Dug this stripped down local Milly joint; Not divey, certainly not touristy. Place totally cool and casual; Staff v kind, friendly and knowledgeable in traditional foods and vibes; English certainly 2nd lang; like me ;) Poblanos present throughout their menu items, V fresh and yum. Gets a chill bar-vibe when hanging out in this energetic space; Plenty of table seating for the adults. My waiter, Anna C. was too kind and helpful in guiding my dinner choices. Went w their chicken and vegetable stuffed poblanos; and house-made chicken tortilla soups; Make sure to ask for their V original house-made Hott sauce, and enjoy carefully. Dinner was v v tasty and super filling, as portions way generous; Left happy read more

Small, quaint establishment just over the 441 bridge into North Milledgeville. Very friendly staff. Quick to seat and fairly busy for dinner time. Excellent jalapeño queso and salsa. Chips on the thicker side but hot and crispy. I had the Burrito Locos and requested one chicken and one steak and it comes with rice and beans. The chicken was ok to me. Cooked but not much flavor. However, the steak was perfectly done and seasoned. The rice and beans were also very good. Overall I'd give my dish a 4. Next time I'll get two steak burritos. My wife had the Two Chili Rellenos. She said it was very well done. Beefy, cheesy and tasty is how she actually put it. She gives her dish a 5. Overall a very good and satisfying experience. We will return and recommend you try it as well. read more

Los Magueyes - Burrito Locos with rice and beans - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

Great food!!! Everything we have had is good! We highly recommend this place! We love this Mexican restaurant.

We love everything about this restaurant; it's definitely one of our favorites. The staff, and especially "Mama" are the best in town. Without a doubt, the very best Mexican food that we've ever had. I especially have my favorite dish which is the Texas House Special, but I'm sure that everything on the menu is Delicious... The ambience is amazing too. read more

Best food, margaritas, and service in town! Highly recommend checking this Mexican restaurant out and ask for Salena! She was an amazing bartender and server! She went above and beyond with her service! Great portions, prices, and taste! The restaurant played great music and the ambiance was fun! read more

Los Magueyes - Skinny Margarita - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

Sat at the bar but it took a while for anyone to acknowledge us. Wasn't aware there was no "fixed" bartender. Should've sat at a table instead. Chips and salsa were as expected. Got the cheese dip on the side. Decent. Ordered the burritos locos (steak). The steak was really good, but the burritos were overall lacking. The red sauce was way too runny and barely any on it. And the menu says it comes topped with shredded cheese. I saw maybe 4 shreds of cheese total on top of my 2 burritos. Besides the slow start, service was good. Really liked the frozen margarita. Decent prices. Altogether, very average overall. read more

Great service and great food. Lucy is an amazing waitress! She makes the best margaritas! We love to get an order of the carne asada fries, Texas house special, or the Fiesta taco salad! The owner is extremely nice. If you haven't been, stop by for a drink and some great food! read more

See all

My first new review for the New Year! Almost anything has to be better than 2020. One thing I miss about not being in Arizona anymore, it's difficult to find good Mexican. So, when I got the urge for it, I decided to try a place that I hadn't been to yet. So, using KNG Delivery, I ordered a side of Chips and Salsa. And, a Fajitas Mexicanas for 1. Chips and Salsa: The chips were fresh, and had a prefect thickness. The Salsa was thinner than one would expect for Restaurant style. And, it had quite a bite to it. While very good, and will give me another appetizer, as well as a lunch, for the price, the quantity was much smaller than other places. Fajitas Mexicanas: Whoa! If this was for 1, imagine what for 2 would be like? The rice and beans were excellent! And the filling (steak, chicken and shrimp) was seasoned nicely, and tasted very good. I did find the chicken to be a bit overcooked. But, nothing serious. However, I'm glad I have some flower tortillas on hand. As the 3 small tortillas are long gone. For sure, I'll get at least another dinner, and a lunch out of it. I just wish I had more rice and beans to go with the leftovers. So, over all, a very good meal, at a very good price. For sure, I'll try them again. read more

Los Magueyes - Fajitas Mexicanas for 1 (yes, 1 person) - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

We have stopped going to Los Magueyes. Food quality has gone down hill. Greasy, tasteless. Often cold. You can always tell when the Owner isn't there. Bright side... service is always friendly and responsive. Just wish the food was consistent read more

We ate here for lunch while visiting Milledgeville. The place was extraordinarily clean! We opted to eat outside and keep social distancing. Staff was attentive. I just wish the food had more flavor and flair. Very basic my husband got the steak and it was very tough almost impossible to chew and lacked flavor. Same for my tamale covered in cheese and taco. It's fine if you want a quick bite but definitely not a favorite read more

Los Magueyes - Steak platter - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

We are at Los Magueyes tonight. It was fantastic. We had flautos, chili relleno and tamales. They were all delicious and we enjoyed the refried beans. The service was excellent. Highly recommend! read more

This is our go-to for Mexican. Definitely the best around. Not at all bland and their cheese dip is so good! The food is delicious every time we go and the grilled chicken is always yummy. We've only had slow service a couple of times when it wasn't busy but they're usually on top of things. Great sweet tea here too! read more

Los Magueyes - Combination plate E. - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

The only good thing I have to say about this restaurant is their salsa was outstanding. They had two kinds and the second one was like none I've ever had and had a wonderful taste. That's where the positive experience ends. Our waitress was very sweet, however she did not Come back with the salsa and chips we asked our food server to send us more of. She never refilled our water glasses and we sat there thirsty for the entire meal. When I complained to her about my meal , she simply made excuses for it rather than offer something else or offer to adjust it in someway. I ordered the chili releno and it was absolutely nasty. It was some kind of flour tortilla she told me that they made there in the restaurant. It looked like a corn tortilla that had never been cooked and was raw. That's what it tasted like too, was raw cornmeal mush with a I piece of bell pepper inside of it and a huge amount of queso cheese, so much cheese it made me nauseous. Cheese was primarily what the dish consisted of. it must be cheap because I could barely find a piece of pepper and that was the worst tortilla I've ever eaten. I had the same type of tortilla on my chicken enchiladas. One of my chicken enchiladas had no chicken. Both of them were covered in a plain tomato sauce that tasted like it came straight out of the can. It was not enchilada sauce ! it had no flavor and no seasoning that resembled an enchilada. When I questioned the fact that it wasn't a corn tortilla and tasted nothing like the ones I made at home, She said : "oh we make our own in the kitchen out of flour. " I have never had a flour tortilla that looks like cornmeal and tasted like RAW cornmeal mush. I am gluten sensitive , but I didn't think I had to explain that since I was ordering what I thought were corn tortillas in a traditional corn tortilla dish. I Won't be back to this restaurant either! Madison has quite a few restaurants that are lacking in service and food! I think people go to this restaurant to drink alcohol , since the table next to us had a man fall out in the middle of the floor Apparently intoxicated to the point he couldn't sit in his chair. The restaurant was very loud and noisy also. We had a booth, so we were blocked off from a lot of it, but because of the alcohol people tend to be talking very loudly. Don't go there if you want to have an intimate conversation. read more

Our go to Mexican restaurant in the area. Been going for years. Food is always good and service is usually quick read more

Los Magueyes - Menu - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

I wish I could give this place a bad review!! My girlfriend and I placed and ordered to go. When we proceeded into the place, it wasn't as packed or full. As we were placing an order SILVIA looked unfriendly, agitated, and unapproachable. She greeted us with an "ok que quieren" as in What do you want? She had a rude and condescending look with an agitated tone in her voice as if placing an order was only keeping her from being there any longer. When my girlfriend finished ordering she kindly asked SILVIA if she was able to get the order. SILVIA seemed like her ego was hurt. She was condescending with the way she replied with an annoyed voice "Yeah I heard you I already got that". We were made to wait for the to go order. While we waited other people came in and ate. We had sat in a booth and were made to get up to give the booth to a dinning in couple. Who were able to get their food before us. These people don't care about you. They only care about money and will treat you accordingly. They were obviously cooking for other people before our food was made. When we told them we were waiting for our food, after 45 minutes she came out to tell us the food was "almost" ready. About an hour later we had our food. When we asked and were told it would be 15-20 minutes wait on our order. SILVIA was infuriated when we asked them how is it possible for 4 different people can come in and get drinks chips and finish their food before our order. read more

Los Magueyes - Mexican Restaurant - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

There was a hair COOKED into an onion. You could pick the hair up and the hair picked up the onion. I brought it to the owner's attention and she said well it's not mine. Lady it's not mine either. I didn't go into the kitchen and cook it in there myself. No apology or anything but tried to say it wasn't their fault the hair was cooked into the food. Disgusting. Absolutely terrible customer service with our waitress before that as well where she disappeared and I asked if she actually went home because she was nowhere to be found for a good 20 minutes. There's plenty of good Mexican restaurants to choose besides this one and I recommend finding a different one to go to. read more

We come here almost every time we come visit my in-laws in milledgeville. I have never had a bad meal Here-just super solid Mexican food. I have had everything from their fajitas to their Chile poblano and nothing has disappointed me. Service is good here as well and your drinks and food come out super fast. read more

We were looking for good Mexican in Milly and we found it! We enjoyed the service and decor as well. Our son has already taken friends back and I'm sure we will go again when visiting him. read more

The first time I ever ate at the restaurant I had beef and bean burrito and I loved it their cheese dip is to die for and it's well staffed

It is a Sunday,6/30/24, and No One is answering the phone. Their website says "Open @ 11:00 am". No answer so I can't order for my family that was expecting their Delicious Mexican food. The website says that they update it every 2 wks, but evidently they haven't updated their summer hours. Poor business acumen. read more

Had a good expereince at Los Magueyes while visiting some family for Thanksgiving. The atmosphere was very inviting with football on all of the TV's. The staff were very nice and the menu had a great selection of dishes, all with very reasonable prices. I opted for the Texas Fajitas, which were a little too well done for my taste (had to scrape some of the chicken off of the fajita pan). All-in-all, a great little Tex-Mex joint in Milly that's nice to enjoy after a day on the lake. read more

Los Magueyes - Texas Fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

Went here for over 5 years,bought my guys lunch there regularly for my business. Always tip 20% or more,one night family was eating there found Band Aid in food,owner acted like it was my fault,asked me if I wanted to be compensated for the one meal,told him no wasn't about the money. Asked nephew to have him call me never did,months later saw him at store asked why he never called me,told me with my attitude didn't need patron like me. Never posted anything on social medial until now. You can see you on the first picture before even started eating it! Posting this for Lance Hopkins I wish I can put negative star on here!!!! read more

Los Magueyes - Just realized the bandaid after eating half of it! I thought I'll die when I saw it. So disgusting! - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

See all

An excellent Mexican restaurant with a traditional menu and some delicious specials. Good service and good food! Ample parking, convenient location and pleasant atmosphere. read more

We were looking for a good local Mexican place and we found it! We had a party of 8. The food here was great! And the service was very fast and friendly. read more

Have ordered take out from here and dined in and each time their food has been hot, fresh and tasted delicious!

Very busy and lively place on a Friday night. Both times I've been here was on a Friday. First time had a chicken taco salad. Waitress brought out beef then argued with me when I told her to send it back that I ordered chicken. We shared a pitcher of margaritas and they were so-so. Watered down in my opinion. Chips and salsa is good. Second time no margaritas for me and I had a combo player which was good and came out as ordered. I think it was an enchilada dish with rice and beans. read more

Came in for lunch. They have an inexpensive lunch menu with good variety and lots of specials. Food was great and the service was fast. The non lunch part of the menu seemed to have LOTS to offer. I will be back for sure! read more

My manager and I stopped in after a days worth of work for lunch. We were almost immediately seated, and our drink orders were taken right away. There was indeed a sense of eagerness in getting our orders put in, but unfortunately not only did they get the drink orders wrong, but my food came out well before my managers food, so I was sitting awkwardly while we waited for his to be served to him. They ended up getting the protein in his order wrong (he ordered beef and they gave him chicken). The food however was PHENOMENAL. the salsa tasted extremely fresh, and you could taste the cilantro quite easily. read more

Food was amazing and the service was great. Our server was very knowledgeable, efficient and just a pleasure to talk to. Will definitely return. read more

Totally thought that this was going to be just another mediocre Mexican restaurant. But this place was great! Amazing margarita, great salsa (with a subtle spice that really made it tasty), and a great entree (my friend and I got a chimichanga and a quesadilla and both were very well seasoned and delicious. Overall this was worth the stop in! read more

Best mexican restaurant in milledgeville by far we eat here several times a month Food is great staff is friendly margaritas are top shelf you can't ask for better read more

It's just a little Mexican restaurant but they do it right!!!!the food is made fresh and ready to order my family eats there at least one day a week read more

Awesome food, fast service, little small dining room but they make the most of it. We'll be back

Best Mexican food in Milledgeville for sure. I left here so so full. I got the quesadilla grande as well as a chimichanga. The quesadilla was a bit tastier because it has more ingredients but both are fantastic. The Chori Queso also did not disappoint. I ate it all myself. The veggie flautas were surprisingly tasty. Most places half ass vegetarian food but they did a wonderful job accommodating. They have this famous drink there for $7.50. It's tequila and soda and grapefruit. Like a smoother bubbly margarita. I urge you to try it. Pleasent experience. Good food. Fast service. read more

See all

The food was slimy and greasy and of poor quality, and when we got the bill, we were unpleasantly surprised by the fact that it overpriced as well. The decorations were minimal but interesting, and the staff was welcoming. Overall based on the experience, tummy ache, and horrible parking, we'll stick with 3 amigo. read more

This used to be our favorite place. The last several times that we called I our order, it was wrong. The lady that took our order was not friendly & short with me on the phone. It's always a simple order, a salad or a couple of enchiladas. She took the order & acted like I ruined her day. read more

Awesome food and service! Best Mexican food in lake country! Highly recommend! Their Salsa is what sold me

The food is not good. Drinks are not good. Service is not good. My burrito supreme was literally shredded chicken inside of a flour tortilla. No beans. No rice. No nothing. read more

Los Magueyes is consistently great for families. The wait staff is very friendly and the food is fresh. The open floorplan is good for groups. Great having near the lake. read more

Los Magueyes - View of the bar area from main dining room. - Mexican Near Me - Milledgeville, Georgia

The food was amazing! The Chimichangas were super good, best i've ever had! Definitely going back soon!!!!