I stopped in around noon on Saturday and found no customers in sight! The case was full of beautiful cupcakes, macarons, cookies, and brownies. We were greeted right away and the girl was quite patient with me as I made my selections. I wanted a box full of various treats to bring a group of friends. Cupcakes were BOGO when I went, so I got two each of red velvet, chocolate chip cookie dough, and carrot cake. We also went with a few sugar cookies and a cosmic brownie. The brownie was absolutely divine and also HUGE. The cookies and cupcakes were super soft and not too sweet. We will definitely need to come back for more. read more

Love Riley - cookies and cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

What a cute lil shop! Hats off to Riley & congratulations on this business venture! I decided to stop here in the middle of my road trip to Kentucky and I'm glad I did, I saw the S'mores Brownie on TikTok & had to try! The girl that waited on me was very polite & patient as I picked out my little treats. I got 4 Macarons; Cap'n Crunch, Funfetti, Fruity Pebbles, & Cosmic Brownie. The Cosmic Brownie Macaron stole my heart as I'm a sucker for any brownie & rich chocolate-based treats, they were all fantastic though! Perfectly executed. I got 2 Truffles; Mocha Cookie & Chocolate Oreo, also both fantastically delicious, & gluten free! Wish I had bought more! The S'mores Brownie was insane & super yummy. Honestly 0 complaints all around AND it had glitter on top! I wish it was visible in my picture :( There were also cupcakes & cookies, but I didn't bite on getting those this time. I shall return in the future for my 2nd trip! HIGHLY RECOMMEND! Riley also makes cakes! read more

See all

How great! I read about Love Riley in the 614 Magazine and was inspired by her story. I finally was in the area to try it out and I was not disappointed! The cookies were beautiful and moist, the buttercream frosting just melts in your mouth. The cupcakes just as much, they are the most flavorful and sweet. Some of the best sweet treats I've had! We got 5 cookies, and 3 cupcakes. I think it came to around $30. Our mom's and grandmas loved these for Mother's Day. Service was quick. The girl behind the counter was super sweet and able to answer all my questions. read more

See all

This little bakery is adorable and has a lovely selection of beautifully decorated sweet treats! We ordered a custom shark cake for my daughter's 15th birthday and it came with the usual cute/chic Riley style. When I saw some of the other brightly colored cakes being picked up, it made me wish I had gone that route! But ours was great and matched kiddo's theme. We'll be back! read more

See all

Picked up 4 cupcakes today and 1 cake pop. I can't wait to eat them!! Everything looks so good!! Everything is hand made and made so well and pretty. Cute store!! read more

When I found out there was a new bakery in the area, of course I had to give it a try! I went there on a Saturday, an hour before closing and there was still a decent selection left. We got a peanut butter chocolate cupcake, junior mint cupcake, banana bread cupcake, and a cinnamon vanilla donut. The woman helping us recommended we let them sit out for 30 minutes before eating, because they were refrigerated. We made sure to do that, but it made the cupcakes a bit wet. Like the butterfinger on top of the peanut butter and chocolate cupcake was soft and mushy. I think they might have been better straight from the fridge. Overall I found the cupcakes to be a little too sweet for my taste, so next time I go there I'm going to try the macarons and truffles. And maybe a brownie, if they're available! LOL read more

Love Riley - Cupcakes and a donut - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've stopped by a couple of times and have been very impressed both times! We got an assortment of St. Patrick's Day goodies the first time and a Tiramisu Brownie the second. Everything was delicious! The service is great- it wasn't busy both times I stopped by so I had lots of time to decide. The cases are so beautifully filled and the location is super cute! read more

Love Riley - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I got my birthday cake from Love Riley and was blown away. I got the chocolate chip cookie cake which was so good and a total crowd pleaser. Their team is so sweet and easy to work with. I ended up changing my design and they were totally open to the change and were kind about doing so. The payment process is super easy. You pay ahead of time online and then you pickup your cake. The shop itself is really cute and I will definitely be going back to try other treats. The total cost of my cake was $170 and it was an 8 inch round. read more

See all

Love stopping by @loverileycakes when I'm in the area! The most beautiful desserts I've ever seen at a bakery! Her cakes are absolutely gorgeous, and so is everything she makes to be honest! The flavors are so good! You can tell she puts SO much thought into her work! When @loverileycakes says to try the PB&J because it's her favorite, you give it a try, and YUM! Also, there is edible glitter on most items which makes it 100x better IMO. Go check out Columbus's newest bakery! read more

Love Riley - Cookie butter, Oreo, pb & j, peanut butter choc - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

After seeing Riley's beautiful creations on Instagram, I was so excited to finally get to visit the bakery this weekend! I went in on Saturday morning and was greeted by two super friendly employees behind the counter. They were nice and knowledgeable and gave me some time to peruse before making my decisions. I finally decided on a vanilla macaron and frosted sugar cookie (Star Wars themed for May the Fourth) and a carrot cake cupcake. The macaron was so perfect with the screen printed photo of Yoda...such a unique creation! It was delicious too - I definitely wished I had gotten more than one. The cookie was fun and the carrot cake cupcake was lovely and tasty. Moist and not too dense. Everything I ordered was very reasonably priced as well. I will for sure be back. Thank you, Love Riley! read more

See all

Unbelievably beautiful and delicious! I ordered via email, which was a bit nerve wracking, and I'd much rather order via phone. That said, the cake and cupcakes I ordered for my daughter's baby showered were nothing short of perfection. The cake was literally a piece of art, with an incredible level of detail. Even better - the chocolate cake was both dense enough and moist enough to make me want two pieces. The salted caramel cupcakes are literally divine - there is a little pocket of salted caramel in the middle and the buttercream is fluffy and not too sweet. I will be a repeat customer. read more

Love Riley - Chocolate cake with raspberry compote made to last ok like a tree stump for a woodland/forest themed shower. - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Cake great! Except I wasn't told the filling had peanut butter and we have peanut butter allergies in the house! Not sure if it's the flavoring with the allergens removed? read more

The cupcakes I ordered for a baby shower were gorgeous and delicious. The texture was wonderful. I got lemon, white, and chocolate cupcakes. Definitely would order again. A winner! read more

I've had the cupcakes in chocolate, pumpkin cheesecake, red velvet, funfetti, cookie dough, and sugar cookie. They were all soft and yummy and did not taste artificial. read more

I love Love Riley! The desserts are always good and service is always solid. My only constructive feedback is that while I love glitter, sometimes a girl doesn't want to wear evidence of having eaten a glitter-dusted cookie all day. read more

Absolutely amazing cake. I showed her a vision for the cake I wanted and she executed it perfectly. The vanilla cake with buttercream frosting was so good!!! The workers are so sweet and treated me great. The store itself is adorable. Everything you want to see when you walk into a bakery. Plus everything looks SO clean. Cutest bakery ever I'll be back !! Here's a pic of my cake. read more

Love Riley - I asked for a cake with flowers on it and the door on the side!! Super cute:)) - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I recently had the distinct pleasure of visiting Love Riley, a remarkable new bakery in Columbus, and I must say, the experience exceeded every expectation. This charming little establishment, founded and operated by the exceptionally talented Riley, has quickly earned its place as a standout in the local culinary scene. Riley, a young woman in her 20s, has created not just a bakery, but a sanctuary of sweet creations, all crafted with an evident passion and dedication that is rare in an entrepreneur of her age. The bakery itself is small but impeccably clean and inviting, offering a cozy and modern atmosphere. It is run by a young and enthusiastic staff, whose knowledge and energy add to the charm of the place. What truly sets Love Riley apart, however, is Riley's genuine ability to blend her talents as both a baker and a food critic. Her social media presence, particularly on TikTok and Instagram, showcases her incredible creations and provides insightful reviews of local eateries in Columbus--further solidifying her reputation as not only a skilled baker but also a trusted culinary guide in the city. The first thing that drew me to this bakery was the stunningly decorated cupcakes I had seen online. When I arrived, I was immediately greeted by a refrigerated display case full of these exquisite confections. The staff was knowledgeable and quick to offer the perfect advice: allow the cupcakes to sit at room temperature for 30 minutes to an hour to let their flavors truly come to life. I followed their recommendation, and it was absolutely the right decision. I began with the Carrot Cake cupcake, and it was nothing short of exceptional. The cake itself was perfectly moist, striking the ideal balance between light and dense. The sweetness was carefully calibrated--not overly sugary, but just enough to satisfy. The carrot flavor was unmistakably fresh and authentic, avoiding the artificial taste that so often plagues carrot cake. The cream cheese frosting, topped with delicate white sprinkles, was smooth and not cloying in the slightest. A small but appreciated touch was the judicious inclusion of raisins--enough to enhance the flavor without overwhelming the palate. I would rate this cupcake a solid 9 out of 10. My only suggestion would be to consider incorporating crushed pecans or walnuts to introduce a slightly more varied texture and deepen the overall flavor. Next, I indulged in the Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcake, and once again, I was thoroughly impressed. The cake itself had a rich, decadent chocolate flavor that paired seamlessly with the creamy peanut butter frosting. The frosting, while indulgent, was wonderfully balanced--not too rich, yet fully satisfying. The small chocolate chunks scattered on top lent a delightful crunch, reminiscent of the classic Reese's combination, but in a more refined form. This cupcake, too, earns a 9 out of 10 from me. The harmony of the chocolate and peanut butter was flawless--each bite felt like a perfect marriage of two beloved flavors. After these two decadent treats, I decided that I'd had my fill of calories for the day and would return tomorrow to sample the Oreo Cookies & Cream cupcake and Red Velvet cupcake. In conclusion, Riley has done something truly remarkable with Love Riley. She has not only created an exceptional bakery that serves some of the finest cupcakes in Columbus, but she has also built a business that reflects her commitment to quality, creativity, and community. It's clear that her talent extends beyond baking--she is an astute and thoughtful reviewer of local restaurants, which speaks volumes about her dedication to the craft of culinary excellence. I'm eager to see where her journey takes her, and I wholeheartedly recommend Love Riley to anyone who appreciates fine baked goods and a true passion for flavor. read more

Love Riley - Box of 6 Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I recently came in last minute for a birthday cake, and I want to say the cakes were beautifully made. That said, I did find the flavor to be a bit overwhelmingly sweet. I also reached out to Riley and learned that canola oil is used in the cakes. Considering the price, I had hoped that a cleaner oil might have been used. read more

The tiramisu brownie is maybe the best thing I've ever eaten. It's like a flourless chocolate cake base with an amazing tiramisu on top. And the frosted sugar cookie is the best one I've had. Highly recommend, everything is delicious read more

i have been here multiple times and have nothing but great things to say about love riley! this is my favorite bakery in columbus ohio and i always come here to grab cakes or cupcakes for birthdays or special treats for myself or friends. the bakery is so cute and clean and the staff is so kind and knowledgeable. i tell all my friends and family to go here and now im telling all of you!!! read more

See all