I don't know why I keep trying to give this place a chance and they keep letting me down. The last two times I've called for pizza pickup and they forgot to make the order TWICE. This time I decided to try a sandwich since their Stromboli only comes with pepperoni. What I got was this old bread, all bread sandwich. Total rip off for nearly $9. I'm done with this place I'm not sorry to say. read more

La Forchetta - Pizza Near Me - Wharton, New Jersey

Got a pizza on the way home from work. Large thin crust onion and pepperoni. We Always ask for it crispy and tonight it was superb. I've learned to check the bottom before I leave. Onions were nice and crispy and very little edge crust. Perfect. read more

Maria was quite possibly the best server I've ever had. We swapped stories about international hiking adventures and talked dogs and puppies, complete with a photo show. The food exceeded our expectations. Great Calzone, Pasta Fagiole, Melanzane. Pollo la Forchetta was unforgettable. Note that it's BYOB, but you can purchase Beer, Wine 2 doors down at the bar (fridge in the back should have you covered). Casual, kid-friendly place, small but very friendly. Pretty sure they have slices to go if that's what you're looking for. read more

I'm a pizza snob so I'd really like to give 3.5 stars. However, this pizza is really good compared to other options in the area. Delivery was on point, food came nice and hot, and the flavors were good too. My brother works at a pizzeria in Totowa and is SUPER judgmental on everything lol, and he even liked it! Not the best, but a great option! read more

First time here. Very impressed and will return! Staff was super friendly and the food was amazing! A hidden gem. This will be my new go-to spot. I don't order out much, but when I do this will be the place. The antipasto for 2 was one of the best I have had. Premium ingredients and ample portion. Also had the margherita pizza which did not disappoint. You can tell the ingredients were fresh and the crust was ample and not paper thin. A little more filling which was enjoyable. I will definitely be a regular after today! read more

La Forchetta - Antipasto for 2 and 14" margherita pizza! House dressing was delish! - Pizza Near Me - Wharton, New Jersey

See all

I stop by going back to my home town cranbury NJ Then my wife is asking if we can eat my son search then he said let's try this place awesome place family business the food is excellent very taste I get pasta Fagioli soup and few slices very good place to eat we strong recommend nice and clean read more

Delicious and budget friendly pizzeria ... I have tried mushroom pie couple of times and delicious

I ordered the pizza and egg plant park. The delivery was on time, no issues with that. However, the pizza was greasy, floppy and without crunch. TERRIBLE PIZZA. The sauce on the eggplant parm was TERRIBLE. Overall, I would never eat there again. read more

Man I am fat....just ate a fabulous meal. Just up from Florida. Have the Veal parm, broccoli rabe, pasta fagoli (if I could spell it) Nice place Thank you read more

Beat pizza in town! Pizza is great and so is the whole menu. Forget Maria's this blows them out of the water

Excellent food. This Pizzaria's food is much better than many restaurants food. Creative, tasty and generous.

Calabrese Caesar Salad is awesome! The pizza is very good, not greasy. Their sandwiches are great. The prices are ok, on par with everyone else. The service is questionable. Counter help takes care of internal strife before a walk in customer. They take care of phone calls instead of customers who are at the tables. They have to realize the people who come to the store are the most important. Phone calls can be put on hold, internal strife can be addressed later behind the scenes. read more

Absolutely delicious pizza and Italian food. The cannolis are AMAZING! We love the vodka sauce, chicken parm and their garlic knots!

The worst pizza I ever had. Thick crust not cooked all the way through. Really sucked

Not sure if it's family owned or not but sure feels like it! Anything I've had from that place is top notch especially the bruschetta slice and White pie . You will not leave without a doggy bag..ample parking read more

Very good pizza. We got it delivered in under an hour, even though the driver got lost. Pizza was hot and tasty, so were the wings that we ordered. My mouth was on fire and they were falling right off the bone. We also ordered a rice ball which was excellent as well. I would order again or pickup from here. read more

I have to admit I had high expectations for this place after reading some of the reviews. Unfortunately my experience wasn't as great as others have had. Now I'm not saying the food was bad - just meh - it's not bad but it's also not great and in my book doesn't warrant and thing above 3 stars. The service was good and attentive . But the food was somewhat bland and tasteless. I also don't see the need to put on so much processed mozzarella on everything - this is probably my biggest peeve. It's not that I don't like cheese, I just don't like so much of it. Particularly when is the lower grade and process stuff. In the end this is a middle of the road kind of place for me. I may eat here again if it's the only option but would likely try other options. read more

Great great service. Food taste really good. The best Italian food I had since I moved to NJ. read more

See all

Everything I've ever had from there is excellent sub sandwiches are full and served on the best tasting bread.Soups are very good and my personal favorite is the Chicken entree s excellent very time From the franchise to the Marcella all really good And generous portions read more

Located in an unassuming strip mall just off of Route 15 is this gem of a restaurant . A very attentive and friendly staff was always available to answer any questions regarding the menu selections. Starting with a daily special the corn chowder with baby scallops was lite, creamy and delicious. Another special consisting of baby scallops sautéed with spinach and served over pasta in a lemon butter sauce was exceptionally good. All of our meals were fresh, served hot and quite ample. This is a great little place that is worth the trip. Oh yea .. the pizza is excellent also. Stop by you'll be glad you did. read more

I am a foodie and I know my flavors well. I don't give high ratings easily but I have been to this restaurant twice now and it has quickly become my new favorite pizza joint and casual Italian food spot. Hands. Down.!! Their gourmet sandwiches are on point and they have *the best* pasta fagole I have ever had in my 38 years of life! I also love that this is a true mom and pop shop where the whole family seems to pitch in. I would definitely come back and recommend this place to anyone who enjoys delicious, comforting, Italian family made food. read more

This place makes a good sandwich. Lots of choices and not at all an ordinary selection. The sandwiches that come on toasted garlic bread are the best. I've also had their soups and pizza, both are consistently good. I've never tried an entree but sometime I will - with a nice bottle of red wine. (It's BYOB) Update from review above - we go here a few times a year. The last time we went, the waiter was slow and surly - definitely favoring people he already knew. It took forever to get sandwiches and we had to ask for our drinks, etc. Was a regular place for us, not going back anytime soon though. read more

If you want pizza that feels like dominoes meets papa johns, and then has a car wreck with pizza hut, then this is your place. Enough said. And oh yeah, service feels like a client of Berminghas is waiting on you, and their dead!!!! read more

No where in the area have I had better pizza Reminds me of an expensive Chicago pie at a low fair local price -/- owner loves her job and couldn't be happier to serve -- 2 topping pie medium only $14//- their cheese is clearly the best grade Run don't walk 5 stars read more

Ordered a half tray of chicken parm from here for a party. It was delicious and the serving size was perfect and was perfect for about 15 people. We winded up catering with them again for New Years. Definitely recommend! read more

The pizza was delicious. I had a honey mustard, ham and chicken slice then I ended getting a second slice, just pepperoni. The pizza was perfect and the service was nice as well. read more

Insulted, teased and poor usage of humor. We had high hopes for this place as we knew Anna Marie's when it was opened. Our waiter in poor attempts to to be funny lifted my friends phone and then.... Catch this played keep away with my wife's soup. Not once, not twice, not three times. Four times before my wife had to tell him to stop his ill behavior. It was only after he noticeably saw our displeasure that he stopped acting this way. On top of this the underside of my wife's pizza was burnt. This was our second try at this place and will not be returning. I know a lot of people in town and will be spreading the word. read more

Pizza was okay today not the best pizza very oily and the Greek salad was not that great very little salad and usually the pizza is fantastic but today was rushed something was off with it read more

Best pizza in the area! Crust was perfectly cooked! Fresh ingredient. Friendly service! We were glad to stop by for lunch for the first time. Prices are reasonable. We we'll definitely be back. read more

Came here because I didn't like how the buffet look next door. From the outside it does look small but once you get in it is a decent-size place. I had the Bentley GT sandwich which was right on the money. It was a vegetarian sandwich and the cheese was fresh and mushroom was at the peak of taste. The waiter what's good and the fountain soda was good. Will return. read more

The food is excellent and Anna and Joe are great! The problem I have is whenever I call in a delivery order and ask for something different, it doesn't happen unless Anna is taking the order. I find this very frustrating and it shouldn't happen. read more

Our new favorite place! Delicious authentically Italian food. Excellent and courteous service! Love this place!

I decided to try this place again. My last review happened to be around when the restaurant was apparently still run by previous owners. It was terrible. The new owner personally called and offered everything and anything to make up for the disaster he was left with. HOWEVER, I ordered the chicken francaise and pasta with garlic bread! It was fantastic!!!! I also ordered the lava cake which was fresh. Complete turn around!!! Also, thank you to the owner for listening a year ago about using fresh delivery boxes!!! Great job!!!! read more

I have only recently stopped in a here a couple of times at lunchtime so my review might be somewhat limited. What I can say is the pizza is very good. It's nice and fresh and crust is not too thick. I would say it's one of tithe better slices in the area. I will definitely stop by again and I'm looking forward to trying some other things on the menu. read more

This is our go to order in Italian/pizza. Delivery is always quick and they know how to navigate our apartment complex. Their pizza is good. I really like their tomato sauce. We usually get mushroom or grandpa pie. I have also got a white pizza with broccoli, which was also tasty. I love their garlic knots as well! They have a ton of pasta dishes to choose from and I've also loved them all. I really enjoy their chicken franchisee and chicken Marsala. During the summer months, I always order their sandwiches, wraps, and salads. They have creative choices for their sandwiches. My absolute favorite salad is the alfanso. It's a great size and has these marinated mushrooms on it that are mouth watering! I wish I could purchase a side order of those mushrooms! Staff is always friendly every time I call. I would love for them to add online ordering. I know other places in the area have that. read more

Great Fried Calamari and cheese pizza. Even when delivered the Calamari is still fresh, hot and crispy! Their hot subs are good too!

Was shopping for dinner at the Wharton Market, and noticed the new place, decided to check it out. Cozy space and helpful staff, we ordered a proscuitto and arugula pizza and the brocolli rabe salad... Very tasty. We will be back soon to try the entrees. The menu is extensive and there's lots of interesting stuff to try. read more

First time: Ordered a grilled chicken panini today and there wasn't much to it. Barely any chicken or mozzarella and the basil was brown. For the price it should include chips/fries. I can spend the same amount of money and get a better quality and tasting sandwich at Theodora's. read more

Such a amazing place to stop and grab a bite to eat. They are small mom and pop place with such amazing food AND it's a BYOB. My husband loves their shrimp fra diavolo and they are so accommodating with changing their dishes around so they are diary free for me. read more

Excellent. Have had their pizza, sandwiches, wraps, and entrees and all have been very good. They deliver to almost anywhere which is nice considering most places in this area do not deliver. Delivery sometimes takes pretty long but food has always been hot and fresh so no big deal. read more