We stopped in here on our way from Show Low to Williams and we were not disappointed! Our food was amazing (pizza & chicken fettuccine Alfredo) and the service was quick. The building does not look like an establishment that would serve hot quality food, but don't let that deter you, as it most certainly does. Definitely recommend this place if you're passing through! read more

Great unexpected Italian food (we enjoyed the pasta dishes very much) BUT do NOT trust the gluten free pasta! (GF kid was truly sick later.) I am vegan and loved the pasta pomodoro. It was fresh and flavorful and satisfying. My partner had the chicken Jerusalem and seemed pretty blissful. Our other kid enjoyed the manicotti and cheese sticks. The restaurant is attached to a sports bar but don't let that stop you from enjoying this. As long as you don't have Celiac! read more

If you're ever in Holbrook, this is place to go for dinner. It's a sports bar on one side and an Italian restaurant on the other. You can get the Italian food on the bar side and vice versa. The interior is cinder block and on either side of the restaurant, there are dilapidated buildings but do. It let that fool you. The food is amazing. I had the capellini pomodoro and it was perfection. Hubby had spaghetti and meatballs and enjoyed greatly. Service was friendly and attentive. Highly recommend. We may permanently change our driving route to come back in the future. read more

Had it not been for an acquaintance telling me about this place, I probably wouldn't have stopped in. This is a sports bar with a restaurant attached to it. You enter in through the bar and off to the left is a non descript door leading you to a find with really good food. Once inside, you'll find 20-25 tables, two hardworking servers and HOT food. When you're warned about the "hot plate" they're not kidding. Service was a little slow, but there are only two servers. Salad was nothing special. Garlic bread could have been toasted more with additional butter and garlic. Main dishes were on point. Lasagna came out hot and tasty. Chicken parmigiana served with spaghetti was steaming hot. It was all really delicious. So, if you're in Holbrook, stop by this little gem and enjoy some good Italian food. read more

See all

The service was great, very friendly, helpful. The food was Very good- spaghetti and meatballs, with a side salad and garlic bread. Dessert was bananas foster and was absolutely delish. this was the 2nd time we ate here--when traveling through town.... we would go again! Great food great place great people! worth the stop! read more

See all

Our server Beatrice was an excellent server. One of our favorite family spots to go to. We enjoy the pizza, wings, chicken/salmon picatta, and calamari fra diavolo. Nothing else has caught our attention. I'd say if you're going to have an alcoholic beverage, choose beer or wine. BTW I tried the bruchetta the last time I was there and wasn't impressed.I have yet to try a lot of other things on the menu. read more

Not a bad spot for Italian and it's a sports bar right next to each other. The restaurant was busy and packed so they sat us in the sports bar area. Music was a tad bit loud but it makes sense for the sports bar. The waiter/bartender was nice and tender to our orders. Sometimes the drinks wouldn't come like the wine a friend ordered but the food came out reasonably. I ordered the lemon salmon piccata and it was fine. Not bad but nothing to write home about. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Lemon salmon piccata - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

Good location close to our hotel (the front desk recommended the place). Very much feels like an Italian mom and pop restaurant. I had the Manicotti and my partner had a personal pizza with wine. I can't remember how long it took to be served but I don't have anything negative to say about this place. The food was great and the service nice. The price is on par with other eateries in the area. Yum! read more

What a great spot! This place definitely has more of a sports bar vibe than a restaurant vibe, but the food is delicious nonetheless! Pool tables, sports on TV, locals hanging out, and a really casual scene. But, again, the food is great! I got the fettuccine alfredo. It came with a salad and garlic bread. I also ordered a whiskey coke, and the totaly was $25. Great deal! The bartender/server was the only front of house staff and she did great. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Fettuccine Alfredo, yum! - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

Food: One of the surest signs of an excellent restaurant is when every single item you order off the menu is simply awesome and when we actually finish all of our dishes down to the last lick of our plates!! Simply a burst of fresh flavors and decent portions makes for a very happy and fulfilling meal. Superb quality food! Burp! :) Service: Our host Dustine is simply the best! Always with a smile, happy cheer, she answered all our questions about the menu very patiently and offered great suggestions especially for the kids. Thank you so much! :) Ambience: Nice ambience with neat tables and well laid out floor plan and nice vibes and decor. Great music too. :) Parking: No issues at all. Restroom: Squeaky clean just like our own home! Impressed! All in all, very very good, highly recommend! :) read more

See all

Ordered a pizza for take out along with a order of garlic bread. The pizza was good. The garlic bread wasn't as chrisp as we were expecting and wish it would of come with some marinara sauce. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

We stopped in during our Route 66 trip! We were not disappointed. Beatrice was our server, friendly, attentive. The salad was fresh, the garlic bread was yummy and our food was nice and hot! I loved the sauce. The bar room was filled I believe with locals and that was fun to watch. It was a great stop, I'd go back if I'm ever in the area again. read more

We were in the area to visit the Petrified forest National park nearby . The ambience was nice for a small town. Definitely a nice sports bar with a good and welcoming crowd. The pasta was a bit bland with not much layers of flavoring, but the garlic bread and caesar salad were amazing. Was a good spot for food in a small town. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Caesar salad - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

See all

Delicious food and great vegetarian options. Stopped in on the way to the painted desert. Great service and good prices. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Tri-Colored Tortellini - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

See all

I shared the Shrimp Scampi with my brother and the price was not worth the taste. More oily with very little taste. We also had an order of Fettuccine Alfredo which was mediocre at best.This was our very first impression of this 4.5 star? establishment, and it was also our last time visiting. Regardless the service was okay. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

Well it's nothing fancy, but the server was nice, friendly and enjoyable to talk with. Food was good, it was a lot but tasted great. I doubt if I'll be on Holbrook again but if I am I would eat here again read more

I love road trips and the random places you can find to eat in towns you didn't intend to stop at. Well this little gem was unexpected and amazing!! Italian food was delish! I wasn't expecting a Michelin star meal but it served it's purpose and the chicken parmigiana was legit good. Better than nice dining I have had in bigger cities. And the bar was a place I could totally see me hanging out in if I lived in the area. It has that local stripped down vibe. The staff was super nice and hospitable. read more

See all

Our first time here and it was great!!!Phenomenal food and service! We tried the pasta sampler, clam linguine, and chicken alfredo. Each dish came out hot, fresh, and tasty. We tend to be a little sensitive to too much salt and sugar but this place perfectly seasoned their food. They brewed fresh coffee for us. The bread is soft and warm. It's clean and quiet enough to enjoy conversation with our table. Highly recommend. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Garlic bread - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

See all

We were driving through again and came back. Still just as delicious. I got the salmon piccata again and my husband got the clam linguine. Both are extremely good. We didn't leave much on our plates. They even needed seconds of the delicious garlic bread. And Jayla did an outstanding job. read more

See all

Went here after a long day at the Petrified Forest on our way to Phoenix. Food was excellent, staff was friendly and provided great service. The restaurant is a sports bar on one side and an Italian restaurant on the other. But once inside the Italian side you'd never know it. Recommended. read more

We celebrated our anniversary dinner here . Dustine was AMAZING!! New Year's Eve and full house we still had a great meal and service read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Chicken Jerusalem - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

See all

Review update! On night 10 of my stay, I made my final visit to Mesa. I'd been here on alternating nights for all 10 nights (5 visits). Yes it was that good. Story time: On my last night in town I accidentally left my corporate credit card on the table. I woke up at 4am and immediately knew that I had left the card. A quick check of my wallet confirmed my fear. All of the hassle of what to do next was really getting to me. They don't open until 4pm and I had to leave town at 10am to catch my flight home to Florida from Phoenix. I went for my early morning walk in the six o'clock hour. My walk took me by the restaurant. I noticed a truck in the parking lot (there was hope!) I walked up to the windows but could not see anyone inside. (My hopes were dashed!) I kept on walking down the street wallowing in my sorrows. On my walk back up the street I saw a woman about to get in to the truck. I flagged her down and asked if she worked here. (She did) I told her about my card and she was more than happy to go back in to the restaurant and check. Christina was the epitome of customer service! I got my card back! I doubt my travels will ever bring me back to the area, but if they do I know where I'll be coming! read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

See all

Not a lot of dining options in this area other than fast food. This is a sitdown restaurant and was very well populated at a Thursday night. Lots of drink choices. Adequate food selections. I had the veal Parmesan with spaghetti on the side. Spaghetti was wonderful. Veal was very tough. It came with garlic bread and a side salad, which was a great value. Best part of the meal was the tuxedo cake that I had for dessert. Service # was good. Restaurant had an odor of exhaust fumes from vehicles. Not sure why that was, but you could definitely smell it. read more

See all

Fantastic Italian dinner! I read about this place on Yelp and boy were we delighted. 11yo ordered the chicken Alfredo fettuccine and it was the standout. Hubs the individual lasagna and me the meatballs linguine. The meatballs were good sized and tender. Pasta and sauce yummy. Service was good. It was packed and the water girl and busser were very efficient. Individual slices of warm baguette with oil and seasoning were tasty. I'd upgrade to the Cesar as the house salad is a little wimpy. Nice dinner option in Holbrook. read more

Definitely an experience worth checking out. Don't judge a book by its cover here. Walk through the lounge to get to the restaurant. Our server Dusty was pleasant and quick to our table, throughout the meal. Food was more than what we expected. The Chicken Jerusalem was excellent! Meat Lasagna was full of meat and also a good sized portion. The chicken Alfredo was also very good and even the bread was great!. All the dishes were served quickly and were very hot when delivered to the table. Definitely something to check out if passing through. read more

I don't think the owners or whoever cooks the food has ever eaten Italian food cooked by anyone of Italian descent. The sauce and sausages were burnt in the sausage and peppers pasta, the artichokes clearly came from a jar and the clams in the linguine with clam sauce were canned. read more

Outstanding food, service and overall experience. The lasagna and manicotti were delicious, as was the house Italian and bread. Even the water tasted refreshing. Beatrice our waitress gave us 5 star service. The chef is amazing! Loved our experience so much we sat in the bar afterwards to have a Coca-Cola and watch the game. The bartender was super friendly. We will definitely be back! Excellent price as well... 5 stars plus!! read more

Traveling back from California, we spent a night In Holbrook At checkin, Mesa was recommended to us This restaurant is very modest but very clean. The host was very nice, professional and hard working Our waitress was as sweet as she could be and went above and beyond for us. We were served very fresh salads and garlic bread My husband is half Italian from North Jersey and knows good Italian cuisine. This restaurant definitely surpassed our expectations. He loved his egg plant Parm and my chicken Alfredo was delicious My only negative is that it's too far from home read more

See all

The service was excellent. Wait time was minimal. The food was very good. We had 1 Chianti, Stuffed mushrooms 2 combos with the red and white sauce and 1 chicken Parm. Everything was very good. The portions could have been a little bigger and it is expensive. But we will be back. read more

Nice little restaurant close to Route 40/66 in Holbrook. Stopped here while traveling across the country since we wanted to see the Petrified Forest NP and Painted Desert. We were in the mood for pizza and we are happy to report it is delicious! Service was prompt and friendly. The pizza dough was amazing. Toppings were generous and the 16" pizza was more than enough for two of us - 3 pieces leftover. Just what we craved. read more

See all

Service was fantastic, food was delicious, atmosphere in the sports bar was interesting given the Italian menu options, but all in all, it was a delightful experience. Highly recommend anytime you're in Holbrook. read more

We stopped at Mesa Italiana while passing through Holbrook and were pleasantly surprised. I ordered the lasagna--hearty, flavorful, and exactly what I was hoping for after a long drive. Our server, Beatrice, was friendly and attentive without being overbearing, which made the experience even better. Prices felt fair for the quality and portions. If you're on I-40 and want a solid Italian meal with warm service, this is a great pick. Would happily stop again. read more

Holbrook is not a big town but glad I found this spot while I was traveling through. Service was good and so was the food. Place is not new by any means but it's a small desert town with that being said it is a good meal. read more

Mesa Italiana Restaurant - Chicken parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Holbrook, Arizona

Six of us went to dinner here when we were traveling through. We had appetizers, drinks and dinner. We were all pleased with our food and drinks. If we leaved near by it would be a regular dining place for us. read more

Good price, exceptional food. Can't go wrong here. Chicken parm was perfect, great red sauce.

I am pleasantly surprised by this place. We were in Holbrook, coming from the White Mountains for the Pat Kenny wrestling tournament. We were craving Italian food and decided to try this spot. We had to go through the lounge bar to reach the restaurant. My husband ordered calamari as an appetizer, and it came out in a spicy red sauce. The calamari was not breaded. It was actually really good alongside the garlic bread they provided. I ordered the grilled salmon, which was also very good, with a light sauce containing capers and lemon, served with spaghetti. My husband had the lasagna; he wished it had more layers of pasta, but overall, it was pretty good. My daughter had the shrimp scampi with linguine and liked it. She also ordered the banana dessert. The banana dessert is questionable to me because it's a little too sweet on my side. Overall, the place is small and cute. It probably needs some remodeling, as it feels a bit outdated. Still, the food is really good, and I would definitely come back again. Four out of five stars. read more

See all

Trust the Italian right on route 66 .Opera music plays in the background. A good red sauce joint - chicken cacciatore was on point. Servers are cool and friendly. Recommended. read more

Only come here on occasion. It's pretty good. The chicken Jerusalem is always a go to, very flavorful.

The last thing I expected to find in Holbrook, AZ was a 5* Italian Restaurant. Mesa Italiana offers superb Italian cuisine, excellent service, and a relaxed atmosphere. And they do all this for a very reasonable price. It's the only reason we stay a night in Holbrook on our seasonal migrations between Wisconsin and Arizona. Highly recommended. read more

Sat at the bar. got stuffed shells which came w a Caesar salad. Stuffed shells were pretty good but salad was not.