This is one of my favorite spots for a quick beer and sandwich. Typically you can get pretty quick service at the bar, which fully fits the pub vibe. Plenty of beers to choose from, a fairly lengthy menu and during the day it is kid friendly. Don't skip the Eileen's Dip either, great with the pretzels. read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - The Full Mickey with two Eileen Dips - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Had many fun nights at McCarthys but, not this night. Wife and I just tried to get some service outside. No one showed up. Went inside to get a drink and the hostess told us since we were outside a server would see us. Never happened. Left and spent our money across the street. Need to do better McCarthys. read more

I ordered the Madison Salad with Chicken for $20. It came with shredded iceberg lettuce, a couple of pieces of escarole lettuce, couple of pieces of Bibb lettuce, 1 cherry tomato split, a handful of almonds, a few pieces of red onions and feta cheese. The chicken breast was not fresh and the flavor was bland. I ordered a bowl of chile for $8 and it was barely warm read more

A nice and clean Irish Pub. The poutine with cheese curds is a must as are both the pub chips and key lime pie. The different pub burgers and drink selection are great. Stay away from the fish and chips though. We will be back to try pub burgers and Irish nachos next time. Thanks for the great service and cheers. read more

Food, Service, Ambiance. The potato chips were freshly made! The coleslaw was a bit small, but the taste was great. And of course the fish was great too, Thank you for such great service! You were very busy ! Thank you read more

McCarthy's is a corner lot staple in downtown PC. I have been coming here with my Army friends for years when we are in the area for training at Camp Perry. They have a very large selection of adult beverages. On my most recent visit, I tried a banana flavored cider and it was delicious. My most recent meal was the shepherds pie over fries. It was a lot of food. I found it to be way too salty so I don't think I would order it again but their shepherds pie on its own is super good. The service is excellent. I have always had a good experience here even if the food isn't always top notch. I will be back again next year! read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - McCarthy's Shepherd's Pie over fries - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

I got the fried bologna sandwich and it was amazing. Fried egg, pickled red onions, melty American cheese and house mustard. It was our servers first day and she did a good job. Classic Irish pub interior. Give them a try! read more

See all

If you enjoy Irish food... don't come here. If you've never had authentic Irish food and love soggy and salty food...this is your jam. Service was slow, tables dirty and zero offers for refills. Just. Meh. read more

Visiting the area and decided to check out this Irish pub. Place was not busy on a Monday night and had a nice atmosphere. Service was so so as we waited forever to get our drinks and it was eventually served with our appetizer. The portions are huge and the food was good. Loved the shepherd's pie but easily could have shared it with someone. My husband enjoyed the perch wrap very much too. read more

See all

Service was friendly and prompt! I ordered from the bar to go. I provided my phone # and got a text when my food was ready. I would go here for food again! read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - Finnegan's Salad with grilled chicken. Hands down the BEST grilled chicken I have ever had! - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Huge serving for my salmon avocado sandwich. Big sides. Friendly service and atmosphere. The balsamic brussels sprouts were really good!

Meh. Not that great. It's decent enough if you stick to the corned beef and cabbage, or Shepard's pie. Still not good enough to warrant revisiting. read more

Food & Drink (4 of 5) Food: Perch Basket - Tasted great; Pretty much fried to perfection for me; Also included cole slaw, tarter sauce and house made chips Drink: 20oz Bud Light   Customer Service (5 of 5) Wait: No wait, seated ourselves and our waitress came over right as we sat down. Table: Table service was great. Our waitress was very attentive to our table; Asked if we needed anything multiple times and brought everything we requested.   Atmosphere (4 of 5) Inside: The inside is like an American Irish Sports Pub. Main bar area, TV's with sports on, and music playing in the background. Cleanliness: The place looked a bit old but was clean.   Menus Prices (3 of 5) Bill: Our total order included Fish & Chips; Perch Basket; Irish Orange Mule; and 20oz Bud Light and our bill before tip was $55. The new inflationary prices are really tough on the wallet.   Overall (4 of 5) read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - Drink menu cover - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

See all

We were in town for the New Year's Eve celebration and needed a place to eat and get warm. This was the perfect spot. The place is huge. Very spacious. It has a bar and a separate restaurant. The service here was good and they have a wide selection of pub style food. Some of which are unique. I went with the beef and bacon wrapped hot dog. It was delicious. The fries are seasoned and were good too. They also have something going on there. It looked like they were having a 1920s costume contest when we were there. They had kid activities during the day and happy hour and daily specials as well. It is an Irish pub, so of course they have a wide range of beer and cocktails. I can speak from experience when I say they have a mean Bloody Mary. In a small town where many bars and restaurants are seasonal, this place is a constant. It is located in the heart of downtown and an excellent place to catch a bite to eat and an adult beverage. If you are in or going through Port Clinton, this place is definitely worth checking out. read more

A family tradition whenever we stay in Port Clinton. Always wonderful service and delicious food. The Spicy Garlic Parm wings and The Full Mickey Burger were OUTSTANDING, and SUZANNE was an attentive, engaging and fun server! See you next year! read more

See all

I had a great perch sandwich and the service is friendly. But on the menu is a car bomb burger. Personally I find that offensive and in Ireland saying things like that is not acceptable. I hope they change the name. I had gone with 1 star but that's not fair given that the place is otherwise fine, so I revised this review. read more

Friday afternoon on Labor Day weekend. The place was near empty. Why? Food was just ok but over priced. Wine was way over priced. We were at the bar and 3 foul mouthed drunks wandered in for drinks. One of the dining room waiters looked like an unmade bed. No shower, no hair brush etc. read more

I'm very happy that I stopped here, since they were only 3 stars so I questioned if I should. Our server was young man name Matt and he did a fantastic job. Our food was absolutely delicious, we really liked the spicy garlic wings and the wings were crispy on the outside but juicy in the middle. I got the Pub club, first its huge for 2 people, I got a side order of Guinness mustard for the sandwich, it was amazing! This should automatically come on this sandwich. Please try the Guinness mustard on the Pub club! I mean it is an Irish restaurant... read more

See all

This place was fun and the food was good! Traditional Irish fare that was hot, flavorful 'stick to your ribs' comfort food. The rye bread was on point! Great ambience and décor. Friendly attentive staff. Very good Guinness! read more

See all

The food at McCarthys is beyond reproach. Always top notch. The bartenders are great, especially Lyndsay. She's professional, personable, and quick. Every time I've come here the experience is phenomenal. read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

There were 5 members in our party, up from Dayton for fishing. I thought I'd researched pretty good and McCarthys was also referred to one of us but we were all disappointed! I always love to try a Rueben when on the menu and the menu picture represented the Rueben as an awesome sandwich but was so disappointed!!! The meat was sparse and the flavor was ok at most. Would not recommend to a Rueben lover. Our daughter in law also was very disappointed in her Rueben. My brother said the perch was ok. My husband said his chicken was ok, nothing exciting. The homemade chips actually "Needed" the sauce for flavor, and that had to be purchased extra. Our son ordered the grilled cheese burger. He said it was ok but felt the pizza place across the street that they ate at the previous night, was better than McCarthys. The best part of our meal for me, was the "Shepherd's Pie" loaded fries. I was looking for a wow factor from McCarthys and was really disappointed. I took photos for social media but haven't posted yet. I didn't even bother tagging us at the restaurant. Our waitress was nice. I did give her my thoughts on the sandwich lacking meat. She said she was sorry, that's it. I personally will not go back but suggest trying for oneself as the experience could be different. read more

See all

This is a strong 2.5-star review. I ordered fish & chips (the chips are indeed chips, not fries) ... so I upgraded to tots. Lots of tots. The tots were the star of the meal, followed by the cole slaw. For the price, the fish portion size struck me as a tad stingy. For me, the filet was a tad over-breaded and over-cooked. Thick breading, crusty/crunchy is not what I was expecting. My buddy ordered a burger that he described as an average, frozen patty probably sourced from Sysco or GFS. Bun? Nothing special. Fries? Again, nothing special. On the plus side of the ledger: - Clean - Good service - Hot food, hot. - Cold food, cold. - WiFi? I forget, but I think "not available." Not keen about the TV volume and the hard surfaces. Conversation at our 2-top required us to raise our voice. Will I return? Nope. read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - Fish and tots - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Service was great! Food was delicious with huge portions! Fun atmosphere and drinks were great!

Hubby and I visited McCarthys on a slow Sunday evening. We were helped to find a comfortable booth on the restaurant side and were greeted soon by our waitress. We ordered the poutine to start. It had excellent gravy, chunks of cheese curds, but cold fries. It could have been so great if the fries had just been hot. I ordered the Reuben sandwich and hubby ordered a burger (fatty something). Both the Rueben and the burger were fantastic. They were more than enough food and we both took half of our dinner home! Decor was great and they were actually playing Celtic music. A few little changes and there's 5 star potential here. We will probably return when we're in town again. read more

See all

Delicious scotch eggs, but was too full afterwards to order a main course. Too bad because there looked like some good options. I sat at the bar and the service was great and a nice atmosphere. read more

Coming back from Cleveland we decided to stop on Port Clinton to grab some lunch and we found this little place. Our bartender was nice and quickly set us up with drinks. I had a Smithwick's and my wife had a margarita, she said that the margarita was great. We ordered the Scotch eggs as an appetizer since we had never had them before. It's a hard boiled egg wrapped in sausage and then covered in bread crumbs and deep fried. You get three of them and they are cut in to quarters when they come out. They are served with a chipotle ranch dip. These eggs are awesome, I could see them for breakfast, the chipotle dip was a nice surprise in itself. My wife ordered the salmon BLT with the bar made potato chips. It was a nice sized sandwich, she loved it. The chips were awesome! I ordered the Rueben like I always do at an Irish Pub. It had great flavor, but it was cold. It wasn't very busy inside, so I was surprised that it was cold. read more

See all

Had a great meal at McCarthy's. We went on a Friday night and they had the all you can eat white fish and it was really good. Our table also got the Reuben wrap and the Corned beef and cabbage. All of the meals were good with good service to go along with it. It is a nice location also as the pub has a separate dining area if your looking for more of a restaurant feel. read more

See all

When we go to Marblehead we like to visit this restaurant. The servers / hostess are great. They sell t-shirts and other things. The food was good. read more

Madison St Salad with grilled chicken was awesome! Tons of food for the $ and great location

Great house made chips - nice patio overlooking downtown by the lake - and fun music and atmosphere read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

So glad we stopped in here to eat. The Scotch Eggs were amazing. The music was great and so was the service. Ate there twice during out weekend stay and the hit dogs may have been the best I've ever eaten. Excellent menu. read more

See all

Great food & service by Jasmine; large tables inside for indoor dining for large parties! Family friendly environment as well. Will return when we vacation here again! read more

Good food, laid back pub style atmosphere. Really enjoyable lunch. Madison salad a great choice-side salad portion was huge. Chili just ok, said it was homemade but nothing special. My friend loved the corned beef and cabbage. Baby bakers( little potatoes) are a must as a side. Ladies room was modern and clean, although toilet was ridiculously low. Can I imagine that anyone with bad knees would enjoy the lowness even with the grab bar. Ok the downside. our waitress was clueless on the menu. Every food question we asked she couldn't answer. She was nice enough but had such a nonchalant attitude that it was off putting. They were fairly busy on a Labor Day Saturday and she made it a point to tell us only one cook in the kitchen. Hopefully other servers are not so hum drum. read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

See all

Chips were horrible. Tasted like dirty grease. Dip had no flavor at all. Perch was over fried and hard . Bartender didn't care nor did he ask about our food. He was busy talking to a local that said beer is the only black thing she has done ! read more

McCarthy's Restaurant - She said it! - American Near Me - Port Clinton, Ohio

Worst place ever. Service was awful. Two losers behind the bar (when place was busy for bar crawl) were dancing and carrying on like it was their party. Was really weird. Ppl left all night. Owners need to be aware. Awful read more

My husband and I have been coming here for years. The food is always great and the staff is always helpful and friendly(we had Maygen today ). We miss the AMAZING sampler platter they used to carry! Irish nachos, sauerkraut balls, wings, skins and mozzarella sticks. It was the best. You could order that, a few Guinness and watch football all afternoon on a Sunday. Please bring back the sampler. Thanks in advance read more

Not much open at 8:30 or so on a Monday night in Port Clinton, but this place was. Not busy in my opinion, but our waitress forgot about us. I had to retrieve ketchup, tartar sauce, silverware, and napkins for our table after receiving my food and it getting cold. She never did bring the cole slaw for any of us. By the time she remembered to check on us, I was over this place and didn't care. When I told her I had to get everything, she didn't apologize. Tartar sauce was very good. Perch was OK. Fries, ehh.... I had an unsweetened ice tea and it was good. Location is good. The restaurant seemed clean, though I did not use the restroom. The bartender that helped me with all that I was missing was very helpful. We sat outside and a speaker was over our table. It was too loud. Not a fan after one visit, but there were other Irish dishes I wanted to try from the menu. I am not often in Port Clinton, so I probably will not get a chance to try this place again. Two stars seems appropriate. read more

Incredible restaurant service! Great food and our server was friendly and so sweet! The service was FAST, and our server Veronica was an amazing presence to have qt our table and her suggestions were incredible. Give this woman a raise, she deserves it! Best dining experience that I've had in Port Clinton so far! I'll be back here every Thursday until October read more

Okay scene for an Irish Pub. Food was pricey. Fires were $9 and soggy, no crunch at all. A couple nice options on tap. I probably would not come back time next time I am in Port Clinton. read more

We really liked it. The shepherd's pie is amazing. The crust and all the gravy goodness inside is soooo good. I highly recommend.