After a full day of skiing, my family of 6 was hungry. We decided to order out and get pizza. The girl taking our order was friendly on the phone. Mario's has a HUGE sign across from a cute small town's square. I had a feeling we were I for a treat. Our Sicilian pizza with pepperoni and olives was so good! It reminded me of what our neighbour would bake for us when we were kids. It was absolutely delicious and satisfying. I would not have expected a Sicilian pizza this good from a small town pizzeria! Pleasantly surprised! Highly recommend to other others. (Interior is on the cozy side, but isn't weird if you choose to eat in. ) read more

Best in NEPA by far! We had the grandmas Sicilian (get the thin crust! ) and a margarita and both were perfect! Small shop so be prepared but I don't think I've had better up here read more

Pathetically small large pizza very light on cheese and sauce and a large crusty edge! I would estimate it cost a whole buck to make this pie. I have to say the service was very good hence the two stars. With plenty of pizza shops in the area you'd think they would do some investigating on the competition! read more

Good pizza, good cheesesteaks, nice little pizza shop. They get very busy and it's no secret why.

This is one of the best pizza shops! The employees are nice, delightful and very friendly. We drive there all the time to have their famous Nutella Pizza! This is a highly recommend for me! read more

Great meal after a long drive from Philly. Good customer service too. Just wish they had a smaller size pie for the individual traveler like me. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered a grilled chicken sandwich, simple right. Menu stated it can with lettuce tomato and bacon. I said no lettuce or tomato. They must have ran out of bacon and replaced it with 1/2 a pound of onion. Also got a turkey club. No bacon. And the tiny boneless wings are a joke for what you pay for them. Horrible read more

Mario's Pizza - Boneless wings from the tiniest chicken ever - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

See all

Decided to try this local place for the first time last night. Called in my order for a small pizza and chicken Caesar wrap. They said 25 minutes. Arrived at the drive through window after 30 minutes and was told it wasn't quite ready and could I park across the street. After being overcharged by about $8 according to the listed prices on the website, charged for fries that I didn't order, and double charged for the extra side of dressing for the wrap, I waited an additional 15 minutes for the food. If the food was good, I probably wouldn't be writing this review, but the pizza crust was paper thin and very dry with a small sprinkling of mushrooms in the very middle of the pie. Still ready to let it slide until I tried the wrap which I had picked up for today's lunch. The tortilla was burnt around the edges and the first bite I took had brown lettuce in it so I decided to open it up and try to at least salvage the chicken. What I found were three tiny pieces of chicken and the rest was a pile of soggy croutons! I called and asked to speak with the owner who told me they have always made their wraps with croutons and all wraps come with fries, even though the menu lists two different prices. No offer to replace the wrap or refund the overpayment. First and last time I will spend money here. Almost $30 for a disappointing, small one topping pie and totally inedible wrap. read more

Biked over from Jim Thorpe. Hoping it was a step above the regular pizza you can get everywhere. Good Pizza is meaningful for me. The Grandma slice was very good, classic,crispy, thin crust, perfect sauce, nicely flavored. Up with the great NJ places. Meatball parmigiana, baked, airy roll, meatballs beefy with nominal filler, light ratio of cheese and good sauce. I asked for an extra side of sauce as they were careful to not overload it, no problem. Clean interior, nicely decorated, comfortable to eat in. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

See all

Came in a little before 1pm on a Tuesday during the winter holiday. The restaurant was empty but boy were we happy to have found this gem. The place was and felt clean. The service was attentive and friendly. The pizza was amazing, NY style thin crust cheesy and crunchy. All the ingredients tasted fresh never frozen. We also had an order of mozzarella sticks with marina sauce that was also very yummy. Mario's is definitely worth a visit if in the area. read more

My wife, 2-year old, and I walked from Jim Thorpe to Weissport and were happy to find a great pizza place for lunch. The manager was very friendly and the German pizza he made for us was delicious. Pepperoni sounded like a strange combination with the other ingredients but the spice it added was phenomenal. We'd definitely recommend Mario's to anyone looking for friendly service and good pizza. read more

Mario's Pizza - German Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

good pizza. good price. speedy service. What more Cheese Pizzacan I customer hope for? read more

Mario's Pizza - large pizza with extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

Very good, genuine italian pizza. Place is clean and cozy. Super friendly host. We will be coming back for more. Greetings from Long Island.

Mario's is a great little Italian restaurant! It's the kind of place that you go back to again and again. Reliable and tasty, what more can you ask? I personally love their cheese steak on garlic bread, their fried veggies are good, and their pizza is good, too. Is their pizza the best?? Ever?? Nope. Is it good? Good enough to go back to again and again?? Yup. I also like that they have a drive through with a pick-up window for take-out orders. Convenient! Nice! Good food! I'm a big fan! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Weissport, Pennsylvania

Got takeout from this place after tacobell messed up our order. Their tomato sauce was absolutely delish. They made penne ala vodka which was not on the menu and was a hit as well. Definitely recommend. read more

I am IN LOVE with their Grandmas Sicilian pizza! Thin crust.. takes an hour to make so call and place order ahead of time for the most delicious thin crust pizza dinner ever. I'm ordering another one tonight :) have probably had like 6 by now lol also if it gets cold on the way home don't eat it! Reheat in oven and the crust gets even more delicious after baking it again for left overs too read more

Amazing. Best pizza in town no question. I've probably had 50-75 pizzas from here over the years since they owned this place and VERY consistent. Calzones, cheesesteaks, hoagies, can't go wrong. read more

The prices are fare, the food is really good, very clean good service, calm environment, plenty of seats, NO alcohol take out. Should try at least 1time when in carbon co. read more

Mario's food is amazing. Each time I visit, my food is delicious and the employees have been very polite. I have eaten in and ordered through the Slice App. There has never been a problem with pick up or dine in. read more

Ordered a cheese pizza, a cheesesteak, and cheese fries. Everything was delicious. Especially that pizza. Perfect thin crust.

Called to cancel my order and they said to do it through the app so I said Okay and hung up. Ended up not canceling it and my payment went through so we get there to pick it up and they said they didn't make it because they thought we canceled it which we didn't so we waited an extra half and hour and the girl at the counter gave us attitude when we finally got our food and we were kind from the start read more

I just got a slice of Sicilian I think it was made Around noon it is 4:30 in the afternoon I can only eat a couple bites around the edge terrible read more

Looking for decent pizza in this area? This is probably a good choice. I drove by late on a Wednesday night and figured that since there was a police cruiser out front and an officer dining inside that this would be a good choice. One thing I've learned in my travels is that cops know where to eat. I wasn't disappointed. Basic pizza. Good service. I enjoyed it. Was it the best I've ever had? Nope, but it probably deserves 3 1/2 stars. read more

Ive had 3 things at this restaurant so far. their german pizza, which is steak onions peppers & pepperoni, the philly cheesesteak pizza, and their bbq wings. the German Pizza was pretty good. The Philly Cheesesteak pizza is chipped steak cooked into the cheese and its very good. I recently ordered 30 BBQ wings (coming at $.65/wing, 50 wings are 26.99). they however were probably the best wings ive have had in the area, but i think they might be even better than BWW & QuakerSteak & Lube. they were quite decent in size and crispy, juicy, and the sauce was awesome. i would definitely suggest at least one trip here to see your thoughts because it could very well become of your favorite restaurants. also they dont have dessert. Edit: Their onion rings were regularly cooked, with ones of the bottom of the bag darker (tasted more along the lines of a blooming onion than onion ring so not terrible, but were darker). After purchasing them twice more, they have been great both following times. Also their Panini was very good, they make their own ranch sauce which is extremely good, and they also have curly fries. read more

Was good for a while but the past year our orders are always messed up and not just ours, my neighbors and my brother in laws. They say there's nothing they can do when you call and tell them the order was wrong or just made poorly. It's sad because they were the best around for a while. read more

My tuna sub (hoagie) had the smallest amount of tuna on it what a waste of $6.50 the 50¢ for cheese. This pizza place should step up because they are a dime a dozen around here. So disappointed. read more

This is the BEST Italian food and pizza, highly recommend Mario's, this place is better than any Italian food I have had in Philly and Jersey or anywhere read more

This pizza is the REAL DEAL. Thin crust and perfect tasting, made by authentic Italians. All we had was pizza but would definitely be back to try their other food. Nice people, too. Also, we live in the city with easy access to the best pizza, so I didn't expect to love this pizza as much as I did. read more

Seriously how do you screw up every single order I place? I live close to here and I have ordered several times and the food is great.... when the workers can actually get your order right. I've ordered here 3 times recently since the start of November and they screwed up my order all 3 times. They even make sure to repeat the order on the phone yet it still comes to me all wrong? How can a business operate like this? Very upsetting! Seriously considering not ordering from here ever again!!! read more

Ordered for delivery a. Garlic bread chicken cheesesteak. While waiting for the clerk to provide me a total she says to a coworker that I talk to fast. The sandwich itself was bland could not taste garlic, the fried onions forgotten Along with blue cheese dressing on the side. Oh I almost forgot the roll fell apart upon picking up the sand which to dine. Disappointed read more

We've eaten at all the Italian places in the Lehighton / Jim Thorpe area (both the pricey and inexpensive joints) and have found this to be the most authentic. Best pizza by far and we've used their catering which we've received rave comments on. We've always encountered very friendly service. We highly recommend. read more

Mario's an very good local pizza/sub shop. They have pizza comparable to the local favorite, Pizza Como, bug more importantly, they do more than pizza. They are hands down the best cheesesteaks and subs in town. They have good fried appetizers and their Stromboli is good as well. Of course the selling feature of Mario's us that unlike Pizza Como, they accept credit cards and they have a drive thru window read more

I was in last week and absolutley loved it. The pizza is the best in the area. The panini sandwiches are also delicious. Very friendly service and clean environment. Will be back read more

Good place we had the white pizza and the Cheese steak stromboli. Service was good. Prices were good. There are about 30 seats total so eat in is. Good option. No fountain soda bottles and cans only. read more

The food I had was typical of a small town mediocre pizza shop with no competition. The store needs some touch-up paint inside but was for the most part clean -- including the rest room I used. I elect not to consume carbonated beverages and was denied a cup of ice water. I was told they don't have water but it is available for consumption by the bottle in the cooler. Good grief! How do they clean anything? The toilet flushed so maybe they use rainwater! read more

Best pizza in the area! Plus drive up window in this former bank building.

Horrible service even with the food the wait is just not worth it we dealt with the service for a couple weeks but got sick of it

Very pleasant and friendly staff, Great atmosphere and wonderful pizza. The order came out In a timely manner and everything tasted great. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who's nearby or driving through. read more

The pizza was good got the buffalo chicken and German pizza was very filling. Prices are reasonable. The service was quick.

The best pizza I've had since leaving the New York area. Good food, good people, and a good time all around. I'll definitely be back. And I'll definitely be sure to try something new. They've yet to disappoint. read more