BEST DINER EVER! I'd travel 45 minutes just to get a pizza burger from this diner! It was so on point! Tomato sauce was light and rich and flavorful like a tomato soup recipe passed down for generations that was simmering all day. Burger was yummy, cooked perfectly, mozzarella was fresh and perfectly melted, and bun was the perfect size. I got fries with melted American cheese on them and they were hot cooked to perfection and cheese was melted perfectly. It was a 10/10 meal Will be back soon Devoured it so quick I forgot to take a photo. My son got the Massapequa pancakes & absolutely loved them. UPDATE (3 days later) So couldn't stop thinking about that burger! Went back today for another! Remembered pics today! read more

See all

Tried to make a return visit to see if any improvement. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was packed on a Sunday afternoon with our table squished into another table.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The room was loud which I found annoying.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They don't do the Greek pasta salad anymore which was a bummer. We politely asked the waiter to bring our child's food first and it came last. I ordered the steakhouse salad which was tasty. Portions definitely smaller than before. The service was not great and though I live close I don't think I'll be running back again. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch. We were promptly seated at a booth. I had three decker turkey club with fries and a coffee.service was just the right amount of attention. The portion was very generous, the brown gravy delicious, the fries perfect golden color. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The decoration of the diner was beautifully retro.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The washrooms spotless and Sinatra was on the speakers the whole time.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It was the definitive Long Island Diner experience. I know diners are closing but I sure hope this place can carry on. read more

Massapequa Diner - Happy diner - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Searched for a diner in the area after an appointment. Massapequa Diner didn't show up in my immediate search but I spotted it while stopped at a light. Glad I did. I found a great Diner with a full menu and great service. I ordered a BLT with grilled shrimp and avocado. Bacon was crispy. Shrimp were cooked just right and the avocado was in the form of a spread. It was all served on a soft, warm Italian loaf. The side of chipotle mayo and pickles gave it extra zing. I opted for onion rings instead of fries. Excellent choice. Massapequa Diner will surely see me again if I'm ever that far out on LI. read more

Massapequa Diner - Shrimp BLT with avocado. Side of onion rings. Excellent. - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

I may be biased cause I'm local, but I mean, this place knocks it out of the park every visit. Excellent menu choices and specials. Everything is fresh, and delicious. The servers are experienced and committed to providing the best dining. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The diner is always clean, warm and inviting.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It's a must try read more

Massapequa Diner - Greek Salad Wrap with Chicken - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Love this diner.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We ask for Sondra because she is always so friendly, attentive and truly makes you feel welcome. My boyfriend always orders the Buffalo chicken quesadilla and she remembers it every time and puts it in right away. Great service and great place! read more

The service is good and all with all the tasty food but the people think I am a young little kid they gave me a small plastic cup of lemonade just because of my height ‍ read more

They have renovated since I've last been here and it's been years. I liked the updates to the decor inside and outside. The gyro panini was good but what I really enjoyed were those buffalo chicken empanadas!!!!! Service was good nothing to complain or rave about. My shirley temple was blah. read more

See all

Sondra is such a blessing. She is so helpful, kind, and caring. Probably the best thing that happened to Massapequa diner!!!

An underrated diner you must try! I've been here at least once every time I go to NY to visit my family. This restaurant hits. I've experienced good service and the food has been consistent since I order the same thing every time. What I ordered: - Coffee: Black, no creamer, no milk. I enjoy it as-is. There's nothing special about their coffee. It tastes as it should and does the job. - Chipotle Chicken Panini: The portion on the plate might not look like much, but it will fill you up. I always go with curly fries as my side. The chipotle on the perfectly cooked bread tastes delish. - Mozzarella Sticks: Best eaten while hot, get that cheese pull you're looking for. They taste amazing dipped in the included marinara. Service was good, I believe Shannon (?) was my last server to help me. Parking is available on the side of the diner and in the back. Plenty of it. Diners are the lowkey hitters, and I recommend this one! read more

See all

Service was outstanding and food delicious. Good good Good good Good good good good Great good and good good good good good read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Bring a parker, it's freezing in here.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They aren't very attentive to the customer. Did not see 1 female worker in this diner. Buffalo grilled cheese was delicious read more

We came here for lunch and were very promptly seated. Our server was extremely friendly and attentive throughout our entire meal. He was very patient when answering my questions about the various omelettes that didn't have descriptions on the menu. Our food arrived fairly quickly after ordering. One thing that I was surprised by were the portions, our plates were huge. So keep that in mind when ordering, we probably should have just split some of our plates because we had a ton leftover. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I really enjoyed the classic diner feel of the place and all of the chrome.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] All in all I really liked it here and would come back again. read more

See all

My wife and I tried the Massapequa diner for lunch. We tried bolt specials. My wife had waffles and chicken, which the chicken was super dry. There wasn't any syrup served with the meal. I had the brisket sandwich on the special very tough and dry. I'm sorry to say I won't be back. Sorry do better. read more

We came here as it was one of the only spots open after a show at mulcahy's. When in doubt, diner it out? Since I knew sleep wasn't far off in my horizon, I didn't want to order anything too heavy, too greasy, or too sugary. So breakfast sounded good. I kept it millennially simple with avocado toast and a side salad. It was pretty underwhelming. Yes, toast, check. Yes, avocado, check. Eggs, too... but there was no flavor in any of the ingredients other than what was there. Not even a hint of cracked pepper mixed into the avocado. Either way, the diner was pretty standard. The service was fine, and there were other diners enjoying their meals which made it feel a little livelier than a late night food run. read more

Massapequa Diner - Avocado toast - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

We've "rediscovered" the diner post-covid through delivery. After hitting our favorite delivery spots numerous time, we figured the variety at the diner would be refreshing. We love their chicken salad, the gyro is awesome and my wife is addicted to grilled cheese.... with a variety of meats to jazz it up. The paninis are excellent as well, and be prepared for at least 1/2 a bag of tots if you upgrade from fries! They package everything well so it nice and warm. It's now a regular spot we order from! read more

Massapequa Diner - The chicken salad is delicious! - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

We were in town for a family function and a relative made a large reservation for 11 people at 5:30 on a Saturday night. It was already fairly busy when we arrived and was packed when we left. Thr decor was a fresh and modern approach to retro. Service was decent. Food was excellent. We sat down to find complimentary heapings of Greek pasta salad which themselves would have made a tasty meal. I ordered a smoked salmon and onion omelet, which is something I have ordered in diners across the country - Maryland, Arizona - and while this is not a dish one would expect to vary a lot, it does. This was the best cooked version of this omelet I have ever had - fresh ingredients, not greasy, and the salmon was super high quality. Also, the portion was huge so, after all that pasta salad, I had to take most of it to go. Everyone else seemed really happy with their food, too. My fiance got a grilled chicken sandwich that he said was excellent and also had to take much of his to go. At a table of 11 people there wasn't a single complaint. Raving all around. If there was one thing I'd skip, it was the desert. We split a few deserts around the table - an apple pie and some chocolate concoction. I didn't love them, thought the crust was too dry. I think these suffered from being in the fridge. But otherwise, a solid solid meal and I wish I could take this place back to DC with me because it puts our diners to shame. read more

I usually don't leave reviews, and I can't remember a bad review I left. This was my favorite place, I literally passed three other diners closer to home to come here. Service has been going down for a while now but tonight was the worst. I waited over half an hour for a burger just to get it cold and hard. I'm giving it another chance because I've been here so often but I don't know if they could recover. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Came here with amazing two friends and had a good time.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Friendly environment and food was amazing read more

See all

Diner Back in NY and had to have the diner experience as they really do not have them in the part of the world I currently live in (except for chains like Denny's). We hit this place for breakfast and they delivered. Coffee was on the table in moments after my butt hit the seat and the waitress was happy to explain some of the items to be dining partner. Coffee was good and hot but a little thin - I tend to like my coffee with more body but it is what it is. Food came out in short order and the portions were definitely large enough that it made them pretty hard to finish. Hash browns were cooked as requested as was the bacon. Rye toast was right on the money and the omelette was good- all in all a very good brekkie. The only downside was that the booth we had was pretty tight - considering neither of us were like massively overweight we thought it odd- can't imagine how a bigger person would fit in it - I would definitely ask for a table next time. Parking lit behind the place but beware it is somewhat tight as far as spaces etc. read more

Just had the freshly baked croissant with chicken salad and freshly made potato chips. Delicious A must try! Services as always is top notch

Sondra is my goat. Amazing service. Best human ever. So wholesome. Came really late and still received great food and great conversation with my waitress. read more

GO TO ANOTHER DINER! Bunch of retired widows - highest tax bracket - most disposable income with least amount of drive to cook anymore will not be returning. Your loss! While the food was fine and the service fine, I was so annoyed that they wouldn't give us a corner booth. That, we were told, was for a party of 7 (we were 5). Really? No party sat there for 2 hours! I was tempted to leave. I can't imagine people being so unaccommodating. But I didn't want to make everyone get back into their car to drive to any other diner! There are still too many good ones to be bothered with Massapequa. I won't be returning. I will take my diner-frequenting butt to the Lindenhurst, Embassy, Carle Place, Nautilus, Oconee, Infinity, Grand Stage, Colonie - any place else that can be nicer to customers. read more

Service was great and the food was also really good. I haven't had worthwhile disco fries in a while.

Yep 3 stars is about right. We came in on 2nd entrance just after Lincoln Avenue (see pix) on Sunrise. Note: did not see the big ramp as it was on other side along with handicap parking, and steps were used. (see pix) Gardens kept up nicely. I ordered a garden egg omelet which I was told is not the special. (so I didn't get OJ) as water was fine. Food amount was plentiful. Others in party had a variety of things all were of adverse and adequate quality. read more

Food was pretty awful. In the mood for something healthy we ordered a turkey burger and mashed potatoes. The turkey burger was fatty, greasy, and dripping with juice (would not call this a 'healthy' option). The mashed potatoes were like soup and tasted like pure salt and butter. It's a big menu so maybe other items are better but this wasn't a good experience. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Place gets a star for being clean[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] and a second star for chicken tenders which I'd rate as "ok". read more

I live in Bay Shore and consistently make the 30 minute drive to this dinner for the waiter Pepino. Pepino is so kind and attentive to his customers. He makes every visit worth it, and provides nothing but the best service. The Massapequa Diner is extremely lucky to have such a hard working man on their staff. read more

The waitress I had was amazing her name was Gina her food service was great and she was very sweet and kind she knew exactly how to treat my table and I and I would recommend going here and asking for Gina because she's definitely the best waitress there God bless her read more

My friends Franklin Sondra Cristina Pepino James Petros always take care of me here, great service, great company to be around. Always attentive and respectful. Have always been so accommodating to any food orders when in a party. [[HIGHLIGHT]]very comfortable and cozy ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Food was great, [[HIGHLIGHT]]the atmosphere was calm and amazing[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. The service was fast and efficient. Franklin the manager was very respectful and friendly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Always welcoming place to be[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. read more

Excellent food choices and friendly service. Great burgers, Omelettes, Salad ( my favorite is the SoHo salad)

My husband and I eat very often at the Massapequa Diner. The food is delicious and the service is excellent. All of the staff there is very friendly but Kristen and Gina are especially amazing. They are very warm and welcoming, they always ask how we are doing and remember our routine order. We are always looking forward to coming back to see them. read more

Just like to say massapequa diner is always great place to eat especially Gina's brooklyn egg creams makes it delicious!!!!! Keep up the great work !!!!! read more

Food was great large portions . Also if you love a good salad I sampled my son's Cesar salad and my wife's feta salad and loved it. Note I would drive from brooklyn to get the salad which is strange for me as I am not a big salad eater. read more

See all

DONT TIP!...if you pay by credit card don't leave a tip..the delivery person left the food outside in the winter saying he rang the doorbell which we don't have and the food was cold after sitting out there...pay cash on delivery that way they will actually deliver it instead of being lazy. The cc receipt wasn't even signed by us for the order ..eager to see if it was still "signed" and need to be looked into read more

In town for a visit and tried this place. The cheese fries are awesome and the service was friendly and fast. We will be back. read more

Massapequa Diner - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Good quality diner in Massapequa, conveniently located on sunrise hwy. Been coming here for years and always get a decent meal. Some of our favorites are the French onion soup, Philly cheese steak, French dip, burgers, and pancakes. Milk shakes are pretty good too lol. Diner itself is pretty large and you usually don't have to wait to sit. We have also done takeout/Doordash from this diner and the food is always hot and fresh. Overall a good diner to try. read more

Very nice diner Excellent menu food prepared perfectly everything fresh what presented the sandwich was just too big so big you couldn't get your mouth around it came with Russian dressing french fries and onion rings read more

Massapequa Diner - Brooklyn's finest Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

This place was spot on for me!!! I came here from Mineola to meet my friend in his home town and Massapequa Diner was his choice for breakfast. This was a good choice. Not far from the Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway and an easy in and out from their large parking lot. I was pleased to see that everyone was respectful of the times and entered the side tent with their masks on until they sat down. The service team obviously never took their masks off. Waiter was at our table in seconds and brought water and coffee. While my friend and I caught up the waiter stopped by a few times to make sure everything was ok and if we were ready to order. So... after making the big decision, I came up with two eggs over easy on well done corned beef hash and potatoes. My friend went with the healthy choice and had the vegetable omelette. (Make sure you see the picts.) My friend, being a regular was cordially greeted by other members of the staff. Funny how you can tell who people are under the mask... Not me! My breakfast was perfect. Actually better, they make their own hash which was delicious along with the home fry potatoes. My buddy, being a regular told me he enjoys all their dishes. I will definitely be back for a dinner one evening as I am always looking for a fun and good dining experience. I HAVE TO SAY that I don't understand the negative reviews. They did such a nice job here. I definitely recommend the Massapequa Diner. read more

Massapequa Diner - A delicious healthy Vegetable omelette. - Diners Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

Gina was kind, funny, and helpful. She managed our large needy group with a smile. I will return soon!