today the cheese would not melt!!! what in the pizza mess is happening to Fabio's ???? such a hit or miss . One day you have excellent pizza . order the following week and it's like a cardboard box with cheap cheese that doesn't melt and old crust also the pizza box has a very odd smell we noticed. We're trying our best to support this neighborhood business but please be consistent. read more

Very good home made breads and crust for the pies and calzones. The owner is right on premise and provides detailed attention to the customers. It is also a good place to get the flavor of the locals. read more

This is actually my 2nd time here. Came here the 1st time & just had the pizza & it was absolutely amazing! Then when my Family wanted pizza recently, I recommended this place, they delivered it & it was perfection. Today, I sat in again. A small venue with it's own parking lot. Today I had the Penne Vodka & garlic bread. Wow!! Best I have had in a long time, especially the garlic bread. Service was surprisingly quick, & it has the typical Italian restaurant interior. It had a few tables & chairs out front for outdoor seating as well. Definitely will be back. Glad it's so close to home. read more

See all

I just waited almost an hour to receive an over cooked pizza . The prices keep going up and the goes quality down. We work hard to treat our family to outside food so it sucks when you receive trash. read more

One of my customers from the Barbershop invited me today Tuesday evening 1/6/26 to Fabios Bristo, I loved the quick attention and service AND the FOOD WAS AMAZING! We had Spaghetti and Meatballs , the sauce was from an ITALIAN Planet DELICIOUSSSS , the meatballs a nice size and great tasting. My FIRST Time here and I love Italian pizza and food , been to over 100 Pizzerias and Italian Restaurants easily. but after todays GREAT Experience I couldn't WAIT to write a Review. Definitely FIVE BIG STARS. (Robert ) The Gifted Cutters Garwood NJ. " Be BACK SOON for More! Grazie. Thank YOU, Gracias. I BELIEVE the business Owners will NEED a Bigger Place. read more

Best pizzeria in the area! Their food has that authentic Italian touch you just don't get anymore! Pizza: 10/10 Delicious thin crust pizza, cheesy and tasty. Wings 9/10: were crunchy, saucy, the perfect amount of spicy and came out HOT! Salad 7/10: fresh chicken on the salad! Salad wasn't too saucy or cheesy but I liked it that way. Family wanted extra Cesar. Garlic Knots 8/10: fluffy, and buttered! A little thicker than I expected but still good! Great service, amazing food. Will be back again! read more

See all

Every single bad review is absolutely true, the food taste like garbage. We saw several roaches climbing the wall to the ceiling. I would never take my guest here again. Pure dollop slop. You will be disappointed and grossed out. Disappointing food · Poor presentation · Slow service never again. Food: 1/5 | Service: 1/5 | Atmosphere: 1/5 Reservation Not sure Special events Not sure Recommendation for vegetarians Would not recommend Vegetarian offerings Not sure Vegetarian options Not much they told me to eat a carrot. Parking space Difficult to find parking Parking options Free street parking Parking They need and exterminator and hair nets we found curly think black hair in our food Wheelchair accessibility None Not ADA Compatible. read more

Found this place while we were at Fannywood day and stopped in quickly for a snack. We sat outside and split an order of mozzarella sticks and they were so good! They came out super hot and they were very tasty. The service was so fast which was nice for a Sunday at a pretty busy time. I also took home a few drunken grandpa slices to have later and they were excellent too. read more

A long-time family favorite for pizza Friday and a staple in the Scotch Plains - Fanwood community! Expect delicious thin crust pizza with the perfect ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings - never too greasy and consistently good. The family's go-to pizza order (never disappoints!): 1 Large - 1/2 Cheese and 1/2 Eggplant and Fresh Mozzarella 1 Large - Fresh Mozzarella Vodka Pizza My family typically orders takeout from Fabios, but the restaurant space is very nice - just small. Things to keep in mind: Estimated wait times are not always accurate, especially on a Friday night (anticipate your order taking longer than expected) read more

Fabio's Bistro - Large Fresh Mozzarella Vodka Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey

See all

We had Fabios's supply catering trays for a party this past weekend... Will definitely use them again in the future! Ronnie was so easy to deal with over the phone and they showed up on time with our order of penne vodka, chicken franchise, sausage and peppers, chicken tenders, order of broccoli... which had such a nice dose of fresh garlic, garlic knots, and multiple pizzas. Guests were raving about the taste of all of these items. And lucky me... I've got a little bit of leftovers for the next couple of days! If you're having a large event... Definitely consider the Bistro known as Fabios! read more

Great and authentic BROOKLYN style pizza from a former manager at J&V Pizza in Bensonhurst!! Top notch ingredients and thinner style than you normally get in NJ. The food is amazing as well and the portions are YUGE!! You'll definitely be leaving with leftovers for a full meal the next day! Give it a try, you'll love it and Ronnie, the owner, is as real a NY Italian as there is, he's from there...he's the BEST!! read more

From what I saw on the pizza box, the pizza was ordered from there. Unfortunately, it did not hold its shape on taking out of the box. It litterely folded in half , appears cheese slid off the pizza. It definitely was not grande cheese.L, which many pizzeria's use. The way the cheese melted appeared to be a lower quality and fat content.. the pizza sauce needs improvement. The crust could've been cooked a little bit longer, read more

Very kind and caring and great food. They are also so great to everyone in the community

It's sad, this place used to be solid, but now, i need to be inebriated to enjoy this pizza. Quality has completely gone down the drain, the pizza is doughy and the flavor is bland at best. Service was also lackluster. The girls at the counter looked like they were bothered that they even had customers standing there. Go somewhere else, wayyyy better options local. read more

I ordered a large cheese pizza on a Friday night. I know it's a busy night for pizza. I finally received the pie after 2 hours, and when I took my first bite, I almost choked on a pistachio shell that was buried in the cheese. I'm disgusted and disappointed. read more

Fabio's Bistro - Pistachio shell found in pizza - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey

Preparation took over two hours. This happened more than once. Last time I will order from here.

I'm originally from New York and can be very critical of the quality of pizza in Jersey. Fabio is literally the ONLY bistro/pizzeria in my surrounding neighborhood that meets NY standards. Their pizzas and dinners are All FANTASTIC. We literally order delivery from Fabio every Week. The next step is to physically dine there. read more

Fabio's is a delicious location that suffers solely from poor operations management. There's no telling if you'll get your delivery or pickup on time, ahead of schedule, or long beyond the stated time. In fact, the inconsistency is a running joke in the town - Any delays or inconveniences around the area are typically blamed on Fabio's (e.g., traffic, bad weather) But there's a reason everyone in town is willing to play order-out roulette with Fabio's so often - it really is delicious. I've had subs, strombolis, pizza, and pasta, and it's all great. The pizza is some of my favorite in the area, especially their "works" pie, which has a ton of flavor. The subs are hearty and a good change of pace from the pizza routine. My wife swears by the Buffalo chicken stromboli, always complimenting how much chicken is included. You should go to Fabio's, especially on a day where timing doesn't matter. But even if they swing and miss, leaving you waiting an extra hour for your pizza pie, you'll be back. We all know you'll be back. read more

I recently moved back to the area and gave this place another shot. Both the pizza and dishes like chicken parm for takeout were delicious. Maybe my experience from years back was just a bad night for delivery. read more

We've ordered there a few times and it's just a good solid go to place for pizza pasta chicken .Prices are very reasonable and everybody that works there seems incredibly happy which helps. it really does feel like a neighborhood place. I'm happy supporting Ronnie and his business. I'm looking forward to them going across the street in a year or so a bigger space. read more

When they're on, they're very good. However they're consistently inconsistent. I'll let the Italian sub photo speak for itself. Just glad I had some ham in my refrigerator to support this weak sandwich. Come on, Fabio's! We know you can do better! read more

Fabio's Bistro - Italian sub. - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey

The food is Always fresh and on time. However, on Friday's, you have to place your order early because it's their busiest day.

Overcharged by $8,00 for the pizza for some reason. I literally paid over $28.00 for one pizza.

There is no way I'm the only one in this town that has an issue with the woman who takes the orders over the phone...why is there always an echo, why is she screwing up every time, like she is trying to not get the order right? What is the deal????? This isn't about the food, the pies and everything is great...but the women who takes the orders has consistently screwed up our order every time they are taken. Even when she tries to repeat it back, you correct her, and she still messes it up....I don't understand what her deal is, and I can no longer order from this place through her. I don't even think that the orders are taken at the actual restaurant, it's a call service I believe, which is even weirder??? Call and ask the lady where your order is, and she gives some dumb excuse, or lies sometimes and says it on its way... GET RID OF THIS CALL SERVICE! read more

I am very disappointed in the food i ordered today. A large pie with the works tasted like old pizza with toppings added and delivered cold. I have never had cold pizza won't be ordering from here again...yuck! read more

Fabio's Bistro - Pizza tonight - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey

A staple! We order from here probably once a week or so and stop by for lunch fairly often too. The service is always so friendly. They also do so much for the community. I love the salad slice!! would highly recommend! Also the Chicken Parm is probably my favorite I've ever had! read more

it is my favorite Italian/pizza, its amazing and so is the service. ya read more

This is my families go-to pizza place. I order from here once a week. We order a scheduled pickup every time, and I never have to wait. The order is always correct. The food is very good and the owner has always been nothing but nice to myself and my girls. He spoils them with ices all of the time, which I guess is both good and bad. We always order the pizza, chicken cheesesteak wrap, and tortellini soup, all very good. Try the penne vodka catering, it is delicious. Love Fabios! read more

Fabio's pizza is just amazing!!! I normally get plain but today I ordered the white pizza and it is so delicious! The staff is so friendly too! I love Fabio's. read more

Wanted so badly to support this local business. Had a horrible experience on Halloween and vowed to never go back. In spite of ourselves, we decided to give them another shot yesterday. Ordered online through Slice. Quoted 45 min delivery. Get another email, delivery goes up to an hour. After an hour and 15 minutes, called Fabio's, waited on hold, and was bounced around before learning that our order was being packaged and sent out then. Fine. 15 minutes later, order arrives. Pizza ($20) arrives with the cheese all fallen to one side. Some slices have no cheese, others are swamped in it. Mozzarella sticks appear barely cooked. Cold inside, maybe lukewarm outside. Cheese is firm and not melted in the slightest. Caesar salad (8.25) is a bowl full of yellowed and browning lettuce and dressing - that's it. No croutons or cheese to begin to justify the price tag. Worst par!t? Called Fabio's to try to discuss my issues last night before writing a reviewing and swearing off the restaurant for good. Owner was incredibly rude. 90 minute wait time on Friday is "normal" -- interesting that this was not communicated at all. Cut me off multiple times as I tried to explain my experience. Salad could not have been brown, he said. Curious, because IT WAS. Customer service and appreciation is SO important and this owner clearly had no interest in hearing me. With so many good pizza options in the area and so many lovely business owners who are appreciative of their customers, don't give your money to this place, please. read more

Amazing ! Right from the door i got my food on time & nothing but friendly service from the door. I got the Sicilian Chicken Wrap w/ fries ( cheat day) & it was worth it. The wrap was great ! Still a healthy choice lol it had spinach , well breaded chicken breast & ozzzy mozzarella melted off a plain wrap. This is my #1 go when I'm in the area. For the price $8 not bad at all cause it added w/ crispy fries. I also got a Large Pie which was good too. read more

Fabio's Bistro - a close up of a sandwich and french fries - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey

See all

Tried the Crazy Slice yesterday and it was by far the best slice of pizza that I've had in all of Scotch Plains / Fanwood. Looking forward to trying more. read more

Ordered the $50 family dinner 1) Penne Vodka was poorly made Alfredo 2) Eggplant Parm dry, breaded with tough skin still on 3) Chicken Parm - same as eggplant parmigiana like they just randomly thru the minimal amount sauce and cheese on some and not other pieces 4) Order came with loaf of bread, I got three garlic knots 5) Salad with barely any dressing A lot of bad food for $50 plus the woman on the phone taking the order was curt and nasty....If i could give zero I would. read more

I placed my order at 6:28pm. By 8pm it hadn't arrived so I called the restaurant they confirmed what I ordered and said it would be on the way. By 9:15 we were so fed up we cancelled the order. I know this isn't their typical service but come on... read more

Usually eat at the restaurant and the entrees are always awesome. Last night I ordered a veggie pizza for delivery and it was outstanding. So happy to have it again for lunch today! read more

Fabio's food is, as most Fanwoodians know, amazing. To better enjoy the food--and keep wait times down for pickups--skip the Slice app and just call or go into the restaurant. We ordered a pizza yesterday via Slice, at 5:50 pm. The app said the pizza would be ready at 6:15, which would have been awesome. However, when my husband arrived at 6:15 to pick up the pizza, it hadn't even been made. In the time it took for our pizza to be prepared and baked, someone else came into the restaurant, placed an order, and received their food before my husband. I don't think this was personal, just a disconnect between Slice and Fabio's. That being said, during a pandemic, people want to limit their time inside enclosed spaces. The manager did offer my husband some free soda as a compensation, but my husband wanted to get out of there, not get a free beverage. So, if you want to order from Fabio's (and you should!), definitely skip the app and deal with the restaurant directly. BTW, the pizza was delicious, just late. read more

The. Worst. Ordered a huge order on Uber Eats. Never came. Called the restaurant 7 times- they kept hanging up....transferring us to a number that just disconnected. We order out A LOT and we have NEVER experienced a lack of customer service like this from an establishment. WTH!?? Never again. Total bulls**t. read more

The food taste amazing. only pizza place makes good grandma pie. the delivery isn't the best on-time service is always late I order earlier then I need it read more

Best pizza in Fanwood! My husband loves the chicken parm pizza and I always order the Brooklyn slice. Only giving them 4 stars because they seem to have a hard time keeping track of orders at busy times (like Friday nights). The wait tends to be quite long if you don't call it in by 5. Make sure you give them your name or your order could be forgotten. Great pizza though! read more

The original Fabio's made pretty good pizza. Since then, it has changed ownership at least once, and is now under new management. I ordered a spaghetti and meatball entrée for lunch. I got it in about two minutes. It seemed that the precooked pasta was dunked in hot water for a minute and not sufficiently drained, so the red sauce was watery. The spaghetti was way overcooked, almost mush, not unlike the two underseasoned meatballs on top. The two surly-looking guys behind the counter (I think at least one was an owner) walked past me several times but did not acknowledge me, or ask me if my food was satisfactory. I ate as much as I wanted to, then quickly left. read more

Fabio's Bistro - Watery, overcooked mush - Italian Near Me - Fanwood, New Jersey