The Best Apple Crumb Pie on the Planet is at Maddalena's!!! We initially went to Duke Farms and then later did wine tasting in Ringoes. Knowing that my favorite Maddalena's Apple Crumb Pie was originally from here, we stopped in to stock up because Gary's Wine ( North Jersey) was out of the Apple Pie. The Apple Pies here are $23.00. I purchased two. The actual shop is very small. However, you do see shipping trucks in the background. Anyway, we met a lovely woman named Kathy. She was extremely helpful. They actually have two apple pies. The one I like has the special crust. They have a variety of cheesecakes, cheesecake on a stick and cookies! In addition, they have many frozen prepared dinners like Swedish meatballs, Lobster crab ravioli, Chicken Marsala, Manicotti.... Also, Maddalena's has Keto dishes. Maddalena's does catering. You can check them out on their website.. Definitely will stop back at Maddalena's, when I am in the area :D read more

See all

We came here on our way back to Philly. This place definitely has the best cheesecakes you can get locally and makes a nice stop before going into Philly. When we went, we placed an order from the menu found online. We waited a few minutes and then the order was brought out to us in the car. We got a cheesecake and an order of the garlic bread. Both were amazing and very tasty. Many of their cheesecakes are the ones you get from restaurants so getting them fresh is really cool. The texture is perfect and the flavor cant be beat. I highly recommend coming here and getting one of their cheesecakes. There are so many flavors, all are good, and totally worth it! read more

The first time I tried Maddalena's Cheesecake on a stick was about 3 years ago when I was still contemplating whether I loved/hated cheesecake... because there's rarely an in between for me lol. I took a bite of my husbands cheesecake and was SO pleasantly surprised. Fast forward to now, I realized that it wasn't cheesecake that I didn't like but it was that the cheesecakes I've tried just weren't cutting it for me. Now I loooove cheesecake but I'm picky as to where I get it from! Maddalena's has perfect reviews for a reason. The cheesecake is soft, tasty and just downright amazing. We always run into Maddalena's truck at events and HAVE to get their cheesecake on a stick, but this past weekend we were in the area and HAD to make a stop... so many options to choose from, but couldn't help with go the usual. Believe me, this is worth the hype! read more

Great cheese cakes When I find out more abut this company I let u now but I like their cheesecake most def read more

Since I live in northern NJ and travel to spend the day with relatives in Ewing, I called on Saturday to ask if they were open on Father's Day and asked a gentleman if I had to order a apple crumb pie. He assured me that they would have plenty. I arrived around noon a asked the women there for a pie. She pulled a frozen pie from the freezer. I said I called yesterday and was told there were plenty. ( not frozen) I had no other option at this point but to spend the $30+ after being scolded by the woman that I was never told they would have plenty of fresh pies. When it was served, I could see everyone,s faces . When I took a bite,I thought I just ate a spoon full of SUGAR. Worst pie ever . Can you say sugar shock? It went right into the garbage! Won't be going back. Very nasty customer service. read more

Delicious keto cheesecake and gluten free options. Family members loved the frozen keto entrees.

I've passed by Maddalena's a few times now and decided I had to give into my cheesecake curiosity. The entrance is located right on Route 31, which leads you to a small parking lot. Inside, which was super cold in the winter time, you'll find a check out desk, a few freezers filled with goodies and an open kitchen where you can see them making the cheesecakes. As a first timer I decided to go with a chocolate chip cheesecake, which I'm saving for Christmas, and two cheesecake cookie sandwiches. The pricing here seemed pretty high, but I guess you pay for the high quality. The cheesecake cookies were DELICIOUS and I wish I had bought more. The cookies were perfect and the cheesecake filling was some of the best I've ever had. Totally a place worth checking out when you want to treat yourself. read more

OMG! The cheesecake is BEYOND this world. I recently purchased the chocolate covered pumpkin cheese goodness with chocolate chip crumbs. Wow, mind blown! So excited to have purchased it. All the cheesecake was so delicious, I was a huge fan! Their toppings are great too, just a fan of the cheesecake by itself. They have apple crumb cakes and other great options! *dont have the burnt coffee* It would be 5 stars but unfortunately they don't sell full cakes. That was very disappointing. Besides that 5 stars!!!! Such good flavors!!! read more

See all

Picked up a strawberry and key lime cheesecake, $18 a piece. I'm a huge key lime anything fan, but this cheesecake was just OK. The cheesecake wasn't tangy enough and could have used more graham cracker crumble. The strawberry cheesecake was also just OK, enough strawberry flavor but just felt like it was missing something. I wish the cheesecake was more airy and light, unfortunately it felt very dense and heavy. read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Key lime cheesecake, not tangy enough - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

I literally cannot say enough positive things about Maddalena's. Seriously, they truly exemplify great customer service and amazing quality product. I pass Maddalena's all the time on my way to work so I finally decided to stop in and check it out one day. It's a tiny place with limited parking. The customer service was out of this world. I didn't know what I wanted so the employee that I spoke with spent about 20 minutes explaining and showing me different types of cheesecakes (cannolis, cheesecake on a stick, cakes, etc), toppings, pricing, etc. He even took the time to write it all down for me. He wrote down the phone number and said to call to place my order a couple days in advance. What surprised me the most is that he even gave me his cell phone number in case I called too late and couldn't reach anyone on the normal phone number. How nice! Since my first visit, I've gotten cheesecakes from Maddalena's a couple times. They are simply the best. I've never hard a cheesecake this good. They are so rich and creamy... not to mention, they are always decorated really nicely as well. I would highly recommend Maddalena's cheesecake to everyone! read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

WOW!!! A buddy of mine brought one of their cheesecakes (Black Forest) to our home for dessert and I must say, it is hands down the best cheesecake I have ever eaten!!! read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

Hands down the best cheesecake ever! No one makes cheesecake like Maddalena's. They also make amazing Mac N Cheese and other desserts and dinner foods. read more

Maddalena's not only has the best cheesecake and Apple crumb pie around but I love them even more now that they've started offering both sweet and savory low carb/keto options. We've tried almost all of their keto cheesecakes because she makes them in individual sizes too. That allowed us to try all of them without committing to a full size cheesecake. All were so good and made with natural sweeteners! We are looking forward to trying some of their frozen keto entrees to take the load off of cooking everyday in quarantine. They are offering online ordering with curbside pickup during this time which is safe and convenient. When things are back to normal we'll restock our freezers with their regular cheesecake and apple crumb pie. They freeze well and are perfect for bringing to parties or gatherings. Always a big hit! Happy to support this local business! read more

Our family and friends have always enjoyed the cheese cakes and we finally went to the store. Upon getting to the front door we noticed the sign describing how we need to shop to ensure everyone is safe during this pandemic. The owner was front and center and was trying to set expectations. We purchased a huge pot pie, some gumbo and meat loaf. Everything we have had so far has been great. I am surprised by the review by Scott K. who seems to be an impatient person who blamed the store for other customers being slow and that he had to wait an entire 8 minutes. Wow...what an inconvenience. And the petty comments about the cheesecake which was never purchased showed even more about that review. Thank you Maddalenas for your service and great quality food. read more

I was at the food truck Festival and upon this product i got the cannoli filled with oreo topping and dipped with choclate. Defintely a must try if into desserts. read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Great cheesecake use orginal ingredients - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

Award Winning is a very strong word and should only be used if other think/say you are award winning...Your Apple Crumb Pie is AWARD WINNING! I was a little surprised because the Pie was sold frozen and all the way home I was bummed! Got home, put it in the frig to thaw. Holy Crap we have a winner!!! read more

Love love love the cheesecake!!! Do try their Black Forest cheese cake and you will not be disappointed

I had the pleasure of tasting this cheesecake at the Laurita winery wine tasting and food truck event. The cheesecake sample was amazing so i purchased the cheesecake on a stick. I order mine dipped in chocolate with nuts. I ordered a small which was $5. The medium was $7 and the large was $9 but I'm not sure who eats that much cheesecake on a stick. I most certainly won't. The small was just fine and the right amount. It was good to try and flavorful when defrosted. read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Small with nuts. Pretty good. - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

We were very excited to try the cheese cake. We didn't get the chance. Very disappointed and frustrated. We entered the store. It's a very small store. We were asked to wait by the door while the previous customer took her sweet time and then stood in front of us to tell us all about the Shepard's pie..... while she was checking out. Further preventing us from even looking at what's available. It was a good 8 minute wait which seemed like an hour. We honored the rules on the door and waited for this woman to move so we could look. After she moved we starting looking, mind you we got maybe a minute before another woman outside decided she was coming in, disregarding the shops rules, literally stepping in front of us pushing us out of her way while she shopped. We waited for the owner, who was still waiting on the original old lady, to say something. Nope as soon as the old lady left, the new pushy woman walked up to the counter and the owner decided to help her. At this point I'm not waiting in line to hand you my money if you can't be bothered to tell this woman to wait.... just like she told us when we walked in. Very poor customer service. May be the best cheese cake in NJ I wouldn't know and won't ever go back. It looks like the freezer section is old stuff. It all seemed to have ice crystals on it and the store again was TINY. The cheesecakes look like mass produced food store stuff, like the Cheesecake Factory. disappointed read more

Best cheesecake and it's in NJ. Found about it at local ShooR groceries. They have more than just cheesecake to. Really liked the huge pot pie read more

I had the pleasure of enjoying a chocolate dipped cheesecake with peanut topping today at the Chester food truck fest. I really think that my fav part of it all was eating it on a stick. The cheesecake was average. The chocolate and nuts enhanced the taste of the cheesecake. I also sampled a frozen apple pie treat which was quite tasty (4 out of 5). I would totally get that again. read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Chocolate dipped cheesecake with peanut topping - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

We found Maddalena's at Laurita Winery's Food Trucks and Fire Pits event. Chris couldn't resist ending the night with a little dessert, so we rolled ourselves to Maddalena's truck for a frozen cheesecake on a stick. These men are geniuses. It's a slice of cheesecake, frozen, on a stick, dipped in chocolate, and rolled in a topping. We got a small slice topped with Oreos. There is really nothing else to be said about it other than - Awesome! If you like cheesecake you will love this. Read our full review here: http://wp.me/p5EPbt-7s read more

Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering - Bakeries Near Me - Ringoes, New Jersey

See all

Instead of traditional pies for thanksgiving, my brother wanted to bring these awesome cheesecakes from a bakery near his work. Awesome didn't cut it! Oh my god! So delicious and creamy! It brings to mind that episode of Friends where Rachel and Chandler eat a neighbor's cheesecake bc it was so good, I imagine them to be eating THIS place's cheesecake! read more

Its a little bit pricey, but I think their cheesecake cookies (Chookies) are really great, some of my favorite desserts that ive had so far

OUTSTANDING! Maddalena's is amazing! Had the pleasure of enjoying the best of both worlds. First course was a delicious freshly made chicken pot pie, fantastic! Topped that off with a huge slice of the best cheesecake EVER, had the Black Forrest. What a delightful dinner. Put this place on your map, can't wait to try Everything! Best customer service as well, absolute Five Star. read more

Janet and the gang were AWESOME! I had them ship cheesecakes and apple crumb pie to all our friends in honor of my son's engagement as their celebration was canceled due to COVID-19. They went out of their way to make sure that each one of our friends received their cakes in great shape. They shipped a 2nd batch to 3 of our friends because the 1st delivery was made late. I was not aware of it until our friends informed us that they got a 2nd shippment. Although their service was absolutely amazing and definitely deserves 5 stars, I would give the cakes 10 stars as the cakes were hands down the best I have taseted. Thank you so much for making sure that our friends were able to celebrate our son's engagement, even from long distance. Rita. M read more

For realz though. . . .BEST cheesecake I have ever eaten. Super creamy and absolutely delicious!

Just found out that I don't have to travel out to the farmstand on Rt 31 to get the best cheesecake on the planet. Found it at the Shopright in Flemington. If you've never tried it, you don't know what you're missing out on. Got it for Father's Day present! read more

Terrific cheesecake. Wonderful owners. I was offered a sample of their "ketogenic" cheesecake, and it was delicious! Picked up a few items for family as my sister and her husband had a tiered Maddalena's cheesecake as their wedding cake 30 years ago! read more

I purchased the apple pie thinking it's as good as advertised. I found it way too sweet for my taste (boiled down to eating a pie w/pure sugar). The apple were overcooked in my view and I've had so called best apple pies in variety of places over the years. read more

Phenomenal cheesecakes, apple crumble pie, chicken pot pie, Jersey pot pie....EVERYTHING is wonderful.

Even though I haven't lived in NJ in more than ten years, I still put in a request for Maddalena's cheesecake for my birthday every year. It's the best. Since I only get it once a year, it's always a real challenge to choose between the regular and chocolate chip. read more

A family owned and operated business that makes the finest cheesecake in the land! They also do scrumptious catering year-round, and in the warmer months they bring out the famous food truck and serve cheesecake on a stick. The cheesecake recipes only incorporate premium ingredients for a distinct brand experience. Extremely service-oriented family that loves what they do, and it comes through in the products. read more

I've been enjoying Maddalena's cheesecakes for years. As a purist, I like plain the best and theirs is the best - creamy and delicious. Frozen cheesecake on a stick is awesome! Then they went and invented the cheesecake cookie - oh my God! They are like an ice cream sandwich only better...and they never melt and drip. Look for their trailer at festivals and food truck events, you'll be glad you did. read more

This is the creamiest, richest cheesecake I have had in a long time. Reminds me of one I used to get in NYC years ago -- same home-baked quality with lots of not-too-sweet cream cheese. Our family waits for the fall to get the pumpkin cheesecake and the key lime was spectacular at our summer bbq's! read more

I have not lived in NJ for many years but do go often to visit family. A must-stop on my visit is to have a piece Maddalena's Cheesecake. Not only can you purchase an entire cake at most Shop-Rites in Hunterdon County, you can now buy it by the slice, frozen on a stick. If there is a weekend event (carnival, food fair, etc.) and you see food trucks look for the Maddalena trailor! My favorite had always been pumpkin, but now it seems that with every visit to NJ they have put together a new flavor! It is always a surprise and NEVER a disappointment. If you want the creamiest cheesecake - Maddalena's cannot be beaten! read more

My husband has lived in the area and loved Maddalena's cheesecakes for over 10 years. We decided to hire them to cater our garden wedding on the fourth of July. They were the best caterers we could have hoped for! Firstly, they were very, very responsive during the planning stage (and we put the wedding together in about two months, so we needed that!). The staff was friendly and cheerful, even though they were working on a holiday. And they were so flexible! We had changing weather (the remnants of Hurricane Arthur as it worked its way up the coast), so all of us were setting up in rain and mud. And with a chilly evening and a shorter-than-expected ceremony, they managed to get all of the food ready earlier than planned. The food was excellent! Very delicious, exactly the right balance of classy and casual. Plus, they coordinated our rental of tables, a large tent, linens, etc. By all means, hit up their farm stand for tasty cheesecake, you can't go wrong (I think the key lime was the biggest hit). But if you're wondering how well they cater, our experience should convince you they deserve every one of the five stars!! read more