Excellent meat and service . They will vacuum pack all steaks , etc . For a nominal fee .read more

Everything is local, super fresh and delicious. A classic family run meat market. I had marinated…read morestew meat and sausages ( green pepper and onion) best I've ever had.

First time was better than the second time. Today's brisket sandwich tasted like it was sitting in…read moreau jus too long or it was reheated from yesterday. Maybe both? The texture and cut were also completely different than previously. Mac n cheese not good today. Tasted like a watered down stouffers frozen dinner without the yummy burnt edges. I may give this a third try at some point, like when it's busier or later in the day when the meat is fresh. $14 for the sandwich and side wasn't terrible for the portion size, which was larger today as well. Maybe they were moving out the old stuff. Who knows? Better luck next time.

Skimpy, mislabeled, and dry. I got the chicken platter with collard greens. Actually, though you…read morecouldn't tell from the menu, the platter is just the sandwich but instead of chips it comes with a small side and a drink. The sandwich, which I got with Carolina sauce, was still dry and had way more bread than bbq. The collards had good flavor. Overall, I was disappointed with the quantity and the quality. I've heard the Mac and cheese bowl is way more food but similarly mediocre. Don't think I'd go here again. If I did, it definitely wouldn't be for a "platter"

This review is based off the pre-prepared/grocery side of the store (although we will CERTAINLY be…read moreback for the restaurant side.) While in town, we wandered in wishing we had already grabbed some baked goods earlier in the day. And with a mission to acquire some meat for the grill later in the day. Immediately we were met with a variety of whoopie pies (we got a traditional one and cookie one, both delicious), and most of all the BEST cinnamon roll we have ever feasted on. Not only was it tremendous but it was perfectly gooey, and the buttercream (or at least that's how it tasted) frosting in lieu of traditional icing blew it out of the water. We also grabbed some chicken bacon burgers which we grilled up and really enjoyed. Just wished the patties were initially bigger. We ended up putting 2 and 2 (out of the 4) together to make burgers which would actually survive the grill. In general the selection is everything you'd imagine in Amish country combined into one little place. Prices were excellent, quality was great. Definitely stop in!

This was my first trip to Lancaster County, PA. My daughter and I took a buggy ride and wanted to…read morewalk to a spot for lunch. Perusing Yelp, I saw Stoltzfus (a local last name that was mentioned by our buggy guide) and it was a deli/restaurant- you had me at meat! You order at a walk up counter, get a buzzer, wait as they make it fresh, get buzzed, and pick your order up. Plenty of clean seating is available. The Philly cheesesteak was awesome! Lots of meat, tender but substantial roll, and hot! I got it sauced - this was new for me. I was thinking cheese sauce, but it was a red sauce. I loved it regardless ( my daughter wasn't as happy - not because it tasted bad, but she wasn't expecting it). We didn't have to wait to order, but once we were eating-the line was easily 25-30 deep. The eating section is called Amos' Place. The meat section is Stoltzfus Meats. A wonderland of fresh, frozen, and refrigerated meats and all the accompanying side dishes! There is also a very good selection of baked goods, spices, and munchies. Oh, the white root beer was good! I will definitely be back!

I have been going here for years and will say their meat is top notch. This butcher raises her own…read morecattle so it's really fresh! There prices are perfectly inline with their quality and will be a customer for a long time. If you haven't tried them I would recommend there Ribeyes or Filets! Both IMO best in the area. No I am not payed and yes I have had meat from multiple meat markets and butchers from the York County, Adams County area.

They have a great selection of deli foods as well as beef jerky. The service is always quick and…read morepleasant. They have sandwiches premade. They have bowls premade sometimes they have fried chicken and other times they have fried fish.

I love this butcher shop. They have a great selection of meats, as well as frozen/deli items. I…read morealso enjoy that they offered dog treats near the front door- that is always a must grab.

I love this butcher shop! Super quality of meats and cheeses, great selection and great service…read more I'm about an hour away, but will make the trip because I can't get that quality near me.

I love the smell as you walk through the door and a greeting from the owners and employees. The…read moreservice is great. The quality of meats are vantastic. They may be small but when in season they have fresh produce. Baked goods, Milk , Ritcheys ice cream which is very good. Worth the trip.

I can only make it up here when I visit my grandmother who lives in the area; however, when I do it…read moreis a must stop. I stock up on the smoke ham (like 5 lbs at a time) which is absolutely delicious and very reasonable priced. They are also very kind people! I highly recommend stopping by.

They always have the freshest meat they always courtesy and friendly…read more I don't know what I would do if I couldn't shop there. Love them so much It's a country Deli butcher shop great variety and they always have specials.

Godfrey Brothers is a superb local butcher. The service is always great with friendly knowledgeable…read morestaff who will recommend the best cut for the meal you want to make if you ask. Quality of their meats is far superior than the grocery store. They also carry gulf shrimp and their sourdough bread partner just started providing sliced loaves of bread.