Went back to try again for crispy crust. Pizza was packed but crust was very soggy. Also had cheese sticks. The batter was good, but the cheese seemed unmelted. Very clumpy cheese not gooey. I give up I guess crispy crust is not possible here . read more

First time at easier was one year ago and I've ate here plenty of times since then their Pizza is fantastic their hot wings are delicious is great service if you want good food go here I highly recommended read more

Love it there - plus they are from the east coast (which really helps!) Their pizza is good, not real greasy and not the overstuffed, bready Chicago style pizza. Their wings are addictive. We get the special large pizza and 25 wings, and I end up eating the left over wings all week! Great family atmosphere - my kids and everyone elses are free to run around. Highly recommend stopping in! read more

Been eating here for 10 years. The best wings you're gonna find in the area. read more

The best Pizza in town! Great people! Family owned restaurant. I have come to this place for years and never had bad experience everrrr!!If you want to try the New York style pizza in AZ!, this is the place to test!! read more

Lucky's Pizza - Specialty pizza! Only @Lucky's Pizza in Surprise! - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Has great pizza and wings, and prefer it over big brand pizza franchises. It is a family-owned restaurant and they know how to cook a great pie! read more

Great pizza! Great service! We do pick up all the time (I don't think they deliver). It's so worth the few minute drive. They are super fast and fresh and have great daily specials. Lucky' s is our family's favorite go to. read more

The pizza is great! We were recommended by a neighbor - I was really leery, with a name like Lucky's - what could one expect?? Got two slices to go - wish I ordered the entire pizza. Born & breed in Brooklyn, NY read more

Moving to surprise and a bit of a pizza snob I found this delightful place. The food is excellent and offers a large selection of New York Italian dishes and great pizza. After coming here a few times they treat you like family and are great folks. Family run and everyone is friendly and eager to assist and chat with customers. Highly recommend the baked ziti and the calzones. read more

Pizza is good - meatball sub was great - steak sub very good - roast beef not so much - read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Like I said two years ago... yum! This is true NY pizza...whoever made the pie last night made the best I've had there! When I crave Pizza...Lucky's is where I go. Just a plain cheese pie so you get a true taste of it all! read more

Well again - I guess I was harsh but it is funny that my review gets "filtered"... OK, it is not the worst pizza in the world, but I guess I am just not a fan of their crust, tomatoe sauce, cheese, toppings, or service. Just to be fair, we will try them one more time and hope that maybe our first time was just a miss. read more

The first time we tried Lucky's was maybe six years ago. I didn't like it then. Hard to remember what we ordered, perhaps a Sicilian style, but either the crust or sauce or something else turned us off and we decided not to go back. Until a couple of weeks ago, when, having exhausted just about every other food place in Surprise two dozens times over, I came up with the jolly idea of getting us some Lucky's again based on all the good reviews. And I hated it just as much this time around as the first. UGH. The only positive thing I can say about this place is that they give you a ~monstrous~ amount of pizza. Imagine a large pizza box precisely filled with a giant square BRICK of a pizza, easily an inch and a half tall and cut into square slices. That's what we got. I'd say it was over 3 pounds of pizza; flavorless and gross. I found it breathtaking that it had that little taste. This was a supreme pizza that tasted through and through like I was eating play-doh. Olives, sauce, cheese, crust, the works. To top it off, the mushrooms were slimy, canned champignons and not fresh at all, and tasted as though they'd just been pulled out of someone's nose. I've had some pretty bad pizza in my time, most of them I'd liken to eating chewy, dry cardboard. This was the first one that was this big and relatively succulent and STILL tasted gross. I stomached maybe six slices over two sorry-ass sittings before throwing about 2/3 of the pizza away. Two pounds' worth of "food", down the sh1tter. I don't know where the mass delusion about this place comes from, but I'll never return. If I want a gutbuster special, especially now that Bronco Billy's is gone, I'll head to Rays just down the road instead. Plus, Lucky's is overpriced. A large and a smaller pizza cost us $30. Most of the smaller pizza was thrown away too - I didn't try any of that one so I'm not reviewing it, but the wife said she was incredibly unimpressed with it, and it was just a plain cheese. If it all tasted good it would have been worth it - I'd have paid that and more for a Chuck Wagon Special from Billy's - but the lack of flavour and value drops my rating of this joint to a bottom-of-the-barrel single star. And just for proverbials and giggles: http://www.maricopa.gov/envsvc/envwebapp/tabs/results.aspx?navigatedFrom=inspectionResultsDrillDownAA&permit=FD-05766&business=Lucky's%20Pizza&address=15508%20W%20Bell%20Rd%20Suite%20207&insp_id=3182324 read more

I ordered two pepperoni pizzas, the crust taste like cardboard, the sauce is flavorless, it was very very greasy, and on top of all that it was over priced. I would not come back. read more

Blah, blah,blah pizza. Honestly what more can I say. Add some flavor to your sauce, maybe some seasoning. Even my kids didn't like it.

This is my go to pizza place. Love the friendly staff. The environment is nice. The food is flavorful. Highly suggest the spaghetti and meatballs. Love their hot wings and cheese pizza. If you live in surprise and haven't eaten here, you're missing out. If you just moved-highly recommend you come here. read more

I admit it. I'm a pizza snob. I grew up in New Jersey and know the difference between good pizza and bad pizza. Good pizza is "anything you could serve in Lodi, N.J. and not have your body found in the dumpster behind the store the next morning." Bad pizza constitutes about 99.999% of the rest of the pizza in the world. Having voluntarily moved out of N.J. at age 18 to attend college (I didn't feel the need to major in herpes, Camaro repair, or ab workouts, so my options were severely limited there), I was taken aback at the culinary wasteland that exists west of the Passaic river. I found this abomination called "frozen pizza" in grocery stores under names like Red Baron and the very appropriately named "Tombstone." I found racks of pizza-like-substances in truck stops, obviously part of a nefarious plan to punish the bathroom attendants working there. And worst of all, there were restaurants called "Pizza Hut," which emanated a neon red siren-call to me as I drove down the highway. In what I attribute mostly to road-hypnosis (staring at the white dotted line for hours at a time), the talking koala bear in my passenger seat finally convinced me to stop at one of these places. After being slapped back into reality by ingesting over a half-gallon of pure grease, and utterly disgusted with my furry friend's trickery, I snuck out when he went to the little-koala-bear's-room and peeled out of the parking lot, sticking him with the bill. I hope washing those dishes ruined his fur. From that point on, rather than return to New Jersey (as if that were a viable option), I decided to scour the vast majority of this great nation in search of edible pizza. I spent many of those years living with soul-crushing disappointment. Lucky for me, I finally found Lucky's. The owners have cleverly tucked this gem away in a strip mall 20+ miles out of the burgeoning metropolis that is Phoenix, Arizona, where damn near no one who lives in the entire valley will ever find it. Hell, most people who live in Phoenix couldn't find Surprise without a GPS, so the chances of someone from Mesa or Chandler wandering in are roughly the same as being given the winning Powerball ticket by a lonely koala covered in pizza grease and dishwashing detergent. After one taste, I was hooked. After living less than a mile away from the place for the past decade, I'm pretty sure I've financed at least one of the cars parked outside of it. Mercifully, they don't deliver, otherwise I'm not sure I could fit through my front door at this point. From reading other yelp reviews, it appears that Lucky's has other items on the menu. I never noticed. read more

Smelly Feet. After seeing multiple positive reviews we decided to try Lucky's. From our experience we will not be going back. We ordered two relatively easy pizzas to go: 1 large pepperoni & 1 large sausage/mushroom. Both had an extremely strange smell which we weren't sure if it was from a) the box b) the pizza oven or c) the pizza itself. The closest thing I can describe the smell to is smelly feet. Maybe Lucky's had an unlucky night but until I have a craving for stinky feet we'll stay away. read more

Great New York style pizza and great wings. Good deal and great people with a great sense of humor. You can tell they actually enjoy what they are doing. This has become a quick favoite of ours for takeout and even eat in. read more

They're not skimpy with the toppings. Ordered olives and mushrooms and got a sea of veggies. The cheese is good quality and the toppings taste fresh. About 16 bucks for a half and half large pizza (and I do mean large!) fed us all four with some left over. Will try the wings next time. read more

I've only been there for a lunch time slice. at some places the slices are better than the pies they sell. I don't know about this spot. great thin crust. very tasty with a bit of chew. fresh toppings. now I want a slice read more

Great lunch specials especially the sandwiches and subs. I especially love their chicken wings...they do them right every time. I'm not a big fan of thin pizza and the several times I have tired a variety of their pizzas I have been disappointed however one exception is their Lucky's Special Pizza.....this is so mouth watering even though its thin crusted I think I will stick to this from now on LOL. The staff is friendly they have TV's to view and the booths are comfortable. read more

Moving from New England to Surprise was a challenge when it came to pizza and we've tried many different places. Lucky's is the place. The pizza and wings are very good. We continue to try different places from time to time but Lucky's has won out. Looks like a family run business and they are friendly. The cheese pizza is delicious. read more

Came here for the first time and it was below average only because the pizza I ordered (by the slice) was definitely sitting for hours. I ordered the 2 slices of the their special edition which contains pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms. They added those toppings and fresh cheese to old slices. The pizza was exxxxtttrrraaa crispy when I got it because they reheated an old pizza. It tasted better than I thought so I'm going back and will order a whole pie just to taste a fresh pizza. Store is clean and staff is friendly. read more

See all

My sons favorite place. Family ran always friendly and great service. He like the hot wings and out garlic on them. Chicken Parm is outstanding. Hot subs are my daughters favorite. If they would change the channel of CNN! Lol! read more

Called in a large Lucky's Meat Lover's Pizza and 25 medium wings for pick-up on a Friday night at 6:30pm. Was ready in 20 minutes, hot and fresh. Generous amounts of toppings on the pizza as described on the menu and the wings were served with a twangy buffalo sauce and tasty ranch dressing. Everything was delicious at a very reasonable price. Lucky's is our new to-go pizza place from now on! read more

The real deal when it comes to NY style pizza.......I think the owner's are New Yorker's (maybe I'm wrong.....i just get that impression), so that makes it even better. We've been eating their pizza and wings for 4 years now. Something I like just as much as their pizza and wings is their consistency. It's always the exact same food, time after time. We never get any surprises. read more

I walked into lucky's tonight to find it busier than I've ever seen it. Despite that they were still making sure everyone got acknowledged and got the correct order. The food was awesome as usual, my sister-in-law seemed to especially enjoy the fried zuchinni being that there was none left. I'm glad to see a local business like this thriving despite an economy where so many family owned establishments are closing their doors. read more

Simply put this place is outstanding. Great food, great guys that run it, decent atmosphere if you eat in and always fast if you're getting take out. Love it. read more

The best pizza! I ordered 5 slices 2 different types and they made me a whole pizza half and half. This is a really nice place ran by great people. Highly recommended!! read more

Good pizza. Thin with plenty of cheese. We only got a cheese pizza, but it was good and we will be back. Service was great and all were friendly. read more

I was starving after a crazy drive to Arizona and waiting another two hours for my friend's aunt, but the pizza was fast, cheesy and delicious, but INCREDIBLE crispy texture, but the sauce was thumbs down not good but I was completely filled and happy. read more

We tried Lucky's last night and I am definitely a fan! Their prices are great and they have specials too. We ordered a large pepperoni and a large sausage and olive pizza. The ingredients are noticeably higher quality than that of the regular chain pizza restaurant. The sausage was what really made me love it though. Shaved pieces of Italian sausage blanketed the pizza. Seriously, you have to try it! My parents are now fans too. read more

For a east coast transplant. I really enjoyed Lucky's pizza. Finally a good place to go for real pizza that reminds me of my hometown. Loved it and so did the hubby, which is a bug compliment from a pizza buff. Great taste and price! Go here! read more

Lucky's Pizza - Yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Lucky's Pizza, Reems & Bell rd., Surprise AZ I've passed this restaurant many times and wanted to give it a try. I finally decided to try it since the reviews sounded good. I went in and placed a carry out order for a med pizza, large Italian salad, and an order of wings. The staff, two gentle men who were working there were kind and helpful in answering my questions and placing my order. I don't think I was there more than 20 mins for my order to be ready. Everything was nicely packaged and delicious. Being of Italian decent from Chicago, I was surprised to find the pizza crust to be thin typical of pizza in the Chicago land area. The sauce and topping was great as well as the crust. The salad was plenty and fed three adults. It was made with fresh crispy lettuce, olives, and plenty of fresh tomatoes and peppers. The wings were delicious and complimented the meal nicely. I have no complaints and list it as a good experience. I would easily recommend it to anyone and will be returning. read more

Great pizza and awesome wings! The staff is friendly and funny. The food is always good and very reasonable. Even during the busy days/nights, you never have to wait for very long. They also have good deals on pizza and wings. read more

Family owned, been going here for the last 10 plus years. Great staff and food! My wife hates onions so we don't get that! This is great pizza! I love to go up there because they have the coldest beer in Surprise. It turns into an ice beer slushy as you drink it! read more

Disclaimer: Having moved to Surprise from the NYC area only a year ago, I am a self-proclaimed pizza snob. Having said that, while I have yet to find pizza in the area that comes close to being "NY Style", (and we've tried lots of places), Lucky's is our favorite. We order it "light on the cheese" and it makes a world of a difference. Compared to Sicilian or Chicago style pizza, yes it's thin, but it's not NY thin. read more

It's been a long time since we have been here because we got one bad pizza, but I really liked the Lucky special, husband finally gave in and took me there! First off grumpy guy behind the counter was not friendly ! Bad sign! Then the pizza was not what I expected, meat toppings were so thin, you could barely taste them, with an over abundance of onions and green peppers ! Well needless to say we will never be back! So many BETTER places to get pizza!! I really was disappointed!!! read more

Lucky's Pizza is a really great Pizza and at a reasonable price. I also really like the fact that they deliver.