Located in the Middle Bass Island General Store. Despite the fact that this place is the only game…read morein town on Tuesday night, the pizza is above a average imo. Service is not bad. It's definitely a locals, divey atmosphere kind of place. Kind place you should walk into with no expectations and you won't be disappointed.

Great place. Great food. Wonderful atmosphere. Bar Three is the place to be! Eat at Joe's!!read more

The pizza here is top tier. I have had several different, but the Margherita is delish with fresh…read moremozzarella and basil. My go to is the pepperoni with extra cheese. They have live music and fun place to be on the island..service is always friendly and courteous. It's not the fastest but you have to wait for good food...I highly recommend.

We were so glad to find a place here on the island that delivered. The pizza was so good! And the…read moreservice was excellent! I'm sure that the ambiance of the restaurant is also good. Highly recommend this place!!

Golf cart rental: Compared to all my visits to neighboring Put-in-Bay, there are barely any golf…read morecarts available to tourists on Middle Bass and they are only available at J.F. Walleye's. My grandpa and I got an early start and came in on the 9:15am ferry. We needed a golf cart around 10am, but turns out you can't even rent a golf cart until they open at noon! Fortunately, we ran into a worker who let us rent out a cart. We were able to golf cart around the whole island by noon and returned for lunch. Restaurant: This is the only standalone restaurant on the island so you can't expect much. The BBQ wings were solid but I wasn't a fan of the walleye bites. I love walleye, but the bites just didn't taste right and they came with a weird honey mustard dressing and the cole slaw tasted like gordon food service vs. being homemade. My Mai Tai tasted like a tropical drink, but not a Mai Tai necessarily. The restaurant features a resort-like wading pool (it's 1.5 feet deep) and there were kids swimming in it on the Thursday afternoon I visited. I imagine the pool and the entire place gets put-in-bay crazy on the weekend. Food and drinks are pricey, which is understandable given how difficult it is to get everything on and off the island. Overall, 5/5 for the service from the golf cart guy and our attentive waitress, but everything else is a bit disappointing just like the island.

This is a gem of a place here on bass island ! Easy to get…read moreto and a killer time with great food ! The walleye is awesome and the rueben is 100% They have live music ! And a nice pool ! It's a fun place and the owners are some of the nicest most accommodating people you've ever met ! And they also have a big chair that is great for a nice Instagram post pic. K

Good pizza and the waitress/owner could not have been nicer. Probably good takeout, but not much…read moreof a dine in place.

Absolutely delicious! Solid 8/10. Sauce was yummy and…read moreseemed to be an average amount to me. The garlic bread was very garlicky which I liked! Will be back in the summer.

The Brick Oven Bistro is a local, family-owned restaurant specializing in making fresh brick oven…read morepizzas, calzones, sandwiches, wings, appetizers, soups, salads, desserts and more. The service was fabulous, second to none. ( my apologies to our pretty and talented server with the Japanese name that I can't remember) she definitely went over and above to make everything special even when my 91 year old friend under tipped her. In this casual ambiance setting by the fireside Rick had the delicious roast beef sandwich, I had a calzone and my friend had a personal pizza. All were exceptional. They also have an amazing, locally sourced gluten-free pizza crust--and other GF options available.

Have to have a Brick Oven Bistro pizza every time we are in or near Sandusky! Best service, food,…read moredrafts, and drinks in the area. The service is very family friendly-owned style, and the staff love working here-great indication of a top restaurant.

This bar has a cool, old, nostalgic, dark wood vibe. We want here for breakfast and it was…read moreextremely good. The bartender was attentive and knew exactly what she was doing.

Brought by a local to Put-In-Bay and was told I had to try Frosty's. Restaurant was classic island…read morefeel. The service was very quick and friendly. The food for me was pretty average but I will give them kudos for their portion sizes for at-least the tots. It could feed a full family of 4. Happy to recommend but probably will check out a different restaurant next time I visit.

Great food and drinks outside patio is huge, Asher special is amazing pound of chunks and two…read moreorders of fries, ranch and your choice of sauce all in one pile

We ostes a retirement party in their back room! We served pizza and chicken chunks. The room was…read moreclean and well appointed with a private serving area, bar and lots of comfortable seating. Included were round tables which I particularly like for events. The food was excellent. The chicken chunks were all chucken, served with a variety of sauces and delicious! Pizza was great and kept warm in some nice warming tables. The server/bartender was attentive and did a nice job serving us all. Flexible with cash and credit card options. We were there in January but the outdoor venue looked very nice and I look forward to heading there this summer!

I absolutely loved this restaurant! From our walk into the place we were greeted by such friendly…read morestaff and treated with kindness and warmth. The restaurant was beautifully decorated and clean. We were seated fairly quickly and served fast. The breakfast menu was pretty big and offered a nice variety of items! We enjoyed the banana bread and the pancake was shareable! Great service and good price!

If you are considering visiting Pasquales....definitely DO! We popped in yesterday for breakfast…read moreand were so glad that we did. From the minute we walked in, throughout the entire meal, we felt valued as customers. We were warmly greeted, even though they were very, very busy. Our server, Keegan, was a delight. He was engaging, attentive and really understood the meaning of customer service. Both meals we ordered were delicious and cooked perfectly. All the other meals passing by that we didn't chose also looked great! Every employee here was smiling, friendly and a perfect example of what we should all expect from service at a restaurant. We will definitely be back!

Nate and I stopped here for a quick drink and had an ok experience. The bartender was so nice and…read morepolite but the drinks were not the best. They were out of a lot of beer and it looks like they only brew wheats and stouts. That said, it was the end of the season, so they were probably just running with what they had. Nate got the wheat beer which was alright. I got an espresso old fashioned which was not that good - it just overwhelmingly tasted like kind of bad espresso. We didn't get any food but the menu looked really good. I'd come back for a meal but probably would skip drinks at this spot.

We got the beer flight and my favorite was the chocolate raspberry brew…read more The smashburger was amazing and huge! And along with fries, it will feed two people easy. Highly recommend them!

As others have stated this general store has all the basics... and then some. Truly a mini grocery…read morestore, complete with produce section and dairy department. I was surprised to see they have a meat department that is manned by a butcher/attendant. Not a huge selection, but enough to have a great barbeque. They were well stocked with chips and soda. We stopped in for ice cream, and there was a decent selection of flavors. Service was efficient. They are trying to get people in, out and on their way. A sign on terminals indicates that the card readers are slow, but it wasn't that noticeable. Due to COVID-19 occupancy in the stote is limited. The store is requiring masks for employees and customers. Patrons must knock on the inside door to be let in. A parking lot is shared with a neighboring business. It provides ample parking for both businesses.

There were five in my party. All were served their drinks perfectly timed, and no one complained…read moreabout their meal. I had broiled walleye, and it was cooked to perfection.