I like supporting family businesses. This place has great wings. The pizza is good but not a fan of the cheese. The crust can improve too. Overall it's good enough to continue to go back for more. The prices are ok. They have good ongoing specials, but I'd like to see different specials or deals. They don't have as many deals as their competitors. Definitely worth a try if you are looking to get pizza from a new place. read more

Lucky's is great if you're looking for this style of pizza. Authentic, great toppings (broccoli my favorite!) and the atmosphere is awesome. The family here is so warm, all of them really funny, always making me laugh when I go in there! Thank you for being the first great food experience I had upon moving to Surprise! read more

As a native New Yorker, I can appreciate decent NY style pizza. This is close enough though I think the cheese is a little skimpy and the pepperoni is sliced razor thin. The hot dishes are also very good. The meatball parm is my favorite. The folks who own, run, work here are very nice too. A reviewer below this prefers Tailgators pizza. I always enjoy a good laugh. I play trivia there on Tuesdays and have had the pizza special. No comparison. Lucky's is light years better. With the impending opening of the awful Oreganos, I hope people remember to keep patronizing this place. I'd hate to lose it. read more

Love this pizza! It's greasy and floppy, the best with only a few toppings or even just cheese.

Fantastic food and service! I brought my family in there last week and there food is phenomenal. True New York style food pizza, wings, pastas everything luckys has to offer is amazing. Family owned and great service and hospitality. I will be back!! read more

We've had pizza and wings several times. Always fantastic! A few months ago, we ordered pizza, and were given a free calzone because someone had canceled their order last minute. It was good too. read more

Very clean and friendly atmosphere. Pizza is awesome! Grabbed slices for myself and my girls. Just the right amount of sauce, lots of flavor, not greasy, cooked just right. Will be going back with the entire family! read more

Been my favorite pizza place since I was a kid! Would go there everyday after school!

Lucky's is great. The ingredients are fresh and it's always a good pie. You can't beat their lunch special. It's a nice alternative to the big chain pizza places. Try their lasagna too, it's really good. read more

I may have to try this again - haven't tried them since we moved here about 4 years ago. HATED it. Bread was chewey and the cheese tasted like rubber. Just not good for me. But then we are both pizza snobs. My husband thinks it's passable - but if I'm going to eat the calories I want awesome pie. Since so many seem to love it I may give another chance, but based on several inital tries they are "Lucky" to even get 2 stars from me unti proven otherwise...stay tuned. read more

This is by far the best pizza in Surprise. The wings are fried to perfection and their salads are delicious. I have not ordered pizza from anywhere else since I started eating here. I order twice a week. It is worth the short drive. read more

I've been coming here for 10 years, and have never been disappointed. The pizza and wings here are great, and the staff are very friendly.

This is my favorite pizzeria in the Valley! The customer service is great and it is a family owned and run business. The pizza is thin and full of cheese just how my family and I like it! It's true Italian pizza! If you're looking for thick, all-crust pizza then this is not the place for you! If you're looking for quality, flavorful, made-your-way pizza, this is the place! They have some pretty cool artwork on the wall at the Bell and Reems location as well. Also, their ranch dressing is to die for! read more

The best pizza you will ever have. I love the people who work there they are so kind and provide the best customer service. Literally everything on their menu tastes like it was hand crafted from Jesus. read more

Lucky's is the real deal for NY style pizza. If you don't like that style, don't eat it and then trash it in a review. They are friendly and quick. The wings are great because they deep fry them instead of baking them. Makes a huge difference. Awesome place. read more

Friendly service and nice environment. Pizza is tasty and not too expensive! You cant purchase by the slice which is convenient.

We ordered over the phone at nine, the guy said the food would be here in 50 minutes. After an hour it still wasn't here so we called again and they said they were on their way. The food didn't come until 11 and when it did the pizza and the pasta was cold. The calamari was just plain bad and the "garlic bread" was three garlic knots as big as my thumb. When the delivery guy came his excuse was that they were busy. We definitely would not be ordering from here again. The ravioli was good. Part of it was our fault for ordering calamari from a pizzeria but the calamari was cold and not fresh at all. read more

if you want true New York Pizza this is the place to eat. There Pizza is thin like NY and really tastes great and the Gravy & Cheese is very tasty. The staff and owner are very friendly. I have been going there for 5 years and have not had a bad meal at all. If you are a New Yorker you really need to go to Lucky's Pizza read more

The food is amazing! The pizza crust is perfect and the wings are to die for. Oh, and they serve Coke! HaHa!

Not bad pizza just kinda regular. way Better than dominos or little ceasers. For the price though it gets 3 stars. The crust could have been a little softer, it was delivered quick and hot though. read more

When I used to live in Surprise this was my favorite pizza place. Not too greasy, always cooked perfectly (I like my pizza well done), yummy cheese, crispy crust, and tasty sauce. The guys who work there are always very friendly. They don't have wait service, you just order to go or sit in the booths, it's totally casual. A good family place. They also have cheap beer if I remember correctly. I've never tried anything besides the pizza because I enjoyed it so much! They don't deliver, I wish they did! read more

After reading all the reviews, we decided to give it a try for dinner. Pizza was very good. The staff was extremely friendly. Not a fancy place, just a great food and cold beer. read more

We're in town for our annual Spring Training trip & the kids wanted pizza. Reviews for Lucky's looked decent so we headed over. Honestly, we weren't expecting much but wow, were we wrong! Very good pizza & wings, excellent eggplant parm & homemade cannoli. Everything was fresh & delicious. The service was very friendly & the food arrived quickly. We're leaving stuffed & happy that we have a new favorite place to hit next time we're in town! read more

The pizza was really good! It was thin and the cheese along with the other ingredients were delicious. The slices are quite large and you will definitely have left overs. It was very satisfying read more

Solid pizza here. Being from back east I am very particular and pretty critical of the Pizza out here. The place has an old neighborhood feel, they serve on paper plates which is how its done, the pizza looks like NY pizza, it has a nice crisp crust and the cheese and sauce compliment it well. The only think I frown upon is the price, they charge pretty high but its the 2nd best pizza i have found out here. The best is Taste Of Italy in Goodyear. read more

Was recommended to Lucky's. We were anxious to find good pizza since we are from the Northeast. The pizza was a nice size and plenty of pepperoni but very soggy. I might try to order it again and ask them to cook it well-done. Maybe it won't be soggy. The staff were very nice too. read more

I've heard nothing but rave reviews about this place and this was the third time I've been here, third time the sauce tastes like it was scorched and bitter. Once is an accident, twice is a coincidence, but three times is a standard. There are much better NY/NJ style places in the WV. read more

Terrific Sicilian pie. Perfect, crispy crust. My wife said the regular pizza was excellent too. We're both from NYC. We'll return to try the rest of the menu. read more

The best! The best slice of peperoni pizza and 6 wing lunch you will be very have. When I want pizza.....this is where I get my fill!

Family owned very friendly service, love the fact that you can watch your pizza made right in front of you, ice cold beer with many choices on tap, the wings are awesome!!! I will definitely be back! read more

Oh my gosh! I was amazed! I could eat pizza seven days a week and this is definitely my new favorite place! We had an anti pasta salad which was good. I prefer spinach or spring mix but the toppings were great, a cheese pizza which was absolutely amazing and a philly cheese steak sandwich that was crazy good! Desert was a cannoli and I thought I was transported to the East Coast! read more

I have been in AZ since 1988 and to date only two pizza parlors stand out above the rest. Buono's Pizza in Mesa and Lucky's Pizza in Surprise. As an old Italian boy (la familia from Naples Italy) from New Jersey/New York these two have the taste and more importantly the proper crust for a Napolitano pizza. If you are from Chicago go to Rosie's in Sun City, it is fake pizza but you won't know the difference. For the real thing, try Lucky's. read more

Luckys pizza is amazing. They always make the pizza really good and the wing sauce is great. Also their customer service is awesome. they're all really nice and fun to talk to. I would definitely recommend going here! read more

I'm on a mission to try all of the pizza joints in Surprise, AZ. I have my two usual favorites that I won't mention in this post but because Lucky's is ranked #1 in Surprise, I thought I'd start with them. Plain and simple, this pizza wasn't that good. I'm always bummed when I have a bad pizza. I don't believe "it was a one time thing." They make pizza for a living and should be able to make the same pizza (pepperoni and cheese) over and over again without fail. My pizza was "meh" at best. Price was ok but I would like to see a little more cheese and pepperoni without having to ask for extra. The crust was good. The sauce was probably the worst part about the pizza. I can't describe the flavor but it wasn't appealing. I wouldn't even rank Lucky' in my Top 10 from anywhere in the US. Tried them once, won't be going back. read more

We have been eating at Luckys for years and I have to say they have the BEST pizza around!!!! Growing up we always are at Rays pizza and once I tried Luckys we immediately found our new favorite!!! read more

I just tried this place based on the reviews and rating. They were right, this place was delicious had pizza and wings. Highly recommend

Ordered the Pepperoni Pizza Roll and was 100% satisfied. I will crave it in the future! It is a cheese lovers delight. The salad was terrific with multiple cheeses, olives. The cheese sticks were run of the mill but good nonetheless. This is a restaurant I would frequent! read more

This is great pizza! I was from the east coast and this is how I remember pizza! The sub sandwiches are fantastic too! Haven't had a chance to try the lasagna yet, but I bet it's just as good as everything else we've had so far! Love this place when we visit for the month! read more

Alway friendly and the pizzas are pretty good. At least I didn't have to wait an he at barros

we have been going to lucky pizza for over ten years. best kept secret in surprise. meals are reasonable priced. check out the chicken parmesan excellent. read more