Great food. Best Sunday after church restaurant in Collierville. Fresh mozzarella made on site,…read moreother ingredients imported directly from Italy. Owner is present to ensure the best quality. BIG FANS!!

This used to be my favorite pizza place for wood fire pizza. Stopped by there to grab a 12" inch…read morepizza at lunch. There was hardly anyone in there. The pizza was $20 - which I was ok paying if it was worth it. Unfortunately, this place has really gone downhill in terms of quality. There was barely any pizza sauce or cheese. All the vegetables on the pizza was still raw and barely cooked. Hopefully, they can turn things around, but for now, I'll be going elsewhere for wood fire pizze.

Amazing pizza. The cheese fries appetizer was on point. The service was good. We don't enjoy any of…read morethe tasty looking beverages from the bar, but next time, for sure. Really good food and I wanted to drop a 5-star rating.

We visited Rotolo's today around 2:30pm and it was the perfect time to go! There was hardly anyone…read morethere, so we were seated immediately with no wait. If you're looking for a quieter time with quick service, mid-afternoon is definitely the way to do it. This was actually our second time here, and it's been amazing both times. It's so nice to find a place that's consistent with both food and service. We ordered the Classic Cracker Thin pizza and it was incredible. The crust was perfectly crispy, the flavor was on point, and the toppings were generous. It's also a HUGE pizza and could easily feed 3-4 people, which makes it a great value for the price. Our server was also so friendly and attentive. I can't remember his name, but he was one of the bartenders. We'll definitely be back again!

Very well made pizza that tastes just like something you would get in New York! I would recommend…read morejust a plain cheese pizza. It really doesn't need anything else!

Listen... If you're looking for real NY style pizza, near the Mississippi, in Western Tennessee…read more.. this is the place. FOR REALS. Their plain cheese, and their pepperoni is absolute perfection. Slices had no slop jalop, but I'd say it varies depending on if it's been sitting. The sauce, the cheese, it all came together. The pepperoni pie is just as incredible, loaded with pepperoni and made right. The crust? Oh yeah. It's got that signature NYC touch. Maybe it's the water? It tastes right. The real deal is how it holds up later, and this crust is just as good sitting on the counter just as it is piping hot fresh out of the oven. It doesn't turn into teeth shattering leather as I've had the pleasure of experiencing with other places. Super friendly folks behind the counter. Fast service, and easily my favorite pizza spot in town. Worth it every time.

Pizza and salads are always on point. BBQ Nachos are very good. My first time getting a…read moresandwich-it did not have the ingredients stated on the menu and was toasted to the point of being burnt. I could have went and complained but was dining with a friend and honestly just let it go because I was more focused on visiting with my friend than the food. Oh, I really enjoy the Community tea and lemonade that they serve-super tasty, great quality stuff. The service there is always good. Never been disappointed by it in easily a dozen visits. I really like that the restaurant is spacious and has very nice outdoor seating as well. My family has enjoyed a few meals al fresco there. Lost is reliable. My poor sandwich experience was a one off i believe.

Ordered a custom built with cupping pepperoni. You have to pick between thick or thin crust. No…read moreregular. So I erred on the side of caution and went thin. Waited half an hour and got what looked like a cheese pizza with 1 pepperoni on it and no cupping pepperoni. Told one person and they said maybe it's under the cheese and the cupping pepperoni just flattens out as a result. I gave her the "c'mon now" look as their own pictures show it on top and nicely cupped. She said hey I just work here. Told the cashier and she said she entered it correctly and then the same story about how maybe it's just under the cheese. Then she just shrugged and smiled. Then Spoke with someone else and they said it's definitely wrong but that they could fix it. I heard them telling the back guys to just rebake the same pizza and I stopped them because I knew the bottom would be burnt af. She said she would have them make a new one. It came out faster. Maybe 15 minutes. when I finally got my pizza there weren't a ton of pepperoni. Taste wise it wasn't anything special. I'd say just average at best. Lots of customers here but they do have a prime location. Not sure what "lost" means in the name but I sure hope they find their way someday given their prime location.

The calzone is small and the topping light... won't order it again. They need to up their game…read more Other better choices in Collierville now.

Yes it is true pizza is food yum pizza on this visit pizza medium sized they offer a smaller &…read morelarger size as well good service chill ambiance Pizza came out hot and cheesy

Pizza was Awesome, I'm originally from Michigan where we…read moregrew up eating deep-dish Chicago-style pizza pies. From my initial call to the restaurant the service was pleasant and inviting. They said my order would take 45 minutes, but I was eating in 30, The delivery driver was courteous and friendly. Finally, the pizza reminded me of home, it was delicious and not soggy and heavy like like some pizza, But it was very filling. Consider me a super satisfied customer.

Pretty good pizza but careless prep. I had Mushrooms and…read moreSausage added. big pieces of mushroom in a few places-some slices had no mushroom. Also did not like the hand tossed crust-too doughy. I should have requested thin crust. Taste was good and good

Hubby loves this place specifically for the old fashioned pepperoni. It's not my thing but that's…read moreok. I really liked the new spicy cheezybread (it wasn't spicy but tasty) especially with the Jalapeno Ranch Cup. It was delish! My all time fav ANYWHERE is pineapple, pepperoni, and jalapeno. It goes hard here too. To Try: Hawaiian Chicken Love: - Pizza: Pineapple, Pepperoni, and Jalapeno - Sauce: Jalapeno Ranch Cup - Side: Inferno Cheezybread - Side: Fiery Cheezybread Like: - Pizza: All Meat - Pizza: Chicken and Tomato and Bacon with white cheese sauce instead of marinara - Pizza: Pepperoni and Pineapple and Jalapeño Ok: - Pizza: Black Olive and Mushroom - Pizza: Chicken Fresco - Pizza: Grilled Chicken Florentine - Pizza: Meat Supremo - Pizza: The Philly - Pizza: Triple Pepperoni Magnifico - Side: Cheezybread Disliked: - Pizza: Pepperoni Magnifico

I love the old fashioned pepperoni from here. I go here just for that pizza the pepperoni…read moremagnicifico. The triple pepperoni magnifico is ok but I really just want the old fashioned pepperoni not the regular one so I will stick to the regular one.

I was impressed with the quality of the pizza and roll. We ordered the thin crust and were blown…read moreaway! Their limited time Greek Feta Roll is worth the try. Our server recommended the garlic aioli sauce and it was perfect! Pretty quickly service overall on a busy night. Server was friendly and gave great recommendations.

It's been years since I last visited a Mellow Mushroom. I decided to go with their sausagefest…read morecalzone, and it was incredibly satisfying. The crust had that signature doughy texture, and they definitely didn't short the fillings. Every bite was meaty and loaded with cheese. My only small adjustment was that I needed to order extra sauce on the side, for the second half. The one sauce didn't quite cut it for the whole 'zone. I'd definitely recommend it. Also, their Caesar salad was actually very tasty! The salad I asked for it lightly dressed, and they brought it perfectly. Overall the service was great and it had the quirky mellow vibe.

Hadn't been in 3 years. Was disappointed that the new owners removed one of my favorite parts…read moreabout the place, the music. We always enjoyed the Frank Sinatra Italian style music playing in the background it was a true Italian experience. The food was ok, the service wasn't the best.

MONDAY NIGHT. My husband and I are trying new places in town and we decided to invite my…read moremother-in-law who is gluten free. They had gluten free spaghetti and gluten free crust (so all pizzas were gluten free - and many gluten free things are not very good but my MIL ate her entire pizza without a single allergy problem). I was extremely happy that they accommodated her food allergies and we ordered a bottle of wine that was really good! (The flower name). The service was really great (I was worried because previous reviews criticized the service). They sat us on the indoor patio and the vibe was exactly what I was looking for! I hope they continue to include gluten-free options because my family and I will be back many times over!! This place so far is our favorite place in Collierville (and we're touring all the restaurants).

Popped in for a quick bite. I ordered the BBQ salad and the shredded pork tasted like shoe…read moreleather that's been sitting around. The salad was mostly lettuce with about 4 big, tough pieces of meat. My son got a gluten free pizza that looked decent...the crust wasn't that great but the pizza itself was just ok. Nothing to scream in delight about.

Stooped in for a quick bite to eat. The line was short but moved VERY slow. The workers were nice…read moreand pleasant just painfully slow. My salad was great. I got a spicy ranch dressing that was very tasty. My husband got the BBQ pizza and he said they were too heavy with the BBQ sauce. Other than that, I was good. We had stopped going for a while but will put this back in rotation.