Max's is a solid, neighborhood Italian restaurant with excellent thin crust pizza and a large menu of Italian food. My companions shared a large Margherita pizza. I had penne filetto de pomodoro, which is pasta in a red sauce with sautéed prosciutto, onion, and cherry tomatoes. The sauce was perfectly seasoned, and it was delicious. The entrée portions here are massive, and everything is served hot and fresh. The servers hustle, and prices are reasonable. There are three pizzaria/restaurants on this same block in downtown Scotch Plains. Massimo's is sheet pan pizza, very good, but with a much more limited menu. I don't need to mention the third place, I'll just come back to Max's. read more

Best Pie in Jersey! Hands down! Cheesesteaks and the Parm Hot sandwiches generous portions and the fairest prices in NJ! The owner Max will make sure you get your sandwich or meal the way you want it. If you want potatoes on your cheesesteak he will make it happen! While other pizzerias will tell you they don't have it or serve it that way. The specialty pizzas are superb, any way you like them prepared Max's makes it happen. Daily specials and 5-STAR SERVICE!! Best Pizzeria hands down! Stop in and give Max's a try I promise you will not be disappointed! Thank you Max's Pizzeria and Bistro, Park Ave, Scotch Plains NJ!!‍ read more

Max's Pizza and Bistro - Cavatelli, light sauce extra cheese - Italian Near Me - Scotch Plains, New Jersey

This local pizza spot is a gem! The pizza is consistently delicious, perfectly cooked, flavorful sauce, and great toppings every time. You can really tell they care about quality. The chicken wraps are just as great too. They're fresh, well-seasoned, and packed with flavor. Great food, friendly service, and we'll definitely keep coming back to. Highly recommend! read more

I had heard about Max'S from social media. When we got there it was empty but 5 minutes later it was bustling. There was one server and while she was amazing our heart broke for her. There were 8 or so tables and girl was kicking its butt. For the food. It was good. I was expecting a little bit more, the chicken was good. Just needed maybe a little more seasoning but will def go back and try the pizza. It's a small quaint pizzeria. As for accessibility, getting in was super easy. Being in a wheelchair I would suggest going to the restroom before you go. You can't get your chair through the hallway. No bars in bathroom. Struggled there. read more

See all

I've only ever had take-out from Max's, so my review is solely based on that, but I've ordered there dozens of times. There is a lot of competition for pizza places around here, but Max's has the best pie. I usually order it well done, which just serves to crisp the crust a little more. Whether we'll-done or not, the flavor and chew on the crust here is excellent. The Buffalo chicken pizza is a standout, and the Gramma pie is great too. Maxs also has the best subs in the area, and this is because the bread is so good. The meatballs are very good and I definitely recommend the meatball sub, and the chicken cutlet sub. The chicken fingers are really good too, not just kid food. The salads are large and generous with the variety of ingredients in them. The chicken franchise is another favorite we've ordered many times and never been disappointed.I have to mention the bread again, as it comes with the entrees, and it just elevates every it comes with. The only misses for me are the wraps. They usually fall apart and are too wet inside. But everything else is really good and reasonably priced for the area. The staff is friendly and they stay busy keeping the orders moving on weekend nights. read more

I've been at this restaurant before so I was totally prepared for a casual atmosphere. The staff was so friendly. They seem to enjoy what they do! Our food was excellent. We had the chicken saltimbocca and the veal saltimbocca. The accompanying salads were fresh and with a good variety of veggies. Love this local place. Of course brought a good Italian wine to go with the food. read more

See all

Food in general is amongst the best vs competition in the area. Particularly fond of their cavatelli w/broccoli, white pizza and broccoli rabe. Delivery is always quick and prices are reasonable. read more

Always a great meal, regardless of whether you get. Everyone is pleasant and service is top notch. Makes the best (in my opinion) eggplant rollatini around. read more

Picked up a pepperoni and onion pizza and mozzarella sticks. The pickup time for a Saturday evening was quick - only 20 minutes and the food was ready on my arrival. The pizza had good flavor, though I wish the crust was thicker. I say that as someone who already thinks Jersey has too much of an infatuation with thinner pizza slices, but this one in particular was really light. The toppings were generous enough, with diiced onion instead of the larger cuts that most pizza spots use. The mozzarella sticks weren't bad, which is a rave review for someone who continues to get mozz sticks for takeout. I don't know who hurt me. I know they won't ever be good, you can't put them in a to-go container. These at least weren't completely soggy after their few minute trip in the foil dish. I'd eat it again, but if I ever hear that they start making their crusts thicker, I could see myself being a weekly customer. read more

Nice good pizza, I got a cheese and a veggie both were good. Nice thin crust and tasty sauce with just enough cheese ! This is our pizza spot now. FYI u have to enter from the back . Hello read more

Great pizza and very friendly staff. Great place to order from, have not tried the restaurant part but have to assume it's good to.

Solid food. A little cra cra on a Friday. But it's Friday during lent in pathetic New Jersey. Tasty food.

I love Max pizzas. I live in cranford nj. Not California as posted. I have also catered from him several times. His food is out of this world. Everyone has enjoyed/loved his food. Best food ever. I will continue to order my pizzas from him. They are the best. love your food! Love your pizzas! Will continue to cater from you also. You are the best! read more

I order pizza delivery frequently and the last 3 times the order was wrong. The chicks taking the order need to pay attention to the callers order. The proprietor needs to supervise more. Their pizza is very good but only if you actually receive what you order. read more

Best pizza! We moved out of state and use Max's pizza as a standard to judge all other pizzas we try in our area now. None come close... I still make it my business to pick up pizza from there whenever I'm in town which is often enough. If you're looking for quality, authentic Jersey/ NY pizza this is it you won't be disappointed. read more

Having only been in Fanwood for a year I was struggling to find a good spot for takeout pizza. Finally a coworker recommended this place made it has been my go to pizza spot. But recently we hosted a large party at our house and we needed it catered and I decided to order from here having never tried their entrées. Everybody loved the food and it was all gone in a matter of 30 minutes and people kept raving about it. Best pizza place and best pasta in town. read more

This is out go-to pizza in Scotch Plains. Their sauce and crust are amazing. We also love their sandwiches and my favorite is the eggplant parmigiana read more

We love Max's Pizza,, whether it's a quick slice or taking the family for a nice dinner, the food can't be beat! Max and all the staff are always willing to go the extra mile to make sure everything is perfect. Definitely my favorite Pizzeria around! read more

Service is poor. Delivery quoted one hour - an hour and 30 min later we were still waiting. When I called I was hung up upon twice. Never again. read more

I really love their sauce. It's not too sweet like other place. I always get their delicious pasta, and I love their hot subs, cold subs. It's not too salty like other places. It's always fresh and just good! I literally order once a week or twice for their good quality foods. I recommend this place. read more

best regular cheese pie in the area. also peperoni is good also. there crust and sauce are very good. want regular pizza this the best.

This place is real deal Italian food. I am very picky about my caesar salad dressing and chicken parm. I have a go to spot that is tough to match. Max's has done it and done it very well. In addition, their pizza is some of the best around. We have a new favorite for pizza Friday which now includes caesar salad and chicken parm. read more

A Local gem! We have ordered numerous times from Max from pizzas to pasta and love everything ! Love their penne vodka, chicken Francese and meatballs! Great customer service as well! They offer delivery for catering which makes it so convenient! read more

Generous portions, very good value. Solid "NJ Italian" favorites. A good choice for fast, reliable sandwiches and pizza.

If you are looking for a good hot italian meal this place is worth going to. I have had a few different dishes and everything was delicious! Staff is friendly and prices are reasonable. Only reason I gave them 4 stars is because I was not a fan of the pizza. I know many people love it but i thought it was so so. But that wont deter me from eating there. read more

I placed an online order tonight and when I showed up the order did not go through until I had walked in the order for some reason although I got the confirmation via email. However, the girl at the front counter and the owner max were so nice to me and max said he would make it right there for me so I didn't have to wait any longer. I ordered a margharita and a Hawaiian pie along with wings and cannolis. Everything was so fresh and delicious. And not to mention everyone in there was so nice and caring after the small hiccup. Will definitely be back!! read more

I've only ordered pizza from Max"s until recently I tried the cheesesteak wrap. Unfortunately I will no be ordering it again as the wrap was burnt . It was supposed to have peppers and onions but I couldn't tell. Pizza is good though. read more

A very good pizza place.... 4 stars from me tasty pizza. I like their salads too. Sandwiches are good as well read more

(In reality 4.5 stars but it's always good to round up.) Stopped in a couple times for takeout and the pizza is always good. Staff is friendly and attentive (especially the young ladies working the front) and prepare orders quickly. They could easily get away with tacking a dollar or so onto most slices to match the prices nearby but they don't. Definitely worth giving them a chance. Only thing I would like to see is a little more variety on individual takeout slices - there's usually only plain and 1-2 other types at once. read more

Terrible service. They don't seem to know how to operate a restaurant. I have been there about six times and the last two visits I walked out. Max is there but ineffective and not friendly. Too bad. I thought this was going to be a regular spot for me. read more

My son and his wife came up for the week. We have had Max's pizza before . It's the best around. Their entrees are unbeatable. If I made it myself it could not have been better. I am told I am a fantastic cook. I can now say I have found a new place when I do not feel like cooking. I heartedly recommend Max. read more

I ordered from there a few weeks ago and I got really sick from the calamari that wasn't even fried like I asked and the wings were raw!

I ordered a meat lovers gradma pizza and the young lady ended up giving me a margherita grandma pizza.. also I ordered 12 buffalo wings and then I asked if the wings were naked or breaded.. she said they were breaded so i decided to change it to 6 wings because I prefer naked wings (by the way they were naked and not breaded smh) when I received my order and realized it was wrong,rather than making a scene, I explained to the worker that i didn't order a margherita that I ordered a meat lovers.. I said if it is possible can I at least add sausage to this pie and I'll pay extra if I have to.. everyone act as if they had no idea what to do so i decided to say if it's such a big deal I'll take my pie as is.. rather than fixing the pie for me they decided to let me leave unhappy.. im in the restaurant industry so I get mistakes happen.. but the way they handled this issue was terrible.. everyone seem so confused as if they couldnt find a way to reheat some saugage to put on my margherita pie) im completely disappointed because that young lady knew 100% that she made the mistake.. I would never order a margherita pizza because I need some type of topping hence why I tried to pay extra for the sausage.. not only that but she clearly told me the wings were breaded when they were not.. I changed my order from 12 to 6 because of that.. smh.. completely disappointed in the customer service.. I will never come back to this place ever!!! read more