Stopped here for a slice. Not sure why but I assumed this place would be bad. I asked for a…read moreslice and they said that it just came out. I wish they would have thrown it back in the oven to crisp it up but they didn't ask. I was pleasantly surprised though. Sauce was decent and cheese was good. A little undercooked but not bad. I would go back.

We gave them a go multiple times, & each time we were left wanting & did not finish their food…read more We ordered some pies, & the only thing done remotely correct was the dough. The sauce has an off taste that I could not place. & the toppings were not fresh, & also did not taste correct. So after not being satisfied with the pies we decided to give their Stromboli a go. Disappointment again. Again the only thing correct was the dough. Now mind you the dough was never great, but it was edible. Overcooked on the outside & still doughy on the inside. The "toppings" again were not fresh & tasted off. The marinara was horrible, it was as bad as the pie sauce & may have been the same thing. When charging $2+ per topping, you expect it to be fresh. Not weeks old or from a tin or jar. Any place (that makes Italian food) that does not even have fresh garlic, worries me! & I am talking from a bulb, again not from a tin or jar. It's no wonder that they have such a low rating, when you can get better food from the gas station across the way!

Great pizza made by great people. Always fast and consistent quality. There are a couple tables…read moreinside.

Casual environment and courteous customer service. They make…read moredelicious personalized calzones ! My family enjoys their pizza a lot! Great family run business!

This is my second visit here so far while visiting my boyfriend's sister. The pepperoni pizza was…read moreSO great the first time around. I was really eye balling the stuffed shells on the menu and the wings other people were eating so I had to come back! Turns out the stuffed shells are great and the wings are as good as they looked. This staff is very friendly and accommodating. Clean well kept place. If I don't make it a 3rd time before I leave, I'll look forward to coming back on my next return to Waterville! Thank you!

Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also…read more Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint.

New changes are... weird…read more We've come here so many times over the years and almost always had a great experience. Sometimes the place is busy and the service is slow because of it, but the food is always good, and I get that it's a learning environment for students, so: be patient, folks. But now the management has changed the whole experience. They've cut back the serving staff to only TWO people, closed the downstairs room altogether, and taken out tables so that there are only 2 booths and 2 four-tops, plus the bar. Their FB page now says "reservations only" but they don't even have an online system so you can see what dates are free. You have to call to talk to one of those belabored *two* people who are covering the entire room. I'm guessing they're also the ones answering the phones for take-out, too. How is this "enhancing [my] dining experience" exactly? To be fair, the food is still good and the two ladies working the night we were there are great and gave us great service. But the room feels spookily empty with so few tables. Plus the idea of being guilted into calling for mandatory reservations? Who does that?! Disappointing management decision that does a disservice to all the hardworking people who work here, and to their loyal customers too. Not sure when we'll be back again, now.

The bar tender was helpful and very cheerful! suggested the Cooper Cuban best Cuban I have had …read more My husband had the 24 k also a very good sandwich. if your in the area I would highly recommend going . out of town guest from Canada

I would call this a bar, plus…read more So it seems to mainly be a bar, with all the locals tipping one back. But they do a little more than just the normal pub fare. They have a billiard table. But it is quite dark inside even with the lights on. & watch your step!

We just picked up pizza and wings there and good lord do they make the best food in here ! Hands…read moredown they got it for the Mo Mo

I always enjoy my selections here: Milano Pizza is…read moreEXCELLENT. (thanks for having non-tomato sauce options) Steak sub is very tasty! Fries are best eaten there otherwise they lose their crunch fast. Even the half order seems HUGE to me. garlic stuffed knots are delicious and reheat well. I keep these in the house to have with soup. They should consider selling them frozen/ready to bake! wings are good Their ranch is DELICIOUS. they make decent garden & greek salads vodka rigatoni pasta is delicious and saucy! spaghetti with meat sauce & chix parm pasta are decent.

Food is excellent, however service is something to be desired, I ordered for a get together the day…read moremy mother passed away, I went to pick up pizza, wings and vodka riggies, and the man behind the counter was rude as can be, he was yelling at me because I couldn't take everything out to my car at once because there were other people in line. There was another lady behind the counter answering the phones making rude comments to customers on the phone. I have not decided if I will go back or not.

Take out pizza Being local, we frequently get extra extra…read morelarge pizza to go,n, sometimes more&=wings with company It has always, (100%) of the time been ready as promised. It is also great pizz, every time Girl at the counter is aways super friendly and instantly recognizes regular customers and has the order on the counter even before I get to the counter Kudos to the whole NYP team for a job well done;every time We wll be back Carl L

This is a hidden gem! Here for a baseball tournament in Cooperstown NY and we are staying close by!…read moreI had the most amazing food! The whole atmosphere was amazing and service was great! You feel right at home! Growing up in an Italian family, this place brings you back!

Small town pizza right along the main drag. It's quaint and has a nice atmosphere…read more Unfortunately, the pizza is pretty average. It's NY style, which I like. But, there just wasn't a ton of flavor. For my fellow midwesterners, I'd compare it to Casey's pizza. In fact, the pepperoni tasted exactly like Casey's. I also tried the Everything But Anchovies (supreme). It was better as the toppings were pretty good. But still, I think I'd prefer Pizza Hut's supreme. One gripe - no delivery. It was snowing like crazy. I would've paid a fee to have it delivered 1 mile up the road. I'd definitely eat here again. But, it's not the best pizza in America that's for sure.

Best pie this side of Pavone's in Manlius. And ice cream and a barroom too! Who could ask for more?read more

Food is terrible, service is terrible. New owner has no personality. Changed to low quality food…read more SOME employees are very rude.

Awful , couldn't even eat it.. had sausage pizza and sausage onion and pepper roll ..read more

Besides being a bit pricey, the sausage topping was all in the center and I think there was 10…read moreslices of pepperoni on a large pizza. What the hell was I paying for, the employee making pizza with his beats on his head? Better make some improvements if you are charging 5 star prices in a barely 2 star at best establishment.

I've wanted to go here since I was a kid. How cool does "Ye olde Pizza pub" sound?! Finally, I…read moregot to go at almost 40 years old. I was a little nervous, despite wanting to go here forever, because some reviews are completely awful and others are super old. So now I'm updating it for everyone else! You're welcome! :) Now, someone people wrote how "dark" and "dungeon- like" this place was.. c''mon! Read.the.name! It was as I expected, darker... but not so bad I couldn't see the people with me or how my food looked. There were super long wooden tables and benches, booths also available. It was chilly (it's a COLD January in CNY) but they had a gas fire and wall heater and the wall thermometer said "72" so it was probably me. It's definitely an older establishment- it was founded in 1971!!! But it brought me back to the bars of my childhood, as weird as that sounds! (I remember going to pizza with my parents after my dad's adult softball games and my parents would split a pitcher of beer.). Anyhow, there were wood panel walls and beige/ brown/ yellow floral tiles around the salad bar. It was an oddly comforting atmosphere. And yes, as indicated, the tables had etchings from since its establishment and they were a little sticky, but it could've been lacquer(?!). The bathrooms had updates and were clean and in working order. Sadly, there were no wenches and beer wasn't served in pub mugs as I'd hoped. Also, no horses out front or knights. Oh well!! Regarding the food and staff- This is an order ahead and serve your self kinda place. There are seats to eat in but you get ur own drink and they bring you the food/ pizza when it's ready or you order to-go. There is a projection tv for the kiddos and video games available. High chairs available. Definitely family friendly. I did call ahead, which I recommend as there was a steady stream of people coming and going. The person who answered was very kind and patient. I was able to locate a menu online although it wasn't connected to any online ordering or their website- fine by me. Everyone working was high school or college aged. Salad bar was good, basic, but yummy. Definitely reminiscent of salad bars of the past! To some people with high expectations, I can see their complaints, it's not a Ruby Tuesday's! We got pizza and taters. Taters are potato wedges for those that don't know- I didn't. I highly recommend them! Pizza was fine, not the best but definitely not the worse. They add ricotta my husband tells me, so it was a little different than I expected. My kids ate it no complaints. They also cut it in squares not triangles like most places. It was also thin cut not pan pizza. Overall, my kids behaved amazingly and enjoyed it. I enjoyed it, I'm glad I finally went. Would I go again?, probably, but I'm not wild about pizza so it wouldn't be my first choice. I hope this review helps anyone that skeptical. I say go and make up your own mind! Don't have super high expectations and you'll be fine.