Mickey&#x27;s Pizzeria

It's just your neighborhood pizza joint. Nothing fancy just pizza and a couple of hero's on the…read moremenu. There's sporadic parking outside, it is more of the kind of place you walk to, and get takeout there. There are three tables with about 10 seats altogether. We're not talking to Michelin stars here. But, it's not a greasy spoon either. Simple and unassuming.

Ode to Capri You have always been there for me, your pizza…read moreand calzones are delicious in my tummy The NY Italian husband is picky But you always deliver Thin crust, Can feed a crowd Cheesy and toppings evenly spread Try the thin cut, fried eggplant on a cheese pizza- welcome to perfection

7/5/25 - where the pizza's made. Menu above

7/5/25 - slice with sausage

See all

Jan. 2026 - the menu

Gino's Pizzeria

4.6(112 reviews)

2.0 mi

This place was voted best pizza in Yonkers and I had to check it out. It's a small space with three…read moretables. They used to be cash only, but now they take card (with fee). The pizza was delicious!

Gino's Pizzeria is a true South Broadway staple and a go-to spot for consistently good food. The…read morepizza is perfectly seasoned--savory, satisfying, and always hits the spot whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie. What really sets Gino's apart is that they offer so much more than just pizza. Their menu includes favorites like fresh, hot zeppoles, indulgent fried Oreos, crispy chicken tenders, flavorful beef patties, and plenty of other comfort-food options. It's the kind of place where everyone can find something they're in the mood for. The service is friendly and welcoming, giving you that classic neighborhood pizzeria experience where you feel like a regular even on your first visit. Reliable food, generous options, and great service make Gino's Pizzeria a Yonkers classic that continues to stand the test of time. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.

July 1st

Pizza slice, garlic knot, and Chicken Parm Roll

See all

Large cheese slice

Roma II Pizza

4.2(50 reviews)

1.0 mi

I love this place. I try to go every weekend for a slice. They also have great little chicken…read morecutlet sandwiches with fresh mozzarella and balsamic on garlic knot looking bread. From their salads & grinders to pizza and dinners everything is hand crafted into perfection! Franks and his workers are friendly and quick. This is definitely a neighborhood stable in the community. It's mostly to-go orders although they have 4 tables and I normally eat here. It's at like one big family between the staff and the patrons. It's clean and they normally have sports on the TV. Thanks Frank we appreciate you & your workers and your reasonable prices!

This place is hands‑down one of the most consistently amazing pizza spots around. The ooey‑gooey…read morecheese, the perfectly thin crust, and that special New York sauce you just can't find anywhere else--it all comes together every single time. The ingredients are always fresh and generously piled on, and the slices are absolutely huge. Frank is the owner and takes pride in his creations. Even after moving to Rockland County, I still travel to Westchester/Yonkers just for this pizza. It's my go‑to spot and the standard I compare all other pizza to. Nothing else comes close.

Chicken Parm slice

See all

Bella Rosa Pizza

4.5(60 reviews)

2.1 mi

If you find yourself in Yonkers this little neighborhood pizza parlor offers up a perfect NY slice…read more Thanks for treating this Seattle native to a wonderful meal this evening.

Yonkers & ALL of Westchester... LISTEN UP! If you haven't pulled up to @bellarosapizzayonkers , you…read moreare seriously missing out Let us put you ON! What we ate (and devoured): PestoRoni Pizza - pesto, pepperoni + hot honey magic Chicken Parm Dinner w/ vodka sauce & penne Chicken Marsala - perfection Cavatelli, Sausage & Broccoli Rabe - elite combo Dark Horse Chardonnay to sip Homemade Tiramisu - chef's kiss And the WEEKDAY DEALS!? UNREAL. You do not want to miss these: Mon: Pasta Night - $10.99 Tues: $65 for 1 app, 2 entrées, 1 dessert & a bottle of wine Wed: $1 wings (no explanation needed) Thurs: Thirsty Thursday PLUS -- they host cooking classes, paint nights, and are available for private events! Perfect for date nights, birthdays, work events... you name it. Run, don't walk. Your taste buds (and your social calendar) will thank you ‍

Garlic knots

See all

Tiny piece of cheesecake

Dom & Vinnie's Restaurant

3.8(145 reviews)

0.5 mi

•$$

Awesome food nice service don't sleep on the entrees there is much more than pizza. Highly…read morerecommend the Bolognese and speciality personal pies

On 8/26/26 I went to D&V after not going in about a year, as I worked across the street and had…read moreretired. I was SOOOOO looking forward to a couple of slices of Sicilian as theirs is the best. When I asked for it, the man behind the counter said they don't have any. I asked if they may have it tomorrow. His [nasty] response: "How would I know about tomorrow, World War III can start tomorrow". What a rude response. I asked if he was the new owner; he said 'yes'. I turned and walked away. That's how you treat [any] customer? After so looking forward to once again enjoying the pizza, what a disappointment. I will NEVER go back. He doesn't deserve my business. Anyone else get such a rude response?

Love me a bread basket

See all

A & V Pizzeria

4.0(152 reviews)

0.5 mi

Pizza is amazing great slice shop with lots of options. Some of the best NY style pizza you will…read morefind.

Women-STAY AWAY-the second they see you, they give you smaller portions. Every time I go in I see…read morethe guys getting regular sized portions but when they give me my order it's always less. Regardless, they still charge me exactly the same as the men.

See all

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

3.7(850 reviews)

2.8 mi

•$$

4.5 true rating So I…read morelast went here six years ago and dined inside. I remember being unimpressed. It wasnt so great that visit and I felt no urge to return. Well my husband is from CT and he wanted to give it a try six years later (again). Reluctantly I agreed after looking through reviews. I have to say. We did half plain half and pepp. I wasn't a fan of the way their pepp came out but the plain was delicious and I would certainly order it again. For some reasons the pizza was cut into kiddie slices which I don't understand. It may have tricked my brain bc i felt hungry after. The pizza was thin, crispy, and flavorful. A power combo. Only downside was very burnt crust ends which I couldn't eat bc they were so burnt even though I was still hungry. Would def try again and sooner!

I really wanted to give Frank Pepe's another chance, especially considering its reputation…read more The last time we ordered from here, we had a horrible experience. To be completely fair, management did make an effort to make things right. We were given a refund as well as a $20 coupon to come back and try them again, which we appreciated. So, we decided to do exactly that. This time, instead of having our pizza delivered, we went directly to the restaurant. We ordered at the cash register, waited for the pies, picked them up ourselves, and brought them home. The photos attached are the pizzas we received. At this point, I really don't think I need to say much more. I'll let the photos speak for themselves. Take a look at the pies and decide for yourself what you think. I'll refrain from picking the pizzas apart ingredient by ingredient because the pictures show exactly what came out of the boxes. After a disappointing first experience, followed by a refund and an invitation to give them another opportunity, we genuinely hoped the second visit would change our opinion. Unfortunately, this was our second chance experience. At least the crust was tasty.

Frank Pepe 's Original Tomato Pie

See all

Inside seating

Montebello's Pizzeria & Pasta

3.1(33 reviews)

0.9 mi

We order a large chicken Parm pizza for delivery and it is delicious. We get it delivered and it…read morearrived hot. I tried their broccoli rabe calzone and loved it, although I thought it was pricy at $12.00.

As a 60-year-old Pizza-holic - Montebello's takes the spot - for the ABSOLUTE worst Pizza I've ever…read morepurchased. They put so little cheese and sauce on my $23.00 large pepperoni pizza - it was like eating sawdust. Horrible. What's worse - this is New York where we know how to make good pizza. I threw half the pie in the trash - which I've NEVER done before. They told me 15 minutes to pick up - I arrived at 20 minutes and stood until 40 minutes when my pizza was finally ready. Steer clear - it's bad.

See all

Full Moon Pizza

3.7(25 reviews)

2.6 mi

Very average pizza. Fluffy crust? Very airy. Fast service but not a ton of flavor. More of a Geno's…read moreguy for takeout Pizza in Bronxville. Have not been to the Arthur Ave location, so not sure how it compares. You a can eat in or carry out. More than just pizza.

I just popped in yesterday and met Larry, the new owner…read more He's a terrific guy and the food was equally terrific. I picked up a few pies for my wealth management business office around the corner. I particularly loved the white pizza with spinach and the Margarita pizza. Larry is even bringing in some new menu items. Miguel is still here and he is a helpful and charming asset to this great pizza parlor. Today I had the chicken parm, my wife Jane had the Linguini with clam sauce, and my daughter Janie had the Penne a la Vodka. All delicious.

Zepolis

Inviting

See all

Dunwoodie Pizzeria

4.2(130 reviews)

1.8 mi

one of the Top 3 pizzas in Yonkers. perfect balance of sauce cheese and crust…read morecooked properly

What can I say.... Dunwoodie Pizza is the Gold Standard for…read morewhat pizza should taste like everywhere. Crispy crust that doesn't flop when you pick it up, melted cheesy top without being burnt. A++++ The decor is nostalgic 70s pizzeria. Friendly staff so you can enjoy one of the best pizzerias in the world, not just Yonkers.

See more unrecommended reviews

@ Dunwoodie, Yonkers, NY

See all

Waiting for my pie!!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

54 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bladizia H.

0

2

0

11 years ago

Best service I have received in Yonkers Mickey & his staff are so kind & down to earth the place is extremely clean nice lay out I was in that place literally everyday when I was pregnant. Mickey delivered to my home even for just one pizza because he knew it was a struggle for me to walk in the snow or drive in bad weather I moved from the area and really wished he would move his business over here to Hartsdale lol. He made me and my family feel at home away from home everyone we stepped foot in to his place. The food is fresh & tasty he has it all there and of you name something he doesn't have he will try his best to accommodate your request for the next time . He's a business man a good one and I've been here a short while coming from Germany he's one of the few business I've came across that's well rounded & welcoming enough to make you remember to write a review on yelp. I'm a very busy women barley have time to blink so this place must be worth me taking out time to write this review. read more

Emiliano M.

0

3

0

11 years ago

This place has always opened and closed as a pizza shop. With its present ownership and quality of food it has become my favorite pizza place to go in yonkers. I have been ordering from them since their early 2015 opening. The staff is extremely friendly and genorous and the owner is open to suggestions if i had any he personally told me when i was a new customer. I have ordered several of their dinner platters and haven't been dissapointed, but my favorite is the chicken scarpariello.The shrimp and chicken parmesan is super delicious every time. For a simple plain cheese pie they are the best around the area. As far as the gourmet pies i can recommend the chicken parmesan,barbacue chicken,penne vodka chicken,and the pear delight is diffrent but tasty with a bit of sweet. I have lived in the area for about 18 years and this place is better than ever. :-) From a family thats pretty much tasted all the pizza in the area we highly recommend it if you havent tried it. read more

Denise W.

0

2

0

11 years ago

I've been ordering pizza from them here and there, but today turned me into a loyal customer. The entire staff is super friendly, but one guy ( I think he's the manager or owner or something ) just really helped me out. I was a little short on cash and he helped me out with a discount. I got to try a slice of pizza that I never had from them before. It was sooooo good, my new fav. The pizza's great (best in the area) and so is the customer service and it's clean and has a great atmosphere. They're also really creative. They serve up the classics as well as new spins on pizza. They have a pie shaped like a cats face with toppings to make the eyes, nose and whiskers. So cute! If you're around I would highly suggest mickeys over the place across the street or anywhere else in the area. read more

Lucy O.

0

8

1

10 years ago

They treat their customers like family, and are very generous. I've never made such a strong connection with a restaurant before. They always remember their customers. They give their customers the special treatment and really cater to your needs. Their service skills go above and beyond what a pizzeria normally does. Their pies are always delicious (especially the chicken bacon ranch and Hawaiian) The wings are delicious and not super greasy which I love. Their cannoli's are also amazing! Definitely worth a visit you will be in love with the staff and the food. read more

Jon K.

0

27

0

8 years ago

Yonkers has some great Italian delis and restaurants but really none by the waterfront area that deliver other than Mickey's. Mickey's is far and away the best Italian spot that delivers near the Hudson. The pizza is great, but more importantly (as anyone in NY does decent pizza) the entrees and subs are outstanding as well. I order from here at least 2xs a month (for me, a significant amount as we prefer to cook for ourselves) and have never once had a complaint other than the delivery time can sometimes be a bit lengthy. read more

Maryann S.

0

1

0

4 years ago

Best Pizza in Yonkers. Amazing food, fantastic delivery guys . Always polite . We don't order from anywhere else. My husband loves the fried Calamari, my daughter has a list . lol. Penne Ala Vodka, bacon cheeseburgers and of course the pizza always a pie half pepperoni half sausage.. Oh can't forget the beef patty for me. I could go on but that's just a few. The gentleman who answers is always polite no matter if their busy or not . Will have to stop by and meet one day They won't disappoint. read more

Randa M.

0

2

0

10 years ago

I ordered from Mickey's for my daughters birthday. The food was fantastic!! The parents loved the margarita pie and the kids loved the all white meat chicken fingers. I ordered the morning of and it was at my house at 5pm (just as I requested). Jimmy's daughter went out of her way to pick up fuel canisters for me and didn't even charge me for them!!! My family has ordered from here many times and it's been great food and service 100% of the time. Thanks again Jimmy!! read more

Ismael S.

0

1

0

4 years ago

Went here a while back with some friends after school and never stopped coming back. The service here is great and the food is even better. I ordered a buffalo chicken roll and instantly fell in love. The people running the business are very nice and considerate and patient. And the roll isn't where the great food ends. The pizza is great, the wraps are great, it's a must try. A small hole in the wall but in my opinion the best pizzeria in yonkers. read more

Melinda P.

93

1

2

10 years ago

If your looking for the best food in town I can put my money on it, when I say this is the place to go. The prices are affordable and the food is AMAZING. Very professional and respectful workers. I come here at least once a week and always catch the workers cleaning and staying on time of the business. I love love love this pizza shop. I never write reviews but I feel this place deserves it. I recommend it wholeheartedly. Great service! read more

Lazaro R.

0

22

1

12 years ago

The best pizza I've tasted in Yonkers in a while. Their buffalo wings are so delicious, always has me craving for more. Salads are on point. Pastas are very delectable. Cant wait to try their wraps. The customer service is exceptionally great. The owner is very welcoming and treats you like a close friend. Highly recommend this hidden gem the if your around the neighborhood. Buffalo wings come highly recommemded. read more

Jacqueline O.

0

1

0

2 years ago

I've been living in Yonkers for five years now and I've been in search of great pizza .. I came across Mikey's pizza on Apple Maps and decided to order for delivery pepperoni pizza pie. This pizza was beyond my expectations. Best pizza I've had in years. I decided to come in the following week to have a slice and see the place. I met Jimmy and he was incredible. Great conversation and warm welcoming. Will definetly be back. read more

Saad R.

0

1

3

4 years ago

The pizza was absolutely perfect. We got a veggie pizza and the attention to detail was great. The garlic knots ordered were also great and extremely well made. My girlfriend had a calzone and it was delicious. I will definitely get pizza from here again and order different pies and people should support their local pizza shops. 6/5 stars if I could possibly give that. read more

Fernando L.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Great service and delivered my food earlier than expected which was even better. Best pizzeria around the neighborhood with fasts delivery! It was more convenient for myself to order online at seamless.com They even offered a heart shaped pie which was even better for the occasion the pizza is made to perfection every time. Define lay ordering from here more often. read more

Tiffany C.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Jimmy is a rude piece of shit. God forbid if you ask a question about items on the menu before you place your order, you'll just get hung up on. He tries to flirt and fuck customers and when that doesn't work you are public enemy number one! Horrible customer service isn't even the word. Burn the menu DO NOT want that nasty energy handling anything I eat. read more

Yashu K.

0

5

0

10 years ago

Mickeys pizzeria has the best customer service i have seen in a pizzeria yet. The staff is extremely friendly and approachable. The variations of pizzas and other dishes are outstanding. Coming from soccer practice i do go there often and im extremely happy that mickeys is my go to pizzeria and so are my taste buds. read more

Luis S.

0

1

0

3 years ago

This is one of the best pizzerias in town. I absolutely love this place because they consistently provide excellent customer service and make us feel like family. Visiting this place is definitely worth it and you won't regret it. The cozy atmosphere makes you feel right at home and you'll feel like you belong here. read more

Sabrinna N.

0

1

0

3 years ago

Owner is a pedophile he raped my daughter and I tried to press charges and no one helped me I just recently called to see if he still was there and he told me the restaurant hours were closed but I just called from a different number and he took another person's order is a liar and a fraud read more

Maria H.

0

3

0

10 years ago

The owner of this shop is so nice - he treats you like he's known you forever! The food is DELICIOUS! I have had the pizza from here and also the Penne alla vodka! Great service, great food and he's catering my daughter's pizza party! We need more business's like this! Thank you Mickey! read more

Patrick T.

0

2

0

2 years ago

Great pizza, the service is awesome, I usually get there around an hour before it closes, but I'm in and out with my order and it's pretty quiet, I like it a lot! My only gripe is that it's closed on Mondays and I'll have to get pizza from across the street and it just isn't the same. read more

Shantell O.

0

4

3

11 years ago

Between the pizza, Millwood salad, Mack Attack, Mickey's wrap, calzones, etc........ Everything is so good!!!!! Staff is great, service is great as well. I haven't tried anything that hasn't been pretty good. Had a party there once, everything was perfect!! Thanks Mickey's :-) read more

Mickey's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Mickey's Pizzeria also viewed

Crosby Pizza Stop

3.8

(115 reviews)

In the evening, if you ask for a slice you get something that's been sitting there all day and…read morenever warmed up properly. The service is lackluster and they tend to treat some people better than others unfortunately. No ambiance at all.

Crosby Pizza fell off. No effort is put into anything they make. Pizza is not the same as years…read moreago. The sause is bitter. The lasagna is gross.

Pizza Barn

(547 reviews)

•$$

the cub, my son Marco, was asking me if we could order some pizza. so we ordered the "thin pie"…read morefrom 19 frogs . w got their 20 mins later, grabbed some parm crumbs, dumped them on the pizza & the cub and I chowed down on some absolutely fabulous tasting pizza slices! i'd reccomend this place big time ! buon appetito!!! mangia

I came here on a Thursday, and it was not too packed. The staff was welcoming. I ordered a big…read morecheese pie that was split in half, with one side being cheese and the other topped with chicken and green peppers. The chicken and green peppers were prepared differently than what I am used to at other pizza shops. The green peppers were sliced, while the chicken was not grilled and had more of a mashed texture, which was different from what I expected. I preferred the cheese side, but both sides were hot, fresh, and tasted good overall. They also have a parking lot, which is a nice convenience and makes stopping by easier.

Joe's Pizzeria

(25 reviews)

Calzone from 50 years ago! I used to go to this Pizzeria in the 70's and it was one of the best…read morePizzeria's on White Plains Road. Manhattan Joe's Pizza franchise can't hold a candle to this old pizza joint. The Calzone I had on Thursday 8Jan2026 was superb! The bread was light and tasty, not heavy at all. In fact, it tasted a bit buttery. The crust was perfecto! Yes, reminded me of the good ol' days, when a plain pizza slice was 20 cents! The place is always nice and clean. With a steady stream of customers it can get busy during lunch. Always worth the trip.

I love it . food is so Delicious and flavorful and staff is so friendly. Deactore was nice and…read moreQuiet.

A & V Pizzeria

4.0

(152 reviews)

Pizza is amazing great slice shop with lots of options. Some of the best NY style pizza you will…read morefind.

Women-STAY AWAY-the second they see you, they give you smaller portions. Every time I go in I see…read morethe guys getting regular sized portions but when they give me my order it's always less. Regardless, they still charge me exactly the same as the men.

Gino's Pizzeria

4.6

(112 reviews)

This place was voted best pizza in Yonkers and I had to check it out. It's a small space with three…read moretables. They used to be cash only, but now they take card (with fee). The pizza was delicious!

Gino's Pizzeria is a true South Broadway staple and a go-to spot for consistently good food. The…read morepizza is perfectly seasoned--savory, satisfying, and always hits the spot whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie. What really sets Gino's apart is that they offer so much more than just pizza. Their menu includes favorites like fresh, hot zeppoles, indulgent fried Oreos, crispy chicken tenders, flavorful beef patties, and plenty of other comfort-food options. It's the kind of place where everyone can find something they're in the mood for. The service is friendly and welcoming, giving you that classic neighborhood pizzeria experience where you feel like a regular even on your first visit. Reliable food, generous options, and great service make Gino's Pizzeria a Yonkers classic that continues to stand the test of time. Definitely worth stopping by if you're in the area.

Alfonso's Pizza & Restaurant

3.7

(40 reviews)

So I personally really enjoy this pizza spot. Their pizza is amazing! I have never ordered and…read morehaven't had good food. One of my favorite items is their fried chicken wings. AMAZING! My only problem is it's hard to order online sometimes their sight is not user friendly. Great service every time I go!

One of my close go to when the wife and I don't want to travel far. Alfonso's have great tasting…read morepizza and more. They also have good conversations while you wait for your order as well. Keep up the good work guys and THANK YOU for what you do in the community.

Dough Boys Pizza

4.2

(13 reviews)

About 10 months ago Doughboys moved locations to Broadway next to KFC. Bigger space more seats for…read moreindoor dining. Been a long time customers and I have many favorites from the menu. The chicken wings are a must so is the Garlic knots. My favorite pie is the Cesar salad one it's different but so good. They have 42 pies to choose from and all equally delicious and made to order. For anyone with a sweet tooth they have funnel cake fried Oreos and my favorite Zeppoles. Thank you Victor for providing great customer service and consistency in what you put out. Your staff is always hospitable.

Hands down the BEST Pizza and Italian food in the area.. The regular pizza is done very well and…read moretastes great. The Sicilian pizza is the best around, not thick and all dough, It is thin, the sauce is semi sweet but you have to get extra cheese. They have meatballs that are amazing, the garlic bread with cheese is perfection and make sure to check out the deserts ..... This place is the real deal ..... Enjoy, I sure do.

Tommy's Pizza

(183 reviews)

Doesn't get more authentic than Tommy's Pizza...Tommy was working the counter and the service was…read morefantastic. This spot has the vibe of an old school NY pizza joint, because it IS an old school NY pizza joint. 10/10 would go again and again

Tommy's is another old school cash only pizza joint with that old Bronx vibe. It's not the biggest…read moreplace but they dishing out big flavor and great pies. Keeping it simple and just making great pizza. There slices have that corn meal crust which adds to the extra crunch. Staff are quick and to the point like everything else in the Bronx and it ain't a bad thing. Was the great lunch a nice sweet sauce can't go wrong with A Dave Portnoy pizza rating as high as they have. Definitely would love some more of there great pizza.

Dino's Pizza

(138 reviews)

Great spot for pizza and pastas! I ordered the penne vodka and the chicken caprese. Penne vodka was…read morea 8/10. It was flavored and seasoned which was different. Also you get a really good portion size for the cost which was around $14. It also came with a basket of fresh warm bread that was soft! You could tell that everything tasted like it was just prepared. I also really enjoyed the chicken caprese. Definitely flavorful and comes with a side of pasta and salad. Again, it's a great deal for less than $20. They do have indoor seating and a bathroom. All the staff is friendly and you can tell that it's a community favorite. I can't wait to go back!

Pizza is ok but not great considering that Salvatore's is much better and closer to us…read moregeographically.

Frank's Pizzeria

4.3

(143 reviews)