I would've likely given a five-star rating, but I have to be honest--the service experience left a bit to be desired. When my family and I visited, we were the only customers in the restaurant, and although there were about five employees present, none seemed particularly engaged. A couple were smoking by the back door, a few were leaning over the counter, and one was sitting idly in a private room. That said, I'm giving this place four stars solely because of the quality of the pizza--it was absolutely amazing. Fresh, crisp, and full of flavor. The only downside was the price--$20 for a small pizza felt a bit steep, but the taste definitely made up for it. read more

See all

The flavors of the pizza were good. The bbq at the ranch was nicely balanced. The honey garlic wings had great flavor but we had asked for them extra crispy and the skin was way too gooey. Pretty disappointed, mostly because what we got vs the what you paid for was so imbalanced. We got a large pepperoni, a large BBQ at the Ranch and 12 wings. $87!!!!! I don't know if I'll order for the family again, but I may try their lunch buffet. Friendly staff for sure. We ordered to go but the atmosphere seemed pretty relaxed as well. read more

See all

This place is great, but what really makes it stand out is a girl named Madison who seems to do everything. She served our table the first time I went there. She remembered me by name the next time and we always request her now. She always has such a great attitude and nonstop energy. The food is really good and I love all the TV's with sports on but it is really Madison's amazing service that makes this place 5 star. I'd recommend this restaurant to anyone but make sure you take care of Madison if you get the pleasure to meet her. read more

We stopped by and had a pie, salad and a few beverages. The pizza was great and the salad bar was also great. We spoke to the co owner who was very informative and proud of his business. Treat yourself and enjoy a pizza. read more

A bit disappointed in this visits pizza. 4 slices had no cheese on them! That's just sloppy! Not to mention stingy that all my slices can't have cheese on them. A sign that I need to stop and get my pizza elsewhere read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Small pepperoni with 4 slices missing cheese - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Open app Your location Mountain Mike's Pizza 13736 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ 85374 This was our First & Last time at this so called Pizza Place. The Price is High for a Pizza Buffet. The Pizza on the Buffet was Old had been sitting there for awhile. The pizza it tasted like frozen pizza it was not good. They never brought out any new flavors or asked if we wanted a particular flavor. The salad bar seems great Except the wilted brown lettuce not good. The manager sat in the corner of the restaurant got up a few times but never went to see if more pizzas being made or asked us how everything was. There were two other customers in there eating but one customer did ask as he left "why no new pizzas on the Buffet" This was at 11:20am & place was empty now we know why! Honestly it expensive for a Buffet & not Fresh or good. We contacted the main company as well oh we got a military discount maybe a plus not much read more

Thoughtful. Craveworthy. So craveworthy, my wife wanted it after she gave birth. And the staff gave her and my daughter a warm welcome with a sweet message and a free cookie pizza. Thanks Mountain Mike's read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

99th Ave, Avondale Mountain Mike's Pizza on 99th Ave, right across from the Costco tire center in Avondale, is hands down one of the best pizza spots around. From the moment you walk in, you can tell they take pride in their food--and it shows in every bite. Let's start with the chicken wings--they are absolutely amazing. Perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and some of the best wings I've had at a pizza place. A must-order every time. The pizzas are next level. The pepperoni pizza is incredibly delicious, loaded with generous portions of pepperoni and baked to perfection with just the right balance of sauce, cheese, and crust. If you really want to go big, the Mt. Everest pizza lives up to its name--stacked high with toppings and packed with bold, satisfying flavor in every slice. They also offer an amazing salad selection, which is fresh, crisp, and a great complement to the pizza. It's perfect whether you want something lighter or just want to balance out the feast. And don't skip dessert--the pizza cookie is the perfect way to end the meal. Warm, sweet, and absolutely delicious. If you're in Avondale and craving incredible pizza, wings, and great quality all around, Mountain Mike's Pizza on 99th Ave is the place to go. Highly recommend! read more

My complain is towards the man working with Buzzed red hair and glasses working on Sunday 8/3. My order was ready for twenty minutes and he ignored me and didn't say it was ready. A female employee came in and clocked in and handled it immediately upon arriving in. Ridiculous and horrible customer service! Will never return back! read more

From the food to the service was great. Pizza was very flavorful. The inside was very clean and staff was attentive. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

They have reasonable prices, big indoor space with huge TVs, beer on tap. And my first impression of this place is they are clean and friendly. Definitely going to bring the fam back to impress. Delivery and pick up available. read more

See all

The service was excellent so that played into the score. The pizza was ok. The wings were not so great. The salad was small. We spent over $100 on pizza and wings which is outrageous. We did get the largest size pizza, but as I stated it was just OK. The restaurant was very clean. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

When during your lunch buffet at 1 o'clock, they only had three pizzas out and they've been there for a while. They didn't have much salad left at salad. Bar restaurant is very clean. The owner sat there watches eating. I think that was part of the problem would like to see if they improved. I will be back to try. read more

Hallie was so nice and made the lunch special. She not only explained everything but she was super friendly and made it nice. Food was good Pizza and Salad. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - We got here as it opened and really enjoying it here! - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Horrible. We showed up at 6:45. To order pizza on news years night. You close at 7:00. 6:45 is not 7:00. Last I checked. This shit should never happen. Your hours are your hours. Figure it out. So what ever your employees tell you you go for. Missed out on a lot of money tonight. Happy New Year. List a customer! read more

We had the all meat pizza delivered, and we experienced fast, courteous delivery of delicious flavor! We'll be repeat customers.

my food was cold and unseasoned and I told the lady no green onions and that's all I could taste smh

The pizza here is always fresh tasting and delicious! I used to go to Mt Mikes in Oakley, Ca years ago (1990's) and loved it ! I'm glad they have a store near my home here. If you're looking for cheap pizza, this is not the place. But if you are looking for really awesome pizza, its right here at Mt. Mikes ! read more

Ordered at the restaurant and took in the atmosphere and ambience. The food is great and I will try other options read more

See all

My husband and I love pizza and we were pleasantly surprised with how delicious it was! We had a small pepperoni and a side of fries. The crust is super crispy and the cheese and pizza sauce are very high quality. The small pizza was like $17 which is crazy expensive but it was worth it since it was good. Staff was nice and there a bunch of TVs so it would be nice to go to watch a game! read more

See all

Best Pizza in Arizona by far! Their Everest pizza has everything on it! They have a great salad bar and wings too. The staff is friendly and the service is top notch. Very clean inside and out. This place even has an arcade with old school games. If you haven't tried this place you are missing out!!!! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

We were going to go to Lou Malnaties pizza but decided to go to mountain Mikes. So glad we did. We read reviews of Lou Malnatis and it was bad greasy dough and raw dough Mikes was so yummy read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

The pizza was delicious but the prices are outrageous. I really enjoyed the pizza it had good crust and plenty of toppings but 2 small pizzas and 2 sodas for $60 was ridiculous! Sorry but I won't go back. read more

Upon arriving to pickup our pizza, there were 5 uber eats drivers also waiting to pickup their orders (1 stating she had already been waiting almost 2hrs for the order). After standing in line for 20 minutes past when our pickup time was scheduled, our pizza still was not ready and the order hadn't even been started yet. Chose to cancel our order at that point. Not sure why they were still accepting online orders if they were that backed up. The restaurant was also completely empty. read more

We tried this again after being disappointed multiple times . I loved my mountain Mikes in California but this is nothing like it . This was another disappointing experience . The pizza sauce was thick and tasted like pure tomato paste . There were barely any pepperonis and it tasted just plain awful. The salad was soggy and the dressing tasted like cheap Italian . We threw 90% out . read more

The McKinley pizza is fantastic. Crispy crust, flavorful sauce and fresh veggie chunks. A little pricey, but what food place isn't these days. A medium pizza, 6 wings, (took them home because they were very slow to.come out and I hate too many slices) and two small drinks came to $47. read more

I have been wanting this pizza place since they opened. I was happy to see they offered a pizza and salad buffet. While the pizza was okay, you have to be a contortionist to get any kind of salad. Maybe if I had 4 foot long arms I could have reached the items in the back row, I wasn't the only one having an issue with the configuration of the salad bar. there was an older couple who expressed their displeasure about not being able to reach most of the items they wanted, too. When i said something to the employee, she just shrugged it off and said that was how it had to be, I told her I would not be back -- and I won't. read more

It's been awhile since since I've been down in Surprise. But today I caught a spring training game and decided to take a trip back to my favorite pizza restaurant. Today I decided to go with the pepperoni pizza and garlic sticks. The same girl from the last 2 visits was working the front and actually remembered me! So that was a pretty cool experience. Once again all the staff was very kind and patient even with a rush! My pizza and garlic sticks came out in just 10 minutes!! This was the fastest that it has ever come out, which I was amazed by because of how busy they were. It was hot fresh and steamy and very delectable. I even had time to play the claw machine. All the spring training games were on and made it a very lovely environment. If you have not made it to Mountain Mikes in Surprise I highly encourage it! read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Garlic Sticks with Cheese Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Mountain Mikes pizza was def tasty. Big wings. (amazing af) Super friendly staff and owner was amazing. Place was clean and fresh salad bar They have a party room with 24 chairs with 3 tvs free of charge and a game room with 6 arcade style games- and are now working with surprise libraries for their summer reading program. I'm pretty picky when it comes to wings and pizza and this was def right up there to being a fave Also an all you can eat pizza lunch with salad bar during the week! Plus their churros taste just Disneyland!! Same supplier. Omg. Heaven read more

See all

We had a soccer team fundraiser and watch party. Great environment with a lot of TV screens. Place was nice and clean. Pizza is amazing! Jeff was a great! We will definitely be back for more fundraising events. read more

Pizza was made right wings were good was hot when I got it home, plenty of sauce on the wings most places barley put any on them. 5 stars

Worst pizza I have ever had!!! It was just a pepperoni pizza. The pepperoni was so burnt we picked it off. Could not eat it. The rest of the pizza was not good either. read more

Clean location great service. Came in to see if they offered gluten-free pizza. They do! They cook it on a rack with parchment paper. They do not use a clean pizza cutter, so if you are celiac or have an allergy, just request them not to cut, and do it at home, or bring your own. =b Nice selection of adult beverages. They have a little corner with games. Large televisions with closed captioned for games. They also have free wifi. read more

See all

Best boneless wings I've ever had real chicken not that pressed something you get at Popeyes trust me they are very very good read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

The service was fast and it was a saturday afternoon the cowboy was very friendly The pizza and mozzarella sticks were delicious read more

First time going here. I was hoping it would be like the pizza we had in California years ago. Not sure if we will return. We had asked for extra red sauce, that did not happen. We have not found a decent pizza anywhere in AZ. The search continues. read more

Our first time here and we tried the Buffett. Had good choices to pick from and salad and soda bar. 14.99 was a pretty good deal. I loved to see the lady took out all the pizza after it sat for too long and made all new pizza. So you know you are getting fresh stuff. They have alcohol like beer and wine and I think margaritas. They also have a small gaming area and a private party section. read more

See all

So we spotted Mountain Mike's pizza leaving the shopping center a week ago. We thought it was just opening. To are surprise they have been here right under are noses. Well we went tonight and it didn't disappoint, the pizza was perfect. The salad bar was super clean and the staff super friendly and helpful. We are so happy and can't wait to go back. read more

The service was great . We were greeted as soon as we walked in and they explained the menu right away. The pizza was great, nice crisp crust with just enough toppings. The wings were very good, too. Would have been 5 stars if they brought the wings out first instead at the same time as the pizza. read more

Very disappointed. With the hype and price of this place, yet they fell flat! I had my in-laws in town and it was the 1st time my father in-law had had pizza in years, so we didn't mind splurging on what was supposed to be really good pizza. Only to have a huge under cooked pizza that no one wanted to eat raw dough. We got the biggest pizza they offer and it went in the trash. The bread sticks were the only good part. Tried them another time and it was over cooked burnt pizza and under cooked garlic knots and dry as heck over cooked boneless chicken wings. Which was very disappointing as at first the wings were my favorite even though they were overpriced. Tried the potato wedges and they tasted freezer burnt.The 1st few times I went it was good, but something must have changed as it been all down hill since like April, must be some changes in management and not for the better. Hard pass, can't recommend this location! If you do go, stick to the salad bar. No issues there. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona