Great pizza and fast service! We had the extra large cheese pizza special and paired it with the steak and cheese hoagie. The pizza was great, but the hoagie was just okay. It was missing the peppers and mushrooms, but otherwise it was good. Very friendly staff! read more

Maisie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Maisie's Pizza is a family-owned and -operated restaurant that opened in 2008. Their foods are available for pickup and for delivery within a 4-mile radius. Menu items include not only pizzas but also appetizers (e.g., fries, jalapeño poppers, and provolone sticks), salads, hoagies, pepperoni rolls, strombolis, calzones, gyros, wings, etcetera. Prices are reasonable. On a Friday afternoon, I ordered food for delivery. I did not see online ordering, so I placed my order over the phone. An employee immediately answered the phone, and he took my order and credit-card numbers. About 45 minutes later, an employee delivered the foods to me on time. He made pleasant conversation about his fun, gigantic pen that I used to sign the receipt, and he said, "Thank you!" Here are my reviews for the foods: Maisie sticks - 4 stars - The online menu describes these Maisie sticks as "thick soft garlic breadsticks with dipping sauce," but the ones that I received were topped with cheese. Did I receive the wrong breadsticks? Well, they tasted good. Cheddar-steak hoagie - 4.5 stars - This hoagie typically contains steak, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, cheddar cheese sauce, but my husband requested no green peppers. The employee correctly made the hoagie without the green peppers. I saw lots of steak and cheese. As my husband ate the hoagie, he said, "Yeah, I like this thing!" Pizza with broccoli - 4.5 stars - I had requested a small pizza with thin crust, but the crust looked more like regular crust. I had chosen a topping of broccoli, and I thought that the employee used a good amount of fresh broccoli. I enjoyed the flavors of this pizza. Garlic wings - 4 stars - I had ordered wings in a garlic flavor. Perhaps I should have chosen a spicier flavor, because my husband described the garlic as the "plainest ever." These wings were cooked well. On the menu, I saw "Jocey Bites," but I did not ask the restaurant what they are. Does anyone here know what "Jocey Bites" are? Thank you! read more

See all

Picked up a Sicilian. Fresh crust but was bland and not a lot of cheese. Was good but underwhelming for the price. Could have ate half a 16 cut myself as was a light pizza. read more

This is an incredible hidden gem and the best pizza around! You would miss Maisie's even when you know it is there because it is hidden in the middle of the strip mall but they have the best pizza, subs, and appetizers around (I recommend the fried mushrooms or zucchini). Every thing is fresh and handmade. I have been a customer here for years and absolutely love them! read more

Great pies and quick, friendly service! We grab the daily XL cheese special and pair it with an app for a meal the feeds the whole family!

Had the XL cheese pie special. This was a great pie. Second day tasted just a good heated up. Never knew the place was there in shopping center. Will go back and try some other items real soon. read more

My go to for a Pittsburgh salad in the north hills. I always get the grilled chicken with ranch and add some sriracha rather than get the deep fried Buffalo chicken tenders which are more standard. Pizza is pretty solid value but the salad gets the 5 every time. Staff is always friendly both on phone, in person, and when delivered. read more

Maisie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I pass this place every day going to PowerHouse gym. I was really craving pizza and did a quick Yelp search. I generally go to another pizza place up the street. Wow! This pizza hit the spot. I called 20 minutes before a Steeler game, thinking it'll take forever, it was done in 15 minutes. Was already ready when I got there. Super fast service. The pizza was full of flavor; the cheese was delicious, sauce was tasty, and dough had a buttery taste to it. It was literally cooked perfectly. Bottom crust and everything was the right golden color. My new go to spot for pizza. Yes a small is small, but I would have eaten an entire large if I order one.... read more

Maisie's Pizza - Small Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Our favorite pizza shop in the North Hills. our normal go to pizza is the Specialty steak pizza.

Hang on, lemme finish chewing.... OK, so Maisie's Pizza in McCandless is the shizz. Had a Meats pizza and Damn! This pie is all the things. This joint is a hole-in-the-wall, y'know like all the best places are - and it's straight-up DUNKING on the pizza game. VERY impressive. In irony, it's like DOORS away from another (puny, mortal) pizza joint, silently laughing all the way. After that first bite, I had to take a good look at the pizza like "where's all THAT tasty coming from?". Seriously, it's the most ordinary-looking pizza, but the crust, sauce and cheese are just PERFECT! The bangin' tomatoey acid from the sauce off-setting the *really good* cheese, sitting on crust you can eat naked. It's just... pizza. But it's GOOD pizza - and that's rare. I don't know who Maisie is, but damn, girl... (*enter innuendo here*) LOL! I got your number baby. Om nom nom! read more

This is one of the best, if not THE best pizza in the city -- and I have tried them all. For sure the best pizza in the North Hills.

First time customer, here and I'm so glad I gave this place a chance! I stumbled across Maisie's as I was searching Yelp and was shocked at how many reviews were actually 5 stars and how few unsatisfied reviews they had. From reading the comments, you can tell that they have a loyal following. I knew I had to try it out. My family and I all had a craving for a good, solid hoagie. We wanted to try somewhere new and not fall back on something we've had plenty of times before. It was Maisie's turn to step up to the plate....and they knocked it out of the park! 3 things stand out about their hoagies: price, ingredients and serving size. They are cheaper than a lot of other places, they're made on Mancini bread (absolute gold), and not stingy with the ingredients. Those hoagies were packed! On top of serving an excellent product, the overall service was pretty pleasant. I called to place my pick-up order and the woman repeated everything back to me and never once sounded rushed. She took the time to do everything the right way. Kudos for that! Unfortunately, I didn't get to try the pizza on my first visit. But I'll be back in a week or two to do exactly that! Maisie's gained a new customer, tonight. JOB WELL DONE! read more

Always good! Love supporting small business. Local gem pizza shop! We love getting the monster pizza for a large crowd!

Relocated here from California and have been looking for a new pizza joint. Well Maisie's Pizza is a place we will go back to. We ordered 2 pizzas and in my opinion some of the best crust we have had. The dough was tasty and the toppings were top notch! They are having a Fall Special $12 for one topping large. Definitely a great price for great pizza. Now I just need an excuse to order sooner than later. read more

My daughter and I stopped after leaving the mall and we loved the pizza! We also had the Italian and Chicken hoagie and enjoyed the taste. Friendly service and great food a perfect combination for local pizza shop. read more

I have driven past this plaza too many times to count and haven't ever noticed maisies. I was missing out!!! We ordered this past Sunday and were really impressed. We got the family deal for $25- large one topping, 12 inch regular hoagie, breadsticks and a two liter. The hoagie was baked- so good. The pizza was very cheesy and fluffy, and the breadsticks were soft with a nice sprinkle of cheese. Overall, definitely will order again! read more

See all

This place is a hidden gem. We ordered the Family Deal (pizza, bread-sticks, hoagie, 2 liter) and it easily fed four adults, and two picky toddlers. The pizza was delicious. It had a good amount of crust, and the sauce/cheese were tasty as well. Bread-sticks were also top notch. Good food at a good price. Can't ask for much more. read more

Really great pizza!! Tried this place as the usual place I order from kept giving a busy signal. I'm glad it worked out this way as I'll definitely be ordering from here again. Food was delivered quickly and was hot - generous with the ranch and marinara. read more

Maisie's Pizza - Medium cheese pizza and breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I got pickup from here this past Saturday evening. Whenever I called I was told that my 2 large pizzas would be ready in 15 minutes. 20 minutes later they were waiting for me whenever I arrived. The shop itself is a small place with very little customer space. Seeing how they do not have a dining area, this is not a problem. The pizza tasted decently with nothing really standing out besides the large amount of cheese on the pizza which I enjoyed. So overall I was satisfied with it. The bottom line for me is that I would come back here again. The pizza was decent and there was nothing bad to say about it. read more

I've been trying to order more from local businesses, and a neighbor recommended Maisie's Pizza to me, so I gave it a try. I checked out their website and saw they had a special going on. For $24.99 you could get a one topping large pizza, an order of breadsticks, a hoagie, and a 2 liter of your choice. I decided to get the special and their appetizer sampler platter for my boyfriend and I that night. They were swamped with orders when I called in, so I just decided to pick up my order, instead of having it delivered. It only took 20 minutes for them to prepare it, which made me quite happy. The aroma that this food gave off after I picked it up was absolutely wonderful! The pizza was spectacular. I definitely enjoyed it! The breadsticks and marinara dipping sauce were a bit disappointing. The sauce wasn't to my liking, and the breadsticks were a bit dry and bland. The sandwich (according to my boyfriend) was excellent. The appetizer sampler was superb! They actually gave us extra breaded zucchini just for coming in and picking up our food instead of having it delivered! Very nice place! I'm definitely going to have to order from here again! read more

See all

Excellent pizza in the north. Prompt. Convenient pickup location. Friendly staff. Takeout only, but outcompetes the other regular places.

We got one cheese pizza and we were in heaven it was amazing . Planning on going there again soon.

I have been ordering from Maisie's for years and never had a bad experience. The food is always good. And I have turned coworkers onto it also. read more

Good crust of pizza. We Like it. Different from other pizzas. We ordered first time a month or two back.

Recently heard about Maisie's and figured we would try a few things, pepperoni pizza, pepperoni roll & steak hoagie, also homemade ranch. Everything was good and the prices were very reasonable. Would consider ordering again. read more

Maisie's Pizza - XL pizza & ranch - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

First time ordering here as we are semi new to the north hills/McCandless area. We like to try new places and see what we like. We got a meatball calzone and pepperoni Sicilian pizza. Absolutely delicious! My husband is very picky when it comes to pizza. He said the crust is just perfect because it's not too thick. Also loved how stuffed the calzone was. Not all bread as some places are. We have definitely found our new pizza place. Prices seemed fair too! read more

This was the first time using Maisie's Pizza ,but it won't be the last I ordered 2 x large double cheese pies, everyone raved how delish they were, I have found my " new place" next on the list will be steak hoagies, reviews on the hoagies were outstanding, I can't believe I just found this gem, try them, you won't regret it. read more

We had this pizza for a birthday party. It was your average pizza. It had average cheese and the sauce was ok. It wasn't the best I have ever had but it's ok. It was expensive since we didn't have any coupons and the venue we were at ordered it. Some people at the party liked it and others didn't. I would say it's average, not bad or awesome. read more

Masie's pizza is pretty good, not much different than any other pizza joint. I loved the fried mushrooms most.

Our hungry crew ordered delivery after NA commencement and it was delicious! It arrived in under 45 minutes and it was hot and the price was a bargain. This was our 1st time ordering with them and we will definitely do it again!! read more

If you live in the north hills area, give Maisie's a try the next time you order pizza. Haven't had a slice of pepperoni this decent in quite some time. I was pleasantly surprised when I was told my total over the phone and satisfied when the delivery came in a speedy fashion. read more

My coworkers and I love Maisie's! We work in the area and regularly order from here! The delivery is quick and they are always very nice! We love their hoagies (Italian) and the pepperoni rolls are amazing! Support local small businesses like this one! Great food, great prices! read more

Amazing hoagies. Their Pepperoni rolls are more like calzones, which is a happy surprise. The cheddar poppers on their menu are like Jalapeno poppers without the firey lava greens inside, and were a hit with my elementary schooler. It's a small little mom and pop type place and that may be a little off putting for dine-in, but man the takeout is worth it! read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would this dumb manager was arguing with my mom saying that we lived to far away .... we live in Ross right by Ross elementary literally 10-15 minutes in rush hour traffic this lady was saying we live an hour away we live parallel to perry highway 2 roads over you literally get off perry highway to Babcock then on to McKnight.... she said they can't deliver more than 4 miles on my maps app and every other gps app I have it says 3.5 to 3.8 miles and that's not even the fastest routes... on the website it says they deliver to ROSS, west view, and mccandless and most of maccandless is further than we live .... the only reason why we even order here is because my grandmother who lives with us likes their one kind of pizza that is all nothing else there is good so congrats Maisie's Pizza u make one almost okay tasting pizza and now you have upset an elderly lady .... I honestly think this manager was just looking for a fight or her employees who are mostly teens are stopping and texting and using their Phones or just driving around trying to find the longest route to our house just so they don't have to go back to work with her read more

Best Italian Hoagies anywhere!! Delivery is fast. Prices are great. We got tired of Adrian's and Vocelli's and one slice of meat on their hoagies. Haven't had their pizza, but the hoagies are great! read more

Don't let the location - a modest strip mall in suburbia - fool you. This is the best pizza in Pittsburgh. Seriously. The sauce and crust cannot be beat. I stumbled upon the place because of an Entertainment Book coupon, and it has been my go to pizza place since. My dad is very picky, and this is his favorite pizza too. So much so that he asks for me to bring it home when I visit (3 hours away). It's a carry out only little shop, so don't expect a table service. You won't need it. It smells so good, you'll have a slice before you get home. read more

Best hoagies in Pittsburgh hands down. Try the steak or italian, also fried chicken is great. Can't go wrong with Maisie's Pizza.

While waiting for jewelry repair last year, found Maisie's pizza and was surprised at how good it was. Nice people and great pizza!! Have ordered it several times for delivery since discovering and would recommend it highly. read more

This pizza is always delicious! Sometimes when I order pizza from other places, it is made different depending on the pizza maker. It is always the same here. Perfect! Hoagies are amazing, too. Great specials & quick service. read more

Our absolute favorite pizza!! They make THE BEST buffalo chicken pizza!! Highly recommend!!