 5 years later we come back, made reservations and damn is this place more packed than what I remembered. It looks much different than the first visit. We sat at the bar, how crazy is that. Nestled in the heart of the Finger Lakes, Kindred Fare emerges as a culinary gem, weaving together a tapestry of local flavors, artisanal craftsmanship, and warm hospitality. From the moment you step into this establishment, it becomes evident that Kindred Fare is not just a restaurant; it's a celebration of community, culinary excellence, and the region's rich agricultural heritage. The ambiance at Kindred Fare strikes a perfect balance between sophistication and approachability. The inviting decor, with its rustic-chic elements and an open kitchen that invites curiosity, creates an atmosphere that is both intimate and convivial. The attentive and knowledgeable staff further elevates the dining experience, providing insights into the menu's seasonal inspirations. The menu at Kindred Fare is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to local sourcing and the freshest ingredients. Each dish tells a story of the Finger Lakes, with a menu that evolves with the changing seasons. From inventive small plates to hearty mains, the culinary offerings showcase a harmonious fusion of flavors that pays homage to the region's diverse bounty. Standout dishes include anything to deal with seafood or steak, a delightful play on the seafood that I had that perfectly encapsulates the chef's creative prowess. The attention to detail in presentation and the thoughtful pairing of flavors demonstrate a culinary finesse that sets Kindred Fare apart. The commitment to sustainability is palpable in the restaurant's ethos. Locally sourced ingredients, eco-friendly practices, and a dedication to reducing environmental impact underscore Kindred Fare's responsibility to both its patrons and the community. The result is not just a meal but a conscientious culinary journey. The beverage program at Kindred Fare complements the culinary offerings seamlessly. The curated wine list, featuring local Finger Lakes wines, and the handcrafted cocktails add a layer of sophistication to the overall dining experience. The staff's expertise in suggesting pairings enhances the enjoyment of each dish. In conclusion, Kindred Fare in the Finger Lakes is a culinary haven that transcends the ordinary. The restaurant's dedication to local flavors, sustainable practices, and culinary innovation creates a dining experience that feels both familiar and extraordinary. For those seeking a taste of the Finger Lakes' culinary spirit, Kindred Fare stands as a beacon of gastronomic delight, inviting patrons to savor the essence of this vibrant and diverse region. read more

Kindred Fare - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Visited Geneva, NY for the week and had the absolute pleasure of having dinner at Kindred Fare! The restaurant is much bigger than pictured with great parking. The drinks were interesting - I had Leo Season from the mocktail list. It was delightful because I expected something similar to a Bloody Mary but it was light, bubbly with a hint of tomato with a splash of sweetness. Worth a try! We had the Mac and cheese and it was of course DELICIOUS! It was what we expected. Gooey cheese and the pasta was cooked perfectly. I had the fried chicken as the main course and I have a lot to say... first, please share this with the table - it's 4 huge pieces. I would recommend ordering a few things and sharing it family style. Second, the sauce that is drizzled on top of the chicken was my favorite part. It wasn't a typical buffalo sauce - had the right flavors and acid. I was finding more on the plate to dip. Third, the chicken itself was brined perfectly. Every meat had flavor and the crust was crispy perfection. Lastly, the dessert..! We had the butternut squash cheesecake. Very different. Not too sweet but it was just right with the coconut caramel graham cracker crust. All in all, they're worthy to be on the every list they're on because they're that delicious. Our waitress was attentive and the hosts were great. The ambiance was nice for a night out or for great vibes! Thank you for a great time! read more

Got a reservation on short notice as I rolled into Geneva late. Good food and top notch service. Drinks were extraordinary.

Good but doesn't live up to the hype. Came here with group of friends. The inside is very classy and extremely clean. We split the cauliflower wings which were super crispy and a perfect texture. I was recommended the ramen by the waitress but wasn't impressed. The noodles didn't work with the soup and I thought the flavor was pretty bland. However a friend got the rice bowl which she said was fantastic. For the high price point, I'd try somewhere else. read more

See all

Went last night with my wife to celebrate our 18th anniversary. I must've mentioned that when I made the reservation because both the hostess and our waiter greeted us with a "Happy Anniversary!" I knew then, we were in good hands. The vibe of the place is really great. The volume of the room is as expected and certainly not loud to the point of affecting conversation. The look into the kitchen from the dining room floor is fun. The food: 1) We got the poutine for an app. Even the smaller size is substantial. The flavor of the gravy has depth and the fries are really well seasoned. I asked for some ketchup simply because I knew it was house made and I wanted to try it. It's a touch sweeter than bottled ketchup but has enough vinegar in it to make that work. This was a satisfying app! 2) The fennel sausage pasta. This dish was amazing. The cook on the house made pasta was perfect and the noodle itself was just the right amount of rustic. The sauce was tasty and complimented the sausage perfectly. The chickpeas in there was a pleasant surprise. And can't go wrong with the burrata on top either. Let me add: You MUST get the focaccia with this dish. Best I've had. And the house made butter is spot on. 3) The fried chicken. Nice crisp fry. Generous portion of chicken- four pieces. The sauce on it was tasty but not evenly distributed. Some pieces had a lot and some had none. Not sure if that's intentional. The coleslaw and pickles were so good and necessary for this dish. I wanted more. I actually would have been happy with three pieces of chicken and more coleslaw. 4) Brussel sprouts side. I loved this but my wife doesn't like mushrooms. So be advised. Nice level of sweetness and vinegar in there. 5) Chocolate coconut tart - very intense dark chocolate flavor. Mostly tasted the coconut in the crust. The raspberry sauce was bright. This was good, not exceptional. 6) Special dessert: Ricotta panna cotta. THIS was special. I would say make it a regular dessert. Texture and flavor so good. Crunchy pistachios (I think) on top was great. There was like a brown butter or caramel/chocolate sauce under it that was very good. The service (Lewis) was excellent. The parking lot makes it an easy place to access. I've already recommended this spot to my Syracuse and Rochester friends. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Excellent service, Justin! Food was excellent, we really enjoyed the homemade pasta special, salad with ginger carrot dressing, crab cake was good but not lump.. instead it was shredded but otherwise tasty and had lots of crab meat compared to filling. We enjoyed the outside patio better than inside, which was very loud. Excellent quality ingredients. We would enjoy coming here again! read more

Kindred Fare - Outside - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

Food amazing...interesting offerings... cooked. Perfectly Great service Excellent ambiance ...welcoming, decor sharp contemporary... lighting relaxing and cozy read more

If you're staying at the Microtel next door, look no further for a good dinner. On a Monday at 6:30 without a reservation, the tables were full, but we were seated at the bar, which was fine. We had the specials- rabbit pasta for me and a 3-course meal of seafood chowder, veal cutlet, and a sundae for my spouse. Everything was excellent, except the veal was a bit dry. Friendly and competent staff. read more

Sat at the bar and had a wonderful experience. Food was great and Kaitlyn provided amazing service. Highly recommend!

We had NE fish chowder, kale salad, pork belly rice bowl, and fried chicken. The fish chowder was too salty to my taste. The kale salad was fine but the dressing was slightly too salty. The chicken was delicious and the pork belly was fine. The restaurant was noisy but clean and nice. The staff was friendly and efficient. read more

Kindred Fare - NE fish chowder - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Geneva is a nice restaurant Town, I've been to several and they're all above average. I was a guest in Seneca Lake, and afterwords the host and hostess took me to this restaurant. Great vibe, at least for us, but then again, our host is a regulars there, so many seemed to happily & warmly remembered them. I started with two appetizers to share, one was the fried calamari, and the other was buffalo fried cauliflower. Again, both were well above average. I am personally ordered a salad, at first I thought $12 seems a lot for a salad, but it was a generous in amount, but more so it was again wonderful and well above a salad at a good restaurant. In essence, I am not unhappy with what I got, and what I was charged. My entrée was a 1 pound flank steak. I haven't made one or eaten one in decades. Loved it and made it all along the way. Great rosemary & garlic fries. My suggestion ask for the french fries crispy. As everything else, wonderful Great service from the waitress as well as the hostess. My only slight disappointment was, it took forever to have a bottle of wine brought to me, whereas everybody else who ordered liquor had their drinks almost immediately. The only other oddity to me was that when I later looked at the receipt, I noticed they charged me a 2% hospitality charge. No, I didn't notice it, and I could've easily have canceled it if I wanted to, but it did seem odd to me. Nonetheless, loved it, and would be very happy to come back read more

The food, the drinks, the ambiance and service were great. Wish there was a similar place around the Morristown area in NJ.

Drinks: 6/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 5/5 Food: 4.5/5 Tucked away next to two hotels and a Sherwin Williams oaint is this amazing restaurant, specializing in local ingredients (both food and spirits) from the Finger Lakes. I have now been here twice, and each time it was excellent. The cocktail and spirits list is comprehensive and focused on smaller distilleries. The service is uniformly excellent. The food? Good-to-great. Highlights include the cauliflower hot honey "wing" appetizer and the rotating specialities. Both times I visited it was crowded (and with good reason!) and we had reservations. read more

Food is AMAZING! Service is even better. Couldn't be happier with our experience. Our server was so friendly and there was a great ambiance to the restaurant. Best food we've had on our Finger Lakes vacation. read more

Kindred Fare was one of the best dining experiences we've had! The food and drinks were amazing. If you're gluten free this is definitely the place to go. Everything is scratch made, farm to table. The calamari and chickpea appetizer was crisp, light and delicious. The house made ice cream was the perfect end to a wonderful meal.The feel of the restaurant is laid back yet upscale. Our server Lewis was a delight and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend stopping in if you're ever in the area. read more

Kindred Fare is great! Wonderful spot for gluten-free dining where you can enjoy majority of the menu even with allergy. My fiancée and I shared a mushroom arancini app (gluten-free) and he got the gluten-free fish and chips, whereas I got a pasta dish (could not be made gluten-free). We also shared a creme brûlée dessert, which was gluten-free. Our waiter was also great and accommodating. Good cocktails too! Everything was delicious! read more

If I could leave 6 stars I would! The attention to detail and thoughtfulness of every aspect of Kindred Fare is amazing and very much appreciated. From the atmosphere, music and the greeting at the door, you know you're in for an outstanding meal and experience. My wife and I ordered local wine and beer to start. The bartender was knowledgeable and attentive. We split the apple sausage flatbread and house fries and finished off with the coconut caramel ice cream. Every part of this meal was better than we imagined it could be. Can't wait for our next stop at Kindred Fare! read more

Kindred Fare - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

We discovered this rustic but modern restaurant in Geneva. The service was excellent. Our waitress recommended drinks to our taste and we love them. Their food was delish. Reservation is recommended. read more

Kindred Fare - Drinks and apps - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Everything about my experience here was bad. We were seated and waited about 10 minutes for the server to come, we were ready to order but she wanted us to look at the specials first, came back 10 more minutes later, we still ordered what we would have. I ordered a poblano burger, medium with fries. No where on earth is a Burger worth $25 but they really didn't have anything else that appealed to me. The burger was served medium rare at best, I love my steak this way but a burger shouldn't bleed. I don't send food back and we didn't see the server to discuss it anyway. There was not enough poblano on it to even taste that it was there. I was starving after a long flight arriving after dinner so I ate it all but wouldn't have given other options. There is a 2% hospitality surcharge on all the food, it says it is to help stay competitive. I explained that I am under expense restrictions and I could either pay the surcharge or tip the server, they quickly removed it but the action offends me. Hidden charges are unethical. When asked about my meal I did not intend to complain so I said it was OK. The hostess became defensive, asked leading questions followed by canned responses. I was not impressed, She told me I should have sent it back or ordered something else, remember the server did not return until she brought our bill. This looks like a really nice place. I hope they step up their game but I will not be back to find out. read more

We had an amazing dinner at Kindred Fare. I had the salmon special with corn salsa, zucchini and brown butter and my husband had the special homemade pasta with roasted rabbit. We split the poutine for an app. Everything was delicious. The specialty cocktails were well-crafted but fairly small. My Espresso martini was half foam. Our server Nicole was wonderful and gave us some great suggestions of local wineries to visit. We're looking forward to going back and trying some of the other dishes. Highly recommend Kindred Fare! read more

See all

What a hidden gem here in Geneva! We were here visiting family from Rochester and was staying for the week on Seneca Lake, reminding me of my days in High School when one friend had a lake house here during our high school years. This time, we had a large group of family, with children from 4-18 with us. Knowing this restaurant is only open a few hours a night, we made it early enough where there wouldn't be any issues with our reservation as well as overwhelming the kitchen. Justin was our server, professional and courteous. Handled our large group with no issues. I started out ordering the Spaghetti squash and kale gratin as an appetizer. It was shocking how good something can be when you smother it in cream and cheese, right? LOL. But it was salty, gooey, and hit the spot. Knowing my nephew ordered something he wasn't sure he would like- I went and ordered the mac and cheese in case we needed to share. It was also delicious, I got the bacon and scallions on the side so that the non-red meat eaters could enjoy the cheesy goodness with also the panko breadcrumb topping. Cannot go wrong when eating here! Turns out, lots of people know about this place. I was shocked it's open from 5-9. That's it. So it counts, when you are supporting a small business. I would recommend coming here for an intimate dinner with that special someone, or with friends to share a bunch of food together- or even that larger family gathering. It all works here. Thank you to Justin and the team here. We enjoyed it, although I forgot my leftovers, (we all did) it still was worth the visit when back in town. Support small owned businesses! read more

Stopped by for a quick dinner and I'm glad I stopped by. The service was great, our server was attentive and friendly. My friend ended up getting the burger, which was well flavored and juicy; the bread itself was delicious. I ended up getting the gluten free penne Mac and cheese with a half order of the kale salad. The Mac and cheese was delicious, it was rich and smooth . The kale salad was fantastic, the dressing/cheese they used made it addictive! We also ordered a drink to share, it was the wallflower, mezcal based drink which was really good. It went perfectly with out meal. This is a place I would go to again if I came back ! read more

Kindred Fare - Gluten free Mac and cheese - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

First time here, and it was fabulous! Delicious choices and we felt fortunate to have a seat at the bar on a busy night. Kindred Fare has a great vibe and our bartender/server Raleigh was outstanding. It was a perfect meal after attending an opening at The Dove Block Project Gallery and I'm looking forward to my return. "Kindred Fare" is a great name, and as we were about to leave The Dove, our last conversation was "it's our favorite place." read more

Kindred Fare - Fennel sausage special with burrata - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Really good food and service nice ambience. Friendly and warm atmosphere. Nice drinks too

One of the best meals I've had in a long time. So much so, that I can't wait for a return visit. My husband and I arrived about 20 minutes ahead of our reservation and was immediately told we would be seated at the "reservation time" and we could take a seat in the vestibule area. The hostess offered to bring us drinks while we waited for our table. To our surprise, we were seated 10 minutes early. We were informed of the nightly specials, which we chose and it was outstanding. We opted for the spaghetti with pork belly, fennel sausage and sautéed peppers. The ingredients were fresh and the pasta was homemade. Absolutely amazing....it doesn't get any better than this. If you're in the Geneva area, stop by. Reservations are a must, even in the bar area! read more

See all

Food service and ambulance was amazing. Our server was very kind and gave great service. We came 40 min before closing and they accommodated. read more

Kindred Fare - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

This place was mentioned to my wife and I a couple times, so we thought we would give it a shot. It has great reviews and was fairly close to where we are staying. We were greeted right away upon entry and then were seated almost immediately. After looking over the regular menu and the prix fixe menu, we decided to go with the prix fixe plus the wine pairing since we are in the finger lakes. We both chose the seafood stew for the first course, which came with these nicely salted waffle chips. The stew was slightly lacking in the flavor department and the swordfish was a bit fishy. For my next course, I chose the flank steak and that came with horseradish mashed potatoes and I believe daikon radish sprinkled on top. The steak was rolled with green onion inside and had a Korean style barbecue sauce on it. The flank steak was super chewy with tendons in it, which made it kind of hard to eat. The flavor was good and the mashed potatoes were as well. For the last course I chose the apple cider sorbet with caramel and apples and that turned out to be the best part of meal. As for the wine pairings, we were brought our wine with each course, but were not told what they were, where they came from or anything. The restaurant had a cool, low lite ambience with like a rustic modern look. If we lived in the area, we may have gave it another try. read more

Kindred Fare - Flank steak with horseradish mashed potatoes and daikon radish straws - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

Came here in September while visiting the Fingerlakes region after my friend recommended this restaurant to us. We sat indoors at the bar and every patron is required to wear a mask inside if they aren't seated/eating, and there was good social distance between us and the next couple at the bar. The food was decent, 3.5-4/5. The spicy chicken is crusted with cornmeal which gives it an interesting consistency, as you can taste/feel the bits of cornmeal. The duck was average and a tad bit chewy (we ordered it medium rare per chef recommendation). Presentation of the food was nice. What really stood about this place was both the ambiance and the drinks. It was a nice, cozy, romantic, approachable yet high class feel (it elicits an interesting mix of feels haha). Most ppl around us were on dates. Sitting at the bar, I first ordered a cocktail, which I can't remember, but then asked if the bartender could whip me up a refreshing, not sweet, mezcal-based drink. After speaking to his fellow bartender, he made a citrusy mezcal drink that was PERFECT! I was very impressed and happy :). read more

See all

Service was really fast! They even cleared our empty dishes early so we had space. Food came our super fast and was so good. I reccomend

Atmosphere is rugged barn feel. Up beat and clean. You can see the cooks at work. We had a great couple of visits with Arial with red hair. Mor like strawberry blond it the light we were in. She makes you feel relaxed and conforable. Attative. Great table side manner. Always has a smile and bubbly personality. Ask for her on your reservation. Wen. To sat. She will make it special. read more

See all

My husband and I were looking for a place to have a nice dinner at the last minute on a Saturday night. We kept seeing Kindred Fare mentioned as one of the best places around and, after our visit, I can see why. Everyone was so welcoming and found a way to get us a table during such a busy night. Our server, Jude, was so kind and knowledgeable, offering excellent suggestions. We ordered the cauliflower appetizer and were impressed how deliciously crispy it was. My rice bowl which I subbed in chicken instead of pork was just so very yummy. My husband loved his fried chicken as well. He added fries and raved about the house-made garlic aioli. We would have loved dessert but we were so full of all of the great food. We would love to return in the future for another fantastic meal with equally fabulous service. read more

Kindred Fare - -PORK BELLY- OR -TOFU VEGETABLE- RICE BOWL* with chicken instead of pork- fabulous - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

Yummy food and great atmosphere! I tried the poutine and it was so good! The fries weren't soggy and the gravy was the perfect thickness. The cheese was also perfectly melted and delicious! The broccolini was also really good! Big portions for both! Service was also good. Not where you expect a fine dining restaurant to be located, but finding it wasn't difficult. Ample parking and good sized restaurant. read more

Kindred Fare - POUTINE* broccolini - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

After walking out of another restaurant for no service after a reservation and 1/2 hr at table , I called here, knowing it was good. They got us in on a Saturday night at 7. Great service, food and quality. Love the vibe. By far the best restaurant in Geneva. read more

Our was very informative, and fun! Yummy food, and drinks were good as well! Clean restaurant and restroom! read more

We have been here about a half dozen times since my daughter enrolled at nearby HWS colleges. Every time we come into town she wants to go to get their gluten free Mac and cheese. I personally hate GF food but I have to admit the dish is pretty darn good! We took a group of people here this past weekend and it was amazing as usual!! My daughters boyfriend said the food was phenomenal...., I would agree! read more

See all

Wow! I'm a foodie and rarely post reviews. This place is a knockout. Cozy ambiance, exceptional service . Food was outstanding, fresh and delicious. Best calamari we've ever had. Location was right next to our hotel (which I would usually not associate with high quality dining), a real treat. read more

Must have been bad timing on my part. I came here at the suggestion of a friend due to their usually decent bourbon/whiskey list. I checked the site the day I was going, and there were 3-4 bourbons I wanted to try, unfortunately only 1 of them was actually available. Ended up doing a super quick app at the bar since reservations for the bar were taken. Got the poutine, which needed a smidge more cheese curds, there were about 5 only on the top, and as i got to the bottom, none existed except for gravy. I can see how some reviews like this place and some say it misses. People next to me at the bar very much enjoyed their food, and the couple on the other side of me said their food was just okay. The place isn't bad, it gives off a vibe and feel of being 5 stars, but it misses the mark. Not saying to skip it, just, don't expect 5 stars. read more

Food - 10 (had flank steak and kale salad) Atmosphere - 8 Management - 10 runs like a well oiled machine Staff - 10 - awesome courteous friendly and attentive. read more

The food, the service and the atmosphere were all great, our waiter was attentive without being over bearing, guided us through the specials and even shared the bartender's recipe for his bitters mix in my old fashioned made with Local bourbon whiskey. This was our second finger lakes trip, but you can bet we'll be back at this restaurant the next time we are in the area read more

Kindred Fare - New American Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all