Came here last year and had an amazing experience. Food was delicious, and we felt like we were stepping into a family member's house to eat. Large portions, beautiful plates and silverware, and quaint, cozy ambiance in America's oldest city. Fast forward to Saturday the 14th, and I'm back again with family visiting from out of the country. The food was good, but the vibe was a bit different. Started with chips & salsa - good, but hardly any chips. We had 3/4 of a dish of salsa remaining after finishing the chips, and we were told that we would have to pay for a refill of chips. Very sad! We also ordered two taco platters, and three chicken quesadilla platters. Food was good, but the side portions (beans and rice) were very small, and served in tiny plastic cups. The plates and silverware were replaced with cardboard plates/trays and plastic cutlery. Although the food was good, the presentation was disappointing. Our waitress did a good job, so kudos to her! $120+ before a tip - a couple more chips would have been nice, and real plates and silver would have been amazing.....just saying. read more

See all

I'm so impressed!! Going to FL from TX, have little expectations on Mexican food but I was proven wrong because Mayita was amazing. I got the lamb birria bowl and it was so tender ans well seasoned. Their rice bowls are very much like chipotle style in components but fresher. Avocadoes are fresh and tasty and they have a bunch of different kinds of hot sauces and salsa on the side. Plaintain chips are good but I wish they were warm/hot. my friends like their beef burritos a lot too. Their ranking was lamb then beef, pork, chicken. Love that the menu is quite simple and easy to order. The staffs are so friendly and helpful and location is right across the Castillo de San Marcos fortress. Would def come back. read more

Mayita - Lamb Birria bowl - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The food was really good! The server seemed very overwhelmed but nice guy! He was initially annoyed because we wanted water no ice but he slowly warmed up to us. Nice cute cozy place. The lamb bowl was sooooo good! The quesadilla was really good too! The chicken bowl was okay - kinda bland. read more

Mayita - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

It's been a common joke to us San Diegans that you can't find good Mexican food in Florida. Mayita just disproved that, but to be fair they are probably the lone example. We assumed this would just be a simple taco shop but we were wrong. The proprietor takes pride in his work and it shows. This was like a gourmet version of a Mexican food establishment. For a brief moment, I thought I was back in San Diego, right down to the Jaritos with the tacos. Well done. read more

Unbelievable Yelp said this was a number one restaurant for Mexican food as close to me as I am on Vilano Beach, which is ridiculous cause this place is awful when they don't give you everything you order to their website is terrible. They have a section that says no and then you have 13 items to pick from that says no to and then if you don't do anything or you're confused and you order on the telephone with them, they give you a completely basic piece of yuck And they don't give you everything you order if you come in to pick up like a local wood just awful. Look at the picture there's a section that you have to say no to these 13 items which we don't understand we asked them verbally and you don't get anything just awful. read more

Mayita - Ambiguous ordering menu - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Visited the Fort in St Augustine and were quite hungry afterwards, so we were looking for a kid friendly and delicious spot that would satisfy our taste buds. Mayita did not disappoint! We were seated quickly and offered drinks- my children love that they have jarritos. We got chips with salsa and queso. The queso was excellent and the salsa tasted fresh. My husband and I got bowls - pork and chicken. Both were excellent. My children got a burrito, quesadilla, and tacos. They also got fruit which looked amazing and was served with lime and Tajín. If you're in the st Augustine historical district, definitely stop into this cute little place. You will not be disappointed! read more

Outstanding! More ambitious and innovative than authentic, but they succeed! Try the taco flight with four locally sourced meats. Truly an excuse to come to San Augustin!!! :-) read more

Great fresh food. Loved the house made salsa and home baked chips. Good food, good service. Marco did a great job! read more

First time here from New York.This Authentic Mexican fare is amazing and better than any mexican restaurant in St. Augustine. The food is amazing and delicious!! read more

Went by at 1:30 today - first time based on great reviews. Spent 20 minutes looking for parking, finally had to pay $10. Get to restaurant - closed! Sign on door said back at 11:00. It's now 2.5 hours later and still closed. Unless there was an emergency, this is poor form. Will not make a trip from WGV again, just for a meal, but may give it another try if I happen to be downtown. read more

Mexican casually served on disposable dishes. Queso birria was excellent and traditional prepared with lamb. Great view of the Metanzas River. read more

Mayita - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Website was very confusing - we ordered for pick up and they forgot part of our order If you call the manager and complain they hang up on you As a local - Not worth the trouble $ read more

We stopped in for lunch and it was well worth it. The food was delicious and our server, Tammi was wonderful. The location just beside the water gave us a lovely view as well read more

Mayita - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Artistic, clean, great service, and delicious food!!! We had the chicken tinga with sangria! Super messy, fun to eat yumminess! Their home made hot sauce is fantastic! We'd definitely come back! read more

We wanted a quick bite when going to Night of Lights. The reviews were good so we came early to beat the crowds. The restaurant is cute and small with a little outdoor seating. The service was very good. We ordered a burrito, the tacos, which had one of each kind, the birria quesadilla and the chicken quesadilla. All were well seasoned and tasty. No free chips and salsa. read more

Awesome place so happy I made it in to try it, service was SUPER !!! Drinks were wonderful fresh watermelon juice was so refreshing on the hot day, the horchata tasted homemade. All the juices were fresh and not overly sweet like other places serve them. Food was yummy I had the chilaquiles with green sauce (tomatillos) super good. I ordered a side pancake for the little. It was so yummy I ate it, we also ordered the chicken enchiladas suizas (they must have been good because my daughter ate them all ! That never happens anywhere we go out to eat at. Loved everything! We will be back. Inside was colorful , pretty decor loved it all. read more

We had the lamb and pork bowls. Fresh, fresh ingredients. Clean place, great service and if your lucky a windowside table. Food tasted great. Will be going back for the tacos. read more

Relatively new place. Food was very good-authentic. Beef tacos and pork burrito, was very flavorful meat. Good service, great view.

This restaurant was a very nice surprise in our last visit to St Augustine. Everything was great, from how cordial and accommodating the staff is, the view to the bay and the carriages outside, to the quality of the food. We had the guacamole as a starter, very tasty and accompanied with, instead of traditional nachos, 4 tostadas. We then had the best tacos al pastor we've had in a while, the adobo seasoning not overwhelming but present and the small pineapple chunks in the right proportion. Highly recommended. read more

The husband and wife owners of this place were so accommodating and kind, felt like we were eating at a friends home. Food was on point, the husband is from Mexico so this is legit. Had the huevos rancheros, and it was excellent. Check it out for a great meal and a friendly smile. read more

Mayita - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This is a delicious Mexican restaurant! Been there twice & the food has been amazing both times. The service has been great also!

Fantastic little jem! Got some steak fajita tacos and el pasture tacos both had outstanding flavor. They offer a really yummy hot sauce too. Wish I had more room in my belly to try more. Very conveniently placed in the heart of town. read more

The food is so good like heavenly good. Service was amazing. They are very kind, and ambiance is very peaceful and great. There is nothing that flaws this place and I will recommend it to anyone. read more

My daughter and I were in downtown St Augustine for St Patrick's Day. Bars and restaurants were very crowded of course. We happened upon this wonderful new place. Beautiful view , perfect location, wonderful staff- it's family owned! Just wanted something refreshing so we ordered watermelon water. Oh my! It was delicious. They use the actual melon not a flavoring.AND free refill! We also got the shrimp tacos and couldn't stop raving about them! Can't wait to go back! read more

Mayita - Menu - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Great food. My husband got the lamb burria bowl. I got the chicken tacos. Very tasty! Nice location across from the bay.

Very delicious!!! I had the caprese benedictinos and the flavor combo was sooo good! Service was perfect, personable, and friendly. I want to come back and try more food! read more

We stumbled on this low-key authentic Mexican restaurant. The food was authentic, Mexican and delicious. The restaurant was clean and we had a beautiful view out the window into the St. Augustine Bay. very pleasant service, value, and exceptional overall experience. Hi Leah recommended. read more

excellent fresh food made from scratch. The owners are very nice and attentive to customers. I definitely felt a 5 star experience! No wonder this place is so highly rated. read more

What a great breakfast spot that recently opened on the water front in downtown St. Augustine! We were so fortunate to find this new spot as apparently the word isn't out YET! We were quickly seated and served. It's an "actual restaurant" where you are handed a menu and they take your order instead of ordering at the counter like many places in St. Augustine. The food was outstanding and service was fabulous. The ambiance includes a Cuban vibe that accompanies the fabulous menu selections. Our party of four ordered the breakfast platter, omelets and breakfast taco...all were delicious! The coffee was especially yummy too. I would give this place ten stars if I could. Do yourself a favor and GO enjoy a great meal with a great view. read more

Found this lovely gem on yelp. I must say from the minute you walk in you feel like you are at home! The food is amazing we tried a little bit of everything and none of the plates disappointed. The owner is so welcoming and sweet she makes you feel like part of her family. Will definitely be coming back on our next St. Augustine vacation!!! read more

Service was efficient and staff very friendly. Had several different Street Tacos. All were excellent. After lunch tried the Flan - second best I have had. Only one better was made by former colleague from Columbia. Excellent place to eat, with great food and very reasonable prices. read more

Amazing staff, this family owned business goes out of their way to make your meal a memory in their restaurant. Feels like you are in a cafe in a small town. Greeted with a smile and a description of the daily specials. They offer special flavored waters like hibiscus and pineapple, prompt to refill drinks. The food was excellent, don't regret asking them for their recommendation. Standard dishes like enchiladas and quesadilla are elevated with flavor here. If I'm ever back in St. Augustine this is where I will visit. read more

See all

Just stumbled i to this little gem of a breakfast place in St. Augustine. Food was delicious and service was excellent. Definitely plan to come back for more. read more

Delicious, authentic food. Wonderful street tacos. Mom and Pop with whole family involved. Very reasonable prices for great food. Highly recommended. read more

Excellent food and service. I got the chicken enchiladas, they were stupendous. The salsa Diabla and their salsa de habanero were both flavorful and had a great kick. The inside is very clean and looks stunning. read more

Mayita - Suiza Chicken Enchiladas - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great micheladas, Tina is so nice, this is a hidden gem, incredible views!!! We will be back soon... read more

See all

10/10 I moved here from Texas a year ago and have been craving some good Mexican food. And this is the place! Truly so amazing!!! If I could give it more than 5 stars I would!! Great atmosphere, food and AWESOME SERVICE and best of all beautiful views. read more

Mayita - Enchiladas & quesadilla - Mexican Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Love the food. Love the service! Very refreshing atmosphere! We looked everywhere for authentic Mexican and this is it!

Absolutely the best food and service in St. Augustine. Food was delicious service was excellent and atmosphere was very relaxing....... Please try this place you will not be disappointed!!!! read more

A real hidden gem. Don't let the small size fool you. The prices are very reasonable and the food is delicious. Our waiter was efficient, fast, and friendly. I had fish tacos and they were superb. My wife had shrimp and steak tacos and was very satisfied with her meal. Our friends were also happy with their selections. Try it you'll like it. read more