This is my 4-5th time here in the last few years. Always a solid choice. Food is always good and service is usually on par. Ambiance is quiet and tranquil. Really can't ask for much more. Prices are regular Italian establishment type. Pizza is decent nice crust, good sauce, and toppings are fresh. Bread is crispy and warm. Pasta fagoli is good, Italian wedding is amazing, and the tortellini en brodo is klller! Deserts haven't partaken...can't seem to get there. read more

Do not waste your money. Food is not good. Nothing authentic Italian about it- frozen meatballs and crap pasta and sauce. Pasta e fagoli had cut up spaghetti in it and pretty sure it was watered down vodka sauce... maybe 6 beans. Pizza was sad since we were in NY. Food came out an hour after ordering- in bits and pieces. Kids meals came out lasts. The air conditioning started leaking from the ceiling. I absolutely question if they are serve safe certified. Servers and cooks in sandals and not following standards. Also- there's a surcharge to use your credit card. Avoid at all costs. read more

For $16.00?I asked for everything I got a slice of ham,salami pepperoni and a slice of provolone. Mayo oil and vinegar green peppers. read more

Villa Italia - Worst Italian combo I ever had.I asked for everything . - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

We love their vodka penne pizza and calamari!! It is so wonderful when they pour the pasta over your pizza you'll love it!!!

Love the food but the red head girl at the counter is incredibly rude every time I show up, twice now! There for food not for a bad attitude. read more

Went here to order to go lunch. Staff was very friendly and polite, I made my order and even before asking they told me how long was the wait. That's something I do appreciate a lot, since places you have ask or they tell you a vague idea so if there wrong you don't complain. The grilled rib-eye steak panini was something else, steak was cooked middle well, but seasoned perfectly and I love they got grill marks well without any over charing. Mushroom and onions were cooked on point and very caramelized. Garlic knots were good, like parm and garlic toppings on them and knots themselves were slightly chewy and marinara dipping was nice and smooth. My plain slice pizza was great, not greasy and great cheese to sauce ratio. The chicken soup I got in place of fries was only negative, not much chicken, veggies were not cooked though and broth was tasteless. Otherwise an awesome lunch read more

See all

Such a bummer. We ordered from this place last week- the food wasn't bad. Decided to order again today- and had a completely different experience. As a local small business owner myself, having a meal delivered is sometimes the highlight of our day. Today I ordered the tuna salad lunch special, and the tuna was gross- super fishy, no Mayo, and super late. It was Dry and unappetizing to say the least. The side salad we ordered was a joke. A few pieces of lettuce and and fixings thrown together. We tried to call and let the business know (RESPECTFULLY) and the reply we got from the young lady on the phone was "oh... yeah... sorry about that" No trying to make anything right, just complete disregard and terrible customer service. We will not be ordering again. read more

See all

Enjoyed a delightful lunch at this comfy restaurant while visiting my mom in the area. You can walk in for a slice at the counter, or have table service in the dining room. Decided on a late Saturday lunch and no one was in the dining area so we had the place to ourselves. One server was working between the counter and the dining room and she was delightful - sorry cannot remember her name. My mom loves baked clams and was in awe with the fresh garlic and butter sauce for these babies. I tried the huge appetizer of eggplant rollatini, calamari, baked clams and shrimp along with a green salad to feel somewhat healthy for this New Year. All super filling and satisfying. read more

Villa Italia - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

The pizza and entrees are delicious. The service is always on point. The vibe is very family oriented. My favorite food is of course the pizza pies, Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala, garlic knots and cannolis. Yum! Enjoy :) read more

last night I picked up the worst dinner from you. I was so surprised. we dine there often. I love your lemon chicken dinner special. I would have come into to dine but I have bronchitis. When I called to place my order, I described exactly what I wanted to the young lady on the phone. She had said it was chicken Francese. I explained it was similar but had mushrooms and the chicken was cut into smaller pieces. After being put on hold several times, she came back said she knew what I wanted and all was good. When I came to pick up my order, questioned the young man who cashed me out because it read "chicken francese". I was told not to worry because it was the lemon chicken. Well, I didn't get lemon chicken or chicken Francese. I got 1 chicken breast filleted into 2 pieces, pan fried with mushrooms over angelhair pasta and butter. it was awful. made me sick to my stomach. read more

Villa Italia - the receipt for the meal - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Service stinks. Sat there for 50 minutes, no salad or apps on way. Ask the waitress why, she tells me I'm wrong and it hasn't been that long. Told her about the table who sat after us already has the food. She tells us if we can leave if we want. Save your money! Place was good when the old man ran it! read more

Villa Italia is top-shelf. This pizza is of the highest quality. The grandma pie is fantastic. Also, their Penne Ala vodka is perfect. The owner, Sam, is a nice guy. I'm telling you, this place has excellent food. The prices, however, are at the higher end of the spectrum. The bottom line is that you get what you pay for. I never had an issue with quality here. read more

Was driving through and stoped here to grab a bite to go. Great pizza and service. A+

Went for lunch today , everything from the bread and salad with Blue cheese dressing was great. I had a pasta dish (Spaghetti Con Salsa Di Pomodoro) delicious with a side of meatballs . My girlfriend enjoyed her Penne Siciliana. Again would recommend Villa Italia read more

Excellent spot! We were coming back from a ski trip and just wanted a bite to eat, but the dishes here are definitely more than meets the eye! I had the short rib ravioli and it was absolutely delicious - huge portion too so I had enough for a meal to go. Definitely worth stopping by here. read more

Villa Italia is our go to for all Italian. We moved her in April and they have not let us down when we want pizza : wings. Food is fresh. Pizza is the best in the area. read more

Service was excellent . Wait staff was friendly and accommodating. Food came out very quickly. The actual food was ok. We had calamari and a pizza. Calamari meh, pizza meh +. read more

The food was great. We had to go pick it up and it was still nice and hot when we got back the portions were wonderful and it reheated very well in the microwave. read more

Atmosphere is nice and cozy. The staff are super friendly. I wish I remembered my servers name to give him a good shoutout. The food is delicious and it comes out nice and hot! I wish I took pictures of the food. I started demolishing it as soon as it it the table. I'll take pictures next time! read more

Literally my favorite pizza in all of Newburgh! Came with my usual crew so they could enjoy all it's goodness! We were promptly seated and our drink order was taken. We took a look at the menu and after a few moments decides on 2 personal pizza and a veal dinner. The waiter brought out bread that was warm and soft, followed by a constant stream of refills which was nice to see he was paying attention. The pizza came out first and to our shock for the price was so large. Their personal is the equivalent of a medium size pizza easily one could of fed the table. The Margharitta was superb with the flavor and freshness of ingredients. My chicken Parm Pizza was just as good full of sauce and pieces of chicken they were very generous on the toppings and giving us the pizza straight from the oven. The veal dinner took about another 15 minutes before it came out but arrived to the table pipping hot and it was well received. It was full of flavor and very tender not dry and over-cooked. I would easily recommend this and say it is the best pizza in all of Newburgh! read more

See all

I absolutely must say, easily the second best pizza I have had since moving to NY AND it is less than 5 miles from the crib. I must say, this has been a pretty great experience. My wife and I just wanted dinner out as we both had a pretty day. Didn't expect much as the reviews are just kinda blah. Man were we pleasantly surprised. Extremely nice waiter and he was great with the food recommendations. His only flaw was not convincing us to eat less lol. We had the Shrimp appetizer (don't remember the full name) and the special pizza (loaded) and it was amazing. By the time we finished their bread, the appetizer, and got to the pizza, we only ate 2 slices. Jeez. I must say, side note, their courtesy bread is YUM! fresh and warm. OMG, we will eat here again PS- I don't know how much longer they will do the 10% check in deal with yelp, as they made it sound like they were done with Yelp. read more

See all

We have been coming here for years. Unfortunately when we went this evening , we were seated and waited as two other families came in and we're served. The food is ok usually but to have to wait and be ignored the food isn't that good. read more

Great quick lunch! Waitress and counter help both very friendly. Ordered pizza and chicken pesto panini. All food fresh and cooked to order. We would definitely go back if in the area again. Cash incentive. read more

Great food. Prices are decent but charge you for using your credit card. Love the Sicilian pizza!

Called to place an order for pick up twice. Both times, the staff was super friendly and welcoming. Picked up my order and the quality, taste and warmth of my pizza pies and garlic knots were impeccable. Certainly one of, if not the best pizza in the Walden/Newburgh area. read more

Villa Italia is a american/italian style pizza place in newburgh. The business is family run. The owners went to NFA. The type of food is pizza but the owners have tried to make this more of a restaurant over the years. I have to say i loved this place when it first opened. There pizza is good. They have everything from plain to seafood style pizzas. Out of all the pizzas i have had,none of the pizzas have lacked cheese or flavor. recently they just re modeled the inside and outside of the building and expanded the dining room area to accommodate more seats.They did a great job with the re model. I do like the pizza here altho there pizza is not my fav in the area, there pizza is consistent. There other food on the other hand is hit or miss. There has been times i have ordered lunch and dinner here and the food is over cooked. I have gotten food that have tasted very bland. For lunch sometimes the food takes a bit. I have also not recieved dressing with my salad before. Another time i was missing a full order. I called them and they told me i could drive back to pick it up haha. so they gave me a credit for the sandwich next time i am in. I travel alot and I have to say there delivery is really good here. Most of the time when i order delivery from here i am in between trips. The food is always really hot oppon arrival. Unlike some of the other delivery places in the area. The price of the food is a few extra dollars than other places around the area. They also charge a $3.00 delivery fee. Overall: there pizza is good They are more expensive than some of the other places around. I would just stick to pizza if you eat here. i will continue to order from villa. PROS: - Delivery is always hot - Pizza is consistant CONS: - Non pizza items are hit or miss. over cooked dinners read more

See all

Oh how I love this place!! This adorable Italian/ Pizza place has stole my heart! I am so glad it's just a couple miles away from my home. When you walk in- the right side is the kitchen and pizzeria, to the left you have an adorable Italian restaurant! The pizza is great whether you order a specialty pie at your table or picking up a slice to go! I love the margarita pizza and the penne vodka slice the best. The lasagna slice is also pretty good! My all time favorite dish is the penne alla vodka! It is sooo creamy, flavorful, and delicious! Easily one of the best vodka sauce I have ever had- and boy have I eaten A LOT of penne alla vodka! I've also had the chicken franchise which is really good too. I love that they serve a salad before your meal. The Cesar dressing is my fave! You also get soft on the inside crusty on the outside bread with olive oil and a few olives in it. They do an awesome deal on Wednesday's for pasta night! It's all you can eat pasta with a salad and choice of meatball or sausage for around $11. The portions are really nice size. I always leave this place happy and full! Until next time Villa Italia! read more

I used to work here as a kid and til this day miss' the staff and think about their penne ala vodka. I look forward to eating their food again. read more

STICKY STICKY STICKY STICKY!!!!! THIS IS A MESSAGE TO THE OWNER: 1:05 pm. june 27th 2019. first time here. upon parking i got a good feeling about your place. i liked the curb appeal, HOWEVER; when i was seated... my table was sticky and had salt granules. i asked the waitress for a damp towel so i can clean the STICKY table. the waitress informed me that all the tables are stock and wiping them down will achieve nothing. i asked for a wipedown anyway. she was right... THE TABLES ARE ALL STICKY. mr owner... you staff is away of the STICKY TABLES yet you dont replace them. I AM GROSSED OUT BY THE STICKY AND DARE NOT LET MY CLOTHES TOUCH. _______________________ the food: soggy French fries. steamed clams not hot. __________________________ PLEASE ENLIGHTEN ME WHY I SHOULD RETURN!!!!!!!!!! read more

Using the "if you don't have anything nice to say don't say anything at all" template I've drafted the following review. ... Sincerely, a first time customer. read more

I ate a late lunch here yesterday. My husband and I have dined here over the past several years, about every few months or so. Our server, Pastor, was a great waiter. We've been served by him several times before. He's very friendly, funny, attentive and polite. Always prompt service! The restaurant is in a great location at the corners of Route 300 & 32, but it is always quiet in the building, as well as cozy. But the ambiance has a bit of a diner feel to it (just a bit). There are no booths, though, only tables/chairs. There are "soft" alcoholic beverages available (tap beer, wine, etc.) and the food is always very tasty and satisfying. You never leave there feeling hungry and I always have left-overs to bring home. I've never had a complaint about the food quality, the quantity or the presentation. Prices are fairly reasonable and in accord with today's prices for dining out. As the name reveals, the primary style of food served is Italian. The home-made pizzas and all of the various Italian style dishes that we've had over time have all been very good, and are always consistantly prepared. Consistancy is very important in the business world. read more

This is the kind of pizza I dream about. That's all. [Dammit, I really wanted to make that the whole review. BUT: I should say the following things. Villa Italia is: -cheap -quick -friendly -dine in or take out -gluten free if you need it -DELICIOUS They have salads, sandwiches, and entrees as well as pizza. Duh. It's a great place.] read more

The pizza is really good.the entrees suck. We ate here once. The seafood was BLAND. My chicken parm was like...stouffers..? I don't understand how this place is always packed.I live right around the corner and will only grab a slice on occasion. I'll drive past it to go someplace that actually seasons and takes time to prepare their food. read more

I love the food here, but tonight's service was garbage. On a special evening such as tonight, New Years Eve, where the current ratio is one waiter per two tables this is bogus. The drinks took 15 minutes, two ordered the same drink and it was served different glasses, and different colors. Bread finally came out, 1 roll for 8 people. The bread refill took another 15 minutes. The dining room is half filled so they can't claim being busy. Don't get me wrong, love their food, but tonight was a wreck for service. read more

Villa Italia - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

You are only as good as the people you train to represent you and having said that yesterday's waitress should be working at a truck stop or Dominoes. On another note...My Italian family loves the tentacles with fried calamari...when our calamari arrived ...I asked where are the tentacles?The waitress says to me nobody likes them,we don't serve them! I thought this is how you talk to customers? And then I said to my husband...That's it! If we dine out for Italian going forward it will be in Westchester. read more

Decided to dine at Villa Italia tonight . There were 4 of us . Let me start by saying When we arrived there was a table of 2 and a table of 8. With 2 waitresses and a busser working . Both tables were finished and just waiting on their checks , leaving just our table . The waitress sat us under a leaking air conditioner leaving the floor wet and drops of water hitting us so we asked to move . She took our drink orders . Took awhile for drinks to come (all soda) asked about bread for the table and was told it was coming. We placed our order and an appetizer of bruschetta. I asked that my granddaughters food be brought out with the appetizer(Kids ziti and meatballs ) After 30 minutes our salads arrived, no bread for the table and no bruschetta and no child's meal. I asked once again where the bread was and if the bruschetta was coming mind you the appetizer always comes before the salad. Was told once again the bread was on its way and so was the bruschetta. We finished our salads. She came back to collect the plates I asked for refills on our drinks and for the third time where the bread for the table and bruschetta was and was told they ran out of bread but that some was just brought in. Not sure if she forgot to place the order or if indeed they ran out of bread and if that were the case why weren't we told from the start instead of waiting (now an hour). And still no child's meal was delivered I reminded her again that my granddaughter has been waiting over an hour and would like her her food to be brought out. We received the bread and the bruschetta at the same time. The bruschetta consisted of chopped tomatoes , alot (overpowering) of garlic and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese But the worst was the oil it that it was so drenched in that the bread was not only soggy but dripping when you picked up a piece , it was disgusting and we sent it back and asked for it to be taken off the bill. Our food finally arrived my niece cannot have garlic she ordered grilled chicken and a side of broccoli and stated to the waitress that it must be Plain . When the food arrived it was loaded with garlic , when we explained to the waitress that it was ordered without garlic the waitress response was " No it was not". My mother ordered stuffed shells and the shelves were so chewy because they were undercooked so she decided not to say anything and just took it home to re-cook them. I ordered a small calzone that never arrived when I asked the waitress she responded that I did not order a calzone. The bill comes and the bruschetta is on there . I told her we would like that removed as we tried to attempt to eat just one piece and sent it back and she said she would have to find out if she could remove it. By then we asked to speak to the owner who never came to the table . The service was horrendous, the food was awful and the kicker was they now charge a fee if you choose to use your credit card ! Usually the fee is incurred by the cost of the meals . I have enclosed a receipt as well as the new fee notice on every menu. It's shocking that they charge $17 for stuffed shells. Can't say I will be back anytime soon . read more

Villa Italia - a brown leather case with a sign on it - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

We had to make a trip to New Windsor and were considering going to Godfather's Pizza just to try the gluten free pizza. The friend we had to visit suggested we try Villa Italia instead, saying his wife also has Celiac Disease and eats here all the time and loves it. The gluten free pizza was not on the menu, so we're glad he told us about it. I ordered a GF pizza and hubby ordered a regular pie for himself. When they came out his definitely "looked" better than mine, but hey, I was going to eat PIZZA again! WOOHOO! The crust on my pizza was ok, I mean it's gluten free so I knew it wasn't going to be wonderful but the sauce they use is REALLY good and so were the toppings. Hubby liked his pizza but had to ask for more sauce as there wasn't a lot on his pizza. We were brought a big bowl of sauce which we both agreed was so good we would have eaten it as soup! Overall, the food was good but the service was a little slow. read more

We had takeout from there recently. My daughter Paid for it over the phone with her debit card. Food was so so. The horrible thing is that the girl who brought the food, we discovered the next day, printed off a separate, bogus receipt, added a tip to it and signed my daughters name!! That's forgery,theft and falsifying a business record! We have proof as the owner gave us a copy of the bogus receipt thinking it was really my daughters and it wasn't!! Other than reimbursing us the tip that this girl added to the total, nothing was done! In fact the workers, and I assume the owner too, are bad mouthing US, saying it never happened and it was a small mistake! The owner couldn't care less that his worker committed these offenses against a customer and falsified a business record. SHE FORGED MY DAUGHTERS NAME ON A SEPARATE RECEIPT! There's no doubt that this girl has done this before and yet she still works there. An apology from the girl would have been nice. My daughter has to get a new card now as we don't know what happened to the receipt that she actually signed. I have attempted to contact the owner to talk to him about what he is doing or what he said to the girl. He is ignoring me. I told him that a reimbursement for our meal would have been a nice customer relation thing to do, but I hear nothing! Instead he has accused us of taking advantage of the pandemic to extort money out of him by way of a gift card! Disgusting doesn't begin to describe this entire incident! Watch your bank accounts if you get food here during this time. The owner doesn't care about you! read more

I ordered a carrot cake for my husbands birthday. It was a layered cake. Supposed to be cake layered with frosting. It was mostly cream cheese frosting and very little cake. It was so sickening that none of my guests could eat it. I suppose if you like to eat spoonfuls of frosting you might like it. I was so disappointed. read more

Not asking for 5 star dining service, but it took us forever to get our food and forever to get our check. We were only out of there before 2 hours because I got up, walked to our waitress, and asked for the check. There are like 12 tables and 4 waitresses, not sure what the problem is. read more