Hands down one of the best cold brews I've ever had. I got toasted marshmallow syrup and asked for…read morea small amount of half and half and it was the perfect color. If I lived here, they would get all of my money. Really friendly staff too!

Cute little coffee shop tucked away in the Cape May mall that is not as commercial as Coffee Tyme…read moreand is also a far cry from Wawa coffee. A great spot to hang out at if you can get the seats beneath the stairs. Well made coffee drinks.

Loved everything about this place. Its cute overall, staff was so friendly, and the coffee itself…read morewas delicious, I'm in love with the coconut mocha. Added bonus is that its on the boardwalk, literally steps away from the beach. Its adorable and has good coffee, just go already!

I've been to 3 or 4 Cape May coffee shops so far. I've found them all to be pretty much the same…read more Decent food, pretty good coffee. None of them stands out above the others. My suggestion- go to whichever one is closest.

Went this morning for cream, donuts, did not disappoint.!! Sticky buns and cinnamon rolls are…read moreabsolutely out of this world, highly recommend worth the trip.!! Customer service was fabulous Maddy was awesome!

Quite simply the best donuts and cinnamon rolls you can possibly imagine eating are served at this…read morefriendly establishment run by a family. You won't find any of those design your own donuts like you might get a duck donuts. These are your classic donuts done with superiority. There's something that they do with that dough that makes it so much better, lighter, tastier; you really do just have to try one to know the experience of eating a Madison's doughnut . Devotion to their donuts starts at 3 AM every day to start making these wonderfully tasty delight. Every year my family comes to Cape May, and we look forward to getting Madison's every morning that we're here. We could not imagine coming to Cape May without Madison's. I hear there are crazy people out there that have negative things to say about Madison's. I have no idea why you would ever say something other than - this is the best donut ever in your review.

Been going her for years and have no excuse as to why I haven't I added to my review portfolio…read morebefore now. BEST Iced COFFEE IN NJ, not just in Cape May. And this is the consensus of a large family of coffee snobs (as well and pizza snobs). Do not go to the mall without a visit!

This is a great setting and wonderful people watching from the outdoor tables. On season I have…read morenever been here without a line. They have a nice selection of bagels and a serve yourself coffee station. I have found the acai bowls to be very disappointing. First of all they are HUGE. No one needs to eat that much, especially with something that is frozen and is going to melt. I have found the ingredients to be icy and a few minutes in the bowls just turn to mush. I have had other acai bowls on island that are much better.

La comida es deliciosa el servicio es espectacular y el ambiente super tranquilo y relajanteread more

The woman working behind the counter when I came in may have been having a bad day -- super…read moreunpleasant! I got a toasted everything bagel with cream cheese. The bagel itself was quite bad and was really just flavorless round bread, hardly toasted. I didn't try the coffee, but would not come back here for a bagel.

Ostara's is always a 5 star experience!! I've been a big fan of the Clue drink specials. I ordered…read morea Pistachio & White Chocolate Matcha. I love almost every syrup and flavor choice they have so it's hard to narrow it down. I also ordered Avocado Toast and added Bacon. Very good idea and highly recommended. The baristas and staff are always great and really make the experience! Food and drinks are always on point. I love all of the local art work & products for sale. As well as the bookstore!

I love this place! I was there this weekend and went Saturday and Sunday. Saturday we ate in and it…read morewas super busy, but not a long wait to get your stuff. Su day we did an online pick up as we were heading back home to PA. The coffee was delicious, sandwiches were all good and fresh ! Everyone was nice and friendly! They sell books and little earrings, paintings etc. outside they have a food pantry bin & a book nook ! When in cape May I'll be back!

This place is SO unassumming! My girl & I had passed by it several times during out weekend in…read moreCape May. But I was craving a breakfast sandwich so we came to check it out. WoW. From the outside you'd never know the treat that awaits you inside! Who knew there was an Orea flavored cream cheese? Or horseradish & cheddar? Or olive pimenta? Or bacon lox scallion? I kinda wish I would have discovered this place sooner so I could have sampled more of the flavors! Anyway, we both go the Lox w/Salmon/onions & capers with cream cheese on a bagel. And I couldn't finish it. I saved the second half for the next morning and it was still tasty! So, to summarize, you can choose your cream cheese and your bagel (everything bagel, wheat, plain, etc.). And of course they've got other items to choose from. Avocado toast was my second option. ...a hidden gem.

The service was absolutely amazing: friendly, attentive, and made us feel very welcome from the…read moremoment we walked in. The only downside was the food and coffee. We ordered toasted bagels, but they were barely toasted and tasted more like plain bagels. The coffee was unfortunately very disappointing as well. Even after adding half-and-half, I couldn't finish it because of the taste. The outstanding service is the reason I'd consider giving this place another try, and I hope they can improve the bagels and coffee because the staff truly deserves recognition.

This is hands down one of my favorite coffee spots in cape May, I love their quiches and I always…read morehave to get a maple latte from there. They have a lot of yummy options for freshly baked pastries and breads. Also in a really cute spot where you can do some vintage shopping while you're there.

Recently visited Beach Plum Cafe and enjoyed our treats. They were good. They have a lot of good…read moreoptions to choose from. We sat outside in breeze to enjoy our coffee and snacks. We tried cranberry slice cake, strawberry scone and biscotti. Strawberry scone was okay, but rest of it was good. Biscotti was the best!