Stopped in without an appointment after unfortunately running over roadkill on Hwy 40 in my…read moredaughter's car. They did a thorough check on the car right away and fixed some minor damage. Very professional and kind and gave us piece of mind that the car was fine for my daughter to drive. Thanks again for the help!

I found James and the team at Winter Park Fraser Tire & Auto online after reading their strong…read morereviews, and they absolutely lived up to them. I brought in my 2024 Subaru Outback XT because I was hearing a squeal from the left rear wheel and assumed it was the low brake pad warning. I asked them to replace the pads if they were worn. They called me back shortly after inspection and told me the pads were actually in great shape -- not even close to needing replacement. Some debris had worked its way in and cleared out during inspection. No upsell, no unnecessary work. Brakes were fine. They also noticed I was at the 42K service interval and offered to take care of that while the car was there. I dropped it off at 8:00 AM and picked it up by 9:30 AM. Fair price, fast turn. Great service, honest assessment, efficient turnaround, and genuinely good people. I'm glad to have found a reliable local option for car repairs in Winter Park.

This place rules. Came in with an assumed faulty alternator. Cesar helped us right away. Did a free…read morequick test (that most folks would charge for) confirmed our issue, checked for the part, didn't have it, ordered it, and had it ready two days later. We came back, they did the install, and we were out of their in under an hour. They were fast, friendly, patient with my questions, and the price was very fair. This is my go-to mechanic in Granby now. No question.

Outstanding service! Had a screw in our tire. Got us right in and back out on the road. Very…read morenice people. Sent us over to a coffee shop across the street and they were all done by the time we walked back over.

We were staying in the Grand Lake area for a 1-week vacation. The 2nd day we were in town, our SUV…read morestarted making a terrible metal on-metal sound as we were leaving our cabin. First thing Monday morning, we called First Class Automotive about getting the SUV checked out and fixed. Don was very professional and helped confirm the information we needed in order to exercise the warranty we have on our car. At least that way we could get reimbursed for the repair expense when we returned home. We had the vehicle towed within the hour. Don told my significant other that if we could get it there by around noon, they'd make time to look at it that day. He called a couple of hours after the vehicle arrived at their shop and explained that a wheel bearing was bad, etc. Turns out he had the part for our Nissan, and they had some time in the afternoon since the part for another customer had not arrived yet. He called by 4pm and said it was fixed. The very next morning we were back on the road and our SUV is driving great. They were a big help in being prompt and communicative so that we could we could enjoy our vacation without having to spend too much on a rental car. We highly recommend this shop!

I am only in town for the weekend. I need to get home (3 hours away) for the closing of my house…read moretomorrow. All the tire shops told me they were booked for the WEEK! The woman working the front desk (maybe the owner?) was soooooo sweet and helpful! They squeezed me in and fixed my tire today!

Honest, friendly and knowledgeable business! If you are to break down in Granby, Colorado, Bill's…read moreAuto Place is where you must go! I live in Texas and was taken care of professionally and I felt like I have gained really good people as friends! I had to tow my vehicle back to Texas and Bill even helped me push it up on our trailer, if only all automotive places followed Bill's example of good business!

Had an appointment scheduled. Brought the car and they said that will work on it first thing in the…read moremorning and to call tomorrow to see if ready to pick up. Called them every day for a week and heard the same story each time- first thing tomorrow morning. They clearly forgot to order required part, and I had to get around without the car for a whole week. Extremely unprofessional!

We were visiting winter park when our car started to have a loud rattle. We called these guys and…read morethey said to come on in to have it checked. Within 5 minutes, they came out and diagnosed the issue with no charge. What a great place! Very grateful

My daughter took her car into this shop. The car has an extended warranty. The car was dropped off…read moreon a Friday and wasn't finished until the next Friday. He said it took 4 days to get parts. John, the owner/manager was very rude and unprofessional. He up-charged the warranty approved amount by over $300 on a $400 bill. I think he took advantage of a stranded out of state young lady. When I called to discuss the bill he ranted about his overhead and the cost of running a business. The warranty company paid his shop labor rate and fair market rate for the parts. I paid the bill so he would release the car. Would not recommend this shop.

Unfortunately, our trip in colorado was marred by a flat tire in the middle of the mountain, at…read moremidnight, 1.5 hours away from any civilization in either direction. The operator for alpine towing truck company was very frank and helpful, giving us a clear price with no hidden costs, and also taking the initiative to suggest we contact roadside assistance for covering said costs (which ended up going through). Finally, the driver performed his role very well, and was genuinely willing to help in every way he could, which was a great conclusion to an otherwise hellish night stranded on the side of the road.

D saved us. So thankful for his help. He was fast and enthusiastic. Was really reasonable! He saved…read morelittle Amelia too!

While pulling our travel trailer up Berthoud Pass we ran into a wheel issue resulting in stripped…read moreand busted lugnuts. Luckily we were able to pull off on a large section of shoulder and get out of the way of traffic. After waiting 2+ hours for our insurance roadside assistance who never showed, we were advised to call Hilly's. I will forever be grateful that we did. Not only was Dom able to get our GMC Sierra towed and to a safe place for repairs, but he even came back the next morning and helped us replace the entire wheel. Ended up needing to remove the axel among other things, with the limited amount of tools we had. Dom brought everything we needed (and made a quick trip to the auto store to get what we did not have). While my 4 year old son and I stayed busy in the dirt ski lot across from Winter Park, Dom and husband got to work at 8am and we were back on the road by 12pm! Their website states "full of good, kind people who know how to treat customers with care and respect." This statement could not be more true or accurate. There are still good people in the world and I am grateful for Hilly's not only saving the day, but being so kind to my family. Thank you.

I lost my power steering which controlled my brakes. Hydrabooster. After getting the run around by…read moremy insurace. I called Hillys Dom answered Saturday at 7 pm Labor day weekend 2026. He showed up 1 hour later with transmission fluid to help my situation out. Great guy very helpful. He followed us back to Fraser to make sure we had no other issues. Cant say thanks enough Dom. Sincerely Dustin.

Beware women that work on your own vehicles!! You will be sold old parts that have been sitting on…read moretheir shelves for years!!! You can ask them for the newer part but they will convince you the older one is still good. I've never had any positive interactions with them. Batteries are old, oil filters are over priced.

Multiple choice test:…read more Got to the ranch late and tired on a snowy afternoon. Night was about to fall and the wind was turning the snow into a blizzard. Pulled up to unlock the gate and was faced with a frozen padlock. Heating it with a lighter didn't work, and our hands were starting to shake from the cold. What to do? What to do? A. Keep trying to flail with the lighter and slowly succumb to hypothermia. B. Siphon some gas from the tank; pour on lock; light with lighter; explode and burn to death. C. Drive to Carquest, buy some spray de-icer from the helpful gentleman for $3.48, return to gate; spray de-icer on lock; open the lock; and uncork a fine bottle of pinot noir, drinking to your honey's beauty and grace. (The correct answer is . . . B. Wait! I mean C. (Whew! If you only knew how close we were to B you'd see this as a much happier story than it first seems)). Sign me, :-David "Saved by Carquest" M

My daughter had 2 flats in just 2 weeks that needed to be repaired. All shops were booked each…read moretime including theirs and they worked me in. Granted, this was a small job to plug a tire and I would not expect the same quick response for a bigger job but no one else wanted to be bothered. My guess is I was dealing with an owner or long time associate who has the ability to figure out how to get it done rather than just saying no. Very nice people to work with.

We are from Oklahoma and traveled to Colorado for vacation and broke down. Looked this place up on…read moreYelp and went to talk to them. I knew from first contact this was going to be a great place. They helped us out and worked our car in quick. Got to enjoy the rest of our vacation. Thank you goes to Kim and her staff at High Country Motors!!! Justin and Bridget Simmons!!