Friends had been telling us about this place for ages so we finally stopped in on the way to see mates in Montauk and really glad we did. Service was friendly, lobster rolls were spot on, nothing fancy just properly done. Only knock is the wait time which on a busy day tested our patience a bit, but definitely worth it and we'll be back. read more

When in Rome, or Montauk, this is a must have! The Lobster is fresh, delicious and flavorful :) This place has a shack off the highway vibe with friendly and knowledgeable staff that are quick to serve! Fried food up the wazoo and plentiful alcohol beverage selections. See for yourself! read more

Lunch Lobster Roll was exactly what we needed for the perfect Mother's Day lunch! From the moment we walked in, the service was warm and attentive, the ambiance was charming, and the food absolutely delivered. We started with a few appetizers: * Crab Dip - not my personal favorite, as it tasted more like spinach dip and could have used more crab * New England Clam Chowder - delicious and packed with clams * Lobster Bisque - WOW. This is a must-order. Rich, flavorful, and loaded with lobster For our mains, we all ordered lobster rolls. I went with the warm lobster roll, and it did not disappoint. It was packed with tender knuckle meat and perfectly buttery. The rest of the table ordered the traditional lobster salad roll, which was equally fresh and delicious. If you're looking for a great seafood spot with fantastic service and amazing lobster rolls, Lunch Lobster Roll is absolutely worth the visit! read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Warm Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

**LUNCH Lobster Roll** is one of those iconic roadside seafood spots that feels like a true Long Island summer staple. The casual, beachy vibe pairs perfectly with their seafood-forward menu--and it turned out to be one of the highlights of our trip. We started with the raw oysters, which honestly we could've skipped--they arrived a bit late and were on the smaller side. But the crab dip totally redeemed the starters--creamy, flavorful, and a great appetizer to share. For our main meal, we went with the warm lobster rolls, and they were *incredible*. Perfectly buttery, generously filled, and hands-down the best bite of the day. Our waitress was fantastic--super friendly and attentive. My brother ordered a frozen banana drink that was so good, I instantly regretted not getting one for myself. Best of all? It's pet-friendly. We sat outside with our dog, Luna, and the staff couldn't have been more welcoming. They even brought her a bowl of water, which was such a nice touch. Overall, LUNCH delivered on great food, good vibes, and a relaxed, dog-friendly atmosphere--definitely worth a stop if you're in the area. read more

Lunch is exactly the kind of Hamptons spot you hope to find. The lobster roll is the star -- packed with fresh lobster, perfectly prepared, and served in that classic coastal way that makes a summer lunch feel complete. The setting adds to the experience, with beautiful water views and a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere. read more

Great Lobster roll. Wife had grilled cheese it was outstanding. Service was great The Margarita was really good read more

See all

There is a reason this place is iconic. Coming to the Lobster Roll in Montauk is always a high point of our summer vacation!! It is a place that takes you back to the best memories of summer. The food is always delicious. Service is always outstanding!! It's like a warm welcome home every time we go. Ate at the bar last weekend. Shout out to James our friendly bartender! Great drink specials during the week! We will be back! Highly recommend the lobster bisque and the margaritas. read more

Food portions were small but Wow Delicious! Service was ok. The drink and food quality was perfect. read more

See all

This place is iconic ... at one point, before the commercialization of the Montauk area, this was one of only two options for true roadside seafood stands in the area. Now, there are too many to count ... but this is the classic. I am not sure if it changed hands ... managers ... owners, etc. but the last few years made it not as good as it used to be. That's not to say it's bad. It's fucking great ... and probably always will be. But it just seemed like one of those spots where everything clicked and it was a true 5-star experience that was just on point. As in, perfect. Now, it's just great ... and I'll take that. Food: - I always get the cold lobster roll. Spoiler alert ... You are not going to get the same lobster roll you see on their Instagram and social. I was taught to always under promise and over deliver when it comes to marketing. The social media that shows giant, red chunks of lobster meat in a light dressing? Not really the case. You'll get mostly knuckle and shredded claw meat. A few chunks but their IG page is the equivalent of a McDonalds menu board showing crispy lettuce, fluffy buns and thick char-grilled burgers, when we all know what you actually unwrap. Having said that, this will rival anything you get in Maine ... or anywhere else. The meat is fresh and the dressing is perfect ... a little mayo, celery chunks and slight seasoning. The bun was toasted ... but not with butter ... which is too bad because that makes a huge difference. I probably could have eaten 25% more sandwich and been satisfied but I will admit that it left me wanting a few more bites for the price. Their fish and chips are my favourite ever. Freshly cut fingers of cod loin fried in light tempura batter. That makes all the difference. I have noticed that you used to get thicker rectangles in the past. Now, the pieces are a bit thinner. I'd recommend getting the full portion. The appetizer portion is a bit skimpy with 4 smaller sticks. Also ... the printed menu says $8 and the price charged is $10. Having said that, I have never had better fried fish. French fries are crinkle cut. Shake Shack stole this. Nothing special ... bagged and delicious. The service: Awesome. It is clear they hire people who truly enjoy working here. They are very capable and on the ball. Most don't use pads and remember your order. Our waitress was cheerful but not over the top ... very friendly and made our meal better. Atmosphere: Inside is a typical beach bar decor. Not fancy at all. The outdoor patio is where you want to sit. The two top tables are placed a bit awkwardly ... you are literally bumping elbows with the table next to you, it's that close. Also, don't expect privacy in your conversation. Also, they look at the tables across from you, so you kind of feel like you are watching someone else eat uncomfortably. Not to mention I had to look at a fat guy's butt crack who was sitting across from me at a picnic table for the whole meal. Overall, this is a classic roadside beach snack shack. Sure, prices are high because you are in the Hamptons but everything is fresh and good and worth the splurge. The music is fun, 1980's tunes and a very good and relaxing playlist. I'll continue to come back even though we're at 4 - 4.5 stars vs. the old days of 5+. read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Cold lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Bagged frozen lobster!! So gross! Stale fries and way way overpriced. Tourist trap! New owner from Tilray is a slob. read more

Summer isn't summer without a lobster roll at Lunch. It was a beautiful day, the restaurant is bright and clean. Service is friendly and welcoming (thanks Vincenzo!) I devoured my lobster salad roll and creamy Cole slaw. My husband opted for seafood chili and licked the bowl clean. It was full of lobster, shrimp and scallops, topped with cheese and accompanied by sturdy tortilla chips to scoop it all up. He finished with the frozen key lime pie (key lime is his all time favorite) and gave it two thumbs up. read more

See all

4.0 / 5.0 Speaking of Montauk, this is the place to be! It was crowded with many customers from the moment it opened. I gave my name at the reception and waited about 10 minutes, but the turnover was good so I was able to enter without waiting too long. The restaurant was larger than I expected, with table seats, counter seats, and terrace seats. I ate on the terrace, but there were umbrellas and other measures to provide shade so I didn't feel the heat of the sun. The famous lobster roll was delicious, but the Baked Stuffed Shrimp was also very tasty with a strong garlic flavor! I recommend sharing it with the roll. The staff were all kind and gave me a coloring book for kids. There are also two clean restrooms. read more

See all

Good food. Service is efficient. Sat outdoors under the plant balcony. Unfortunately it was a bit cold but the food was fortifying. Better value here. Hot lobster roll was a DIY adventure. Manhattan seafood chowder was satisfying, full of flavor and goodies. Clam strips were meaty and delicious. Crab cakes were good too, with minimal fillers and binders. read more

See all

Excellent as per usual. Got my lobster roll fix here, and sat outside on the back patio. Great place, great staff, great food, friendly and fast service every time I come here. read more

See all

A must lunch stop while visiting the Hamptons! They easily accommodated our party of 5 after only a 15 min wait and a drink from the bar. Recommend the Lavender Gin Lemonade. We all got the Hot Lobster roll which comes with a side of slaw. We shared crinkled fries and onion rings. Had a fun celebrity spotting too! read more

See all

This restaurant is by far my favorite stop right before entering into Montauk. This place just brings back so many great memories of vacationing here with my family. My fiancé and I decided to come here for dinner and when we arrived it was busy but not packed. Our waitress came right to our table and served us drinks and our food came out pretty quick. I ordered the crab cakes platter with coleslaw and french fries. The crab cakes were so tender and they fell apart easily when cutting into them but they were very delicious. My fiancé ordered a lobster roll because he hasn't had one in years and he was very happy with it. The inside of the restaurant had a very nautical look and just felt like you were on a boat. Again, I have nothing but nice things to say about this place and we can't wait to return! read more

See all

This was on so many reels and Tik toks for must try places when you're in the Hamptons. So, obviously we had to try it! It wasn't busy so we were able to get a nice table outside. I can't remember the name but I had a banana pina colada of some sort that was really good! I started off with the seafood dip which was a bit too spinachy for my liking. The hot lobster roll was delicious! It comes deconstructed so you have to make it yourself but it's definitely a winner read more

See all

So happy to find this place again! I stumbled across it years ago and knew it when I passed it again this weekend. We got lucky and didn't have to wait long for a table. Everything was so delicious and fresh. We started with the fish bisque and New England clam chowder. I'm a chowder girl and this one definitely measures up. We got one of each of the styles of the lobster rolls and the fish&chips app. Everything was perfect. So much lobster in each roll. Our waitress was lovely. Look forward to coming again. read more

See all

So absolutely delicious - cold or hot you can not go wrong with a lobster roll here!! Staff was incredibly nice and the food came out fast. Side note, they have the best cherry coke!! read more

See all

Clams on half shell were fresh and tasty, cold lobster roll was packed with meat, Cole slaw was delish and fries were perfect. Tap beer was great. read more

Outdoor seating last night. The warm and cold lobster rolls are still 5 stars. Didn't have the clam strips this time but I did order the dozen clams. The lobster bisque was so good. I had to take another back home for later tonight. read more

See all

The lobster roll , fried seafood combo and clam chowder were excellent! Great service too!!

Delicious hot and cold lobster rolls, insanely good chocolate cake, charming outdoor dining under a grove, an iconic staple in the Hamptons. A must-stop when you're here. Only good things. 5 stars!!! read more

See all

This is my boyfriend's favorite restaurant of all time. He is obsessed with the lobster roll and baileys banana coolada (I'm not sure if that's the name because he always calls the drink a BBC). Drinks are always spot on and the patio is the best place to enjoy the summer weather. I'm not exaggerating when I say we go 5 times a year. The only feedback I have is that the vegetarian options are a little limited- I wish there was more than just a veggie burger- but the fries are classic and the vibe of the place is killer. read more

See all

Very cute spot right on the side of sunrise and easy to drive right past. Yes it is called lunch. Apparently they have some proprietary mayo that goes into their lobster roll which will run you $37 (menu says MP). Ordered the lobster salad so lobster on a bed of greens with coleslaw and some dressing. Lobster roll portion it self was fair and basically what you would expect. Mayo was nothing fancy Clams on half shell - even though I asked for oysters they made a whoopsie but all good. Yummy fresh and delicious but tiny itty bitty little necks Seafood nachos - seafood chili over nachos. Sounds bit crazy, pretty darn yummy but lacking salt Clam chowder New England- what you would expect but also lacking in salt Overall a nice place. Prices are reasonable for the area. Food is good, nothing really over the top amazing. Staff are friendly and service is quick read more

See all

Food was served quickly. Very fresh and service was friendly and efficient. Very good menu in terms of variety and cooking method. Broiled, steamed, fried hot and cold. read more

Food was fantastic. The lobster bisque was chock full of seafood. Also loved the fried clams. I got the hot lobster roll - fries were not worth it but the lobster roll was fantastic. My husband had the fish and chips the first time and the flounder sandwich the second- both excellent but the sandwich made me wish I ordered it lol. We went with family and someone tried the crab cakes and really enjoyed it. The berry pie was a skip as well for me. The ambiance was great - beautiful outdoor seating and I always wanted to go here since seeing the Affair and the inside was reminiscent of the show. The staff was nice and service was fast. We loved it so much we came twice during our 5 night stay in the area. Highly recommend !! read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Lobster roll with fries - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

Finally got to come for a lobster roll here. Have passed it a bunch of times off season when they're closed. We sat inside. The decor is simple and the seating is a wooden booth/bench style. Our waitress was sweet and attentive. My husband ordered the lobster bisque which was probably one of the best I've ever tasted. Our toddler loved it too. We both got the hot lobster roll which came with a generous portion of lobster that you put into roll yourself, coleslaw, and fries. It was very good, though some lobster pieces were chewy. We will be back! read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

The hot lobster was amazing! I also had striped bass which was also super tasty! Beers were cold and our server kept them coming! Perfect lunch on a hot spring day! read more

one of the best seafood restaurants on Long Island. JJ was our sever she was wonderful and very nice. Definitely suggest coming here

Best lobster roll I've had in NY. Highly recommend the hot lobster roll and lobster bisque. The hot lobster roll comes with a generous amount of lobster in a dish, with a buttered New England style roll. Both soups are good, but the lobster bisque is better than the clam chowder. Indoor and outdoor seating that all feels picnic table-like. Patio is great on a warm day. read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Lobster Roll, Lobster Bisque, Clam Chowder, Sweet Potato Fries - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

My husband took me out for brunch on a Monday because it was my day of work today, and he wanted me to experience Montauk because I love the beach and wanted me to try their lobster roll. I'm not a fan of lobster rolls, but I do like a whole lobster. As we walked in, we noticed it was a cute location, and the semi-outside and outside seating were pretty busy for a Monday early afternoon. The only problem is that the hostess did not observe that we were a pretty husky couple and continued to sit us in plastic outside chairs. It is uncomfortable for us, who are new to the location. I asked my husband to say something, but he stood quiet and was a Good sport. The drink prices are overpriced, $18 for basic drinks. I tried the Mango Rita, and it was okay, but I would not recommend it because the mango syrup they use initially tastes like it should be in a smoothie. Maybe for the price, use organic mangos and blend them, I idk, would hurt to try more. Also, the strawberry daiquiri is overpriced $18 for being basic and using bacardi rum. When ordering drinks, stick to regular ones. I should have just ordered wine. For appetizers, we ordered Buffalo calamari. This place should remove the buffalo sauce because it was drenched and soggy. The calamari is nothing to rave about, and I do not recommend it. It's frozen, does not come with the baby octopus, and has no presentation. I ordered a hot lobster roll for entrees because I observed another table, gave in, and ordered it. Omg, the lobster roll was excellent. It's simple butter claw meat, but it tasted fresh and not frozen. The butter bread was delicious, and the cold slaw was simple but fresh and refreshing. My onion rings were frozen, but it was nicely fried. My husband ordered the fried flounder pub sandwich, and omg it was amazing, delicious as well. They do not give much fries, and it is basic carnival Fries, in which you add hot cheese to. They should change their fries to tator tots or waffle fries, but go for the sweet potato fries because other people ordered them, and they look great. Overall I would go back again if I'm in the area because after lunch there is a beach close by and we went for a quick dip and the water was nice a clean and definitely you can bring the kids to go for a walk and look for shell. read more

See all

This is a cute spot right on the highway where you can stop easily. Keep an eye out or you'll miss it! The food is good; just get the lobster roll. They're so fresh and the lobster chunks are huge. You may think it's pricey, but it's on par with the rest of town. You can sit outside on nice days and it's worth waiting for a table. read more

Stopped in with the gals for a late lunch and cocktail. This is a beachy, fun, touristy place that serves the usual oceanside fare. Lots of fried food options and fun cocktails. We sat outside under the arbor in back which is a neat atmosphere but a little buggy. The food is good, not great, but I think you go here for the fun of it. Servers are friendly and helpful looking to turn tables but not so much that you feel rushed. read more

See all

Hands down the best lobster roll on the island! One of the best rolls and not loaded with mayo, comes with hot clarified butter and a side of coleslaw, at MP so prices tend to fluctuate. Service is fast but there can be a significant wait depending if you arrive during a lunch or dinner rush. We started with drinks and they were delicious. Highly recommend the spicy dragonfruit margarita if they still have it on the special drink menu! The fried clams were fresh and delicious with cocktail sauce instead of tartar sauce. The lobster seafood bisque is a favorite of mine I order it every time. The clam chowder is also delicious, extremely creamy and heavy so be prepared for a food coma. The baked jumbo shrimp were good but nothing special. I love being at lobster roll/lunch as they have fantastic indoor and outdoor seating. read more

See all

Shouldn't miss the outstanding lobster roll, both the hot and the cold are fabulous. Fried shrimp were huge and so tender. Very noisy though and 5 people a bit of a tight squeeze. read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Lunch with our dear friends - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all

Stopped here on our first day of vacation. It was a rainy Sunday so it might have been why it was so easy to get a table but service was quick, friendly, and efficient. Prices are reasonable for a beach location and the food is fantastic. Possibly the best lobster roll I have ever had. Also if you have ever seen the show the Affair a lot of it is set here they just gave it a different name which made it extra fun to look around and see. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Service was amazing, very attentive. Food was good, we had the chowder soft shell crabs and the poke bowl. All of which were good. Outdoor seating was very shaded to stay out of the sun. Definitely worth a try if in the area. read more

Lobster roll aka "lunch" is the perfect taste of Hamptons summer with some of the best lobster rolls in the area. There are two locations - Amagansett and Southhampton. We opted for the classic hot and cold lobster rolls with sides of fries. The hot roll had large, meaty, buttery pieces of lobster that made me an instant convert. We paid $37 for a roll (inflation is no joke!) but left happy and full. It's a cute nautical spot, very beachy vibe. We lucked out and had a 5 minute wait for a party of six for Saturday lunch. Come early, it gets busy especially during peak weekends. read more

See all

Fast service and solid food. This is great place to stop for lunch on the way to/from Montauk. At the table, we ordered the sweet potato fries, lobster sliders, chicken, and regular fries. The sweet potato fries were great. The food came very quickly, though we were given the fried fish instead of the chicken at first and had to do an exchange. The exchange was the longest part of the meal and unfortunately we finished most of the other food by the time it came. The chicken was good, but wasn't the crispy chicken as advertised on the menu. The lobster sliders were great - would return to try some of the other dishes. read more

LUNCH Lobster Roll - Lobster sliders - Seafood Near Me - Amagansett, New York

See all