Food and service was great!! 100% would recommend! The scene was great, furniture clean, everything was perfect! I would definetly visit again. read more

We bought a small birthday cake when we visited our daughter in Manhasset. We ordered is on-line. The cake was delicious, perfect buttercream icing and a cake that was not dry, but moist and good to the last bite. Great service, friendly staff, and ready when promised. Thank you read more

We ordered a Tres Leches cake for my mom's birthday as she requested. Everyone really enjoyed the cake! However, I was a bit disappointed because I expected fruit on top, but it was only included inside the cake. The pickup service was fast, though the ordering process was a bit difficult. I called on Thursday to place the order, but the woman who answered told me she couldn't take it and that I had to speak specifically to Diego on Friday. Diego took my order. I assumed all tres leches cake have fruit at the top. Diego didn't ask either so it could have just been a miscommunication The store itself was very clean. Compramos un pastel de tres leches para mi mamá porque ella lo pidió. A todos les gustó mucho el pastel, sin embargo, pensé que tendría fruta por fuera (encima); solo traía fruta por dentro. El servicio fue rápido cuando fui a recogerlo. Llamé el jueves para hacer el pedido, pero la señora que me atendió dijo que no podía tomarlo y que tenía que hablar con Diego el viernes. Diego no me preguntó nada de la Fruita encima del pastel. Yo pensé que todos los pasteles de tres leches eran así. La tienda estaba limpia. read more

See all

Love some of the bakery goods, but i love to come here to the store because: In the past, there'd be two lines, one at the display case and another for coffee. This is a really great bakery. Everything is fresh and very tasty. They even added a section where you can eat. I recommend that everyone read more

See all

Had my sister grab me some treats after following this place on Instagram for a while. The good: the chocolate chip muffin was outstanding and so was the jelly donut. Both very fresh and delicious and friendly service. The not so good: wrong items. I was looking forward to their crumb cake my sister asked for it 3 times and somehow gave us a pumpkin cream pastry instead? I don't love pumpkin so I was very disappointed. Also the place is pricey which I get it's Manhasset I wouldn't have minded but I mind when I get the wrong items and not what I want. The pie was ok it wasn't the best pie or the worse it was lacking a bit in the flavor department. Overall, I'd return but double check if I got the right items before leaving. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Apple pie - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

Cute bakery with a whole lot of pastry options! Perfect place for a quick breakfast/brunch, they have plenty of tables to dine at. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

We had several pastries and everyone was a hit. Can't wait to try the cakes. Coffee and tea were delicious.

Looking so much forward to try this awesome bakery that I have visited hundreds of times in new Hyde Park. I saw the photo in newsday of their awesome pancakes, check out the photo it clearly doesn't look like the one in newsday. I had the burrito which was delightful. And the coffee was spot on and not too burnt like Starbucks. I generally judge the restaurant by the number of cars in the parking lot and the number of people in the restaurant. This was Sunday morning, and we were the only one there. It's clearly a one and done café. read more

See all

Went to buttercooky to get some sweet treats to celebrate and did not regret it. The tres leches cake (which is my favorite) was delicious, moist and perfectly sweet. The fruits as well were fresh. Everyone loved this cake it was finished that same night! I recommend 100% The chocolate mousse was also the cutest thing! It was not overwhelmingly chocolate and was amazing as well. If you're a chocolate fan, you need to try it! Overall, I definitely will be back and the tres leches cake WILL BE my birthday cake this year read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Chocolate Mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

Ordered a custom cake from here for a friends birthday. The cake came out amazing, service was prompt and they were flexible when my dates changed overall great experience and would order again. read more

See all

I live here. Enough said. Lobster tails are what dreams are made of. I also love to get the strawberry shortcake's for parties.

The iced cafe latte was unusually good--better than what I usually get at most other coffeehouses. I ordered it decaf, unsweetened and unflavored. The barista used the Corsica blend of La Colombe coffee, and I could taste its strong chocolate notes. It was velvety smooth and slightly acidic. I would not start my day any other way again. I am now going on lacolumbe.com to buy the beans to brew at home. The Buttercooky Bakery is in a location that is relatively big for dine-in purposes. The tables are spaced well, and there is plenty of seating. It is a good place to sit with a book or laptop. There is WiFi and plenty of plugs, too. The service is quick, the staff is friendly, and the prices are on par with competing bakeries. read more

See all

Came here for lunch with a friend. It is a bakery cafe. Lots of pastries to choose from. We ordered lunch at the counter. Prices were somewhat reasonable. My sandwich was very good and it came with a little salad. The chai latte was delish. There is only street parking available and you can park on the side streets. Decent amount of seating. Service was friendly and efficient. Will have to try the pastries next time! read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Chicken Garlic sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

The breads and pastries are delicious-so many different varieties available. Great place to grab a treat and a drink

Custom cake not what I ordered-no response from owner Such a disappointment! I ordered a custom cake for my granddaughter's baby naming at Manhasset Buttercooky. I chose a cake directly from their catalog at the store. However, the cake I received looked nothing like the one I ordered. See the pix below! The sales person said the cake would be 5 inches tall but the one I received was no more than 3 inches. The flowers were tiny instead of big and beautiful, and the bright pink that they added did not go with our decor. The custard filling was almost nonexistent. I tried numerous times to get in touch with the owner, but he was never available. I emailed him and never received a response. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - This is the cake I received - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

Stale pastry. Tasted old with a hint of soap. Looked fresh but went right into trash can after first bite. I am disgusted. This place used to be quality years ago. A shame what has happened. Will never return. read more

3.5 We found out no more savory food when we got there around 4:15pm. Too bad, my mom was missing their quiche. Our group ended up getting a few dessert pieces and sharing them, with coffees and teas. Our picks were the Earl Gray eclair and plain cheesecake - we did like them- didn't find them too sweet. So much to choose from but prices are not labeled so have to ask for each item. They still call out when order is ready. Place is clean and modern. Restroom available. read more

See all

One of the older women who works there doesn't know how to pull the draft oat milk lattes, and the cup ends up half full after the foam quickly settles. This is the second time it's happened, and it only happens when one woman does it. When I questioned it, she says that's how it's supposed to be, but it comes out normally every other time. I was in a huge rush, so I didn't have time to argue with her. The photo below makes it look like there is even more in the cup because my dashboard tilts toward me. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Really poor pull on an oat milk draft latte. This is "full". - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

Outstanding service and advice !! Will definitely go back Strongly recommend for any special occasion or just a cup of coffee with a colorful delicious deasert read more

Amazing ambiance and great food and beverage options! This cafe is spacious and also has dependable WiFi. And the staff are very warm and friendly. Don't miss it! read more

great options nice and quiet the eggs is very good The croissant egg sandwich was delicious I love this restaurant read more

This place is an absolute overpriced joke. I placed an order for delivery and got the completely wrong items. when I called the manager to tell him what happened, he told me he does not believe me and that I'm lying. His exact words were " I trust my packer". I spent $60 on my order and was told that they wouldn't help me. do yourself a favor guys and don't eat or even go to this establishment. read more

Solid bakery. There are many variety of cakes, pasties and cookies. It is very spacious inside with plenty of seats available . The staff are friendly and helpful as well. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Fresh Fruit Tart - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

I really love the cakes cake and I buy one once a month! But I'm so shocked how cheap their workers are. I took 6 forks for a $36 cake and the worker didn't let me take it! Which is insane ..: won't be back ... they're so greedy. Paris baguette offers candles, and a good quality knife for free.. read more

Was surprised that a for a more high end bakery that the people working there were picking up the desserts with their bare hands ungloved. There's small little cardboard underneath but it's barely enough to put their fingers on it. I also found the choosing and purchasing process BEYOND frustrating. I was looking for something that didn't have food coloring and didn't have raw eggs (I.e. custard) I had to ask one by one by one (seriously how do you not know anything about your pastries?) and the two different people I worked with (I guess one went on break in middle of taking my order?) were absolutely clueless as to the ingredients, and constantly had to ask a third person. At least he knew. But it made the process much much longer than it needed to be. In the end I made my purchases finally!! But before I picked up my bag from the counter I looked at the receipt and realized they charged for an extra pastry! When I inquired what was in there it was an item that I said I'm not sure I wanted and needed to check with X person if they wanted it. I never said I wanted it. Instead of removing the item immediately, they made me wait about ten minutes. Ten minutes!!!! And I was at the counter!! I didn't leave and come back in. There wasn't a line. Ten minutes with a little one Just to take an item out of the box. In hindsight I should have just left. And for some reason they instead removed all my pastries (ungloved) and put it in a smaller box new box. Not sure why but maybe to keep them from sliding? Now the dessert, sugar! Literally all sugar zero flavor. So much sugar!! I ate one pastry and was so nauseous from all the sugar. There was nothing tasty about it. They look beautiful but wow zero flavor and just sugar. They get 1.5 stars because it is a nice quiet place to sit both indoor and outdoors. In the past we looked into having a birthday cake made there. They have some unique options. The process itself was such a turn off. They had us standing at the counter with a very wriggly baby to show us items. There was an entire counter between us and the whole process felt so cold. Plus we weren't even speaking to the person who makes the cake. I found it odd that they didn't even sit us down. And when we asked for a small sample of just the filling we were told we need to purchase it. For the price of the cake they seriously couldn't go back there and put a small bit on a spoon for us to taste?!? read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Lotus (and eaten satan & silk) - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

There's been a decline since my last visit. Pastries (carrot cake, in particular) are less fresh, the service less personal and prices are higher. I got 4 pastries, a sandwich and iced coffee. I would skip next time. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Chocolate Hazelnut mousse cake - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

Stopped on a whim for some pastries and was pleasantly surprised at the variety of options they offer. Space looks newly renovated and spacious. I got the pistachio chocolate croissant and the fruit tart croissant which were both delicious! I will definitely be back to try the savory items read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

I came here for a networking lunch on a Tuesday afternoon and it was a great experience. The place is so trendy and clean. It is a pleasant place to work while sipping on coffee. I ordered the grilled chicken avocado salad and it was to die for. The ingredients tasted fresh and it was delicious. However, it was $18 for a salad but I understand its manhasset. I would come back just come to ve prepared to spend. read more

Had a great first experience stopping by this bakery to grab a quick and small birthday cake for my SIL. the line was short and the variety was quite generous. they have many options for baked good as well as a new brunch menu with many seats to sit down and enjoy. The small confetti cake was very enjoyable but I was more impressible with the peaches and cream tart. It was killer! I wish I bought ten of them. Will definitely come back here to try to the cold brew on tap one day. read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

First of all, the cakes, pastries, and cookies are very delicious and beautifully presented. You can also sit in a lovely interior and enjoy a hot cup of coffee. read more

Chocolate cigar excellent. Coffee excellent. Highly recommend both. Service great too.

Best danish, rugelach, cakes and nicest people All 3 bakeries they have are yummy Best bakery in Long Island read more

Beautiful bakery. Everything looks delicious, including the design-/layout. Great coffee. Not happy that I had to Tetris my garbage into a huge overflowing pile of debris. Also, three desserts barely meh; mini fruit tart was ok, Whole Foods makes a better tart. Crumb cake looked great, inside fluffy, outside hard and flavorless; lastly jelly cronut was filled with great jelly, but the outside was so hard it could have been used as a weapon. If the dessert isn't awesome, tell the customer to get something else. Coffee wonderful. read more

Ordered the most beautiful napoleon cake for a surprise 80th birthday. Once it was cut and served two pieces had hair wrapped inside of the cake. I called immediately from the celebration from embarrassment only to be told the manager was on his break and will call me back in 5 minutes. No return phone call and an hour later when I called back, he left for the day. read more

We visited Buttercooky to buy some desserts before heading home. It was about half hour before closing; however the staff did not make us feel rushed or unattended. As you can see, the desserts are beautiful and the flavors are incredible. There is a very spacious and clean seating area and the decor is adorable. We bought the honeycomb, strawberry shortcake, silk n' satin, Biscoff, fruit tart, and seven layer. They all tasted just as good as they look. I also love reading the descriptions of each one. They make you want to try everything! My personal favorites were the Biscoff and silk n' satin. They also offer cookie trays, macarons, coffee, and even savory meal options that can be ordered off the overhead menu. I got the vanilla oat milk draft latte. It wasn't too sweet and I finished it within 15 minutes. The flavor notes aren't anything too unique but something about it made me want to keep drinking. I'd probably visit every day to try a new pastry and coffee combo if I lived nearby. read more

See all

The variety is amazing. All sorts of baked goods and desserts for all tastes. Service was prompt and friendly. All the desserts we got were so yummy. Glad we found this place! read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

I got a delicious sourdough grilled cheese with perfectly cooked French fries and a salad. Afterwards I needed a jelly donut and it was the right call. Yummy!! read more

I used to come here so often when I worked in Manhasset and it's been a long time since I've been back and they haven't disappointed. We stopped off because we were in the neighborhood and their selection of croissants is great. There's something for everyone with a range from regular croissants to Nutella and red velvet. We got berry custard croissants and they were great, not too sweet as the berries were tart, it was a perfect balance. The gingerbread Hot Chocolate was delicious too read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Berries & Cream Croissant - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

Went to lunch with a friend and wanted to try the Valentine's Day hot chocolate. I ordered the breakfast wrap and hot chocolate and both were delicious! The hot chocolate itself was really good and adorably put together, but there was too much whipped cream/frosting on it. Half the cup was frosting and half the cup was hot chocolate. The staff are extremely attentive and the line moves very quickly. It is a cute spot with a good amount of tables for indoor dining. I suggest giving them a try! read more

Buttercooky Bakery - Valentine's Day Hot Chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - Manhasset, New York

See all

They have amazing bagels! And the people here are so nice, do come! It is such a lovely and cute and pretty and quaint bakery!!!