Located in the Middle Bass Island General Store. Despite the fact that this place is the only game…read morein town on Tuesday night, the pizza is above a average imo. Service is not bad. It's definitely a locals, divey atmosphere kind of place. Kind place you should walk into with no expectations and you won't be disappointed.

Great place. Great food. Wonderful atmosphere. Bar Three is the place to be! Eat at Joe's!!read more

This pizza is awesome and so fresh it's refreshing! Words can't express how my lady and I really…read moreenjoyed every bite of it!

The best part of this spot is the staff! Every employee was over the top friendly and…read moreaccommodating. The food always came out hot and fresh and full of flavor, and the service was excellent.

Great food and service. The biggest pork sandwich I never had! The cute little gift shop is a bonusread more

Golf cart rental: Compared to all my visits to neighboring Put-in-Bay, there are barely any golf…read morecarts available to tourists on Middle Bass and they are only available at J.F. Walleye's. My grandpa and I got an early start and came in on the 9:15am ferry. We needed a golf cart around 10am, but turns out you can't even rent a golf cart until they open at noon! Fortunately, we ran into a worker who let us rent out a cart. We were able to golf cart around the whole island by noon and returned for lunch. Restaurant: This is the only standalone restaurant on the island so you can't expect much. The BBQ wings were solid but I wasn't a fan of the walleye bites. I love walleye, but the bites just didn't taste right and they came with a weird honey mustard dressing and the cole slaw tasted like gordon food service vs. being homemade. My Mai Tai tasted like a tropical drink, but not a Mai Tai necessarily. The restaurant features a resort-like wading pool (it's 1.5 feet deep) and there were kids swimming in it on the Thursday afternoon I visited. I imagine the pool and the entire place gets put-in-bay crazy on the weekend. Food and drinks are pricey, which is understandable given how difficult it is to get everything on and off the island. Overall, 5/5 for the service from the golf cart guy and our attentive waitress, but everything else is a bit disappointing just like the island.

Great pizza, very clean dining area with super friendly staff. Generously built pizza. They have…read morewings that we will try next time. We will be back.

We like to support small business. This family run small business is a refreshing change from some…read morelocal chain store experiences. The people working here are truly kind and that makes a huge difference. The young man behind d the counter was courteous, kind and helpful. He offered to carry the pizzas to my car for me and although that was not necessary; it was a nice gesture. He did hold the door open for me and thank me for coming. The pizza was your average take out. I asked for light sauce which they did accommodate. It's nice to have a request honored. Toppings were adequate. The dill pickle pizza with ham was delicious cold the next day. The pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza was best hot out of the oven but reheated nicely in a pan on the stove. We love cold leftover pizza but this one was better reheated.

Don't let the old strip mall behind it fool you; this place is a true hidden gem for great…read morebrick-oven fired pizza. On the outside it looks like it's in an old Denny's. But when you walk in immediately see the pizza oven with its fire and contents. There is also a full bar (huge beer list with some on tap, too) and plenty of seating. Dining is very casual and not pretentious at all. The service was quick and friendly...what more could you ask for.

We enjoyed our meal, and note that the restaurant is busy. On a Thursday, we waited over 20 minutes…read morefor a table. Not sure if they take reservations. The waitress was really nice, and they have a very lengthy drink selection. I enjoyed the pizza and atmosphere. Portions are massive. You will have leftovers!

Unreal bar. Opened early. Has a nice outdoor patio. A few food options as well. Extremely nice…read morestaff. Anna Maria I believe was her name. Super sweet and nice. The food we did not try but has many options. The drinks were great. They had a "shot of the month" it was called Golden Tea. It was delicious. The Rum Runners were fabulous. Definately a must return. Overall a great experience. 8.9 out of 10

Brought by a local to Put-In-Bay and was told I had to try Frosty's. Restaurant was classic island…read morefeel. The service was very quick and friendly. The food for me was pretty average but I will give them kudos for their portion sizes for at-least the tots. It could feed a full family of 4. Happy to recommend but probably will check out a different restaurant next time I visit.

I couldn't have asked for a better place to have our Dad's 90th Birthday Celebration at. The air…read moreconditioned ballroom was perfect!! The service was spectacular and you can't beat the deal you get on their jumbo/flavors of pizzas. They helped us every step of the way from the planning to the full service day of!! The Left Field staff was definitely top notch and went out of their way to make it a perfect celebration!!! Thank you again!!! P.S. Their appetizers are awesome!!!!

We ostes a retirement party in their back room! We served pizza and chicken chunks. The room was…read moreclean and well appointed with a private serving area, bar and lots of comfortable seating. Included were round tables which I particularly like for events. The food was excellent. The chicken chunks were all chucken, served with a variety of sauces and delicious! Pizza was great and kept warm in some nice warming tables. The server/bartender was attentive and did a nice job serving us all. Flexible with cash and credit card options. We were there in January but the outdoor venue looked very nice and I look forward to heading there this summer!

BEST breakfast on PIB!!!…read more I was so happy we tried this place when we were at PIB! It was packed but we got sat quickly and the service was awesome! I got the visitor sandwich- it was pretty big and it was good! I was more excited to know that ALL their sandwiches come with tater tots and not fries!!!!!!!! My friends got many different places but devoured them all! I do have to give a shout out to the banana bread because- WOW! Is this not the prettiest banana bread you've ever seen? It even has an orange marmalade! It was PHENOMENAL!!!! Next time I'm back - I will be eating all my breakfasts here!!

Excellent restaurant for brunch. A varied selection of delicious food options…read more We dined here multiple times and had their omelettes, pancakes, and eggs Benedict. Their Grilled Banana Bread is do very good. Would definitely dine here again when we visit the area.

Cool little brewery on PiB! Popped in for a drink after dinner and really enjoyed it. Our server…read morewas friendly and our drinks were served quick!

A big selection of beers. Very neat building. Can see the brewing process from right outside the…read morewindow. The staff wasn't the friendliest. It was Noon on a Friday. Not a big crowd. The bartender acted like we were bothering her ( no other customers). No complete answer, just 1 word. I ordered the Watermelon Wheat. Not the best. Wasn't refreshing. Luke warm beer. The flavor wasn't packing a punch. Average. The Margarita we ordered was very, very strong. Almost too much salted brim and almost too much syrup Not the greatest. Bad sticker selection. Overall a 6.9 out of 10.

As others have stated this general store has all the basics... and then some. Truly a mini grocery…read morestore, complete with produce section and dairy department. I was surprised to see they have a meat department that is manned by a butcher/attendant. Not a huge selection, but enough to have a great barbeque. They were well stocked with chips and soda. We stopped in for ice cream, and there was a decent selection of flavors. Service was efficient. They are trying to get people in, out and on their way. A sign on terminals indicates that the card readers are slow, but it wasn't that noticeable. Due to COVID-19 occupancy in the stote is limited. The store is requiring masks for employees and customers. Patrons must knock on the inside door to be let in. A parking lot is shared with a neighboring business. It provides ample parking for both businesses.

There were five in my party. All were served their drinks perfectly timed, and no one complained…read moreabout their meal. I had broiled walleye, and it was cooked to perfection.