Back today with my family for an early Father's Day meal. I must say I was really really impressed. The chicken parm, calamari, eggplant past and our salads were delicious. If an Italian restaurant can't make a delicious sauce the what? But Butera's staff manager made us fell at home in grandmas kitchen. We had a 2 year old and he was also given attention and he loved his dinner also. Thanks from r a great meal read more

Great food and the best baked clams you will find . The service was great and friendly, its a simple casual place will be returning for sure. read more

A lot of hype about this place but for me it was just meh. It felt outdated and a bit closed in. The service was less than par and the food at best was just ok. My chicken franchise although dipping in sauce was somehow still dry. I will leave this review on a positive note by saying, they do give you large portions. read more

See all

We went for Father's Day. The service was terrible. This is the 3 time that there was an issue with the service. Not likely to go back for a while. read more

Came here as a party of 4 on a Saturday right before the dinner rush. Didn't have a reservation but they were able to squeeze us in, as it filled up quickly as the night went on. I realllllly wanted to love this place! We came here once literally 10 years ago so this was a 2nd try, a decade later. Safe to say - not much has changed! The decor, furniture, etc is very outdated. The table we had was uneven so we were scared to place our glasses and pitchers down. Cleanliness wasn't that great either - my water glass had mouth prints on them so it wasn't clean at sit down. The food in general was VERY good, just a little on the salty side. I loved how this was family style with the option to order half portions (40% cheaper than full price) Service was unfortunately slow. Not sure if I will be back due to not much improvement a decade later - but would love to see some improvements made to the restaurant. read more

See all

Went to dinner for wife bday with some family members. Reservation mentioned her bday and said they would make notation,didn't happen.We ordered chicken Marsala and side rigatoni with Marsala sauce,others ordered shrimp parm with angel hair pasta with red sauce. Dinner arrived and pasta dishes were wrong, sent back to to fix and came back in 3 min. They washed the sauce off rigatoni and put Marsala on. Same with angel hair pasta. I noticed right away because still had pieces tomato on pasta and angel hair mixed. Manager came by asked if all good and I mentioned what I felt. Rather than listen to my complaint he challenged me with ,how long you in restaurant business,how do you know how long to cook pasta. Totally unprofesionnal.I think he caught himself and took pastas off bill,that said was a little taken aback by response. On bright side chicKen was tender and deliciou.4 stars for entree 3 for the mix up and remedy and 2 for professionalism. average is a 3. read more

Food is great, service and staff are really good! Well managed by Paul and Jerry. Very family friendly Patsy read more

My husband and I had a great dinner at Butera's in Sayville on New Years Day. We were greeted warmly by 2 young ladies and a gentleman and seated immediately even though we arrived 30 minutes before our timed reservation. We were given a plate of bruschetta and a basket of assorted breads. Our waitress Meghan was awesome. The meals are "family style" but they will also serve individual plates at a 40% less than the price of the family dinners. We decided on the shrimp parm for the 2 of us. There was enough shrimp for 3 or 4 people. The shrimp were colossal size. We did get a side of pasta for $10. Not sure if the gentleman that greeted us is the owner. But he did go to every table wishing us a happy new year. When we left he thanked us for coming out on such a cold night and again wished us a happy new year. We will definitely return. read more

My husband and I came here with the Sayville theater movie package. Such a lovely experience. Food was great and portions are large. My husband had the chicken parm and I had pasta with vodka sauce. SO good. Doesn't taste like the same old rotation of Italian food, it really felt homemade. Our waitress was excellent as well. Very personable and sweet. The manager was also making sure we were comfortable yet also very personable. read more

Butera's is always good. Jerry makes you feel welcome. Great spot to start out a walk through downtown.

My boyfriend and I went there for the first time yesterday I say the food was absolutely amazing. The very nice and sweet and attentive. She was really great with us... Then I went to the bathroom. My positivity ended there. The place is very dirty. It could use a good paint job. The bathroom hasn't been cleaned in forever. The moldings the door the fingerprints absolutely disgusted me. Sadly, we will not be back because of that I could only imagine what the rest of the place behind the scenes looks like if that's the way they present themselves to the public. Very disappointing. read more

We had such a nice evening at Buteras, I can't wait to go back. The bar area is small but a nice group of regulars who were all very welcoming. A few nights later, I was in the mood for a cozy take home meal, #1 they are open on Modays! #2 the first Monday of each month they have this amazing jazz band there and the place was hopping! I can't wait to go back for that too... read more

The food was great! Great staff, very quick and accommodated form my disabled son. In 1998, I ran over a woman while drunk driving and never went to prison. read more

Butera's - Italian Near Me - Sayville, New York

I so wanted to be giving a better review, but my last experience was lackluster. Let me even that out by saying I've gone there and had great meals and even held an event there once, and thanks to Jerry they were all top notch. But this last outing for a birthday just fell flat. So this review and rating is for this specific occasion, not my overall perception of them. To be fair, let's start with the good. The veal chop caprese was the star of the show. When I saw the price I thought this better be a massive chop, but instead it was two massive chops for slightly over what you would pay for one chop at another spot. The sauce was amazing, the veal was well cooked, and the breading was delicious and fried to perfection. The hummus with bruschetta flavors to start the meal was excellent. Continuing with the average points of the meal, the lobster ravioli special was good, not great. The dessert of a rainbow cheesecake was also good, not great. But, kudos to them for comping it for the birthday. It definitely ended an otherwise subpar experience on a high note. Now the rough spots. The vodka sauce which is usually very good was bland and disappointing. The chicken was tough and over cooked. The shrimp were meh at best. After waiting ten minutes, we had to ask for bread. And, when we arrived, the hostess continued a conversation with a waitress about tables instead of addressing the customer. For a while. Just a series of hospitality and service fails and a lackluster plate that really dragged the whole night down. That being said, it won't stop me from giving them another shot in the future. But I won't be racing back any time soon. read more

See all

We arrived for a 3pm reservation.. after 10 min our waitress came over.. we ordered drinks.. after they arrived we ordered appetizer and our dinners.. we were a party of 6.. Our appetizers were seved 15 min after ordering.. but the food took almost an hr later.. we watched 2 tables of 6 who came in after us and was served appetizer & dinner before us.. we had 2 hungry children The food was very good... Except there was no gluten free deserts for our granddaughter.. Our waitress was pleasant... But our waiter time very disappointing.. read more

Located in the heart of the charming and historical bayside Village of Sayville, Butera's is a family owned restaurant and bar renoun for their family style dishes. My dad, brother, and extended family recently dined here during lunch time. Being in the heart of the Village of Sayville, Butera's is ideal for that nice meal to complement a relaxing stroll on Main Street. Its front entrance overlooks Main Street not too far from the historic Rexell Pharmacy Building. The back entrance overlooks a Village of Sayville parking lot. This is the door where we arrived inside Butera's. At the time of our visit, there was zero issue with finding a parking spot. From the back entrance, Butera's looks like it is incorporated inside a professional building. But Inside it is a different environment. From the moment that I stepped inside and set eyes on the bar close to the door and the dining room straight ahead, I felt like we were entering a historic inn. I could picture George Washington sitting here at the bar back in the day that wooden ships graced the Great South Bay. The restaurants wooden floor, wooden chairs and table with the walls and lighting fit in more with the history and charm of the Village of Sayville than it did Italy. The service was solid. The Hostess seated our party of six right away. Throughout the meal, the service was consistently solid. The spacious table gave us plenty of room to eat. During lunch when the South Shore sunlight lit up the room, I ordered off the lunch menu. Those huge tasty family dining portions were nonexistent on my plate. At the price of $12, I ordered the chicken parmesan sandwich off the lunch menu. It featured a breaded chicken breast, marinara, and melted mozzarella on Focaccia bread and came with fries. It tasted three stars solid. With the food, I drank a bottomless soda. Overall, I thought that Butera's was solid. If we happen to return here when I visit Long Island, I will most likely order the family dining eggplant parmesan. read more

Our family recently went to Butera's restaurant following a funeral service for a family member. They were very accommodating as our headcount was rather fluid. Their service was excellent as was the myriad of dishes the family enjoyed. The food was delicious and very well prepared. Thanks to the owners and staff especially Gerry and Joe. I highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area and desire great Italian food. Thank you for making a rough day a little better for our family. read more

Ambiance: Okay friendly greeters quick to seat with reservation. Bread and water filled right away. Asked if they had an Arnold Palmer to start as I add a shot of vodka. I was told of course. Got unsweetened iced tea with tiny slice of lemon. Wine for wife was good. Ordered Goat Cheese salad. $32 for salad for two. For dinner we ordered chicken shrimp in vodka sauce. Pasta was too too soft like it was in water for two days. Vodka sauce needs to be reinvented. It did not taste like a proper vodka sauce. Drinks ran dry and sat empty for a while. I had to stop waiter for more drinks as he checked on food after delivered but not looking at drinks. He was a bit overwhelmed with his job and never was attentive as he should be. Truly Mediocre service. I ordered a coke as a second drink because the original drink was not ordered. After dinner I asked for a double espresso and I was given a single in a single serving espresso cup but I was charged for double. No spoon provided with the espresso to stir sugar in. I again needed to ask for spoon. Then after waiting for waiter I flagged him down and was given a large tea spoon pulled from table vs a proper espresso spoon. I could barely stir spoon so I needed to spin spoon in order to mix coffee. Lastly. There is a gentleman walking around looking to clean the tables the entire time you are there. He stopped at my table 4 times to clear table of items and showed up three more times than my waiter to check on us. Please let your customers eat. Our large salad was half done and he was looking to take it and then kept trying to take it's the moment we are finished. Let your customers breathe. Let them finish and enjoy the moment of eating dinner. That person walk the entire dining room which is fine but the customers should not be interrupted through out the meal. You make it feel like you are rushing us out and no one likes being watched in order to clear an uncluttered table. This is my second time here and the service was the same both times. 3 stars is truly the best I could give. It could've been a lot better. read more

Service was ok. The food was bad. We ordered an appetizer of mozzarella frittas and got mozzarella caprese. They did come back and bring out the right appetizer. But they were very greasy. When we got our food it tasted ok, but it was very, very salty. I had to stop eating it! It was just to salty for me. We have been to the one in Bay Shore a few times and love the place. So we gave this one a try. We were very disappointed with it. read more

Went to a comedy show here last night. The comics were top notch, the food and service outstanding. The owner, Gerry, was very friendly and accommodating! Can't wait to go back! read more

We had a delicious meal and great service! we hadn't been to Butera's fo a while. We food the decor extremely tired. worn table and the floor was all scuffed up and did not appear clean. we were seated in a corner table by the window. The window sill was sprinkle with dust and tiny dead bugs. the blinds had a heavy layer of dust and vent above us was dripping in dust. it was obvious that the place was not cleaned in a long while as this was not dust and such accumulated over a day or two. With that said...one wonders what the kitchen might look like. read more

Great dinner last night at Butera's. Was extremely early for our reservation but staff did everything they could to seat us earlier, which we appreciated. Menu prices are listed as family style prices. Would love if they added individual prices in there as well. A bread basket is always brought out with an additional dish of hummus. Two dishes - can't beat that! Yummy as always. For an appetizer, we ordered the fried calamari. It was a little burnt (see photo) but was nonetheless delicious. I ordered an individual potion of the penne a la vodka and my boyfriend ordered the individual portion of steak Gorgonzola with cheese (his favorite Butera's dish). Not a huge fan of their pasta (sauce is always chunky) but it was still pretty good. Plate was small so it was hard to spread the sauce around. We didn't eat dessert here. Not a lot of chocolate options. Would love to see a chocolate cake added on! The manager (?) was extremely nice. He came over to our table to ask how our meal was and was very nice to the other diners here as well. read more

Butera's - Fried calamari - Italian Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

This was one of the worst dining experiences. It started with ordering two bottles of wine for 7 people the waiter put out dirty soap scum filled glasses I sent them all back. He then came back with slightly better glasses and just put the bottles of wine in the middle of the table... didn't taste me on it or pour to any guests. I felt like I was at a buffet or something not a family style italian restaurant. I passed out plates and served the food as well to my whole party. I would have let some of these things slide if the food was decent but it was one of the worst tasting italian meals i have ever had. The rigatoni vodka pasta tasted like chef boyardee due to the weird bacon flavor throughout. The chicken parm tasted like they dumped a whole can of kraft parm on top. Don't even get me started on this horrible lasagna dish that was ordered read more

Heather is the best bar tender ever!!!!! Come hang at the bar and come thirsty!!!!! Food is amazing Great variety! and the service is impeccable!!! read more

We enjoy this restaurant and have been coming here once a week for 15 years. The Food is consistently good and the staff is always friendly and attentive. We highly recommend this restaurant. Paul, the manager always stops by the tables and chats with the customers to make sure everything is to their liking. read more

My wife and I, along with friends recently ate at Butera's in Sayville. The restaurant is spacious and very inviting. It has well appointed features and decorations. The staff and general manager were very friendly, professional and courteous. I can't say enough about the food. Everyone at our table, loved everything that we ordered. Beside very large portions, the food was amazingly delicious. This is up there with the best Italian food that I ever had. It could be the best that I ever had and I have been around for a long time. I give good and bad reviews on yelp. Regarding this restaurant, you should try it! read more

Went today for lunch with my sisters and our Mom to celebrate a few birthdays. It was our first time at Butera's. The food was great and the portion sizes were generous. Our server, Jeremy, was outstanding. Management and the other employees that we had contact with were all very, very nice as well. It was a great afternoon and we will definitely be returning. read more

Great food and great people always happy with Butera's whether dining in or takeout the food and service is always amazing.

The service was outstanding! Gabby took excellent care of our group of 14. The appetizers were not that good but the main courses were better! read more

The food was as good as ever but the portion size was so small that the 4 of us left hungry.

Nice young man was our waiter. Early dinner reservations to venerate Celebrate. Bread was hot anns served w buter. Water was asked to be filled. Salad was fresh, crisp, served on a chilled plate with dressing and croutons. Dinner was served warm. Pasta was delicious chicken sausage and cheese. Dessert was delightful. After dinner drinks were exceptional. Manager/ owner visited each and every table regardless of who was dining.. couples, families, singles! They are a beautiful Long Island establishment. Wonder ifv they have live music on verandas? A must try A+ read more

See all

Ordered take out food was good but very small portions . But was good. If you are a big eater either order double or go somewhere with bigger portions. read more

Had dinner here last night. The food and service was amazing! The manager was going up to all the tables to welcome and thank them which made you feel comfortable! Would definitely recommend this restaurant and will be back! read more

Our experience was fine. Nothing better or worse. The Rigatoni Butera and the baked clams were the standouts, they were both excellent. However, the mozzarella fritta was completely covered in oil, and the prosciutto didn't taste fresh. My fiancé had the stuffed lobster special, which was subpar. Both of the Prosecco's we drank were incredibly sweet and hard to finish. Our server was very pleasant, not a bad thing to say about her. However, we likely won't return. read more

Had a delicious dinner at this friendly place where you are greeted with a smile & the food was delicious!! Yes it was a hot summer night but when our very friendly waitress Krysta told us about the special appetizer soup of fennel,tomato & spinach bisque with pesto. It was AMAZING..fresh tomatoes mixed with tastiest fennel & delicious spinach leaves. I had veal lasagna for dinner which,while I consider myself a better than average home cook,I never make lasagna because I'm the only one who likes it. My husband suggested it & I was again so pleased with the crumbled veal sausage, layers of lasagna oozing with the ricotta mozzarella mixture..so good. The gentleman who greeted us when we entered came by a few times to see how we were enjoying our dinner..in a word DELICIOUS Highly recommend Buteras. read more

Butera's - Tomato, fennel,spinach bisque drizzled with pesto - Italian Near Me - Sayville, New York

We came here to celebrate my mom's birthday. In summary, the food was good, the ambiance could use some help to match the food. The restaurant's entrance is the form a parking lot. It's really unassuming. The building just looks like a standard office building and the inside is a little outdated. We started with the calamari, lifeguard style, and it was the highlight of the meal. Lots of flavor, great spicy, crunchy and tender all at the same time. I also had a coconut martini which was yummy. I live the toasted coconut floating in the center. This was also flavorful and not too strong, but clearly had alcohol in it. The restaurant is family style, but also offers kids' meals. Two of my boys got pizza and the other pasta marinara. The pizza was great. I worry sometimes places zhuzh it up and then it doesn't appeal to my kids. But this was great and the kiddos were content. The amount of food is a lot too. My oldest finished his plate, but it was a feat. As for the adults, the three of us split the chicken and shrimp vodka sauce and a house salad. It was enough for all three of us for sure, with some to take home. The salad was good and fresh. The pasta was ok. Not as flavorful as our app. The chicken and shrimp were nice and plentiful. Definitely giving you a lot of food for the price. Our servers were nice. The food is yummy. The place is a little loud and dated in decor and ambiance. read more

Being that I am usually really against family style I wasn't exactly excited about coming here. I figured another mediocre Italian spot was on the horizon. To my surprise though the food really surpassed expectations, and some of the negative experiences mentioned in other reviews seemed to miss us as well. Came on a Wednesday night so I'm sure the weekend is a different experience. -Fried Calamari: 5/5, tough to screw up anything deep fried but this was definitely better than a lot of other places I've had calamari at. Perfectly fried and no fishy taste. -Scampi Limoncello: 4/5, never had or even seen this dish as an option before. But it was freakin delicious. Portion was a bit small for the table but it was very good. -Chicken Parm: 5/5, again kind of a staple at an Italian restaurant so wasn't expecting anything great. This was very VERY good. Huge portion, the cutlets were cooked perfectly, and the cheese was great. -Penne alla vodka: 3.5/5, had better had worse. Definitely good but nothing to write home about. -Chicken Scarpiello: 3.5/5, again not great but definitely good. The chicken was a bit bland but the sausage & potato were very good. Overall, I can say that I'm impressed with the food here. Yes it's a bit pricier but for a special occasion this is a great Italian food option in my opinion. I'm sure I'll be back! read more

Food was not up to par. The family style menu is inconvenient. Although you can order a single dinner the cost is 60% of the family (double) size. Pasta or salad does not accompany entrees. Service was slow. On a brighter note wait staff were polite and friendly. read more

Had a great dinner and was very happy to meet Jerry there. He was a great host (owner) he opened the door for my family and welcomed us in. Very polite and he made our night. He offered us drinks and was asking how everything was. Thank you. We had great service from the waitress & your food was sooo good. Great espresso martini. read more

See all

Over price horrible take out. 34.00 dollars for 13 shrimp in sauce give me a break pasta is 6.00 more. Crazy. I go somewhere else !!!!! read more

Butera's - 34.00 dollar dinner 13 shrimp and sauce what a meal !!!! It's such nonsense. Don't go there for take out they will rob you !!!!! - Italian Near Me - Sayville, New York