This is my second visit here so far while visiting my boyfriend's sister. The pepperoni pizza was…read moreSO great the first time around. I was really eye balling the stuffed shells on the menu and the wings other people were eating so I had to come back! Turns out the stuffed shells are great and the wings are as good as they looked. This staff is very friendly and accommodating. Clean well kept place. If I don't make it a 3rd time before I leave, I'll look forward to coming back on my next return to Waterville! Thank you!

Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also…read more Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint.

Great pizza made by great people. Always fast and consistent quality. There are a couple tables…read moreinside.

Casual environment and courteous customer service. They make…read moredelicious personalized calzones ! My family enjoys their pizza a lot! Great family run business!

We were in town for the baseball tournament at Dreams Park. It was like a second honeymoon. No kids…read morein tow and our son of course stayed in the barracks. It was wonderful. :-) We came here with friends also parents from the team. Easy parking. Fast service. We sat upstairs - it was like our own private dining room. We got a couple of different pizzas and some salads. Everything was very good. Absolutely recommend.

After a rough playoff loss, we came here for lunch. A bit off of the beat and path from…read moreDreamspark. They have a small parking lot and there is street parking as well. We wound up parking a block away as they were pretty busy. You can dine in or take out. Table area was very clean. You place your order and they bring everything to your table. Service all around was excellent and smooth. Everyone went above and beyond. The kid got a small buffalo chicken pizza. I got a meatball parm sandwich. Meatball sandwich was very good. Quality of the meatballs was impressive. Sauce had a nice kick to it. They didn't cheap out on the amount of sauce or cheese. I made the right choice. I snuck a piece of the Buffalo Chicken pie. Chicken was on point. Nice size pieces. Not over powering with spicy sauce. Personal preference, dough was a little too thick for me, but again, that's my personal preference. Kid definitely enjoyed it. Boxed up a few slices for later on. A great alternative if you're in the area.

Stopped here for a slice. Not sure why but I assumed this place would be bad. I asked for a…read moreslice and they said that it just came out. I wish they would have thrown it back in the oven to crisp it up but they didn't ask. I was pleasantly surprised though. Sauce was decent and cheese was good. A little undercooked but not bad. I would go back.

We gave them a go multiple times, & each time we were left wanting & did not finish their food…read more We ordered some pies, & the only thing done remotely correct was the dough. The sauce has an off taste that I could not place. & the toppings were not fresh, & also did not taste correct. So after not being satisfied with the pies we decided to give their Stromboli a go. Disappointment again. Again the only thing correct was the dough. Now mind you the dough was never great, but it was edible. Overcooked on the outside & still doughy on the inside. The "toppings" again were not fresh & tasted off. The marinara was horrible, it was as bad as the pie sauce & may have been the same thing. When charging $2+ per topping, you expect it to be fresh. Not weeks old or from a tin or jar. Any place (that makes Italian food) that does not even have fresh garlic, worries me! & I am talking from a bulb, again not from a tin or jar. It's no wonder that they have such a low rating, when you can get better food from the gas station across the way!

I got a slice and the flavor was great, though super greasy on top and a bit overdone on the crust…read more I'd give it a 7.5/10 on the slice. Great selection of toppings, tho.

Great parking, well lit. Good seating with a lrg TV. Now about the food, oh yes the pizza sauce is…read morehomemade, the dough is delicious and great texture, the bake is spot on cooked and not burnt. I ordered the large one topping mushroom and it was SO GOOD!

Just got delivery from here and had NO idea this place even existed! I absolutely loved the pizza…read more-- and everything else we ordered as well. Worth every penny. Being born and raised on Long Island and living up here for the past 28 years, I've spent a long time searching for pizza that reminds me of home. This is the closest I've found to the classic Long Island pizza I grew up loving! I am on my 3rd slice and don't want to stop.

We enjoy there food. Always fresh when picked up. Serves excellent. Highly recommend.read more

Heavenly hand-tossed pizza, adictive breadsticks and outstanding wings. You can't say much more…read morethan that, but wait there's more: the service is exceptional. All in all, this little eats spot smack dab in the center of Indian Lake is a definite must-visit pizzeria every chance we have.

Great pizza and great food overall! Puterko's has great, friendly staff. We love this pizzeria!read more

Take out pizza Being local, we frequently get extra extra…read morelarge pizza to go,n, sometimes more&=wings with company It has always, (100%) of the time been ready as promised. It is also great pizz, every time Girl at the counter is aways super friendly and instantly recognizes regular customers and has the order on the counter even before I get to the counter Kudos to the whole NYP team for a job well done;every time We wll be back Carl L

This is a hidden gem! Here for a baseball tournament in Cooperstown NY and we are staying close by!…read moreI had the most amazing food! The whole atmosphere was amazing and service was great! You feel right at home! Growing up in an Italian family, this place brings you back!

When I first walked in, I noted how absolutely clean this restaurant was. It was late morning so at…read morethe very start of the lunch rush. I was immediately greeted in a friendly manner, the employee was polite when he took my order after allowing me time to review the pizzas they had out. And those pizzas looked wonderful! There was a large variety to choose from. So anyone who is vegetarian would definitely have an option. I ordered a couple of slices, and they were huge slices. I had selected thinly sliced fresh tomato, and thinly sliced fresh red onion without red sauce. This cheese mix was more traditional, I wouldn't be surprised if it was 100% mozzarella. That was a nice treat, as many places will mix cheddar in and it makes the cheese mix pretty oily. I also ordered a chicken tenders meal, but did not want the fries with it. The owner came out and gave me a little extra something since I only wanted the tenders. The bathroom was clean. It's not a restaurant with sitdown service, you do order at the counter, but they do bring your food to you at the table if you choose to eat in. The entire place was very clean and I was quite impressed. The pizza was delicious. The chicken tenders had a nice crispy breaded outside. When passing through again, I will definitely stop and try more of their very extensive menu.

Really the only pizzeria in a 15 mile radius. Amazing, others might be cheaper but there's a reason…read morethey are ! Clean and amazing food for over 40 years