Delicious! I know my…read moresweet tooth and I did my best to control the urge to sample every one. A quick glance I kind of already knew what I was going to order, Dark Salted Caramel and Butter Pecan. There were a couple others I was tempted to switch out but was very pleased with my selection. Staff was super friendly and accommodating. You can tell they all love their job!

When in Rome... eat fudge. Our visit to Mackinaw Island wouldn't be complete without seeing fudge…read moremade- and sampling some. There's something relaxing about watching the hot liquid be poured onto a marble table and worked over until it's solid. Joann's is supposed to be one of the best spots on the island for fudge so we made it our spot for viewing and nibbling. The staff was friendly and patient as we asked questions and made our small selection. Located directly on Main Street- you won't miss it! (Ice cream in the backyard of the parlor)

On an island filled with fudge and ice cream shops, Sanders is one of them. That old cliche is…read moretrue: You really could throw a stone on Mackinac Island and hit 10 fudge or ice cream shops. (Is that a cliche? It should be.) And if you don't like fudge or ice cream? Well, you're S.O.L., my friend. Luckily, my kids like ice cream, so we headed to Sanders because it was basically across the street from our hotel. They got a milkshake and a scoop of chocolate ice cream in a cup (their standard orders), and they were happy with their treats. But if you're looking for some other kinds of ice cream treats, they also have sundaes and things of that nature. Sanders also has a whole case of chocolate goodies, like peanut clusters, coconut clusters and pecan clusters (they seem to like their clusters here); chocolate-covered Rice Krispie Treats; truffles and peanut butter cups and toffee; caramel apples; and lots more. Oh, and fudge. But honestly, I would get fudge somewhere else that isn't a chain. There are lots of fudge places on the island. That's the thing: Sanders is a chain. But it's a Michigan chain, and originated in Detroit, so it's kinda local. Nevertheless, it's a good place to pop into to find something sweet to eat.

My wife really enjoyed the ice cream at Sanders. I thought their fudge was OK. Something really…read morecool about this place is they offer fudge that is sugar-free, dairy free, or they have a gluten-free fudge option as well. If you have dietary restrictions, you should definitely check this out.

Not my favorite fudge or peanut brittle on Mackinac Island, but you GOTTA get the Peco Flakes here!…read more Peco Flakes is a bit like coconut brittle to me as it has coconut flakes (as well as peanuts). The texture was still cronchy like brittle but there was something about the coconut that kept me coming back for more. May's Candy Shop didn't really open on time as stated (which was 10:30am but when we walked by at 11am, it was open!) , but hey -- that's island time for ya!

May's is one of several fudge shops in town. The woman working here was friendly and provided us…read morewith fudge samples. I'm not a fudge connoisseur by any means, but they all tasted good to me. I ended up getting the almond bark because they were very good. ....| \ _ , , , - - , , _ , .../ , ` . - ' ` ' . _ \ - ; ; ; , _ ..| , a - ) ) _ . ; . ( ` - ` - ' - ' ' - - - ' ' ( _ / . _ ) - ' ( _ \ _ ) 2019

We loved standing outside and watching them make the fudge from the window. We couldn't be inside…read morevery long because it was very hot standing in there the day we visited. The staff were okay, we felt a little rushed even though there was no line when we came in. But the fudge is amazing- literally the best I ever had. We chose the chocolate cherry to share. Your piece comes wrapped with a tiny wooden knife to cut to share. Staff told us it lasts weeks out of the fridge.

I was really looking forward to this place and was very disappointed. First of all, they only offer…read morea sample of one favor they decide on, you are not able to taste any of the other flavors. Secondly, they do not offer any smaller sizes of each flavor, only a giant slice of something you don't even know if you're going to like because .... they don't offer samples. And thirdly, the workers are beyond rude. I get the fact that you deal with hundreds upon hundreds of people a day but you need to realize that for each one of us, this is an experience we have been eagerly anticipating. So reluctantly,I purchased three giant slices because they had a buy 2 get a 3rd half off deal. The fourth disappointment came when I tasted it, it was so dry that I regretted buying them. I gave them 2 stars instead of one because I did enjoy watching them make the fudge, that was interesting.

I tried fudge at five different popular shops on the island. I thought Joanne's Fudge was the best…read more It was very soft and creamy. They let you have samples of any of their flavors. All the employees were really nice. They actually have two shops on the island and I bought fudge from both. They also have excellent chocolates. They make the fudge there in the store and you can watch it being made during the day. You won't regret your purchase.

Got two boxes. 1st box of 3: Double dark chocolate, dark chocolate espresso, dark chocolate salted…read morecaramel. 2nd box of 3: Double dark chocolate, dark chocolate raspberry, dark chocolate mint. A bag of salt taffies. Just under $80 Would have liked a dark chocolate with Irish cream or maybe French vanilla for my mom. The raspberry, mint and double chocolate are tasty. You can really smell the chocolate goodness wafting from the store. They were letting a new batch cool some on the counter.

The Best Fudge AND The Best Customer Service! First of…read moreall... Ruba's Fudge is the BEST fudge ever! It's rich, smooth, creamy, and absolutely delicious. I love all the flavors, and honestly, it's hard to pick a favorite! I bought several boxes earlier this year to take with me on my Alaskan cruise for a candy gift exchange. I froze the fudge without the boxes and carefully put the boxes away so I could repackage everything when it was time to give them as gifts. Well...fast forward to getting ready for my cruise, and I couldn't find the boxes! PANIC! My husband called Ruba's and explained what I was doing with the fudge and asked if we could purchase replacement boxes and have them overnighted. Thankfully, I found the boxes shortly afterward, so he called back before they shipped. But here's the part that really impressed me... They were going to send the boxes to us FREE OF CHARGE anyway! They didn't have to do that, but they were more than happy to help make sure I could give these little Mackinac Island treats as gifts on my cruise. So not only does Ruba's have the best fudge on Mackinac Island, but they also have the BEST customer service! And let's be honest--their adorable little boxes make the perfect gift, too! If you're visiting Mackinac Island, Ruba's Fudge is a MUST! Buy some for yourself, buy some for your family, and definitely buy some to take home as gifts. You won't be disappointed! Best fudge. Best customer service. Cutest boxes. What more could you ask for?

I was on the hunt for vegan fudge for a friend and I believe Ryba's is the only one on the island…read morethat carries a vegan option. Nate and I also got a few slices for ourselves; chocolate cherry, chocolate mint, and chocolate peanut butter. Of course they had samples so we were sold. They packed our fudge up in a cute pink tote, which made for a great gift bag when I gave my friend her fudge. She said the vegan fudge was really good and my favorite was the chocolate peanut butter. The cherry was a close second! They have plenty of flavors to choose from and you really can't go wrong. I will be back the next time we're on Mackinac Island.

We went to check out if they have any bitter sweet chocolate sauce for Mom…read more They have several different sauces: caramel, chocolate, chocolate with salted caramel, why not any bitter sweet chocolate sauce though. The popcorn bags here look decent, not sure if they would be good enough to last for my team next week though. We ended up grabbing a bite or of water and chamomile brewed tea with carbonated water in a can. $7.60

Very welcoming the smell was amazing!! I stopped in for some ice cream and fudge and can I say I…read morewasn't disappointed! I love it here

Delicious! Classic confection shop with that old timey feel…read more The store is located within downtown and is pretty large with high ceilings. Open area to see where they make their sweet treats. Staff are friendly and we chatted with one staff who said she has worked there season after season. Tons of fudge, ice cream, sweet treats, and freshy made waffle cones. I went with the pumpkin ice cream in a waffle bowl and it was heaven! The ice cream so smooth and rich. The waffle bowl was churchy and sweet. It hit the spot! Also got some fudge and it was just as delicious!

My favorite ice cream flavor from Kilwin's is their Mackinac Island Fudge and there was something…read moreso poetic about ordering this flavor (one of my first ice cream cones of the summer season) at the Kilwin's ON Mackinac Island no less! Kilwin's is a Michigan staple that I absolutely LOVE! I live closest to both their Ann Arbor and Plymouth locations, which are the ones I frequent the most, but often times they run out of their Mackinac Island Fudge flavor. I was so glad it was in stock on Mackinac Island AND that this Kilwin's was the largest Kilwin's I've been to yet! There are live fudge demos that you can watch, along with their entire "kitchen" area looking like it's out in the open so you can watch the workers hard at work! They have a massive selection of so many different sweets and treats - so many more offerings than I've ever seen at another Kilwin's too! It was a *treat* to see and always a MUST VISIT stop whenever you find yourself on the island! Love you, Kilwin's! :D