I used to frequent MB when it was owned by the previous owners. Several days each week I would drive from my home in Great Neck, and pick up my order of half a dozen egg sandwiches on toasted bagels or a pound of lox cream cheese and a pound of veggie cream cheese. This ritual went on from 2015 - 2019. My family and I loved the food from MB. Fast forward to 2020 and now my family and I live in Manhasset. MB has a different owner and the quality in my opinion has gone south. The bagels now are bigger but are way too dough. I recently purchase a pound of lox cream cheese and there was barely 2 or 3 little oueces of fish in the pound of cream cheese. The sausage, egg and cheese and bacon, egg and cheese bagel sandwiches leaves a lot to desire. My kids now get all their breakfast sandwiches from Orlando's. When it comes to our hankering for yummy bagels, we go out of our way and hit Munsey Park Bagels on Northern Blvd. MPB has a wide variety of freshly made bagels. They have the freshest lox, veggie, scallion and jalapeno cream cheese available anywhere. In fact you actually taste the delicious smoky lox in every schmear and bite. Their tunafish salad is to die for and is always fresh and reminds me of the tunafish salad my mom used to make when I was growing up. The only thing better than the food at Munsey Patk Bagel are the people who work there! read more

Best NY-style bagel I had in this area of Long Island. Had an egg bagel with cream cheese, and it was fluffy and flavorful. Sat inside to eat, but not a lot of tables to choose from. Every bagel place in the NY-area feels like they have to make a black and white cookie, and they don't. I'm a big fan of B&W's and cake icing doesn't belong on this cookie (texture-wise), yet the flavor of the black and the white side was pretty mellow (which was good). The cake bottom was too thick and a little too dry. read more

See all

Delicious chicken salad . Bagels are great. Big and soft . Really enjoyed the food. Also their muffins are amazing!

Love these bagels. They are our go to bagel spot. Sandwiches are good too, try the chopped cheese.

I don't live in Manhasset, my town has more bagel shops that any town needs ... and still I always travel to Manhasset for these bagels. For many years now. Always delicious. Great texture, great flavor. My favorite, hands down. I'd include a picture if I didn't just devour my everything bagel! read more

I went it in and the customer service was just ok. I ordered a a bagel with cream cheese and they literally just scraped the CC on my bagel. read more

Manhasset Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

I feel good writing this because I have been there many times and finally penning this long overdue review. I am really happy with this shop.. It's not far from my workplace and I have had the opportunity to dine in and many times takeout lunch to eat back at my office too. It's a nice bright shop with a friendly team. I really never new the old owners so I can not compare. The bagels here are always fresh and tasty. I always remark that I like these "plump" bagels. I would not feel the same if they were not as soft and fresh as there are. Plenty of types to choose from too. My standard goto sandwich is always a tuna on bagel. The tuna fish salad is fresh and tasty and not over-run with mayonnaise. This makes a huge difference, even if you like mayonnaise as much as me. You can really taste the tuna. To make it even better they give you a small portion of macaroni salad (or whatever you want) and some pickle. A perfect meal... Kudos to the team at Manhasset Bagels. read more

Manhasset Bagels - A terrific tuna on a bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

The bagel was ok , skimpy butter and skimpy cheese and it was a touch over 6 dollars. Has the world gone insane ? Have I been asleep for 40 years ? The bagel is listed for under 2 dollars , so the electricity to toast , a half ounce of butter and two skinny slices of American cheese adds 4 dollars ? I just should have said no. I will not return , just cannot do it. If we all stood up to this insanity , it would stop and please don't tell me the rent is high. Sorry but I had to say something. read more

We order 4 breakfast items from here on Father's Day but they gave my order to someone else before I got there. The employees didn't tell me this until I had paid for the order and was waiting for 10 minutes. After waiting 20 minutes and multiple people coming in after me receiving their orders before me we decided to cancel the order. The employees never apologized and actually thought it was humorous. We received a refund with attitude and left. We gave the store another chance and ordered delivery from here last weekend and there was an eggshell in my omelet.... We won't be going back here. read more

I'm very selective of how I want my bagels. I like them toasted with the butter melted and a small amount of grape jelly ... however Manhasset Bagels are so fresh they didn't need to be toasted , my bagel arrived warm with this sweet butter that you can still slightly see which I got upset about at first but when I bite into it , I was pleasantly surprised. The bagel was so fresh and soft and sweet I was blown away. Also our tea arrived still very hot which was impressive as well. The only bad thing is there delivery time , it took over an hour to receive. I would 100% order from them again in a heart beat . Definitely one of the freshest bagels I have gotten in a very long time . 2/25 - update : I ordered a egg sandwich and I was kinda disappointed I wasted egg and cheese on a bagel with bacon so we ordered 2 sandwiches , my mothers came out perfect and my sandwich had like bacon bits and it was falling apart . I don't know i wasn't really happy to be honest read more

Manhasset Bagels - 2 Eggs with Bacon Breakfast - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

Best bagels & deli on the planet!!! Reggie is the best and his staff will treat you like family!! Everything so Fresh & Delicious!!! I visit several times a week they have so many good foods to choose from!!! Highly Recommended!!! read more

Manhasset Bagels - BLT!!! - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

Not quite the quintessential NY bagel. Something is missing or not quite right. That said, the bagels delivered were full of toppings, fresh, heavy, large and delicious. I was very happy with the product and suggest you give it a try. Please note, this review is exclusively on the bagels. read more

Large selection of bagels early in the morning, they are definitely ready. The bagels themselves were on the larger side, lacked a bit of the chewiness from the better ny bagels and didn't keep as well in the fridge as leftovers. They seemed to dry out a bit faster. read more

This is round 2 of deli reviews that I've consumed a ton of times, but have never actually stepped into said establishment (shout out to Harbor Deli). I'm not sure when or why, but we (co-workers and I) used to take out from that aforementioned quoted delicatessen whenever we were celebrating a birthday. This year, things have switched to Manhasset Bagels. I can't say I see (or taste) much of a difference, but consider that a positive as it's just as good. I'm a creature of habit and often if I find something I like, I stick with it (just ask the other deli we frequent: Orlando's). At Manhasset Bagels, our call-in order is basically one of two items for me. When we first started the switch, I would go with The Mikey L. This was a super tasty wrap of flavorful proportions. Grilled chicken with broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomatoes, garlic and oil. If you don't like rabe, then this isn't for you, but me and this veggie are like two peas in a pod (odd to use a vegetable to describe another vegetable). Just know the tastes balance out perfectly. More recently, the last four or five times now, I've moved away from Mikey L and have gotten to know Frankie Knuckles. It sounds like I'm hangin' out with some low level mobsters! But seriously, Frankie Knuckles is another quality wrap with grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, tomato, fried onions, avocado, and italian dressing. Put avocado on anything and you've got a winner, but add fried onions (and these are some quality fried onions), and you'll fall in love with Frankie (from a sandwich standpoint). Honestly, Manhasset Bagels' quality comes close to five-star calibur. The problemo with the place is in the factors that lie outside its walls. What I mean is their delivery ain't the best. We have an early lunch period at work so I understand the timing might not always jive, but on more than one occasion, there have been a few snafus (i.e. arguments) about delivery times and not having drivers and not being able to guarantee when they'll come and so on and so forth and blah blah blah. It's a bit of a turn off when you don't know if your lunch is going to make it in time for lunch. Luckily, these issues don't happen every time, but it's something to seriously consider when ordering. Overall, Manhasset Bagels is a superb lunch spot in tastes (and I'm guessing their bagels might be good too?). We'll continue to order in from there as long as the delivery can hold up to it's slightly-above-par abilities. Maybe one day I'll enter through its doors and buy some grub in person which might up the celestial total, but until then, consider this a pretty solid four star situation. read more

Manhasset Bagels - The Mikey L. If you like broccoli rabe, then you'll love this thing. - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

I ordered eggs, spinach, and feta on a plain wrap. I received eggs and feta on a whole wheat wrap. How do you mess up all of 4 ingredients? And for the ambience, very unprofessional and uncomfortable. They are rude and unwelcoming. read more

order few bagels and bread, I'm always their loyalty customer for few years. All of their bread are very soft and fresh. Specially the chocolate bread which is my favorite. They also keep pick up service during COVID-19 that make more safety I will keep supporting their business and hope they keep doing well read more

Manhasset Bagels - Love it - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

This place is horrible! They are extremely unprofessional and they're food is always way below average. I called to make a small request for my order and the woman on the phone was so rude and started yelling at me. She could have easily just explained nicely that they don't offer that. I will definitely not be going back! Please avoid, there are so many other better places that have bagels that actually taste like bagels. read more

So haven't been here for over 4 years... new owners .... first thing I notice is this place is not clean. Place does not look taken care of. It's kind of amazing people go here still, since most of Manhasset is so boujie .....but bagels still are bad so that why the 2 star rating and probably why they still have customers still. read more

This place is awesome!! We brought about 4 dozen bagels back from NY to San Diego to share with our neighbors and they were ready for our return. Also, we had Manhasset Bagels make a sandwich to take on the plane to eat on our trip home and everyone on the flight wanted that sandwich! The staff is polite, and they seem to know their customers very well. We also had a bacon, egg & cheese breakfast sandwich before heading for the airport and that was a full sandwich that tasted great! We love this place!! read more

Large order on a Sunday, but it was all a hit! Everything bagel, toasted with a lox spread is alway my choice and they knock it out all the time. Love the generous servings and that the seasoning is both on the bottom and top...but could use more garlic and salt on the actual seasoning read more

When I do get a breakfast sandwich I normally get turkey, egg and swiss on a roll with gravy so my first time here I wanted to see how theirs measured up to my usual spot. The roll was fresh, the eggs cooked perfectly but the gravy...the solidifier fell short for me. It wasn't as dark nor as rich in flavor and a tad bit too oniony. On top of that it was $2 more than my place. Rest assured I will be back because the bagels and cream cheese options looked out of this world which clearly by name is their specialty. So my faux pas but not really because I still enjoyed my sandwich. read more

Manhasset Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

My husband picks up bagels here. It's fresh, large ...delicious. I usually grab my bagels in the city (Tal Bagels) and Manhasset Bagels are just great too. We normally get their scallion cream cheese. Great place for the neighborhood. read more

Great bagel store conveniently located on Plandome Road in Manhasset. Best bagels on the North Shore- hand rolled with generous coatings of seeds 8n a wide variety of s Flavors. Excellent smoked fish and salads. Excellent muffins too. read more

Argh! They messed up the order again! None of the bagels were toasted like they were supposed to be. Okay guys I have to ding you one star, I love your bagels but you really need to work on your quality control! read more

Well, Another disaster after years of great service! Been going there for years, live in the area and it was always a very comfortable place with great bagels and service! So before I get started let just say, the young African American teenager who is taking the orders in this place is absolutely the star in this place!! He's is kind and understands customer service! Placed my order over the phone, got there and the order was 16 dollars.. I noticed the place was empty at 7:30am where it was normally packed under the old owners! Anyway, after being in the food business for 40 years,you tend to pick up on things, like their whole wheat bagels aren't whole wheat any longer, they are oat bran dough without the actual oat bran on the bagel!Its a great way to cut cost I guess?? Anyway, it's the only bagel I eat and it was horrible! But that wasn't the worse part, my order was 16 dollars, so I swiped my card, and then I noticed a muffin I thought my kid would like. After the woman who was taking care of me was done speaking to the other lone customer in the place, while taking care of me, told me that even though I just spent 16 dollars, buying the muffin was now a separate transaction and I should purchase the muffin with cash?, because I would need to spend at least 5 dollars to use my card again????? She obviously was off her meds, because when she told me that, instead of saying, ok, I can do it this one time, because we know your a regular, but moving forward, this is our policy, I would have gladly agreed!!! BUT, I took the muffin and gave it back to her, and wished her luck, because they will certainly need it!! Manhasset is a tight knit area, and now I will never go back and I will let others know how stupid she sounded. They got rid of everything and everyone who use to work there. The bagels aren't as good more, and the egg sandwiches are weak and tasteless.,but they have no issue charging whatever, like 3 dollars for a medium coffee!!!It use to be a place where you could run in and get an ice coffee and everyone was there from the neighborhood. I understand that the new owners want to hire who they want but just because you can afford to buy the store, doesn't give you any qualifications on running the store. Tell the new owner to get back into his place, and stop staying home looking at the stock market in your draws! There is no way your place should be empty on a Wednesday morning at that time, with 2 take out orders on the wall and 1 of them was mine!! Over a muffin you lost a good customer and I will make sure, friends and neighbors get the hint! You can't just assume, hey, Manhasset has money, and they will spend it here, so let's give them crap!!! Like I told the woman who didn't know how to serve me, Good luck, you will need it!!!BTW-THE PICTURES ON YOUR YELP ACCOUNT AREN'T YOURS, THEY WERE LEFT THERE FROM THE OLD OWNERS WHO WHERE COOKS AND CHEFS.......STOP MISLEADING THE PUBLIC read more

Working close by so i decided to order from Manhasset Bagels. Bagels fresh. Bagel sandwich was greasy but tasty. I asked for toasted Bialey...not toasted. Delivery was fast. Delivery person not friendly... read more

amazing quality, friendly staff. couldn't recommend enough! we want three days in a row and it was excellent each time. the cream cheese is incredible read more

I gotta tell ya. I didn't believe my husband when he said you guys named a sandwich after him. I googled you and found out it's the truth. 5/5. Will carry this legend on for generations to come. read more

Manhasset Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

Ordered for pick up for Yom Kippur 2020. The process was extremely organized. I showed up at my pick up time and all of my food was ready. They went through my order with me to make sure nothing was missing. The bagels were delicious and I particularly like their tuna salad. There is always plenty of street parking nearby. read more

Not the same since the new ownership. Bagels are good but service and attitude leaves a lot to be desired.

Tried their bagels once. Not a fan of it. Bagel was barely toasted and they put way too much cream cheese. Coffee was good though! read more

Inedible bagels. Tried twice both terrible go elsewhere. Many good places in Long Island.

Hand rolled doesn't get any better than that !!! Food is fresh call in on a weekend to save time on the line read more

Manhasset Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Manhasset, New York

Phenomenal bagels probably the best I've ever tasted. Dangerously good! Doughy and big. Unbelievable with scallion cream cheese and nova (swoon!). read more

The BEST BAGELS ever!!!! Stop wasting your time and money anywhere else, and start going to Manhasset Bagels to enjoy the best bagels you have ever had. Somehow they keep getting better and better. In addition, being able to order online and on the phone literally can save you so much time, because the line is usually out the door and calling or ordering ahead gives you the bagel-fast-pass. It doesn't get any better. read more

Love that they have mini bagels in different flavors. Mini bagels are really big! Love this place!

Best bagels on Long Island. They nail it every time. It's a real New York bagel. They can be a bit pricey, but I guess that's what happens when you have to pay rent in Manhasset. read more

I've been going to this store for years and the new owners are doing a GREAT job! I used to dread how I would be treated by the old staff, now I genuinely look forward to my experience as a customer. The bagels are the best, They are fast and my order is always correct. What more do you want out of a bagel shop? read more

This place must be Under New Management because the food one from just okay to unbelievable... Fresh and delivered in plastic containers so you can eat the next day... Really nice size portions. Has to be New Management. read more

Excellent bagels and totally worth the 20 minute drive! We had the onion bagel with lox spread and the raisin bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese...freshly made and perfect with a cup of coffee! Look forward to trying some of the other options next time. read more