We have been trying to go to McKinely's for weeks now! Every time we try to stop by they are closed it seems like.. But some times, tragic stories have a happy ending. We stopped by on Saturday at 10:40 and saw their sign said 11:00 they would be open! We parked out side and waited until opening. Every minute of waiting was worth it! The interior has been very nicely done; granite countertops at the desk, chalkboards, a beautiful array of cupcakes, paintings, etc. The man at the counter was very friendly and welcomed us to his shop! For food I ordered a Reuben (of course) and my wife ordered the chicken, bacon, ranch sandwich. Both come with coleslaw, a pickle, and bag of chips. The Reuben, I would argue to say, was one of the best I have ever had in my life. The marble rye was so fresh and flavorful. The sauerkraut was amazing, I'm not sure how they got it to taste so good? My wife's sandwich was amazing! It had a blend of perfectly cooked tomato, chicken, ranch, cheese in a panini. Our next visit is definitely going to include trying out the cupcakes they had on display. They looked absolutely perfect! Their flavors were: French vanilla, mandarin orange, double chocolate, pína colada (spelling?), red velvet, and probably another that I'm forgetting? Can't wait to try one! In the pictures I have posted you'll find the menu with the hours so you can catch them when they're open! Enjoy! We sure did! read more

See all

Always enjoyed lunch here, yet this time the chicken salad was not up to par. It was very dry, and the chicken was big chunks. The croissant had no dressing on the bread. Lots of rules for customers to follow...maybe an off day. read more

First time in and they didn't disappoint. Food was delicious. My mom got chicken salad sammie and me the turkey pesto panini they were both delicious. Served with a bag or kettle chips, a pickle, and coleslaw. They have a area with lots of homemade dessert. You order at the counter they give a number and bring to you. It was $30.00 for our lunch and 2 teas. They bus the tables after. Very clean and cute decor inside. We will return. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Chicken salad Sammie - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

See all

I've been here twice now, and both times the sandwiches were absolutely beautiful, delicious (triple clubs ?) They definitely don't scrimp on lunch meat. service is Great I've always been greeted with a sweet friendly smile! Looks to be a nice place to meet friends for lunch.. I didn't get pictures read more

The sandwiches were good, but not quite what we were expecting. At around $35 for the Italian sandwich, the Ultimate Club sandwich, 2 bags of chips, 2 drinks, and a cupcake, it was also more expensive than we thought it would be. Each sandwich was fine, but also something we could have just made at home. It would have been nice to have the bread toasted or something other than sliced white/wheat to elevate the sandwich. The cupcake was very moist and I enjoyed the chocolate frosting, but I wouldn't call it "famously large" - while bigger than an average cupcake, it wasn't nearly as large as we made it out to be based on that description. read more

Food is fantastic! A little pricey for lunch prices but, with the way food prices and the quality of products they are using it is fair. My only complaint would be that they stayed open longer hours. read more

Fantastic lunch spot! The best sandwiches and super fast service!! This wrap was popping with flavor! read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Balsamic Chicken & Blue - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

This place has such limited operating hours. Several times we've tried to go there and they are closed before the sign says they're supposed to close. Yesterday they closed early and were even rude to us about it. Not going there again and recommend you avoid it too read more

Stopped in 30 minutes before they closed, server was great and quality of food was excellent . read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - a plate of salad and a burrito - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

I love this place it's great for lunch and the sandwiches are twists to the original favorites and some originals as well as baked delicious goods read more

I met my father who is handicapped here for lunch to celebrate Veterans Day. I went in before him to secure a table because he would need to sit right away. The owner came over to me and said I need to order my food first before getting a table. I explained my father needs to sit while I order the food. The owner then threw his hands up and huffed in annoyance and walked away. I wanted to walk out after being treated this way but it takes such effort for my dad to walk into a restaurant. Will never go back after being treated that way. Not to mention the sandwich's are mediocre and overpriced. read more

I travel for work and eat all over the place these are some of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time they were fresh they were hot The ones that should be of course everything was just super amazing I would totally come back to this place anytime I'm in town read more

Excellent chicken salad croissant. Sandwich was over flowing with chicken, and apples. My teenager also thought the Ultimate club was excellent. Neither one of us cared for the dry, vinegar based coleslaw. Nice quiet atmosphere. Friendly employees. Food was brought out in minutes. We will definitely return. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Half of the ultimate club. The other half was already devoured. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

See all

Pleasantly surprised to stumble across this sandwich shop! The pastrami panini I had for lunch was DELICIOUS and a generous portion. I also had one of their cupcakes (red velvet) which definitely lived up to the hype of multiple customers telling me I had to try one! Easy parking, indoor or outdoor dining, and friendly service. I would definitely recommend! read more

Nice little sandwich shop but hard to find as the only sign is a small white name on a mirrored window. I enjoyed the chicken salad salad. It came on a bed of spring lettuce with slices of cucumber and tomato and a small dressing. The chicken salad was well seasoned, and had Craisins and diced apples in it. It was a couple dollars more than on the menu that's here on Yelp, but it was a decent size salad. For a sandwich shop experience I would give this around four stars. I should probably do three stars just based on the number of signs they have posted around with rules on them like not sitting down until you order, not moving tables, not returning dishes to the counter, and several others. Even the number that you take to your table had instructions on where to place it on the table! It definitely detracts from the ambience, and if you are a rule follower this may make you a little nervous. I would not want to have an issue with my order because it didn't seem like a very customer friendly little place. read more

Food is good but rude owner! Wife and I rode a bike trail nearby and stopped in afterward for lunch about 11:15. My wife stepped away to the restroom so I sat at a table by the door to rest for a second and to wait on her before ordering. (Note: There were already seven people in line to order anyhow) Shortly after I sat down the taller of the two owners appeared from the kitchen and quickly and LOUDLY asked me if I had already ordered. Surprised, I replied no, that I was just cooling off from a ride and waiting on my wife first. He then "loudly" stated I am not to sit at a table unless I had ordered! I then stood and repeated what I previously said to him at the same volume he was throwing at me as if he thought he had the right to belittle customers that way for everyone in the establishment to hear. Then he turned and disappeared back into the kitchen and closed the door. I then stood there realizing after noticing their little 8x10 sign saying customers are not to sit or save tables unless they have ordered. So, he thought I was saving the table but I wasn't; but too late now. OK. Who does this? Right. No one but this bunch. Now that he had made his disgustingly rude public scene, and after my wife returned, we decided to leave and eat elsewhere. I mean I'll always abide by a business's rules, no matter how stupid they are, or I'll just quietly go somewhere else, but this time someone crossed a line and accused me of something I didn't intentionally do, loudly and publicly! Epilogue: There are nice ways to talk to people. I'm the customer. No business owner will ever talk to me like I'm an idiot, loudly and get away with it. Thus the reason I gave it back to him. So, we won't ever be back and the only reason I'm posting this is to: 1. Inform others what to possibly expect if they unfortunately get out of line in this establishment. 2. Ensure them there are indeed consequences of not treating customers with respect at ALL times. Food has always been quite good there but there are better and cheaper places to dine. I rarely to never leave negative reviews but they 100% earned this one on their own. Bye. https://fb.watch/lI5Bwid3VN/?mibextid=cr9u03 read more

Friendly service and great food! The chicken salad is delicious - a combo of chicken, cranberry, and apples. Get it on the croissant! It came with coleslaw and a 1/4 pickle. I'll definitely be back and recommend this to folks looking for great food. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Chicken Salad Sandwich on a croissant, 1/4 pickle, and coleslaw. Highly recommend! - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

Great service and food was made fast and delicious. There were a variety of cupcakes and desserts to choose from. I recommend the red velvet. read more

Corned beef on rye, I'll prepared to the extent the sandwich should have been served with a spoon.

How can you go wrong with a sandwich shop using Boar's head products. Cupcakes are great as well. Just wish they were open on the weekend.

While I did not eat here, I tried. Went for lunch and I felt I was brushed off when I was asked if I was eating in or to go. I said eating in and was told it will be a while and the person just went back to the kitchen so I just left. It looked like a nice place on the inside. I just felt since I was a single they wanted a bigger group. read more

Only open for lunch but they have the BEST soup, salad & sandwiches around. Deserts are to die for so leave room.! Highly recommend this place.! Friendly staff. read more

Thought at first they were out of business because their big sign by the road is down, but was happy to see they are still alive and well. Prompt, professional, and polite service. Nice selection of sandwiches and salads. Excellent food. Loved the outdoor patio area. Would definitely recommend! read more

Delicious lunch! Everything I had was wonderful . The staff is friendly and efficient, and the place looked great. Everything was very reasonably priced, and they have a wide selection. Stop in here when you get the chance, it's a cozy little independent business, with good food. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Turkey pesto panini, cole slaw, Zapps potato chips and pickle spear - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

Always have great fast service and the food is always AMAZING. The cupcakes are a must!

This shop opened recently, so I popped in to have a go. It turns out that the owners are the same folks that had Crave Sweet Shop on Highway 90. Nice people. The menu is the same and they still have delicious cupcakes. You can peruse my review of the previous location at the page for "Crave Sweet Shop Cafe." I'm going to excerpt a couple of paragraphs from that review below, because my comments from last year still apply. I mentioned my girlfriend's chicken salad sandwich, so the plurals below are referring to that. I had the Cuban sandwich (see the picture), which also came on a ciabatta roll, which was then toasted on a panini press. The bread was crisp and chewy, just like the bread on a Cuban sammitch should be. I could taste the mojo-marinated pork roast and the ham had the taste and appearance of home-baked and -sliced ham. Instead of regular yellow mustard, a spicy variety was slathered on both sides, which was quite tasty. Hearty dill pickle chips and Swiss cheese complimented the main ingredients. A bag of chips and a side of very good cole slaw came with both sandwiches. We were both satisfied with the quality, although I thought the Cuban, at $10, was about $3 too expensive for the portion. Back to the present day. Look, it was a very good sammitch. Above average in every way. But with a Diet Coke, my bill was $12.51. After the tip, I paid $15.01 for lunch and left hungry. This is Milton, Florida, not Miami or Atlanta or Los Angeles. As good as it was, I'm not going to spend $15 on lunch very often. I expect steak for that sum of cash...or boobs. Although I don't wish to survey nakedness while I'm eating. I wish them well, honestly. I just can't imagine much return traffic at those rates. So, my 5-star sandwich gets clobbered down to a 3-star rating, solely on price. If you don't mind spending vast sums on good food, you should visit. My girlfriend loved her chicken salad. I loved my Cuban. I just don't love spending $15 on a lunch that I have to supplement with other food from less expensive places. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Cuban Panini with slaw side. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

Been here multiple times the sandwiches are very good. My wife and I have had different sandwiches and they have all been great. The pimento cheese with bacon is wonderful. read more

Haven't been there for a minute. But when I was there it was very good and service was also good. Food is awesome and well priced.

It wasn't what I expected...not the typical sandwich shop. You order at the counter, get a number and take a seat. They make your sandwich in the back. The bread was awesome and they put plenty of meat on the sandwiches. The Buffalo Chicken Wrap had more chicken in it than any wrap I've ever had. It was all very good and high quality. Everything seems to come with a bag of chips, cole slaw and a pickle. The only negative was that if you want anything other than water or tea, it is sold by the can. But...their sweet tea was fantastic. Watch their hours...only open for lunch. read more

There aren't that many places to eat around Milton but I heard that this place is decent. I went with the cuban sandwich which really didn't have any taste for some reason. I mean, it had the right ingredients on there, but I think the meat was just too dry. If they used fresher/juicier meats, I probably would've loved my sandwich. I liked their fresh-tasting coleslaw and the big partial pickle they include with the meal. I don't think I'd come back here but it's not a bad choice for lunch. Maybe just don't get the cuban sandwich! read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

The wraps and sandwiches here are epic! My favorite wrap is the chicken balsamic blue They have a variety of soups on rotation that are great, too. For a tasty dessert, the cupcakes are a wonderful treat! read more

Was slightly disappointed they didn't have their chicken salad, but that was quickly overcome by the absolute awesomesauce that is their Turkey & Cranberry; recommended. A bit on the sweet side with the cream cheese and cranberry spread - but couple that with some Zapps Voodoo chips and a pickle slice, BANGARANG!! read more

First time back in 2 years due to Covid. Wife had huge chicken salad which she loved. Chunkier chicken than the usual which might have overloaded a sandwich but She had it on greens with baby tomatoes. 1/2 came home with us. I had, despite my formal jewish deli upbringing a "pastrami reuben" . Now a reuban is corned beef, not pastrami. I was concerned. No worries, other than too drippy russian dressing, or maybe it was excess sauerkraut juice leaking into and diluting the dressing , my plate, shirt and hand, it was excellent. But folks, press that kraut before slapping it on and consider diy dressing with mayo, catsup, garlic, relish as a less liquid spread. 1/2 came home with us. Stopped at the store for swiss cheese and rye bread to remake it for dinner. read more

This is my go to lunch spot for takeout at work! Always fast friendly service and excellent quality sandwiches for not much more than you'd pay at a fast good chain! So happy you guys are surviving 2020!! read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Chicken salad on croissant. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

Well. You know how it is. Everybody's taste is not the same. We stopped by McKinely's for the first time to check out their lunch menu and had no problem making our selections. Unfortunately, we picked a busy time as there wasn't much for seating. The service was good. The food arrived promptly but it was tasteless. Even the cupcake we shared was dry. Our first visit was our last. read more

This place was amazing. The cupcakes were to die for. The frosting was so sweet and very good. The cupcake was moist and very tasty. I loved my sandwich and would totally get it again. The flavors were great and I wouldn't have expected them to work so good. But I was presently surprised with how good it turned out. The people were sweet at the front and very helpful. I would totally come here again read more

This place doesn't look like much from the outside, but after stepping in we were pleasantly surprised. Great crowd for 11:30 on a Wednesday, too. Really excellent sandwiches, and not just run-of-the-mill combinations. Nice atmosphere and good service. The "blue Chicken" wrap was to-die-for and my husband said his club sandwich was the best he'd had in ages:very generous with really nice meat cuts. Looks like our new favorite lunch place! read more

The best sandwiches and coleslaw I've ever had came from this restaurant. I live 5 hours away now and as soon as I get a long weekend I will be driving back to Milton for a sandwich - that's how good they are. The owners are personable and I have never seen them treat a guest with anything but respect. Having gone here more than 50 times, I've seen a lot of different customers and all were treated perfectly. The owners are accommodating when people want to alter their orders and are willing to make changes. We had a group of 14 people meet here for lunch one day and they took care of it flawlessly, even though we asked them to split checks in 5 different ways. They're accepting, tolerant, and Milton could use more people like them. People seem to like to complain about the price, but Boar's Head meat/cheese isn't cheap. If you just want a plain old sandwich with nothing special, Subway isn't far. read more

McKinely's Sandwich Shop - Turkey Cranberry - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Florida

Generous portions on the club. Was not expecting a local diner to be so generous. Bacon was thick sliced and as you wrap your mouth around the sandwich you know there is more than bread and mayo. Small facility but great on flavor. Will return as time permits. Prefer to go here now than SUBWAY, sandwich weighs more than a footlong loaded with toppings. read more

Stopped here yesterday for lunch. I was told it was good, but wasn't sure what to expect from a Milton sandwich shop. Well, they definitely wow'ed me. They even had a closed-in outdoor patio to enjoy the nice weather on. I ordered the chicken salad sandwich on a croissant. It was good sized and tasted awesome. Came with chips, a pickle, and coleslaw. After I was done, I wanted another to bring home. Will definitely be back to try the rest of the menu. Also, there were some very tempting looking cupcakes there. Not sure if they were homemade or made by someone else locally, but they looked dangerous! read more