Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Magic Mikes Pizza

    4.2 (326 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    Order Magic Mikes Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Magic Mikes Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    MAGIC MIKES PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Happy hour specials
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Magic Mikes Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Gluten Free Deep Dish Meat Lovers and Gluten Free Deep Dish Hawaiian Pizza
    Sara S.

    AMAZING gluten free deep dish pizza! My husband had the large gluten free meat lovers. I had the small gluten free Hawaiian. Both absolutely delicious. The crew working was super helpful and friendly. They checked ingredient lists for me (the Alfredo sauce is gluten free; it's made with corn starch). They also have gluten free pasta. Overall 10/10 for food and service.

    Clear stringy pieces, when I chewed them they felt rubbery, like thin rubber bands mixed with the cheese in my pizza

    I've been ordering pizza from this place for about a year and never had a problem until today, which is why this experience was so shocking. I ordered online and when I picked up my order the employee told me the first pizza had been accidentally overcooked and they had to make another one, so she gave me both boxes. I didn't think anything of it at the time. When I started eating the pizza in my car, I noticed something strange when I bit into it. At first I thought the cheese just hadn't melted properly because there were clear stringy pieces, but when I chewed them they felt rubbery, like thin rubber bands, not like cheese at all. Some of the strands got stuck in my mouth and throat and it actually made me gag. After looking closer at the pizza, I could see several clear rubber-band-like strands all the same size and length coming out of the pizza. It was really disturbing and made me feel physically sick. I ended up gagging and feeling nauseous the rest of the evening. I've eaten here many times before and never had this issue, but this experience was very concerning. I'm posting this so the restaurant is aware and to warn others to check their food carefully. Something clearly went wrong in the preparation process and I hope it gets addressed so it doesn't happen to someone else.

    White wine and lemon pepper wings.
    Keith R.

    Great food, wine, beer and service. The wings were fresh, hot and well seasoned. The supreme pizza was on point with the crust extra crispy as requested. You can buy wine by the glass or bottle; but because we were going to have a couple of glasses we were told that it would be cheaper to buy the bottle. Ambiance is great for a pizzeria. There is both indoor and outdoor dining. Big screen teles indoor and one giant outdoors. What's amazing is that you can order roasted Brussel sprouts and other upscale side items at the pizzeria.

    Spaghetti and Italian sandwich
    Joanna G.

    Everything was so good!! We've tried several different dishes here, but the wings are perfectly crispy just how I love them, but the spaghetti and Italian sandwich were fire. The service was top-tier they cleared plates quickly off our table and kept checking in on us. The staff is super friendly and very welcoming. They also show all the sports, which is a big plus. Definitely come check them out!!

    Greasy brussel sprouts
    Araceli A.

    Don't know why I went to magic Mike's I guess cuz it's close by. The service was good But I ordered a pizza the meat lovers pizza. It was so salty and the Brussels sprouts were so greasy. I'm just sorry that my son was not impressed it was his first time eating magic mikes pizza. Not so magic.

    Nothing
    Jillian O.

    Pizza is good, cottage fries are ok, decided to get kids spaghetti. I paid $12. I get home and find a little scoop of noodles with some sauce. I go to California pizza kitchen and for $8 I get literally the same container but it's full and lasts 2-3 days because they give us so much. Fucking insane to charge $12 for a scoop of cafeteria spaghetti. I called and got a refund but I think I won't be coming back, I'll stick to CPK

    White Signature Alfredo Pizza
    Alex T.

    First I wanna say idk how this place is empty when it's the best pizza! However the pizzas are a bit pricey even for a small pizza and they don't have side salads only large orders which is interesting but they should make meal combos for the small pizzas. I got the White Signature Alfredo Pizza and it was so bomb you won't regret trying it. Also their cheese bread is really good. The customer service was okay even though I did come on a slow afternoon so not much interaction I was in and out of there within 10 mins.

    GLUTEN FREE PIZZA 8X10"
    Syd M.

    Wow, finally found a place that does gluten free pizza with THICK crust! I felt suspicious that the crust might be a regular one. My GF pizza was pretty yummy, I got regular red sauce & cheese with bacon, Italian sausage, and red onions. It cost around $20-21 for a small pizza. I'd def come here again because I can't find any GF pizza that comes in thick crust. Parking was good, lots of spots. Service was okay/good.

    Sneak peek at the Meat Lovers Pizza

    See all

    Photo of Gabe V.
    115
    17
    2

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Page 9 of 9

    Magic Mikes Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Magic Mikes Pizza

    Are your wings deep fried?

    Yes they are

    Can you explain what a "Mike's Way" crust is? I'm looking for a place that can do a New York style crust.

    Is Magic Mikes open on Christmas?

    No.

    View All 5 Questions

    You might also consider

    Ghost Sando Shop - The Melrose: Dutch Crunch Roll w/Melrose spread, Black Forrest Ham, Oven Roasted Turkey, Bacon, White American Cheese, house slaw & tomato

    Ghost Sando Shop

    4.4(272 reviews)
    3.3 mi
    $$
    Family-owned & operated
    Veteran-owned & operated

    This is the kind of experience that reminds you how much good customer service can completely…read morechange a first visit. This past weekend, our daughter had a game at Cypress High School. We were headed toward REI to grab some outdoor chairs and decided to stop at GHOST Sando Shop in Huntington Beach. I've driven past this place plenty of times and never really knew what it was. It also happened to be one of the only places open in the shopping center that early, so we figured, why not? Man, we had no idea what we were missing. We ordered the Melrose for ourselves and a Club for our daughter. Marco took our order and was also the one making the sandwiches. A few minutes after we sat down, he actually walked over and asked me, "Are you sure you want the pepperoncini and tomato on the Club?" My first thought was basically, uhhh... yeah, of course I do! Then it clicked. The Club was for our daughter. Marco had remembered that from our conversation when we ordered and knew that a lot of kids probably aren't exactly excited about pepperoncini and tomatoes. Meanwhile, Dad over here completely forgot to ask for them off. That might seem like such a small thing, but THAT is customer service. Marco wasn't just taking an order, collecting payment, and moving on to the next customer. He was actually paying attention. He remembered who the sandwich was for and took the extra few seconds to come over and double check before making it. Good looking out, Marco. Seriously. And that wasn't the only interaction we had with him. Marco was incredibly friendly from the moment we walked in. He talked with us, answered questions, and even gave us suggestions on other sandwiches we should try the next time we come back. Nothing felt forced or scripted. It was just genuine conversation from someone who seemed to actually care whether we enjoyed our experience. There were only two guys working while we were there, yet everything was running smoothly. The restaurant was clean, the atmosphere was relaxed, the bright green interior gives the place its own personality, and there's plenty of seating inside along with a really nice outdoor patio area. And most importantly, the sandwiches were GOOD. The Melrose was a great first choice, and Melody enjoyed her Club, thankfully without Dad accidentally loading it up with pepperoncini. We also grabbed some Calypso lemonades, which went perfectly with everything. We originally stopped here simply because it was open and convenient. Now it's somewhere we'll intentionally come back to. There are thousands of places where you can buy a sandwich. What makes you remember a restaurant is usually the people behind the counter. Marco made us remember GHOST. Excellent food, clean restaurant, great atmosphere, and genuinely outstanding customer service. We'll definitely be back, and next time, Marco, we're taking you up on those recommendations.

    I wasn't expecting to be this impressed, but this one definitely lived up to the hype. The flavors…read moreall worked together, and the Dutch Crunch bread really made the sandwich. My husband approved too, which says a lot. We'll definitely be back to try a few more sandwiches. Ghost Sando Shop is worth the stop if you're in Huntington Beach

    Photos
    Ghost Sando Shop - Food ordering area

    Food ordering area

    Ghost Sando Shop - Uncle Nikki: Dutch Crunch, mayo, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola, Provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, pepperoncini, house dressing | $18

    Uncle Nikki: Dutch Crunch, mayo, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola, Provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, pepperoncini, house dressing | $18

    Ghost Sando Shop - The Uncle Nikki on Dutch Crunch(ish)

    See all

    The Uncle Nikki on Dutch Crunch(ish)

    Shootz

    Shootz

    4.3(1.6k reviews)
    1.6 mi
    $$

    We came in on a Saturday afternoon and it was quite busy for us to order our food but fairly quick…read morefor them to give our order! It has quite a few seating spots in the front of the shop but there's also seating areas throughout Rodeo 39. We ordered the katsu chicken and shrimp mix plate and the spam brûlée musubi. The flavors were so delicious with their kimchi butter really making the dish! And I loved the brûlée on the spam musubi. I'd say this wouldn't be the place for veggies but would definitely come here again!

    Came last Sunday to introduce a couple of friends to Rodeo 39 right at 11 am opening. I ended up…read morewith Shootz and ordered the Kimchi Butter Shrimp plate. It was delicious and portion size was great, but the service and promo were frustrating. They had a huge sign advertising FREE Ube Beignets for downloading their app. The cashier told me to download it and redeem it in-app. I tried, but the app didn't have clear instructions on how to redeem. When I went back to ask for help, the original cashier brushed me off saying she was on break, and a male server told me they didn't even have any Ube Beignets available??? Umm, wait it's less than an hour past opening time. Being "out" of a front-and-center promo item 30 minutes after opening feels like a bait-and-switch. Take the sign down if you can't honor it. Food is good, but the experience left a bad taste.

    Photos
    Shootz - Inside

    Inside

    Shootz - Kimchi butter katsu chicken

    Kimchi butter katsu chicken

    Shootz - Kimchi Butter Katsu Chicken Plate, pure deliciousness!

    See all

    Kimchi Butter Katsu Chicken Plate, pure deliciousness!

    THH Sandwiches - Westminster - Spring Roll Variety..90 cents each. (minimum 20)

    THH Sandwiches - Westminster

    3.9(696 reviews)
    1.3 mi
    $

    On this occasion, I ordered a bánh mì sandwich (#19 - crispy pork belly @ $8.75) and an iced coffee…read more($6.25). With tax ($0.81), my ticket was $15.81. The sandwich was slightly longer than what I usually see at other bánh mì shops. And while there were slivers of pickled daikon and carrots, the cucumber slice stretched the entire length of the sandwich. (Could this be a brand differentiator?) The bread was very good, and the crispy pork belly was crunchy and well-seasoned. The pâté had a good flavor and texture. This was my first visit to this location and my first interaction with this brand. I've noticed "THH" shops scattered around Garden Grove and Westminster. Each store has a slightly different look, so I'm guessing they might be franchises. If so, this store represented the brand well with this sandwich.

    Chiều hôm nay (August 25, 2026) around 4:00PM, chúng tôi ghé mua 2 ổ bánh mì baguette ở tiệm Tân…read moreHoàng Hương trên đường Westminster góc Goldenwest. Khi mang về nhà ăn thì mới phát hiện đó là bánh mì đã cũ và được nướng lại, một điều rất dể nhận biết là bánh mì cũ được nướng lại thì khi bẻ ra nó sẽ bị bể vụn hết lớp vỏ bánh bên ngoài, và phần ruột bánh bên trong rất khô! (Hình đính kèm). Tôi thiết nghĩ cách làm ăn nầy hoàn toàn không bao giờ hợp với bất kỳ một thời buổi nào và ở bất kỳ một đất nước nào! Buôn bán cần sự uy tín làm hàng đầu, chúng tôi đã mua đồ ăn của tiệm nầy khá nhiều lần trong quá khứ, và đây là lần đầu có sự việc nầy xảy ra, và cũng như lần cuối chúng tôi sẽ say good-bye tiệm nầy!

    Photos
    THH Sandwiches - Westminster - Banh Mi Variety (Yes Bread is made in house, baked every hour)

    Banh Mi Variety (Yes Bread is made in house, baked every hour)

    THH Sandwiches - Westminster - Noodles with Shrimp and Squid $30, $40, $50 trays

    Noodles with Shrimp and Squid $30, $40, $50 trays

    THH Sandwiches - Westminster - Shrimp Fried Rice $30, $40, $50 sizes

    See all

    Shrimp Fried Rice $30, $40, $50 sizes

    Magic Mikes Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...