This review praises a local sports bar for its consistently good food like the Reuben, pizza, and…read moresandwiches, a lively game-day atmosphere, and a fun pool table where friendly locals play. .

ants crawling all over the wall and few on our table. service wasn't good…read more will never be back!

Great friendly fast service! Decent prices. Plenty of parking. Currently undergoing renovations but…read morestill open. Good pizza. They also sell fresh local cheeses. We purchased a tomato and basil pie. Toped it with fresh grated parm. Yum. We will be back! Try it you'll like it!

Yummy, real pizza. So nice, they thanked us multiple times…read morefor ordering. Take out only.

The best pizza ever...and I've eaten a lot of pizza in a lot of places. The pizza itself would be a…read more5. By-the-slice can be limited at the street level window due to its popularity, but I've never had a bad slice even when I ordered something I wasn't sure I'd like. When dining upstairs the service is just okay at best. The servers can be pleasantish enough, but not super-efficient in how they manage serving customers. I say that as a former wait person of 10+ years. I've been there when it's been packed and when it's pretty mellow. In the summer, upstairs can be as hot as what you think the front porch into Hell might feel like. In winter, don't sit by the windows even though they're closed. One dude making pizza and serving downstairs at the slice/pick-up window can get kind of grumpy. He reminds me of Seinfeld's "Soup Nazi." Kill him with kindness, and it'll work out in the end. In spite of that, I can't think of anywhere else I'd rather get pizza. There IS a place off a highway near Nyack, New York, but it's a MUCH longer trip. Pizza here is a solid 5, service upstairs is a 3, service downstairs is a 1-5 depending on the direction of the wind, ambience is a 3+ because even though it's really probably a 2 in most people's eyes, the building is old, funky, has history, and I like that.

Ready for a delicious pie to take and enjoy outside in this beautiful downtown? Look no further!…read more Our pizza was filled with toppings for a Hawaiian, and the sourdough crust proofs overnight.

Lovely addition to Coupeville. We've been here for cocktails a few times and they make excellent…read moreversions of classic cocktails (I had a margarita this most recent time) and also have a great curated list of cocktails. The service is friendly, knowledgeable and excellent and the food is creative and interesting. Whidbey tends to do classic dishes well but is a bit light on the innovative creative dishes - this place makes up for that gap. We had the asparagus special on a potato puree which we loved as well as the "Curd" pizza which was super interesting. Bonus is the Roost has a water view!

We're volunteering in the area for two months. When we heard about Goldies, we thought it would…read morebecome our "go to" spot. I mean, wood-fired oven, eclectic ingredients, and local sourcing. What's not to like, right? Well... We ordered the sausage and added their garlic mushroom special topping. While the crust had just the right amount of char, it was really chewy. It may be grown and milled locally, but it lacked the crispness and airiness of a good Napolitano pizza crust. Also, we paid an additional $8 for the mushrooms. There were minuscule amounts on our pizza. There wasn't that much of sausage, either. We ordered a glass of Sangiovese and another of Tempranillo. They were imported and fairly acidic. Why not take advantage of the great WA wines? The guy handling the orders (dark hair and a good amount of ink) was great. He apologized that they had just run out of the Walla Walla onions we wanted to add to our pizza. He gave us a reasonably good estimate of the wait time. When we finished our wines and decided to change our dine-in to to-go, he made it happen with no issues, despite dealing with a long line of people placing orders.

We stumbled upon The Wayfinder Cafe and had a wonderful visit. It was near the tail end of the…read morelunch window and places were getting ready to close up for the day, lucky for us the service at The Wayfinder is so pleasant, we felt like locals. They have menus by the window, and you order at the counter, we found ample seating near the windows to look upon the passerbyers. We ordered cold items so they wouldn't take too long up prep; a side of macaroni salad, a Keegan-the-Vegan sandwich and a Honey Lavender Latte to share. Everything was lovely and a perfect portion for us, splitting the sandwich and the creamy mac salad. The sandwich had curried chickpea salad and it was delicious! The Lavender Latte was perfection, not to sweet but a yes in the lavender world. We overheard others come in specifically for their cookies, so we grabbed a coco loco to go. It was filled with coconut and macadamia nuts, was so perfectly moist in the center. Thank you Krista for looking after us!

We were on vacation, and because my husband's name is Connor, we had to come explore La Conner! We…read morewere hungry for lunch after the tulip festival, so we drove up here. There is some street parking, but we ended up parking in a public parking lot north of the cafe. The place is cute and charming, and it's decorated with art that is for sale. The menu on the wall was just for drinks, and their food menu was laminated nearby for us to peruse. We had a nice chat with JJ (who I think is the co-owner), and he was very bubbly and nice. It was fun to witness his kindness to other customers and neighbors as they came in. This place seems very involved with the community. There are a few tables both outside and inside. The TV behind us was playing Pandora for radio music. Nearby, they had some free chocolate-covered coffee beans and your own water and silverware station. I got an Arnold Palmer, and boy, was it tart! I got my own sugar to try to sweeten it up. I also ate the Ricky Ricardo panini, and it wasn't my favorite. The aioli wasn't flavorful enough for me to notice, or maybe it was missing, and the pickles were too thick. I didn't love the flavor profile on this sandwich, and it was pretty hot (in temperature) to eat, so I had to let it cool down a bit. Connor loved his smoked salmon toast! There were a ton of capers, so lots of salt there. The herbed cream cheese was the star of the show, with the flavorful toast being a close second. He really appreciated it. I think I'd be happy to come back and try a different sandwich.

Pizza was amazing tonight, and so were the bread bites, but this dessert was definitely overcooked…read moreand a disappointment. If there's a recommended temp I would definitely lower it or take it out about 5mins sooner!

This review is for the service…read more The team tonight was very attentive and everyone addressed me, especially since I came to pick up the order earlier than I should've. They welcomed everyone right when they walked through the door and looked happy to be here.

I like stopping in here when I'm in Coupeville. Food is good. Gabe does an awesome job! His…read morecustomer service skills are top-notch. I hadn't been in for a while and he still remembered my name. That says a lot about him. Recommend stopping in if you're in the area.

I ordered a pizza for pickup, I was disappointed that delivery didn't start until 4:20 pm. However,…read morepizza was very good service was fast and friendly.

The pizza was very good. The owner and cook was in the kitchen yelling and cussing at the employees…read moresaying if the customers didn't like the wait they should go somewhere else. the kitchen had an open window to the seating area. I felt this was very unprofessional.

Ordered two pizzas to go (Margherita and Spinach & Goat) a Caesar salad and grabbed a bottle of…read morewine when we picked it up. Pizza was great, staff was very friendly and they had a nice selection of wine. Highly recommend if you want a pizza fix while in Friday Harbor.

Burnt pizza, I rarely get anything good from this Pizza Hut. Order is usually wrong, burnt even…read moreraw or they forget items. Don't have these issues with Domino's.

In Sunday 12/5 around 5 pm we placed a pick up order: Lg…read moremeat lover pizza Family size pasta 6 garlic Parmesan wings 6 Buffalo wings We did not receive any wings Called back (Cheyenne) and we got the obligatory "sorry about that" and were told we could come back and get them or take a store credit. Husband went back and I had reminded Cheyenne we needed ranch dressing (we didn't have any at home and granddaughter wanted it). Got the wings but no ranch dressing. Time to look into different pizza restaurant.

What a lovely escape on Whidbey. The staff was lovely; attentive yet gave space to not feel rushed…read more The menu was fun and featured local oysters, a trio of ceviche's and a perfectly prepared halibut. I missed getting pictures because I was too busy feasting with my eyes to remember to pull out my phone! I did catch a single picture of the whites by the glass and can't recommend the "White crush" enough!

Oystercatcher is a South Whidbey standards bearer-consistently good in all ways…read more We recently had dinner for our anniversary and everything was excellent-carrot small plate, grilled oysters, pasta primavera and pork tenderloin. The pork tenderloin was a very well composed dish-put every component on your fork and it is great. I loved how the grilled oysters originally came out with 5 and before I could ask, they came out and said "the numbers weren't matching" and served us the additional oyster. It's a very nice setting-modest whidbey house made over to a restaurant. You can be casual and formal and feel at home. Service was exceptional tonight-personal and quick. Oystercatcher is a "must eat" for your Whidbey visit-local produce and excellent food.