The old menu was better for me. Bring back the peanut butter bacon dog and the dog of the month!read more

Really enjoyed the pimento cheese hot dog they have. The…read moreburger was definitely good. A little over priced but so is everything so maybe it's not‍. Very cool little store front. Inside seemed clean and bright. Will be coming back next time I'm in the area for sure.

Best fries..Great food and service.hope you are open today. Missing my jersey dog!..read more

Sadly not as good as it used to be. It used to be more like Callahans, that was in Fort Lee. Now…read morethe dogs are smaller and dryer. Maybe ownership change? Cut backs? But it was fabulous when it was in the little storefront!!!!

We love this place! My daughter who lives in TN loves a good burger and has a vegetarian finance…read more Everyone found something to eat here that we absolutely loved! Our vegetarian opted for the build your own burger. Veggie burger on a pretzel bun w/ pallet jack, chipotle mayo, fries, frizzled onions and avocado. He loved it! My daughter and I split an order of pierogies and the amazing bacon onion marmalade burger. They even cut it up for us from the kitchen and put it on separate plates (love the attention to detail and service) My mother daughter truly enjoyed her pineapple jalapeños burger and was in heaven. Not too much heat but just the right amount of kick. Hubby is trying to be more health conscious so he opted for the Brie & Apple turkey burger. He said it was very well seasoned and enjoyed it thoroughly. We all took a sip or two of the peanut butter shake and left happy! The service was great and we complimented the owner his beautiful flowers and decor.

Cow Patty's is a fun little burger joint right off the main drag in Wantage. And I say right off…read morebecause as you pull in and out of the parking "lot," you're doing so onto NJ-23. Be prepared! Inside, we were met with a kind staff and a delicious lunch. The boomin bloomin onion was a favorite for our crew, with the typical blooming onion sauce you know and love from the steak chains. What differentiated it was the thin slicing of the onions, which made it easier to just keep dipping a little bit more. The only letdown of the meal, which was a relative letdown given how solid the burgers and onion were, was the fries. They didn't have flavor, even though I got mine with Cajun seasoning and my wife got hers with a beer cheese dip. They need to punch up the salt fresh out of the fryer to really let the other seasonings shine. We actually overheard another table say the same thing after we finished our fries, so I don't think it was just a fluke order. That said, if you're nitpicking over the sides at the burger and shake place, I'd say you're going to the wrong places! This was a tasty meal and a stop I'd easily go back to if I was nearby.

The best Smashburgers. I could Not stop eating. True smash burgers and their Signsture "Taylor Ham…read moreJam" is a must try. It is absolutely awesome and it goes on everything. Plenty of options form smashburgers with 2 or even 4 patties (quad) , deep fried hotdogs and French fries. All sauces are made in house and beef is locally sourced and it's all fresh. Chicken wings and chicken nuggets, milkshakes as well. Here's what I tried : Rock Burger 2 smashed patties * cheese * pickles * rock sauce (burger sauce) Quarry Burger 2 patties with our "quarry sauce" * onions * brown mustard Sussex Smash Fresh onion smashed into 2 smash patties * cheese * pickles * ketchup Quarry Dog Our "family all the way recipe" * onions * brown mustard Slaw Dog topped with our homemade cole slaw, quarry sauce and rock sauce Dirty Fries- topped with Famous Taylor Ham Jam and Rock sauce Fluff fries - sweet potato fries dusted in cinnamon sugar and topped with Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal and marshmallow fluff My Only regret is not getting the Taylor Ham Jam on everything and not getting a jar of it to take home. Fast friendly service. Plenty of seating. They do special burgers and shakes all the time. I'd like to go back and try other menu items.

A perfect smashburger! I ordered the 'dirty burger' which had two patties, cheese, taylor ham jam…read moreand rock sauce ontop. The taylor ham jam was amazing! One of the workers let me try some before ordering which was very helpful because I was unsure if I would like it or not. The burger was super juicy, super messy and super delicious!!

I was in White Plains today to shop @ the International Wholesale Jewelry Event & I doubled bk to…read morehave lunch here. Soooo many choices of dogs & toppings to eat. There's even a kids menu. Lots of locals support this Hot Dog spot. I recommend this spot! Yummy

OMG why havent i been here before? I paaa by it so often and never really stopped by. Oh but…read morefinally I did and im Sooo happy I did. This is a great little spot with an impressive variety of options. They have plenty of outdoor sitting where you can relax take in the fresh air on your lunch break or enjoy a little tic tac toe game while digesting your delicious hot dog. The prices are very reasonable for specialty dogs. Definitely try the Guac star dog and the rancho loaded Fries. Delish! I will come back to try more options.

Great spot and what you would expect from tasty deep fried hotdogs and milkshakes. Great outdoor…read moreseating. Would have been 5 star but the window staff were very transactional versus pleasant. But that is their job, transactions.

Hot Dog Johnny's is the kind of roadside stop you root for…read more We came across Hot Dog Johnny's on a Sunday afternoon while heading home from a weekend away, and the sign caught our attention right away. Open for 80 years and owned by the same family, that alone was enough to pull us in. Classic roadside diner feel, big hot dog sign, and a simple, no-nonsense menu: a handful of hot dog options, fries, pickles, a house root beer, and milkshakes. We ordered to go so we could get back on the road. Three hot dogs and two orders of fries, which honestly was more than enough fries for all three of us. The hot dog was solid and satisfying, exactly what you want on a road stop, and the real win here was the value. Our entire order came out to a little over $17, which feels almost unheard of these days. This is a true mom-and-pop spot doing things the way they always have, keeping prices fair and doors open for the community. We were glad we stopped and happy to support a place like this. If you appreciate old-school diners, simple food, and great value, Hot Dog Johnny's is worth pulling over for.

Paulie's Hot Dogs is one of those places you can always count on when you want something simple,…read moresatisfying, and done right. The menu is basic in the best way--classic comfort food that hits the spot every time. The real standout, though, is their disco fries. They are absolutely scrumptious--crispy fries smothered in rich gravy and melty cheese, just the kind of indulgent treat you crave. Nothing fancy here, just solid, reliable food that delivers exactly what you're hoping for.

Good dogs and (a lot) of hand cut fries. Friendly staff and clean establishment…read more All this food and two fountain drinks for under $20. Would definitely return

I just heard the sad news that Andy's Roadside Dive is closing. This is truly sad news and the hot…read moredogs will be missed. I wish all involved the best of luck in their future endeavors.

Wow, what a great find! I first heard of Andy's a few years ago in an article on the best hot dogs…read morein NJ. At the time, Andy's was a food truck, but now Andy has a permanent storefront on Howard Blvd in Mt. Arlington. I tried to stop here previously, but it was closed (note...check the hours, it's closed Tuesday's and Wednesday's). We'll today I got here for lunch, and this place didn't disappoint. For my first visit, I went with a chili/cheese dog and a dog with cooked onions and mustard. Both were outstanding! I dined in, so I had an opportunity to speak with Andy. He explained that all the ingredients are homemade. Andy's been in the hot dog business for 12 years and knows what he's doing. He even reviewed the menu with me and suggested the pulled pork dog. That's on my list for next time! If you like hot dogs, you really need to give Andy's Roadside Dive a shot. It's only a couple of minutes off Rt 80 and definitely worth the trip!