My boyfriend and I ordered take-out from here. I had the kani salad and the mimosa roll. I requested the kani salad be made spicy, and spicy it was. Definitely on point with the spice. I also had the mimosa roll. It was good and fresh. It came with a small side of mango sauce. I'm happy the sauce was on the side and not all over the roll. My boyfriend had steak hibachi rice. He said it was really good. We would order from here again. read more

See all

During Easter, there are a limited number of restaurants open so it's a win. This used to be the sayville diner. It's definitely a local neighborhood restaurant. We ordered the following: - baby back ribs - best part of the meal - sushi and sashimi platter - some fish were fresher than others. It comes with soup and salad. - tonkotsu ramen - the noodles were overcooked and not a lot of filling though the soup was pretty good. Not a bad spot though I leave that for you to decide after you try. read more

See all

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place before now. We've been living here for four years and this is our go to place when we do SUSHI. The food is amazing ranging from good to great. I've never had anything here that I disliked. The Korean wonton soup is a must for me. Poké bowls also great. Avocado bomb. Kani salad, Lobster cracker or tuna cracker all great appetizers. Plenty of options for those who don't eat sushi. The best tempura I've ever had hands-down. The ambience is not amazing, but the place is always spotless read more

The service was OK. The only thing was that they didn't fill up our waters too often. the food is pretty good too I've had better sushi but it's close by and a great option if ur craving sushi. We got some apps too the calamari was quite chewy. Gyoza and chicken satay was tasty. Ambiance is what you make it open seating in a booth it was a nice time. read more

See all

We ordered tonight through DoorDash. While eating I felt something sharp, then pain. I spit everything out to find a STAPLE IN MY SUSHI. This would've really really hurt me and caused so many very scary issues if I swallowed it. Never again. I'm so angry. read more

Koi Sushi - Mango Hawaii Roll and a freaking STAPLE. - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

The service there arent very friendly godzilla roll is to die for cocktails are realy strong a little humble place

This is our go to sushi to have delivered when we are feeling lazy and don't want to go out! I love the house salad with the delicious and fresh ginger dressing! The clear soup is on point! You must try the fire island roll with the shrimp tempura. All the rolls we have had are beautifully done and so very tasty! I highly recommend! read more

I so wanted to love Koi. They had good reviews so I decided to take a break from my usual sushi spot and try something new. It was a mistake. I ordered online mainly because they offer 10% off and it was very easy. You go and pick up your food off of a table for a contactless pickup. Super some, easy and safe. That's the main reason I am granting this restaurant 2 stars. The food itself was terrible. We ordered gyoza, spicy tuna roll, tornado roll, love boat platter, and chicken katsu. Overall my main complaint is the food was very, very bland and the supposedly spicy rolls had zero spice. Like none. Additionally, the sashimi in the love boat was borderline frozen which was absolutely disgusting and went in the garbage. The breading on the chicken katsu was falling off and the "katsu sauce" was legit elementary school bbq sauce, which to be honest had me going back for more due to the nostalgia despite the fact that I was repulsed. Ultimately, I spent $95 on a meal that I threw a solid 33% of in the garbage. Will not be back. That's what I get for cheating on my regular place ehhh read more

Koi Sushi - "love boat" platter - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

I've been in the Sayville area for over a year, and I've yet to try Koi, until last night. I must have passed this on Main St hundreds of times since then. I was pleasantly surprised when I walked in and saw how nice it was. From the outside, it looks a bit dated and not too inviting, but the inside was nice. I really hope for their sake they update the outside, as it would tremendously help the curb appeal and grab more peoples attention. We started off with drinks and Rock Shrimp Tempura. We really enjoyed the that app, it's was super fresh and the shrimp had a great texture. For dinner, we shared 2 Sex on the Beach and 2 Empire rolls. They were really good, and our waitress was super attentive. Water was refilled without asking, and refills on our drinks were asked as they were being finished. I really do hope they look to update the outside, I truly believe it would do a lot for their business. read more

Koi Sushi - 2x Sex on the Beach 2x Empire Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

very rude disgusting behavior from woman in front with short hair. I came in for a pick up and she was very cold asked her if the order was ready nicely and she goes 'No NOT Ready.' and is typing. I go well that's okay, do you know when? she goes 'NO, I DONT KNOW'. very dismissive and gross. No sorry for the wait just get out of here type attitude. also how do you not know what's going on in the kitchen? read more

First Time *Lunch Review: Passing by this Restaurant more times than I can count, I never thought much about the simple outer appearance. Stepping inside was a breath of fresh air. The Restaurant was incredibly clean and surprisingly spacious. The service was quick & very friendly. The Food was delish. Located in the heart of Sayville, parking might be tricky. If street parking isn't available you'll need to find parking behind the stores on either side of Main St. The Lunch Prices were phenomenal. The portions were great for lunch. The Service was spectacular. Every time I needed, refills were provided, even without request. If your in a hurry or want to have a long relaxing lunch, this restaurant will accommodate you. The Food was Delish! Best Sushi in the surrounding area for sure. Everything was incredibly fresh. I noticed they offer so many creative specials unique to the area, I'm intrigued to try a few on my next visit. I will be reviewing what I tried: -Steak Teriyaki Bento Box: Some of the tastiest Teriyaki Sauce I've ever had. Came with Miso Soup, Steak (7 decent sized slices), a tiny portion of Veggies, 1 Scoop of Rice, 4 Pieces of California Roll & 3 Shumai. The Steak was juicy. Loved the Shumai and the Miso Soup was marvelous. I also ordered a house salad for an additional $3 and was happy with the freshness of the lettuce and the house made dressing on top. I would definitely order this dish again. 5 out of 5 Stars -Lunch Roll Special (2 Orders of Spicy Tuna Rolls, 1 Order of Shrimp Tempura Rolls): $13 for 17 pieces of Sushi is a great deal. I thought the freshness of the fish makes Koi a #1 Local Sushi spot for sure. 5 out of 5 stars Overall I'm so happy with my first visit to Koi. Come for lunch if your in the mood for a great deal. I'll be trying dinner next! read more

See all

The sushi and poke bowl were delicious fresh vegetables and fish and full sized, prices very good on all. The restaurant is a very clean cozy setting, we were comfortable at a booth for 6. The service was excellent!! Definitely a great experience. read more

Always fresh and delicious. They are consistently nice and very accommodating. The poke bowls are amazing, and the Sayville roll is like none I've ever had. You must try the lobster crack, a fan favorite in our group. read more

This was my 2nd time visiting Koi. Both trips were enjoyed. The fish seems fresh and the menu has decent offerings. There are choices for those not into sushi. Some Chinese and Thai options. We tried a rib special that I was sure I would not enjoy. It was very very good. Meat fell right off the bone. Delicious sauce that was not overpowering. They should put those ribs on the menu. Everything else was great. Tried a Beaty and the Beast roll. Few pieces of sushi and a peppered tuna roll. My only complaint on both trips has been with their drinks. I'd skip the cocktail menu, go for a beer. read more

See all

I don't really have anything negative to say about this place. I ordered from DoorDash and picked it up both times. They gives nice big pieces of sushi. They have it on a table with your name on it to pick up. Also, the wasabi isn't as potent as other restaurants read more

Koi Sushi - Sushi and Sashimi Combo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

Wow, good sushi!!!! This place was super cute. First time I had ever been. We were looking for sushi but wanted something different than the places we usually go to. It looks like an old diner on Main Street which is cool because it adds a twist to the classic sushi place. Such a warm welcoming, atleast the waitress we had. She was super nice and sat us right away and told us about the specials on food and drinks. We got the Mai Tais and they were super good. I was here on a date, and it was def a good spot to go to for sushi. There was music which added a little fun but it was also was a good environment to chat and have a nice dinner. Ok now on to the food.... YUM!!!! I got the Panhandler and it was delicious. Nice big roll that def filled me up. I tend to go more with cooked rolls when I eat sushi, so I can't speak on the rest of the menu but I did see a plate of sashimi pass by our table and it looked very nice. The presentation was the best part, so cute !!!! Had flowers and designs on the plate... Made it fun when it arrived.... Very appetizing and enjoyable to eat. I would def come back to this place. It was a little pricy, but I feel like you get what you pay for when it comes to sushi and I could definitely taste the difference between this and an "all you can eat" type of menu. Def recommend! read more

Koi Sushi - Mai Tais for two ! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Cute place, good food but the service is lacking. Nicer inside than expected based on the fact that the outside looks like an old diner. Other than the bar, all I saw was booth seats. I'm assuming we got the male waiter other Yelpers complained about, not sure cause no name was provided and the person looked androgynous. While mostly polite, once the food arrived we didn't see the waiter again until it was time to clear the plates. No mid meal check in, no replenishing of our waters, nothing, thank god our meals were too moist to choke on. You might want to consider bringing an Epipen because the chef doesn't care about your food allergies. We asked for a habachi dish sans mushrooms but it arrived with them (this wasn't the waiter's fault, they documented the request). Thankfully it was comped but that doesn't do much for the hives. read more

This was our first time trying Koi. We came on the recommendation of Newsday and we are fairly new to this particular area. They have ample parking behind the building which is a plus and the restaurant itself is very small but clean. It's a converted diner so that's how it's set up inside - with a huge bar spanning the length of the restaurant and booths around the perimeter. We started off with a chicken satay that came with 4 pieces and a side of peanut sauce. The chicken was very lightly fried and was super tasty. The only downside to this dish is that the portion was a little small - we wanted more! Next we had 2 rolls - Sex on the Beach and Air Force One. These were great and tasted fresh. The pieces were cut much wider and bigger than other places I've been so it was a little hard to fit in our mouths. :/ Hubby thought the saki was smooth and delicious. Overall this place was great and we'll be back to try more. The prices are a little higher than normal but you get what you pay for. read more

Koi Sushi - Sex on the Beach and Air Force One - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

Fairly new edition to the adorable town of Sayville.. perfectly located on Main Street where you will find many shops and food selections to meet your needs... saw koi while sitting across the street from Super Bowls... immediately I knew I wanted to head in there after to grab a bite and taste this new, cute sushi spot, ya know peep the scene.... The place is nice, not too big, booth style seating appropriate for parties 2-6 I'm sure they can accompany more though... we walked in and there was a pretty strong scent of fish in the air, common in most sushi spots but it just smelled rather strong... however, that was my only issue. The tasty bites we inhaled: salad, miso soup, shumai and tuna and salmon rolls on soy paper were very good. That seems like an easy enough order anyway but we did really enjoy our sushi.. peeped other plates as they were passing on by and they looked decent as well... The place wasn't like an amazing experience but they were very nice, the place was clean (besides the smell which I didn't even notice after sitting there for a few), and our food was served pretty quick. The quality of the fish was very good, I eat sushi a lot and the tuna and salmon were very good, fresh and cold. I would come back here when in the area. read more

Koi Sushi - Shumai - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

I Koi! It's so easy to order online and they always deliver as scheduled. We went there on Sat night and the service was perfect, the drinks were good and the sushi super fresh. I've NEVER had a bad roll here, the food is awesome. read more

Food here is fresh and delicious. We really enjoyed every bite don't let it fool you from the outside. The Rick shrimp was fantastic and all the special rolls where delicious. read more

See all

Great food. Great service. The best sushi in the area. I would highly recommend this restaurant for anyone looking for high quality, fresh, delicious sushi. read more

Came here the other night to give it a shot and it was good! The place was pretty empty for a Friday night and the vibe was excellent but the food was still good and that's what's most important. We started with the house salad and spring rolls. The ginger dressing of the salad was not our favorite and there was way to much of it on the salad. The spring rolls however were excellent! We wanted more! They tasted fresh and were light and delicious. We got the crunch roll which I forgot to take a picture of but it was really good! Next we got the chicken and broccoli that comes with white rice. Another excellent dish. It wasn't over-sauced and my girlfriend really enjoyed that the chicken pieces were "nice and flat". The broccoli was also softer then most places, which I really enjoyed. Overall our experience here was very good and I would recommend it to anyone. The menu is huge and serves everything from hibachi to poke bowls to sushi to classic dishes, so there is something for everyone. read more

See all

Excellent sushi! Very fresh and nice quiet atmosphere and comfortable booth seating since it's an old diner. The bathroom was a little skeevy. The food was great. I wish I would have known about their Tuesday 2 specialty rolls for $20 special because I will probably do that from now on and save myself 15 bucks. read more

Koi Sushi - Great sushi! Too much panko on the one roll but it was still good. - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

I've been here twice. Once on a Friday night, another on a Saturday night. Both times the sushi was phenomenal. Three of us stopped by and we ordered a bunch of rolls along with the avocado boat as an appetizer. When you walk in, the staff was pretty attentive and sat us right away. We ordered some hot saki and some beer- the drinks came almost immediately- we also happen to get on the servers good side by joking around, she had a good sense of humor. The atmosphere was cozy and if I were to go alone, chances are I'd sit at the bar. They location looked like they had a full bar and its pretty obvious since it's the first thing you see when you walk in. I will absolutely be back when I'm in town. read more

Garlic edamame is good but I will not order again. (Delivery so could not check the bag) Fried tofu is mushy and unappetizing. (Inedible slime) Sushi is okay but ordered enough for three people and got ONE soy sauce and ONE chopsticks for three people. Called restaurant and woman argued with me. Said I had to "ask" if I wanted more than one each and next time I should ask. Sorry there will be No next time. I guess she does not know the customer is always right and that I will not come back OR recommend this place. read more

I have been waiting for this sushi restaurant to open in Sayville ever since we first saw the signs that they were moving in. Since I moved, I just recently went for the first time and it didn't disappoint. We got the spicy tuna pizza which was a very good appetizer we almost got 2! But we knew we had more food to come so we ordered the sayville roll, Godzilla roll(middle of picture) and spicy girl(right side). Sayville and Godzilla were definitely my top two they were amazing. With 3 of us it was enough but decided to split the tempura cheesecake and that was great beyond belief. Happy we tried it as we probably won't again since we aren't big on desserts out but I definitely recommend trying it! read more

Koi Sushi - Sayville roll back left, Godzilla roll in front, spicy girl right side stacked - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Sushi was not great. the spicy tuna had a weird taste. And what was a restaurant is now an eyesore. It's time to open up and get back to normal. I'll be finding another place for sushi. read more

Since the place I usually order through door dash was closed I looked at the wonderful reviews I thought to give this place a try. I should of realized when the sushi smelled fishy to not eat it. I got sick and now 27$ is down the drain. Do not go here! read more

food is absolutely the best in the area. however the wait staff are probably the worst and rudest people i have ever met. disrespectful and no filter. read more

I was happy to find that the former Modern Diner was turned into a sushi place.  Talk about an upgrade! They make some of my favorite chicken pad tai, and it has become my go-to order.  I also ordered some shrimp tempura rolls, but I wasn't blown away. I found that the shrimp was overcooked, and little too firm.  Still, I love that Koi is in place and I will definitely order from them again. read more

Koi Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

Very good food. Great taste. Fresh sushi full of flavor. Family operated . Very good restaurant in Sayville.

Very delicious & fresh! Definitely a go to sushi place. Drinks are well made. Appetizers are great! read more

Love the hibachi filet mignon...The koi roll was terrible and the sexy girl roll was even worse.. They skimp on the meat in the fried rice and charge for sauces. It's a little disturbing that my husband and I keep going back for more. I think we are done with them now. read more

Koi Sushi - Koi Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Sayville, New York

I went online to order, placed my order, after 4 minutes of trying to get the order to go thru I geT a message they took ty payment but the order did not go thru. SMH why would you process my order but not "place my order". They said I will receive a refund in 3-4 days. WHAT??? That is ridiculous! I called and spoke to "coco" she said we are busy took 2 other calls and put me on hold. The food is not good enough to be treated like that. What the hell happened to customer service. read more

I've gone here several times never impressed but the LAST time I ordered for delivery there were scales in my tuna roll... GROSS! First I thought it was hard rice which I've experienced before from this sushi joint but no, after further inspection whoever filleted this fish was careless and ruined my meal and who knows how many others. I understand there are scales on fish but I don't want to eat them. DROP THE PRICES OR RAISE THE QUALITY! read more

This was my first time at KOI and it was GREAT! The waiter was adorable (I got his number for my daughter) and the sushi burrito was unreal. I would live here if I could. The waiter recommended the mango sauce which I then proceeded to bring a whole pint home. I recommend this place to everyone and can't wait for my daughter to date the waiter and get me free food!! read more

First time dining here- First things first- for a cold evening the restaurant is nice and toasty! My mom and I started with the tuna avocado cucumber bites. Very, very tasty! We both decided to try their hibachi- both had filet and seafood ( shrimp for me, scallop for mom) Hibachi meals came with soup( delish, mon thought it was a bit salty) salad ( mom thought delish, I thought dressing was a bit too sweet and lacked the real Japanese "gingery" flavor, but fresh and nice cold greens! ) Meals arrive- food plate was broken into sections; vegetable, fried rice ( no hibachi style, just fried, but still good ) Meat and seafood was in a sauce- not your traditional hibachi style- more Chinese take out style. Once we both ate our protein ( filet and seafood) both were over cooked. Well done is most fitting. The waitress as soon as we picked up our forks to try the food asked " how is everything" from first vegetable we tasted, both responded " good" it was a bit later when we sampled had we notice and at that point did not see the waitress. When the waitress returned we said " love the place, loved the sushi bite, and many part of the main meal, however, the meat and seafood both over cooked. For $77.00 there should have been a small concession- I'm not looking for a free meal- but at least take off an ice tea or a fried rice. The waitress poorly handled our complaint, management didn't come and address the problem. When I mentioned to the waitress there should be some sort of adjustment/ concession. When the waitress stormed back she snapped we took $3 off and next time say something- I know there is a language barrier, and delivery by the waitress was salty. So if you have an issue with you meal my advice Juno out of your chair immediately and complain. As for the management- you have good reviews no doubt, but this is the only sushi joint in Sayville. Make certain you come and speak to customers when they are having an issue and not have low level employees handle customer complaints they clearly cannot handle. All in all if we ever come back we would stick with trying sushi. Give the place a try but remember if there is an issue with your food "complain immediately" read more

Food was great only downfall was.... we did a group order from where I work and I ordered a sashimi tuna and didn't think to ask it be out in a seperate container. They placed it with my co workers meal so I didn't have my own dish. I didn't think to ask for a separate container for a separate item on the menu. Food was delicious tho!! I have also heard after this that they do combine rolls and such so if not asked to place in a different container they will place all in one! read more

I am a very picky sushi roll person and this was, by far, my favorite! Great selections read more

See all