We usually start our summer off with a visit to Lenny & Joe's in Madison. We enjoy the outdoor area with the picnic tables and the BYOB is nice too. We made our first stop of the season there this past weekend and we were a bit disappointed. The prices are up and it seems the portion size is down. They are putting the food on smaller plates to make it seem like you're getting a lot, but it doesn't take much observation to see that the portions are less. We got calamari as an appetizer and it was a small portion for the $16.99 price and it was a bit greasy. I've had way better elsewhere. The 2 way combo no longer has scallops as a choice, but they are available for 2 bucks extra. Our bill was $107.31 for the three of us without drinks. The food quality was just OK. We got our usual ice cream and found that also to be very expensive at around $6.00 for a small portion. It might be time to find a new "go to" place. There are better options out there for that kind of money. Too bad. We like the atmosphere but I also like to get my moneys worth. read more

I've been eating Lenny & Joe's since the days when the only way you could get it was ordering from a screen porch on a shed with high schoolers for cooks. It's still a destination and locals restaurant. Westbrook was very different from Madison when it opened and people flocked to it for the dine-in experience. I've lost count how many times I've eaten here but it's always delicious. Staff is always friendly. Everything on the menu is "can't miss." read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Baked stuffed shrimp with double slaw instead of fries! - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

See all

Whenever we visit my hubs' family in CT every year during the last week of October, we never miss to make a stop at Lenny & Joe's for our classic New England seafood favorites: the fried clams and the Connecticut-style lobster roll with warm butter (my preference over Maine-style with mayo). The fried clams were lightly battered, golden, and crisp on the outside, yet tender and briny inside. It was fresh, not greasy, and came in a portion generous enough to share and enough for some leftovers too. The side of tartar sauce was creamy and tangy, but honestly, the clams were so good they didn't need much dressing up. The lobster roll, I must say is one of the best in the area. The lobster meat was sweet, plentiful, and perfectly cooked--no rubbery bites here. (In Cali, they seem to split the lobster meat into 2 or 3 rolls as there isn't much lobster meat). Served on a toasted bun with butter, it was simple, classic, and exactly what a lobster roll should be. The service was quick even though the place was busy. It's the kind of spot that feels like summer in Connecticut, whether you're sitting inside or out on the porch. If you're visiting anywhere near Madison, Clinton or Westbrook, don't miss Lenny & Joe's! read more

See all

the clear broth chowder was gray it shouldn't be gray! it's as if they don't rinse the clams and you're eating dirt.. The picture I added is what it should look like... read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - The correct look of clear broth chowder - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

Stopped by Lenny & Joe's and had their ice cream with Reese's Cups mixed in, and it was absolutely delicious. The ice cream was creamy, the Reese's added the perfect amount of chocolate and peanut butter, and the portion size was great. The staff were also very friendly and provided excellent service from start to finish. Overall, a great experience, and I'll definitely be back to try more flavors. Highly recommend if you're looking for a tasty treat. read more

Greatest fried seafood in Connecticut, hands down. I ordered the 2-way fried combo of shrimp and scallops, with fries and cole slaw and brought it home. 15 mins in a 350° oven and we're good to go. Great dinner for a beautiful Saturday evening read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Fried shrimp and fried scallops with French fries - the 2-way. Comes with Cole slaw. - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

See all

Casual seafood spot to grab a lobster roll. We both had hot butter rolls with slaw. Solid portion of sweet lobster but my bun split on the bottom after second bite. We also shared fried pickles with a tangy ranch dipping sauce. The server informed us we could grab a drink from the cooler in the car so BYOB. There's also a cute ice cream shop outside with a carousel for the kids. All around a pleasant dining experience on the way back to NY. read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Twist with rainbow jimmies - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

We came in on a late Friday afternoon just before 5:00 and it wasn't busy at all and we were seated right away. Our service all night was off the charts good - 6 stars out of 5, that good! Always checking in and bringing our food out hot. We started with 1/2 dozen oysters. 5 were really good and 1 was gross. Weird look abd texture. But it with a knife, tasted it and quickly spit it out. Not worth getting sick! I had shrimp and scallop casserole with crabmeat stuffing (extra charge for special stuffing). My wife had the lobster roll. Lobster was amazon fresh and cooked to perfection. Price was good. Closer to home we get these stuffed with more lobster but it was very good and nothing to be embarrassed about here! Fries were abundant and hot!!! We love our fries hot yet so many restaurants, even expensive ones, serve them cold or soggy. Not here! My shrimp & scallops were very good. The stuffing not so much. I paid extra so it wasn't just crumbled corn flakes but it was only a little better. Very dry and nothing much crab or "excitement " in the stuffing. I added drawn butter and it helped a little. Food was 3 - 3.5 and service 5 stars. 4 stars overall and worth a visit. Wish we trued the lobster bisque as it's a favorite. We liked the casual feel of the restaurant and family like atmosphere. read more

See all

The service was wonderful and our waitress was pleasant the interior had a seafarer's theme. We started our meal with a nice warm homemade loaf of wheat bread. I started my meal with the Shrimp Cocktail which was 4 huge shrimp with cocktail sauce. The shrimp was served with the entire shell on not just the tail but the entire shrimp, which I thought was a lazy way to serve shrimp cocktail as most places remove the shell, except for on the tail. I had the baked stuffed sole, the fish was flaky and fresh but the stuffing was supposed to be ritz cracker crumbs with crab meat, instead it was greasy buttered seasoned bread crumbs, not a bit of crabmeat or even ritz crackers in sight. The fish was served with mixed vegetables and boiled potatoes. My boyfriend had a cheeseburger, as doesn't eat seafood. The burger was generous in size and juicy, cooked to perfection, not dried out. read more

See all

The food is the freshest seafood around. They give you sizable portions. The shrimp roll is loaded with shrimp. The service at the bar is a guy who has been here for over 20 years- he remembers your name and is very jovial. I've been eating here for years. read more

See all

Every one that works there are fantastic, very friendly , we have been going there almost once a week for years and never had a problem service or quality of food, HIGHLY RECOMMEND. read more

On a Friday evening at the beginning of the 2025 Labor Day weekend, I had dinner at Lenny and Joe's Fish Tale Restaurant in Westbrook, CT. One night earlier, I had dinner at Trattoria Dal Forno in North Haven, CT. The North Haven restaurant does not describe itself as a seafood restaurant, although seafood is a part of their menu. Since Lenny & Joe's does describe itself as a seafood restaurant, I expected my order of scrod wood be of at least the same quality as a restaurant that didn't specialize in seafood. That was not so. The quality, presentation and seasoning of my scrod at Lenny & Joe's was unacceptably bland. I was the guest of my niece and chose not to send my meal back to the kitchen. Instead, I only tasted my dinner and chose not to eat it. The meal came home with me, but I intend to throw it out. Service was very good, but the ambiance was extremely noisy. It was very difficult to have a conversation. I found the noise level annoying. If it wasn't for quality service, my rating would have been no stars let alone one star. All in all, I wish I had not accepted the invitation to Lenny & Joe's. It was a waste of my niece's money. read more

Stopped in with my parents after shopping at the outlets. It was our first time here in 15 years and it didn't disappoint! I had the shrimp scampi with onion rings and mixed veggies. The scampi sauce was delicious, so buttery and flavorful and came with about 12 shrimp (I started eating before I took the photo). The onion rings are made daily in house and were crispy and greasy, some of the best I've ever had! Mixed veggies were bland. My dad had the salmon lunch special and loved it. Mom had the fried shrimp roll and enjoyed that too! read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Shrimp Scampi - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

Very tasty. Clam chowder was loaded with potatoes, and tasted like ocean, mix between Rhode Island and New England chowder. Lobster bisque is smooth and creamy and the lobster roll is delicious. Clam strips weren't soggy, cooked to perfection! Cute carousel for anyone that wants to ride, proceeds are donated to charity! read more

See all

This a great spot to go for some really yummy seafood dishes. My favorites are the fried shrimp and the shrimp scampi. We were here recently (which is definitely the off season) and it wasn't super busy so we got seated quickly and the waitress was very prompt and helpful. This place can definitely get super busy during the summer but they have always had good staff and managed moving diners in and out very efficiently. My father-in-law always gets the swordfish and my husband usually gets the clam strips. I'm not sure why their boiled red potatoes are extra yummy, but I love them, and they make the only coleslaw I will eat! Give it a try. We definitely will be back. read more

I know there are two of these restaurants named the same and, honestly, you can't go wrong with either. Great food great service ambience that brings your sea shanty fantasy alive. read more

Great service! Very friendly staff. Portions are enormous! Atmosphere was very casual. Kids friendly restaurant. Delicious seafood! Would recommend! read more

See all

Lenny and Joe's Fish tale has had consistent quality for years. Their seafood is fresh and delicious. The menu is extensive with fried, broiled, and baked seafood options. Like everywhere else, the prices have gone up, and the portion sizes have decreased significantly. The restaurant was clean and organized. Isabella, our waitress was professional, friendly, efficient and wonderful. It is the perfect place on a summer afternoon to have a delicious lunch. We started with the lobster bisque, and had clam strips, a lobster roll, and was even treated to a beautiful rainbow as we were leaving the restaurant. read more

See all

That Lobster Roll 10/10. Blue Point oysters delicious although they gave me some really small ones. The seafood here is fresh and tasty! The waitress was kind and attentive. Tons of people were there and we still got a table immediately. I can't wait to go back here again next time I visit CT! They do need to update the prices on this listing though quite a bit more now. read more

An amazing dinner as always! I realized when here that I have been coming with my family for 55 years to Lenny and Joes! The food is just as good! The difference is now the indoor seating they bring you to your table and have a menu that they serve you from. The outside you can order from the booths and they will bring the food to you The ice cream shack and the carousel rides cost but all goes to charity! This is a must if you are on the shore-- COME AND ENJOY!!! read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Clam chowder - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

See all

Love love coming here as it never disappoints and always great quality. Very roomy location as it is very large and authentic ocean atmosphere. Always come here during the summer. Service is always great- nice and quick as we ordered lobster roll, crab cakes, and halibut. Rather large portion sizes and priced appropriately (lunch deals run great). Loved my crab cake as it is extremely fresh plus the side are delicious too. Overall Defs have to come here as it is a classic- really recommend read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Crab Cake Sandwich Platter, Hot Buttered Lobster Roll Platter, and halibut fish - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

Worst Lobster Roll that I ever had. I had a take-out order, but they forgot the butter. The lobster was overcooked and chewy. Many better places to go, like Bill's Seafood up the road, but this place was not good. Coleslaw seemed out of a can, yuck. . read more

My cousin & I wanted to see what all the hype was about. We always wanted to go to the New Haven location but never got to(it has since closed down). We wanted to grab a bite to eat after shopping at the outlets. We came across Lenny & Joe's & were excited. It was rather busy in there but we still got a table promptly. Waitress was attentive & made our experience pleasant. I ordered the fried shrimp dinner. It came w/ fried shrimp,fries, tartar sauce,& cole slaw. Shrimp were very small.Coke slaw tasted weird (maybe it was old).Tartar sauce was way too chunky for my liking. Needless to say I was disappointed. Inside has an old school boat themed vibe. I like nostalgic stuff. read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Fried shrimp dinner - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

For decades I have been enjoying fried clams at both locations. Until today, in Madison. The clams were undercooked. I sent them back. They were returned still undercooked. The server explained the clams were so large that it was impossible to cook them adequately. I don't know if that makes a lot of sense but is it healthy to eat undercooked shellfish? To be fair the server offered to take them back again and bring me whatever else I wanted but after two long waits I had run out of time. The inconvenience and absence of an editable meal were not reflected in the check. It arrived as if nothing had happened to tarnish the experience. read more

Fresh seafood cooked pretty good fresh oysters and clams outstanding the fried seafood a bit on the oily side but I will be going back

This is a really solid authentic no-frills coastal New England seafood joint. Atmosphere/decor -- think greasy spoon meets inside picnic tables. Lots of great newspaper and art from the past 4-5 decades on the walls. This is the opposite of pretentious. Casual, casual, casual, but upbeat and fun down to earth style. Service -- was fairly good. It's big and at times hectic so lots of different servers and assistants coming by to fill up drinks and remove finished dishes. Our young kids spilled a few things and they came over with napkins and/or to help clean it up quickly. Food arrived a little later than you'd hope with young kids (and asking for a few dishes as soon as they're ready) but not unheard of. Food -- awesome grilled, fried, and broiled seafood options. You get a mountain of food with some of the combos. We definitely over ordered. Love that the kids dishes came with so much food and had some healthy side alternatives besides brown/white fried everything. Good bit of options for folks who aren't eating seafood and/or want some healthy alternatives but it's mostly typical americana fare. Drinks -- lots of good beers, including some regional and local microbrews, range of sodas, or concoctions. Price -- your typical down to earth yet seafood ain't cheap prices but slightly less so. Great to see the docks from the eatery -- hopin' that has something to do with brining down the prices a tad compared to your usual lobster roll or friend fish platter prices. read more

See all

Went to one of my favorite places to eat until this last visit.. I believe they have a new owner because nothing tasted the same . The chowder was bland I always get the hot crab roll my absolute favorite but was told that they had not had it for several weeks. So I chose a fish sandwich onion rings was so mushy the batter just fell off . I immediately sent it back. My friend ordered a salad with steak it was very plain for a large salad meat was tough . The fried pickles were pretty good . I might try it again because it is a good ride for me . But definitely disappointed in my meal left there only having chowder . Enjoy Chris M read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - A salad with Tenderloin Tails on Salad - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

See all

First we grated a very knowledgeable waitress who her own suggestions on the salmon which my guest took !! But this time I thought order the baked stuffed shrimp !! And when it , it didn't disappoint!! It was stuffed with a ritz cracker stuffing with crabmeat and a Monterey Jack cheese!! And the small red potatoes and the coleslaw just rounded the lunch . read more

Been coming here since the mid 90's, even bringing out-of-town guests occasionally. I almost always order the fried scallops. And when I don't, I regret it (see my previous review). If it ain't broke, don't fix it. Meals are not the cheapest around but you're getting a consistent quality that's worth it. The shirts, as of Spring 2023, are $7.99, which is still a great deal! read more

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale - Fried Fresh Scallops & Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Westbrook, Connecticut

Had heard they had a good lobster role but it was the worst one, I ever had. Lobster was definitely not fresh, French fries were cold and Cole slaw was tasteless. Worst meal I have had in CT. Service was uninspired. Sorry I went there and won't go back because there are so many better restaurants. read more

Haven't been back in awhile because the last time we went it wasn't do great as it had been for years. We hit the very few open outlets today and decided to give it another try. So glad we did! We ordered Clear clam chowdah. Slightly cloudy not creamy and had great flavor. The lobster bisque was really, really delicious. Steamers came out well viewed snd cooked well. Not my favorite thing but I tried one. Tasted fresh and was tender. Lobster rolls. Decent amount of tender lobster. Sides were fries and coleslaw. I was told it was good. I got the fisherman's platter cuz I like leftovers! You came choose your items from 2-4 I ordered cod, scallops, shrimp and clams. Light crispy crust and nice fresh fish. All was delicious! They're baaaaaack! Give them a try ! read more

See all

There not as good as it used to be they need to change the oil more often and more food for what they charging $$$$ clam castle is doing a great job noticed more people are saying they they enjoy the food there better !!! read more

46 Years Serving Quality Food, Great Service & Great Times My wife and I were were driving from New Jersey to Newport, RI today and I planned a lunch at Lenny & Joe's in Westbrook, CT. This is one of my all-time favorite restaurants. I grew up in area and have been patronizing Lenny & Joes since they opened. It is one of the best seafood restaurants you can eat at in the state. They never compromise on freshness, quality, quantity, or service. My wife ordered the hot buttered lobster roll platter. You get a buttered toasted hotdog bun loaded with 100% lobster meat and had a side of coleslaw with an unsweetened iced tea. I ordered the twin Maryland Soft-shell Crab platter. They were two gigantic wale crabs perfectly fried sitting on a hamburger bun. (Needless to say, I was in heaven!!!) I had rice and coleslaw for my sides and an unsweetened iced tea. As far as I am concerned no one beats Connecticut when it comes to soft-shell crab sandwiches, fried whole belly clams, and lobster rolls, and no one does it better than Lenny & Joe's!!! If you never tried L & J or have not been there in a while or just traveling through Connecticut please try them, I know you will not be disappointed. read more

Iconic local seafood place with a huge menu and a ton of both indoor and outdoor seating. The indoor seating includes both table and bar seating The menu is comprised of a wide range of seafood options, most of which are fried. I tried the lobster bisque and a fried clam-strip sandwich. Both were fantastic. The vibe is very family friendly and upbeat Supposedly the place can get packed, but since I went in the middle of the day it wasn't crowded at all and the service was pretty solid 8.5 read more

This was our first visit to this location of Lenny & Joe's. Our first and last visit to New Haven's Fish Tale got me hooked on their lobster bisque. (that location is now closed.) So obviously, while at another location I needed to give it another try to see how consistent they are. I could probably eat this soup 7 days a week. A thick velvety smooth soup with large chunks of lobster floating around. That's my idea of soup. Also on the menu for me tonight was a Lobster Mac & Cheese. (I ordered the fries for the dog.) Mac & Cheese was a layer of pasta (shells) topped with cheese sauce. On top of that was the lobster meat which was strewn across the top of the entire dish. It was then topped with buttery bread crumbs. SO enjoyed a broiled haddock meal that was cooked to perfection. Seating is available outside under a tent or inside. (CDC guidelines loosing up makes restaurants easier to navigate.) Parking was plentiful. Servers were efficient and brought a small bowl of water for the dog. read more

See all

Steamers, chowder, fish sandwich and Cod Dinner (lemon caper sauce) YUMMMMmmm! Great food and service, thanks crew!

I wish I could give them more than five stars just for lobster bisque. It was AH-MAZE-ING! It was full of lobster, creamy, hot, and honestly, I think about it at least once a week. The fried calamari was good although not as amazing, and the fried lobster was also delicious. I was originally on the fence about ordering it, but it cooked the lobster thoroughly and added a fun crunch! The waitress was very nice. I recommend eating in the back room - it was wooden and very clean. read more

See all

Would like to say 3.5 stars, but can't, so giving the restaurant the benefit of doubt. Lenny and joes is a hometown favorite, but it disappointed in a couple ways. Our drinks, Long Island ice teas, we very tasty. We got a bowl of lobster bisque that was fabulous, good flavor with chunks of lobster meat. The bread which accompanied it was excellent too. My husband got the baked stfluffed shrimp and I got the baked stuffed sole. The stuffing supposedly contained crab but it was not noticeable, rather the stuffing was all cracker crumb and butter. The "stuffed" shrimp was a bowled of the "stuffing" with the shrimp stuffed into it. We will consider going here again, possibly, but would definitely choose something different to eat. read more

Nice enough people but the service was slow and the food quality is overrated. I was expecting more from the food and the ambiance was very underwhelming for the prices. read more

I was shocked to find out my family of 8 was denied seating at the restaurant on Friday night. the place was empty. we tried to reserve a table and was told no reservations. very disappointed. We were looking forward to eating there. Shame on you. read more